????%20Moral%20Reasoning

1
????Moral Reasoning

• ????? ??? ??
• http//homepage.ntu.edu.tw/hwlin/

2
Euthanasia(???)

• James Rachels Philippa Foot

3
Active and Passive EuthanasiaJames Rachels

• ????
• (?)?????????????
• (?)?????????????

4
Active and Passive Euthanasia

• ????A????????????????,????????????
• (?)????????????????
• ?,??????????
• (?)?????????????,???
• ????,???????????

5
Active and Passive Euthanasia

• ????B???????????,???????????
• (?)?????????,????????????????

6
Active and Passive Euthanasia

• (?)??????????????,??????????,????????????????,???
  ?????????
• (?)?????????????????,??????

7
Active and Passive Euthanasia

• ????C????????????,????????????????
• (?)???????????????????,????????????,????????,Smit
  h?Jones??????,???????,????????????,?????????????

8
Active and Passive Euthanasia

• (?)??????????Smith?Jones,???????????????,????????
  ???????,??????????????????,???????????

9
Active and Passive Euthanasia

• (?)?????????????????????,???????????(mercy
  killing),???????????????????????,???????????????

10
Active and Passive Euthanasia

• (?)??????????????????????,?????????
• (1)?????????????
• (2)???????????????
• ????????
• ??(2)???,?????(1)???,?????????????????

11
Active and Passive Euthanasia

• ?????????????????,?????????,??????????,??????????
  ????????????????????,????????????

12
Active and Passive Euthanasia

• ?????
• (?)??????,?????????????????

13
Active and Passive Euthanasia

• (?)?????,????????,?????????????,?????????????????
  ????????
• (?)???????????,?????????????????????????????,????
  ???????????

14
EuthanasiaPhilippa Foot

• ????????
• (?)???????
• (1)??????????
• (2)?????????
• (3)??????????????

15
Euthanasia

• (?)??????????????????????????,??????????????????
  

16
Euthanasia

• ????????????????
• (?)???????,????????
• ?????????
• (?)????????
• (1)???????a)????????????????b)????????c)???
  ???,????????

17

• (2)?????????????,??????????????,?????????,????
  ????????,??????????????,??????,???????

18

• (3)?
• a)?????????????????????
• b)????,????????,??????????,??????????

19
Euthanasia

• ??????????????
• (?)???????????????
• (1)???????,???????
• ????
• (2)???????(claim-right)???
• (3)???????????,??????????,???????????????????
  ???????????

20

• (?)??????????
• (1)??????????,???????????????,???????,?????????
  ?
• (2)???????????????????????,??????????????????,?
  ??????????????,??????????????

21
Euthanasia

• (?)???????????
• (1)??????????,?????????????
• (2)?Rachels?????????
• (3)????????,?????? ???????,?????????????,??????
  ?????
• (4)????????????????????????

22
Euthanasia

• (?)?????????????
• (1)?????????
• (2)????????
• (?)??
• (1)??????????????
• (2)???????????????
• ?

23
Euthanasia

• ???????
• (?)????????
• (?)?????????????,???
• ???
• (?)???????????

24
????Moral Reasoning

• ???!