Title: Financial Journalists Presentation
1Financial Journalists Presentation
- The Following are highlight slides of a day long
presentation given to the American Society of
Business Publication Editors (ASBPE) at the City
Club San Francisco on January 20, 2004 by Brian
Berberet, CFA and Jim Keene, CFA, CFP.
2A Primer on Risk, Valuations and Financing of
Assets and Companies and How Companies Use (and
Abuse) Financial Accounting
- Brian Berberet, CFA
- Principal, Carrick Bend Advisors LLC
- Public Relations Committee, Security Analysts of
San Francisco - Jim Keene, CFA, CFP
- Portfolio Manager, Bingham, Osborn Scarborough
- Faculty Practitioner, University of San Francisco
- Media Contact Liaison, Security Analysts of San
Francisco
3About Brian Berberet, CFA and Jim Keene, CFA, CFP
- Brian Berberet, CFA
- Principal, Carrick Bend Advisors LLC
- Co-managed a Morningstar 4 Star Small Cap Fund
- 8 years experience as securities analyst
specializing in banking and telecommunication
services - Former Institutional Equities Trader
- Jim Keene, CFA, CFP
- Over 20 years experience in real estate
financing, venture capital investing and private
client advising - Over 200mm financed in real estate, 100mm
venture portfolio managed and 175mm private
client assets managed - Portfolio Manager at Bingham, Osborn
Scarborough, a S.F.-based wealth manager - Teaches Alternative Investments and Financial
Markets for Security Analysts of San Francisco
CFA prep classes Faculty Practitioner at
University of San Francisco Masters of Science
in Financial Analysis
4About AIMR
- Association of Investment Management Research
- Mission Statement To advance the interests of
the global investment community by establishing
and maintaining the highest standards of
professional excellence and integrity. - 67,000 members (including 54,000 who hold
Chartered Financial Analyst designation) in 112
countries and territories - 63 of members serve primarily institutional
investors and 37 primarily serve individual
investors - Offices Virginia, London, Hong Kong
- Local CFA Societies Around the Country World
- Contacts Rich Wyler rgw_at_aimr.org
434-951-5344 - Kathy Valentine kmv_at_aimr.org 434-951-5348
5About SASF
- Security Analysts of San Francisco
- Mission Statement The SASF promotes high
standards of competence and ethics for its
members, encourages their continuing educational
and professional development and sponsors
programs to interchange investment ideas and
corporate information. - Approximately 2,200 members (79 are CFA
Charterholders) - Founded 1929 second oldest financial analyst
society in U.S. - SASF is dedicated to Promoting Financial Literacy
with fund-raising through its Annual Wine
Charity. Funds raised provide Bay Area high
school students and teachers with programs that
improve financial literacy. Now serving 60 high
schools in the Bay Area. - Contacts Jim Keene (415)781-8535 ext. 233
- jim.keene_at_bosinvest.com www.bosinvest.com
- Tina Myers (415)259-0765
- sasf_at_vkam.com www.sasf.org
6About the CFA designation
- No other designation within the profession of
investment management carries as much integrity
as the CFA charter. - The CFA program sets the global standard for
investment knowledge, standards and ethics. - To be awarded the Chartered Financial Analyst
designation, a candidate must meet the following
qualifications, as specified by the Association
of Investment Management and Research (AIMR). - Examinations Three six-hour exams must be
passed sequentially testing knowledge on a range
of investment topics including portfolio
management, accounting, statistics, economics,
asset valuation and ethics. - Experience Have at least three years acceptable
work experience in the investment decision-making
process. - Compliance Once an individual becomes a CFA
charterholder, he or she must comply with AIMRs
conditions, requirements, policies and procedures
of a CFA charterholder and AIMR member, including
those set forth in the Code of Ethics and
Standards of Professional Conduct. - Education There is a voluntary professional
development program that recommends 20 hours per
year of qualifying education in investment and
ethics programs at a level above the CFA exams.
7Our Agenda Part I
- Return, Risk and Cost of Capital
- Cash Flow and Accounting Differences
- Revenue Recognition Channel Stuffing
- Minority Interests and Joint Ventures Impact on
Debt Ratios - Leasing Off Balance Sheet Debt Other Forms
SPEs - Stock Option Accounting Off-Balance Sheet
Equity - Pension Accounting Analyzing Pension Cost Today
with regard to a Liability Tomorrow
8Return and Risk
- In the financial world there is a relationship
between return and risk. - Everyone is familiar with returns
- S P 500 up 28.7 for 2003 (Capital gain and
dividends) - Lehman Brothers Aggregate Bond Index returned
4.1 for 2003 - San Francisco Bay Area housing up 9.4for the
twelve months ended November 2003
9But What about Risk?
- In general, risk is uncertainty. However, there
are certain types of - risk
- Systematic Risk risks that affect a large
number of assets, also known as market risk - Uncertainties around inflation and interest
rates tend to affect all investments and are
systematic risk factors - Unsystematic Risk risks that affect a single
asset or small group of assets, also known as
unique or asset-specific risks - Loss of a government defense contract is an
example of unsystematic risk it primarily
affects that one company
10And More Systematic Risk!!
- Operating Risk (of the firms equity) The risk
associated with a firms operating activities - High fixed cost, low margin firms tend to have
more operating risk than low fixed cost, high
margin businesses - Financial Risk (of the firms equity) The risk
associated with a firms use of debt financing - As a firm begins to rely on debt financing, the
risk to equity increases (and the required return
on equity) - While each firm has a specific business and
financial risk profile, the risks are common to
all businesses. As such, these are known as
systematic risks. - The total systematic risk of the firms equity
is comprised of operating and financial risk.
11How Do We Measure Risk?
- The risk of a project or investment can be
evaluated in many ways. Some common quantitative
methods include - Standard deviation of returns
- Cash flow of projects and appreciation/(loss)
- Measures range of actual vs. average returns
- S P 500 has annual standard deviation of 14
- based on average historical long-term return of
11.5 this means that annual returns range from
(2.5) to 25.5 (/- 14 from 11.5 average)
two-thirds of the time - Measure of volatility
12Other Measures of Risk
- Downside Risk - How much can an investment
decline in value? - Often, the most important measure of risk for
individual investors - The 401K Plan statement risk the investor who
didnt want to open his or her financial
statements during the March 2000 October 2002
bear market in equities - Downside lower for investments such as
- Short-Intermediate term bonds (4.1 loss in
1993-94) - Un-leveraged residential real estate (14 down
for LA in early 1990s) - Small Company Value securities (31.8 loss in
bear market compared to 48 decline for S P 500)
13And More Types of Risk
- Businesses are subject to event risk, also. This
is the risk of unexpected shocks to the economy
including - OPEC agreements that restrict the supply of oil
- Geopolitical events (war in Iraq)
- Strikes and labor unrest and severe weather
conditions affecting crops - Event risk tends to negatively impact the capital
markets stocks and bonds - There is a positive impact with commodity returns
- The nature of event risk is that surprises
occurring in commodities markets tend to be those
that unexpectedly reduce the supply of the
commodity to market - Event risk measured by skewness and kurtosis
14Systematic Vs. Specific Risk
- Firm specific risk can be materially reduced by
owning stocks in several different companies. - Systematic risk can not be diversified away so
easily. - Since Firm specific risk can be easily
diversified away, investors are not compensated
for the amount of risk they take holding
concentrated portfolios.
15Bringing it Together Risk and Return
- The Security Market Line describes the
relationship between systematic risk and expected
return in the financial markets. Systematic risk
is simply risk associated with investing in
financial markets, in general.
16The Security Market LineExpected Returns
- Expected tong-term annual returns for
increasingly risky investments - Asset Class Exp. Ann. Return
- 3 Month Treasuries (risk-free) 0.9
- 5 Year Treasuries 3.2
- Lehman Brothers Aggregate Bonds 4.6
- Diversified Pool of BBB (High Yield) Bonds
7.4 - Diversified Pool of Office/Ind. Real Estate
8.2 - Large Company U.S. Stocks 10.0
- Small Company U.S. Stocks 12.0
- Emerging Market Stocks 13.0
- Leveraged Managed Futures 16.0
- Diversified Pool of Venture Capital 20.5
17 18Capital Asset Pricing Model
- The capital asset pricing model shows the
expected return for a particular asset depends on
three things - The pure time value of money (as measured by
risk-free rate) - The reward for bearing systematic risk (the
premium for bearing an average amount of risk) - The amount of systematic risk (relative to an
average asset) - The relationship is as follows
-
- Expected Return of Asset i Risk-free rate
(Expected Return of Market Risk-free rate)
Sensitivity of Asset Returns to Market Returns -
19CAPM and Equity Cost of Capital
- The Capital Asset Pricing Model can help estimate
a firms equity cost of capital - All you need is a firms estimated Beta (or
measure of sensitivity to the market or
average asset) - Assume the following information for CAPM
- Risk-free rate 4.13 (10 Year Treasury)
- Average risky asset has an expected annual return
of 10 (large company U.S. stocks) - General Electric stock has an estimated beta of
1.106 - What is General Electrics Cost of Equity
Capital?
20General Electric Cost of Equity Capital
- 4.13 (10 - 4.13) 1.106
- 10.62
21Weighted Average Cost of Capital
- A firms overall cost of capital is a weighted
average of the costs of the various components of
capital structure - The value of a firm is maximized when the
weighted average cost of capital (WACC) is
minimized - The typical components of capital structure are
debt and equity (there are hybrid instruments,
also) - Debt is unusual in the respect that it has a tax
shield that is, the interest on debt is tax
deductible
22The WACC of a firm is
(Equity/Enterprise Value) Cost of Equity
(Debt/Enterprise Value) (1 Tax Rate) Cost
of Debt
23General Electrics Estimated Cost of Capital
- GEs capital structure is
- Total Short-Term Debt (9/30/03) 165B 19.1
- Total Long-Term Debt (9/30/03) 389B 45.0
- Total Equity (12/19/03) 310B 35.9
- Total Market Cap. (Debt Equity) 864B
100.0 - Note Debt should technically be marked to
market - GEs cost of Short-Term Debt (2 Yr.
Maturity) 1.87 - GEs cost of Long-Term Debt (10 Yr.
Maturity) 4.69 - Cost of Equity (based on CAPM)
10.62 - GEs WACC Cost of Short-Term Debt Cost of
Long-Term Debt Cost of Equity ((19.1
1.87) (45.0 4.69)) (1 35) (35.9
10.62) - 5.42 after taxes (assumes 35 tax rate)
24What Does the WACC mean?
- Companies should only invest in projects if they
exceed the WACC - This is true whether acquiring a delivery truck,
building a new store or buying entire company - WACC is very sensitive to changes in interest
rates hence, the power of the Fed - As stock prices increase, the WACC goes down
stock becomes currency (end of 1990s) - WACC is also known as the hurdle rate (minimum
return required on project investments)
25Major Differences Between Accounting and Cash Flow
- Revenue Recognition Channel Stuffing
- Minority Interests and Joint Ventures Impact on
Debt Ratios - Leasing Off Balance Sheet Debt Other Forms
SPEs - Stock Option Accounting Off-Balance Sheet
Equity - Pension Accounting Analyzing Pension Cost Today
with regard to a Liability Tomorrow
26Partial and Controlling Acquisitions
- There is different accounting treatment for
ownership in businesses depending on - Degree of Ownership
- Level of Control or Influence
- Accounting Method Ownership Criterion
- Cost lt20 No significant influence
- Equity 20 50 Significant Influence
- Consolidation gt50 Control
27Accounting Treatment
- Cost Method
- Investments in common, preferred shares and bonds
of other companies held on books at cost as long
as there is no significant influence - Equity Method
- Ability to influence investee operations and
strategic decisions. Investor recognizes
proportionate share of income and net assets of
investee - Consolidation Method
- Ability to control the operations and strategic
decisions of the firm. Account for all assets,
liabilities, revenues and expenses on financial
statements and back less than 100 in minority
interest accounts
28Major Differences Between Accounting and Cash Flow
- Revenue Recognition Channel Stuffing
- Minority Interests and Joint Ventures Impact on
Debt Ratios - Leasing Off Balance Sheet Debt Other Forms
SPEs - Stock Option Accounting Off-Balance Sheet
Equity - Pension Accounting Analyzing Pension Cost Today
with regard to a Liability Tomorrow
29Options Contract Preliminaries
- Intrinsic Value The difference between the
exercise price of the option and the spot price
of the underlying asset - Time Value The value of the option as a result
of remaining contract life and volatility of the
underlying stock and interest rates
Option Value
Intrinsic Value
Time Value
30Market Value of Call Option
Profit
ST
ST - E
Market Value
Time value
Intrinsic value
ST
E
Out-of-the-money
In-the-money
Loss
31History of Stock Option Accounting
- APB 25 (enacted in 1972) and controversy of how
to account for stock compensation has since
continued - Stock options were considered a cost only if the
price of the stock was greater than the exercise
price (or in the money) - If not, then not reported, and hence, not an
expense - An effort was made in the mid-1990s to conform
financial reporting to economic reality (now FASB
123), but was refuted by the opposition ...
mainly technology companies
32History of Stock Option Accounting
- Technology companies argued that
- They could not attract top talent without sizable
option awards to executives while disguising
their true cost - Stock options had no value and thus, had no cost
- The opposition forced FASB to compromise
- FASB 123 became optional
- Permitted use of APB 25 coupled with supplemental
footnote disclosures - Essentially no one was changing to FASB 123,
until more recently
33History of Stock Option Accounting
- FASB 123 designated as preferable GAAP for
accounting for stock options (also mandatory by
International Accounting Standards Board IASB) - If an entity adopts FASB 123, it cannot revert to
APB 25 for financial reporting purposes The
entity must employ ONE set of rules for all stock
compensation programs and plans in effect - APB 25 Key Issue Stock Options are valued at
Intrinsic Value - Market Price less Cost (Strike) Price of the
stock - When difference gt 0, then expense recognized
- Time to Expiration Value not considered an
expense
34Stock Option Example MicrosoftThe New Economy
- From Footnote 15 Had compensation cost for
the Companys stock option and employee stock
purchase plans been determined as prescribed by
FASB 123, pro forma income statements for 2000,
2001, and 2002 would have been as follows
- Stock Option COMPENSATION impact growing on Net
Income - Difference in Net Income in 2000 1.3 billion
(14 impact) - Difference in Net Income in 2002 2.5 billion
(32 impact)
35Stock Option Example MicrosoftThe New Economy
- The weighted average Black-Scholes value of
options granted under the stock options plans
during 2000, 2001, and 2002 was 36.67, 29.31,
and 31.57. Value was estimated using a weighted
average expected life of 6.2 years in 2000, 6.4
years in 2001, and 7.0 years in 2002, no
dividends, volatility of .33 in 2000, .39 in
2001, and .39 in 2002, and risk-free rate of
6.2, 5.3 and 5.4 in 2000, 2001, and 2002.
36If all companies used FASB 123
- If the nations 500 largest companies expensed
the cost of the options, their annual profit
growth from 1995-2000 (during the Tech Boom)
would have been 6 instead of the 9 reported
37Major Differences Between Accounting and Cash Flow
- Revenue Recognition Channel Stuffing
- Minority Interests and Joint Ventures Impact on
Debt Ratios - Leasing Off Balance Sheet Debt Other Forms
SPEs - Stock Option Accounting Off-Balance Sheet
Equity - Pension Accounting Analyzing Pension Cost Today
with regard to a Liability Tomorrow
38Components of Annual Pension Expense
- Service Cost increase in pension obligation due
to employee services performed in the current
year - Interest Cost increase in pension obligation
due to time value of money (uses an assumed
discount rate) - Expected Return on Plan Assets what the plan
sponsors assume the long-term rate of return is
for the plan portfolio
39Standard Poors Core Earnings
- Standard Poors has attempted to set standards
for earnings calculations that more accurately
reflect the earnings generated by the ongoing and
sustainable operations of a company. Certain
items that are included and excluded from Core
Earnings are - Items included and excluded from Core Earnings
- Included
- Employee Stock Option Grant Expenses
- Restructuring Charges from Ongoing Operations
- Write-down of dep./amort. Operating assets
- Pension Costs
- Purchased R D Expenses
- Excluded
- Goodwill Impairment Charges
- Gains/(Losses) from Asset Sales
- Pensions Gains
- Unrealized Gains/(Losses) from hedging activities
- M A related expenses
- Litigation of ins. Settlements and proceeds
40Our Agenda Part II
- Asset Valuation, Cash Flows and Discount Rates
- Asset/Entity Financing
- Merger Acquisition Waves
- Success of Mergers Acquisitions and Motivations
Behind Them - Review of CFO Magazine Articles
41Asset Valuation, Cash Flows and Discount Rates
- The most important concept in finance is present
value (and net present value) - Present value is used to calculate the value of
an asset or interest (in a company) - Present value depends on expected cash flows
discounted at the appropriate risk rate
(remember cost of capital) - The present value is calculated as follows
- The last cash flow includes proceeds from the
terminal value of the asset. Cash flows are
discounted for n periods representing the total
time periods for the cash flows. Modifications
to model can be made for infinite life constant
growth of cash flows (often used in equity
valuations)
42Free Cash Flows To Firm
- Free cash flow to the firm (FCFF) are the sum of
the cash flows to all claimholders in the firm
including stockholders, bondholders, and
preferred stockholders - Two methods to calculate FCFF
- Free Cash Flows to Equity Interest Expense (1
tax rate) Principal Repayments New Debt
Issues Preferred Dividends - Earnings Before Interest and Taxes (1 Tax Rate)
Depreciation Capital Expenditures ?Working
Capital - The primary difference between Free Cash Flow to
Equity and Free Cash Flow to the Firm are cash
flows from debt and other non-equity claims
(preferred dividends)
43Free Cash Flows to Equity
- Free Cash Flows to Equity (FCFE) are used to
value company equity (equity shareholder value)
vs. the entire firm value under FCFF - FCFE are the residual cash flows left over after
meeting interest and principal payments and
providing for capital expenditures to both
maintain existing assets and create new assets
for future growth - FCFE Net Income Depreciation Capital
Spending ?Working Capital Principal
Repayments New Debt Issues - The FCFE is a measure of what the firm can afford
to pay out as dividends.
44Valuation Examples
- Calculate the present value of a bond
- Assume a 30-Year U.S. Government bond has a
coupon rate of 7.5 and the market rate is 7.75.
The value of the bond at issue is - Real estate is valued using the same methodology
- Assume an income-generating piece of real estate
generates the following three years of cash flows
(see following slide) - Year 1 - 63,000 The sales price of the real
- Year 2 - 66,450 estate at the end of 3 years
- Year 3 - 70,085 is 778,717
- At an 11 discount rate, what is the value of
the property? -
45Unleveraged Income Real Estate Value
46Private Equity FCFE Valuation
47Discounting FCFE
- In order to arrive at an estimated value of firm
equity, we need to assume a discount rate - Some factors to consider
- Relatively low margins
- Volatility of income stream
- Concentrated customer base (two customers account
for 58 of revenues) - Private firm (no immediate prospects of IPO)
- Modest financial leverage (5,000,000)
- The risk in firm equity is estimated at 17/year
given these risk factors (See Security Market
Line for comparisons)
48Private Equity Valuation
- Under the FCFE valuation we estimate the
sustainable cash flow to equities, discount it
at the appropriate risk level and adjust for the
long-term growth rate of the cash flows - In this example, we have a 17 discount rate and
approximately 8.5 annual increase in net income - The value of the equity of the firm is
-
- (in thousands)
- Note Private equity firms differ from public
firms in the lack of liquidity the lower
liquidity either needs to be factored into the
discount rate or the value of equity needs to be
discounted for the illiquidity
49Our Agenda Part II
- Asset Valuation, Cash Flows and Discount Rates
- Asset/Entity Financing
- Merger Acquisition Waves
- Success of Mergers Acquisitions and Motivations
Behind Them - Review of CFO Magazine Articles
50Venture Capital Investments
- Main category of private equity investing
- Intent is to grow firm and go public or sell as
exit strategy - Institutional and wealthy investors access VC
through limited partnerships - Capital is committed and called in stages
- High percentage technology, biotechnology and
health/life sciences applications
51Venture Capital Stages of Investing
- Seed stage capital provided for a business idea
product dev./market research - Early stage companies moving into operations
prior to manufacturing - First stage capital to initiate commercial
manufacturing and sales - Second stage capital used for initial expansion
of company already producing and selling a
product - Third stage capital provided for major
expansion (physical plant, marketing, etc.) - Mezzanine (bridge) financing capital provided
to prepare for going public
52Venture Capital Investing Continued
- Seed stage historically is least profitable
(contradicts general risk/return tradeoff) - Most venture capital investing done post-seed
stage - Return hurdle rates are 40 100/year on capital
actually invested in companies - Long-term venture returns to limited partners
approximately 20.5/year (last 20 years) - Difference between individual company targets and
actual net return to investors accounts for
failures and general partner operating expenses
and incentive compensation
53Venture Capital Raised by Year
54Venture Capital Finance Basics
- Professionally managed venture capital primarily
financed using participating preferred
convertible stock (PPCS) - PPCS is convertible stock where, under certain
conditions, the holder receives both the return
of the original investment and a share of
companys equity - Has liquidation and dividend priority over
owners equity so owners maintain incentive to
effectively add value to business - Often has certain level of operational and
strategic control (Board representation, ability
to block mergers, set minimum prices for IPOs,
have first rights on additional financing, etc.)
55A well researched article does a good job showing
the important role that valuation can play in
bankruptcy proceedings.
56(No Transcript)
57(No Transcript)
58(No Transcript)
59(No Transcript)
60Final Notes
- Theres no free lunch in investments returns
are matched with risks - Cash flow much more important than accounting net
income challenge is to translate accounting to
cash flow - Maintain a healthy skepticism when evaluating
financial transactions whether in real estate,
venture capital, distressed debt or corporate
mergers and acquisitions - Dont be afraid to ask management what seems like
a dumb question