Title: Ronald J. Silva
1Short Sea Shipping for California and the West
Coast - A Complete Door to Door System -
By Ronald J. Silva President/Owner Westar
Transport
Matthew P. Tedesco, Ph.D. Technical and
Management Consulting
Office (800) 800-3551 rsilva_at_westartransport.com
2Contents
- Who is Westar Transport?
- Why is Westar Transport Interested?
- What is Short Sea Shipping (SSS)?
- Proposed Westar Transport SSS Model
- What are the Benefits?
- What are the Challenges?
- Reference Material
- Roll-On/Roll-Off Vessel Overview
- CCDOTT Project Overview
- Existing Operations
Westar Transport
Westar Transport
3Who is Westar Transport?
- Westar Transport has moved truckload freight over
the 11 Western States with an emphasis on
California and the West Coast for over 24 years. - Company operations include dispatch, billing,
accounting, shop services, and marketing. - Westar Transports primary yard and offices are
in Selma, CA. Currently there are 64 full time
employees, which include 50 company drivers,
operational and maintenance staff and 15
independent contractors (owner-operator trucks). - The companys success is a result of its
emphasis on customer services and safety. - Westar Transport sees Short Sea Shipping as the
solution to critical problems facing the trucking
industry today - Driver shortages
- Congestion and lost revenue
- Increasing concerns over emissions
- Increasing concerns over safety, security, and
liability - The challenge of increasing freight volumes
We View Short Sea Shipping from the Perspective
of a Door to Door Transportation Enterprise
4What is Short Sea Shipping?
Northern California 150 mile terminal service
area
- Short Sea Shipping is the diversion of domestic
and international cargos that move by highway
from major metropolitan areas to major
metropolitan areas by water along coastal routes. - - It is also the diversion of International
cargos from large municipal ports to the smaller
ports closer to the cargos final destination.
This provides port congestion relief, and takes
trucks off the Highway between the ports.
Fresno
Southern California 150 mile terminal service
area
5West Coast Short Sea Shipping Model
- Thousands of trucks that currently run on the
Highway daily between these port service areas
could be diverted off the Highways between them. - Any type of trailer can be routed onto the ships
or barges. - Ships will provide next day service in 400 mile
markets, matching todays truck service. - Ships will carry 600 to 700 trailers each.
Seattle
Portland
Northern California
Humbolt Bay
An estimated 4,000 to 8,000 trucks per day could
be diverted in the start-up model
Southern California
Currently 10,000 trucks per day travel into L.A.
and 10,000 trucks travel out of L.A. each day.
Westar Transport
6The OperationNorth to South Model
- Trucks work in 100 to 150 mile radiuses picking
up and delivering daily freight. - Trailers of all types are moved into the terminal
where they are loaded onto ships. - The ships move down the coast to the opposite
terminal and the process starts all over again. - Truck operation will reduce empty miles driven.
- Any type of trailer with any cargo can go onto
the ships.
Loaded
Loaded
Loaded
Pittsburg, CA
Empty
Empty
Empty
Empty
We will create truck load saturated areas,
producing more capacity to the shippers.
7The OperationNorth and South Modal
When over flow cargo reaches a point where ships
can be filled, we then bring more ships into
service and take the trucks off the roads. Short
Sea Shipping can grow with it.
- Cargo moves by truck when ship is full.
- Drivers move to and from a drop yard back to the
origin terminal. - Drivers still go home daily.
- Drivers can be based out of any terminal.
- Gives drivers the opportunity to relocate and
stay with the same employer.
Northern CA
Each driver makes two trip
Each driver makes one trip
It is a system that can easily grow to meet
freight capacity demand.
When the day shift driver ends his shift, the
night shift driver uses the same truck.
Better utilizing assets
8Loading a Ro-Ro Ship
9How the barge feeder will pull containers from
all terminals. At the Port of Los Angeles and
Port of Long Beach.
Roll-on Roll-off terminal
International containers sit in port for 6 to 10
days.
International containers can move by short haul
truck under bond (like off dock rail) to a Ro/Ro
terminal to be loaded onto barges. This will
pool all the available volumes from all the
terminals. The containers are consolidated on
the barge going to the smaller ports. Barges are
used where time is not critical, barges are
cheaper but slower.
10How the barge feeder will pull containers from
all terminals. At the Port of Oakland
- Containers may be consolidated by short haul
clean fuel trucks from all terminals and moved by
barge to Sacramento, Stockton, and Pittsburgh for
Los Angeles bound freight. This can be done using
2007 truck models with less diesel or LNG. - Dedicated water front for three barges will be
required for the systems to work properly - This system will move containers faster from the
terminals, providing through put, and will
provide increased capacity at the container
terminals.
Stockton
Sacramento
Pittsburgh
11Port of Long Beach
Coastal Ro-Ro Ships
San Diego
Port Hueneme
12The Barge Feeder Operation ModelNorthern
California
Port Pittsburg
Oakland
Barges carry 512 trailers or containers on
chassis 2-Barges per day (round trips)2,048 daily
512,000 annually.
Westar Transport
Designated water front areas will be necessary if
a barge system is to exist.
13The Barge Feeder OperationSouthern Model
Pollution Reduction 6,150 tons of NOX/ 15 tons of
Particulate Matter
Pollution Reduction 200 tons NOX / 15 tons of
Particulate Matter Annually
LA/LB Port
Barges carry 512 trailers or containers on
chassis 2-Barges per day (round trips)2,048 daily
512,000 annually.
Pollution Reduction 250 tons of NOX/ 15 ton of
Particulate Matter Annually
Westar Transport
Barges can be loaded at a roll-on roll-off
terminal, trailers are then moved by short haul
trucks and pull volume from all terminals.
14Why build short sea shipping?
It reduces congestion, pollution, and improves
highway safety.
- The Benefits
- Short Sea Shipping reduces congestion and
pollution by removing thousands of long haul
trucks off the highway, and in doing so will
increase highway safety. - Reduces Green house gases in the Central Valley
and through out California - Reduces dependence on foreign oil by using less
diesel daily. - Short Sea Shipping can be used for an Emergency
Relief System on the West Coast. - A local truck operation
- - Uses half the truck drivers required in over
the road system. Will help fill part of the
national truck driver shortage that is scheduled
to increase in the next ten years. - - Short Sea Shipping takes long haul drivers and
turns them into local drivers. - 1) Use small trucks and trailers with spread
axles that can haul more weight on heavy loads,
small trucks will eliminate 1 out of every 10
loads shipped. - 2) Local trucks work in shorter routes allowing
the opportunity to convert trucks to cleaner
alternative fuels like LNG. - 3) Local Drivers get home daily, and do not have
to sleep in the truck allowing them better rest,
allows better family and community involvement. - 4) Smaller local trucks have more visibility and
shorter turning radius. These trucks will be
safer in traffic and on city streets. - 5) Empty flat beds can be double stacked on the
ships when moving empty, taking more trucks off
the highway. - 6) Divers will work 1-shift and go home. The
trucks, with a fresh driver each shift, can work
day and night if the customers allow it.
15Why build short sea shipping?
- Benefits (continued)
- - Reducing pollution
- By diverting thousands of trucks off the highway
thousands of tons of emission are removed from
those areas the highways run through. The ships
will be the cleanest that can be built and
emissions are moved out to sea where trade winds
can better disperse them. - An estimated 4,000 to 8,000 tons of NOX
and 200 to 400 tons of PM can be removed annually.
- Increase highway safety By removing
thousand of trucks daily from the highways along
coastal routes, lives will be saved due to
the reduction in truck related accidents.
An estimated 200 to 400 lives per year could be
saved.
16Why Pursue Short Sea Shipping?
Cost of expanding U.S. Highway system is
significant
Existing Transportation System Inadequate!
- More Congestion
- Increased Pollution
- Infrastructure Inadequate
- Truck Driver Shortages
- Hampers Economic Growth
- Increased Accidents
- New highway cost 32 Million per lane mile
- Expanding I-5 to provide one single lane 335
miles running North and South10.7 Billion! 4200
trucks with safe distance creates 335 miles of
lane - A Short Sea shipping start up cost 80 less and
provides the same amount of highway lane. - New interchange costs over 100 Million each
Adding Lanes is Costly, and Only Mitigates
Congestion Short Sea Shipping is Less Expensive
and has a Broader Impact. Short Sea Shipping is
the only system that does not interfere with the
current systems while under construction.
17Westar Transports Perspective
- Available truckload capacity continues to be a
primary concern - Trade will double in the next 10 to 15 years
- Trucking struggles to meet the challenge
- hours-of-service, 6 to 9 rate hikes (each year
predicted) - continually rising fuel costs
- shortage of qualified drivers (bad today worse
tomorrow) - driver pay package increases
- Emissions restrictions
- Truck and rail will lack adequate capacity to
meet the challenge - Fuel costs continue to rise
- Highway congestion will continue to escalate
need alternative modes - Port congestion will continue to escalate
market for feeders will grow - Environmental concerns will continue to shape
transportation - Drivers will continue to leave the industry
- Logistics costs will continue to grow as a
percentage of product costs
We Need More Options!
Short Sea Shipping is needed in order for the
logistics system to grow to meet the current and
future demand
18Challenges We Face
- Secure funding to finish the on going study work
to determine cost of operation and social
benefits. - Modify Harbor Maintenance Tax (HR3319) so it will
not collect on domestic cargos. We need all
California Members of Congress to Support HR3319.
Congressman Jim Costa has agreed to co-sponsor
the bill. - Secure financing for start-up. If the operation
will not produce sufficient returns for investors
to fully fund the start-up the state or federal
governments will need to help fund the Start-up
so the investors will participate, or loan an
operator funding. - Find available and financially feasible ports and
labor, especially in Southern California and
Northern California. - The government should not subsidize short sea
shipping with-out subsidizing the trucking it
will compete with.
The ships, barges, trucks, trailers, ports, and
the cargos already exist.
Short Sea Shipping is the missing link to the
supply chain.
19Dual-Use
Roll-on Roll-off vessels can be used in time of
need and during peace time to move military
cargo. Vessels can also move goods in and out of
areas when natural disasters or terrorist attacks
make roads inaccessible.
Ro-Ro Terminals are Strategic Terminals! Ro-Ro
Vessels Provide Benefits to Military
20Ro-Ro OperationsAlready Successful in Niche
Markets
21TOTE Existing Roll-On/Roll-Off (Ro/Ro)
- Conventional displacement vessel
- Length Overall 839' 0
- Beam 118' 0
- Maximum Draft 29' 6
- Speed 24 kts
- Trailer Capacity 600 F.E.U.
- Auto Capacity 200
- Cargo Deck Area 360,000 sq. ft.
- Load/Unload time less than 9 hours
- Cost per vessel 175 M (2002 dollars)
- Two vessels, NASSCO, 2002/2003
Short Sea Shipping is Already Successful in Niche
Markets
22TOTE In-Port Ro-Ro Operations
Fast Turn-Around at Ports is Critical Ro-Ro
Terminals are Simple and Efficient. In the study
we will look at slips so both sides of the ship
can be unloaded at the same time.
23Crowley and Trailer BridgeRo-Ro Barges
- Largest Ro-Ro Barges in the World
- Triple-Deck
- 736 x 104
- 512 FEU capacity
- 340 53 trailer
- Travel at 9 to 10 knots
- Serve Florida to Puerto Rico market
24 Study
25- The Center for the Commercial Deployment of
Transportation Technologies (CCDoTT) - Chartered university center at California State
University, Long Beach (CSULB) - Partnership of academic institutions, government,
and commercial corporations - CCDoTT project is a program operated by the CSULB
Foundation - Implemented to enable the Department of Defense
(DOD), through the United States Transportation
Command (USTRANSCOM), and the Department of
Transportation (DOT), through the Maritime
Administration (MARAD) and other participants to
leverage advanced transportation technologies - Mission
- Leverage advanced transportation technologies
including emerging High-Speed Ship systems and
Agile Port Terminal systems in solving defense
and commercial transportation infrastructure
problems - Conduct sponsor applied research and development
in support of defense and commercial
transportation infrastructure initiatives - Provide a bilateral technology transfer/dual use
bridge between the DOD and commercial industry - The prime contractor is the CSULB Foundation.Â
USTRANSCOM and MARAD have oversight
responsibility for the CCDoTT project. MARAD
serves as the contracting entity for the CCDoTT
project and is responsible for authorizing
project and financial activities. MARAD
collaborates with USTRANSCOM to ensure that
programs are compatible with commercial and
military related objectives.
26- Westar is Teamed with MANALYTICS for Fy-05
funding (300K) - Market Data
- Economic and Transportation Systems Model
- Ship/Barge Design(s)
- Port Access
- Emissions
- Financing Plan
- Enabling Technologies
- CCDOTT Team
- CDI Marine (Band, Lavis and Associates) Naval
Architects and Marine Engineers - Westar Transport Trucking and Logistics
- National Steel and Shipbuilding Company (NASSCO)
Builders of TOTE vessels - Matthew P. Tedesco Technical and Management
consultant - Scully Capital Financial models and access to
financing - Manalytics Market data (International to
Domestic Interface) - San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District
27West Coast Short Sea Shipping
- There are FOUR possibilities of how short sea
shipping can be funded and built here in
California and the West Coast. The study will
look at the result of these four scenarios - Short Sea Shipping can be built with 100
investors money. The investors will demand at
least a 15 profit each year. There are currently
3 interested investors, but they must see the
study results first. ( They will not fund a
study.) - The study may prove that Short Sea Shipping will
not create an adequate return on investment of
15 as required by investors, and will need the
publics help to provide the funds for the
start-up modal. (Subsidize) If marine industry is
subsidized it would be un-fair to the trucking
industry. - Federal and State loans may be necessary to
provide the start-up cost to the operator. This
would allow the system to have a low to no
interest rate on a loan that will help short sea
shipping lower operating costs. The loan can be
viewed as the publics investment or trade in
return for the social benefits. This chosen
operator should agree to commit 90 of their
bottom line in profits over the life of the loan
to growth, to keep up with freight growths
demand. This would not subsidize short sea
shipping, and would be fair to trucking and all
other transportation industries as the system is
built. - Short Sea Shipping must be built, but in the case
that California doesnt think it will save money
for the state in roads and lives, leaving it only
in concept and study will prove More air
pollution, more congestion, and continued
accidents that are up to 200 lives lost a year.
This will increase the current work load of the
Council of Government, Business, Transportation,
and Housing, and Cal-Trans because they dont
have the available funds or ability to keep up
with the demand of Californias population, or
the future in increased cargo volumes.
Westar Supports Our Troops and Red Fridays
Each Friday we wear RED in Support of Our Troops.
Ron silva CEO- Westar transport 9220 e. South
ave. /Selma, ca. 93662 P (800) 800-3551/F (559)
834-3133 E rsilva_at_westartransport.Com Please
visit us at www.Westartransport.Com