Title: Fund Administration in Europe.
1Fund Administration in Europe.
Deloitte Touche House Thursday, 4 December 2008
2Agenda.IntroductionRonan Nolan Head of
Investment Management Practice2008 Survey
ResultsBrian Forrester Partner, Investment
Management Managing in a DownturnDerek
Moriarty Partner, Financial Services QA
3Fund Administration in Europe.2008 Survey
ResultsBrian Forrester, Partner, Investment
Management 4 December 2008
4Contents
- About the Survey
- The Credit Crunch
- Future Marketplace
- Challenges and Issues
- Final Thoughts
5Why was the survey conducted?
- In 2006 and 2007 Deloitte carried out a survey of
the Fund Administration community in Ireland, in
order to obtain an understanding of the key
business issues facing the industry - This year, the survey was extended to include
fund administrators in Luxembourg and the Channel
islands (Jersey, Guernsey and the Isle of Man) - The results have been reported on a Europe wide
basis, with jurisdictional differences being
highlighted where appropriate - The survey was carried out in November 2008
6Who participated in the survey?
- We had responses from 63 companies providing fund
administration services across Europe - The respondent Fund Administrators currently
service nearly 4 trillion of assets which we
believe represents approximately 70 of the total
industry in those countries - Summary of various sources
- Comments contained in the findings and analysis
that follows have not been attributed to survey
participants to maintain confidentiality - Not all participants answered all questions
- No part of this report may be reproduced or
distributed without the prior written permission
of Deloitte Touche
1485bn
3873bn
7Asset profile of respondents
- It is difficult to obtain consistent data on
assets under administration (AUA) in each
country, and the table opposite reflects the mix
of assets between alternative and traditional
assets as confirmed by respondents - This demonstrates clearly that the Channel
Islands administration companies focus almost
exclusively on alternative asset classes - Luxembourg and Ireland have a large base in
traditional assets, although alternative assets
have been growing in both. The responses from
Ireland in particular conflict with data provided
by the IFIA which suggests alternative assets
account for approximately 60 of the total
Source IFIA Statistics September 2008
8Alternative assets mix
- The mix of alternative assets shows a clear
distinction between jurisdiction - The vast majority of AUA in Ireland are in hedge
funds and fund of funds - In Luxembourg the main asset class is fund of
funds, and overall there is a greater mix of
product - The Isle of Man also has a good mix of product,
whilst Guernsey and Jersey are dominated by
Private Equity and Property Assets - The mix of product has evolved over time and is a
combination of the nature of expertise available
and the local investment products
9Contents
- About the Survey
- The Credit Crunch
- Future Marketplace
- Challenges Issues
- Final Thoughts
10What a difference a year makes
- In October 2007 we asked administrators in
Ireland Do you believe the credit crunch will
have a material impact on your business in the
short term and long term. Responses were as
follows- - 12 months on it is clear that the impact of the
credit crunch has indeed been significant. The
administrators who responded in 2007 were not
alone in their prediction last year, and the pace
and impact of the credit crunch has been far more
severe than most could have anticipated
11Direct Impact
- We asked participants how the impact of the
credit crunch has been felt - By a clear margin the most significant impact
has been the reduction in AUA which impacts
directly on fees earned - This is also impacted by the No. 4 issue of a
reduction in new funds launching - There has been a move towards liquid investments
in money market funds which typically earn lower
basis point fees - Margins already under pressure due to rising
costs are now being squeezed even further - Managing liquidity issues (redemption gates, lock
ups, sidepockets) is the number 2 issue. This
can be very time consuming - The approach to investment valuation is also a
significant issue
No.1
No.2
No.3
No.4
12Reduction in New Hires
- 83 of respondents noted that their head count
plans had changed - For an industry that has traditionally been a
heavy recruiter of graduates and experienced
resources, these statistics will be of concern in
the wider community as a recessionary period is
entered - Not only is there a significant decrease in
expected hires, 14 of the 63 respondents stated
that they were looking at redundancy and
redeployment programmes. This is spread across
all jurisdictions - It is clear that industry will have to find
different ways to service clients without adding
head count
16.9
83.1
13Contents
- About the Survey
- The Credit Crunch
- Future Marketplace
- Challenges Issues
- Final Thoughts
14The Future Marketplace
15Outlook for Growth
- In 2008, 65 of respondents expect their revenue
to fall or grow by less than 10 - In 2009 this increases to 70
- This compares with the predictions of the 2007
Ireland survey where 75 expected growth greater
than 20 in 2008 and 2009 - However, 72 of respondents expect revenue growth
in 2008 and 76 expect growth in 2009 which shows
a certain resilience in the industry in the face
of significant challenges
12.9
37.1
21.4
28.6
12.7
16.9
46.5
23.9
16Business Confidence
- We asked respondents whether they were positive
or negative over their outlook for their business
over the short and longer term - In the short term 44 of respondents had a
pessimistic view - On a 2 year view however 83 of respondents have
an optimistic view - This timeframe is consistent with most
commentators
25.4
43.7
31.0
1.4
15.5
83.1
17Contents
- About the Survey
- The Credit Crunch
- Future Marketplace
- Challenges Issues
- Final Thoughts
18Update on key issues arising from 2007 Ireland
survey
- We asked respondents to consider whether the key
findings from the 2007 Ireland survey were likely
to be more or less of an issue in 2008 - 84 of respondents said that cost containment
would be more of an issue - 67 felt that maintaining service quality was
more of an issue - Only 29 felt that managing internal expansion
will be more significant - IT enhancements remains a key issue to keep pace
with the industry
19Margin Pressure Key Issues arising 2008
Market Forces
Margin Pressures
Reduced Income
High Fixed Costs
Maintain Service Quality
20The Need for Change
- The landscape is changing and businesses need to
move with the times - Re-evaluate service offerings and align
operations with client needs - Review individual client margins. Assets dont
always equal profit - Strategic client de-selection
- Resources
- Productivity Improvement opportunity to
implement changes on the long finger - 71 already implemented process standardisation
- 46 in the process of implementing improved work
practices - They say you should invest in a downturn..
21Expected Cost Savings
- 63 of respondents expect annual costs savings in
the region of 6-15 - In the current market of falling assets is this
enough to maintain profitability? - Need to balance short term cost reduction with
the expected upturn in 2 years
Short Term
Long Term
22The People Agenda
- It is interesting to note that despite the
downturn experienced hire recruitment remains the
number one HR challenge. Good people are still
hard to find! - Strategic hiring
- This is closely followed by retention, although
attrition levels expected to fall - Increasing compensation is still an important
challenge, although less so that in previous
years - 14 respondents noted redundancy and redeployment
as a key issue
No.1
No.2
No.3
No.4
23Outlook for Attrition Levels
- The industry has suffered from high levels of
staff turnover in recent years - 85 of respondents expect attrition levels to
stay the same or reduce in 2008, rising to 87 in
2009 - Reduced attrition should allow for higher levels
of productivity - Every cloud has a silver lining!
14.7
52.9
32.4
13.1
44.3
42.6
24Outlook for Offshoring/Outsourcing
- Both outsourcing and offshoring are expected to
increase in the future - Evolution towards Global Operating Model
- 78 of respondents have already started
offshoring - Main driver for outsourcing is to deliver cost
savings - Procurement not strategic mindset
- 70 of organisations who have outsourced
operations believe they could be achieving more
from their outsourcing arrangements
4.3
50.7
44.9
7.5
55.2
37.3
Source Strategic Outsourcing for Success,
Deloitte 2008
25Use of systems
- The use of specialist 3rd party systems are
prevalent across the industry - 85 of respondents use a third party fund
accounting platform - 67 of respondents intend to make significant
system improvements in the next year
26Contents
- About the Survey
- The Credit Crunch
- Future Marketplace
- Challenges and Issues
- Final Thoughts
27Final Thoughts
- The market place is different to 12 months ago.
The impact of the credit crunch was far more
severe than predicted, and the future for the
fund administration industry is uncertain. All
European jurisdictions are feeling the pinch and
short term sentiment is negative. - In recent years the alternative asset classes
have grown faster than traditional asset classes
a situation that is predicted to reverse.
Administrators who have invested in people and
systems to support growth in the alternative
space may need to re-assess. - Falling revenues have led to significant pressure
on margins which in turn is requiring a
significant focus on cost. Headcount is under
pressure, and a number of redundancy programs
have been announced. This is likely to increase
in the short term. - Falling revenue does not always lead to a falling
workload, and the reduced workforce will need to
maintain the same service levels as previously.
This will require administrators to look at
process improvements to increase operating
efficiency. - A number of operational projects have been
deferred in recent years owing to client demands.
The downturn may allow administrators to
undertake some of the improvements that are
necessary, and be better positioned when the
upturn comes. - But..on a 2 year horizon administrators are
positive about their prospects, which suggests
the above challenges can be overcome.
28Fund Administration in Europe.Managing in a
DownturnDerek Moriarty, Partner, Financial
Services4th December 2008
29Recap The Future Marketplace?
30Need to balance strategic with tactical
initiatives
The Nature of Enterprise Effectiveness
Tactical Improvements
Strategic Redefinition
Operational Efficiency
Streamlining the Cost Base
- Business Scope (market / customer choices)
Creating a low cost Operating Model
Increasing benefits sustainability
- Leverage lower cost locations
- Remove bespoke services (unless cost to serve can
be justified)
Quick Wins
- Simplify standard processes
- Reduce error rates (six sigma Lean techniques)
- Process improvements,
- ( e.g. activity reduction)
- Strategic sourcing
- (e.g. outsource IT development)
- Reduce headcount and increase span of control
- Policies procedures
- (e.g. corporate expense reduction)
- Known inefficiencies / low value tasks
- Recruitment freeze
- External spend review
Increasing implementation time costs
Key Success Factors
- Establish the cost base
- Apply rigorous process
- Balance timing and scale of benefits
- Ensure senior management commitment
- Engage the business
- Generate savings initiatives (use a variety of
techniques identify more saving than the target)
31Outline Approach
Phase 1 Establish Baseline and Size Opportunities
Phase 2 Define Improvement Recommendations and
Develop High-level Action Plans
Phase 3 Implement Action Plans
High-level Action Plans for Key Areas
Recommendations for Prioritised Opportunities
Opportunity Assessment
Performance Mgmt, Metrics Tools
Baseline Cost Model
Quantified Savings and Costs
Confirmed Change Management Plan
Service Delivery Model Analysis
Prioritised Opportunities
Immediate Improvement Opportunities
Project Launch Workshop
Opportunity Gating Process
Executive Dashboard
Savings Tracker
Detailed Implementation Action Plans
Benchmarking
Phase 1
Phase 2
Phase 3
- Opportunity assessment - Opportunity
prioritisation - Launch quick win opportunities
(no regrets) - Anticipated benefits and
costs to achieve - Resource requirements
- Change management and stakeholder alignment
plans - Detailed action plans for
implementation
- Baseline observations - Service delivery
model observations - Benchmarking (internal /
external) - Immediate cost savings
opportunities - Customer retention pipeline
management
Key Output
32Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu is a Swiss Verein
(association), and, as such, neither Deloitte
Touche Tohmatsu nor any of its member firms has
any liability for each other's acts or omissions.
Each member firm is a separate and independent
legal entity operating under the names
"Deloitte," "Deloitte Touche," "Deloitte Touche
Tohmatsu," or other, related names. The services
described herein are provided by the member firms
and not by the Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Verein.