Title: What
1Whats Emerging in Emerging Markets The New
Frontier
Texas Investment Portfolio Symposium March 24,
2006 Lawrence Speidell, CFA 5036 Founder
Co-Chief Investment Officer Ondine Asset
Management
2Whats Emerging
- History
- The Past is Prologue
- Globalization
- Demographics
- Internet
- Jobs
- Middle-Class
- Risk
- Diversification and Risk are Opposites
- Optimism
- The World is NOT going to _at_?!! in a hand-basket
3Emerging Countries Under 10,000 GDP/capita
4Emerging Countries Under 10,000 GDP/capita
5Frontier Countries Not in MSCI Emerging Markets
6HISTORY Emerging Countries Euphoria The
Golden Age of Emerging Markets 1989-1995
- Iron Curtain falls
- Communism Discredited
- Politicians Businessmen committed to Reforms
transparency - Rising Capital flows
- Falling Capital Costs
- Economic Growth
- Rising Liquidity
- Falling Volatility
7Emerging Countries Disappointment The Age of
the Innocents 1995-1998
- Crony capitalism
- Currency pegs
- Inadequate regulation
- 25 year old investment bankers
8Emerging Countries Disillusionment Age of
the Cynics 2000 - ?
- Peso Crisis, Asian Crisis, Russian Crisis,
Brazilian Crisis, Venezuelan Crisis, Argentine
Crisis, Turkish Crisis - Corruption Cronyism
- Rising Volatility
- Falling Liquidity
- Rising Correlations
9History
10History
11History
12History
Cuyahoga River 1971
13 History
14 History
15History Progress
16History Progress
17History Progress
The GUM Department Store 1991
18History Progress
The GUM Department Store 1991 and 2002
19History Progress
20History Progress
21(No Transcript)
22Shanghai The Maglev Train
23Chinathe Country
24Chinathe Country
25Pudong
26Night Life
27History Progress
Russia
2000
Bulgaria
1990
1990
1970
28Globalization Let there be light.
29Globalization Demographics
30Globalization Urbanization
Urban 2005 2030 China 40.5 60.5 India 28.7
41.4
31Globalization Education
32(No Transcript)
33Globalization Education
Source Jeremy Siegel, 2006
34Globalization Jobs
35Globalization Jobs
Hourly Labor Costs Mexico 1/6 U.S. China
1/6 Mexico
36What are our Products?
37(No Transcript)
38Globalization Quality Products
World Class Production
39Globalization Quality Products
40Globalization - You Call, We Haul. . . .
41Education Jobs Middle Class
42 Education Jobs Middle Class
43(No Transcript)
44Education Jobs Middle Class
45Education Jobs Middle Class
India Passenger Car Sales
(Thousands)
1,000
900
Rate drops below 20
800
700
Introduced Financing
600
500
400
300
200
100
-
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
00
01
02
03
04
Source Citigroup India
As of 30-Nov-04
46A Virtuous Circle Inter-emerging market trade
What China needs
Source Deutsche Bank, 7 December 2006
47A Virtuous Circle Inter-emerging market trade
Africa has to sell
Zambia DRC
Angola Cameroon E. Guinea Gabon Nigeria DRC
Ghana Niger South Africa Zimbabwe
Mauritania South Africa
South Africa
E. Guinea
Source Deutsche Bank, 7 December 2006
48A Virtuous Circle Inter-emerging market trade
Africa is upstream of China
US bn
Source CEIC, Deutsche Bank, December 2006
49Risk
50Risk Standard Deviation
51Risk Standard Deviation
52Risk Diversification
53Risk Diversification
54Risk Diversification
55Risk Diversification
56Risk Diversification
57Risk Diversification
58Risk Valuations
59Risk Valuations
60Optimism Tyranny of the News
Source Human Security Centre
http//www.humansecurityreport.info/HSR2005_PDF/Pa
rt1.pdf
61Optimism Tyranny of the News
Source Human Security Centre, UBC
62Optimism Tyranny of the News
Source Human Security Centre, UBC
63Optimism Fewer Conflicts
Source Human Security Centre, UBC
64International Wars are low Historically
Source Human Security Centre, UBC
65Fewer CrisesFewer Deaths
Source Human Security Centre, UBC
66Genocide and Politicide are down
Source Human Security Centre, UBC
67More Peacekeepers and Tribunals
Source Human Security Centre, UBC
68Optimism Democracy Prosperity reduce War
Source Human Security Centre, UBC
69Emerging Countries Under 10,000 GDP/capita
70Economic Freedom The Heritage Foundation
71Economic Freedom The Heritage Foundation
72Economic Freedom Frontier Markets are
improving 2000-2007 Developed 3.6, Emerging
-0.8, Frontier 2.0
Frontier Market Average
Emerging Market Average
73Economic FreedomThe Heritage Foundation
74Corruption is a problem in many Frontier Markets,
but it is also a problem in Russia, the
Philippines, Argentina, India and China And
frontier counties are improving scores up 3.9
from 2000 to 2005, versus a drop of 0.1 in
emerging markets
Source Transparency International, 2006
75Red TapeEfficient is Good. Improvements in
Indonesia, Peru, India, China, Mexico Czech
Republic
2005
2006
765 Opportunities?
DEVELOPED
DEVELOPED
775 Opportunities?
DEVELOPED
DEVELOPEDC
785 Opportunities?
795 Opportunities?
DEVELOPED
DEVELOPED
80Optimism Determination
81Optimism Determination
82Optimism Determination
83Optimism Determination
84Optimism Determination
85Optimism Determination
86Optimism Determination
87Spirit
88Whats Emerging in Emerging Markets
- History
- The Past is Prologue
- Globalization
- Demographics
- Internet
- Jobs
- Middle-Class
- Risk
- Diversification and Risk are Opposites
- Optimism
- The World is NOT going to _at_?!! in a hand-basket
89Tomorrow is Coming Fast
90The Beauty Contest
- Professional investment may be likened to those
newspaper competitions in which the competitors
have to pick out the six prettiest faces from a
hundred photographs, -
- the prize being awarded to the competitor whose
choice most nearly corresponds to the average
preferences of the competitors as a whole
91The Beauty Contest The General Theory John
Maynard Keynes, 1936
- so that each competitor has to pick, not the
faces which he himself finds prettiest, but those
which he thinks likeliest to catch the fancy of
the other competitors, all of whom are looking at
the problem from the same point of view. - It is not a case of choosing those which, to the
best of one's judgment, are really the prettiest,
nor even those which average opinion genuinely
thinks the prettiest. We have reached the third
degree where we devote our intelligences to
anticipating what average opinion expects average
opinion to be.
92Terrorism is up
WTC
African Embassies
Source Human Security Centre, UBC
93Emerging Countries Under 10,000 GDP/capita
94(No Transcript)
95(No Transcript)
96Emerging Countries Under 10,000 GDP/capita
97Emerging Countries Under 10,000 GDP/capita
98Emerging Countries
99(No Transcript)
100(No Transcript)
101(No Transcript)
102(No Transcript)
103(No Transcript)
104(No Transcript)
105(No Transcript)
106(No Transcript)
107(No Transcript)
108The Investment Case Why Africa?
Once a vicious circle now a virtuous circle
- Increasing political stability
- Highly varied economic development
- Investing windfall commodity gains prudently
- Corporate governance focus on sustainable
development projects
An unexamined opportunity
Map source http//www.cia.gov/cia/publications/fa
ctbook/geos/tu.html
109The Investment Case Why Africa?
Introducing Africa
Africa 7 Emerging Europe Africa as a of Emerging Europe
Population (mns) 359.8 239.9 150.0
GDP (US bns) 560.8 1,657.7 33.8
Africa 7 represents the 7 countries on this map,
Emerging Europe is Czech, Hungary, Poland,
Russia and Turkey Source EIU, OECD, IMF,
Bloomberg, Citigroup, World Bank
110The Investment Case Why Africa?
Growth potential
of Global GDP
of Global Population
Market Cap/GDP (rhs)
The next frontier
GDP in Purchasing Power Parity Market Cap
as at January 2007 Source World Bank, Bloomberg,
Figures as at end December 2005
111The Investment Case Why Africa?
Improving political and economic framework
Country Regular, non-violent elections Sustainable development Investable exchanges and attracts foreign listings
Botswana ? ? ?
Egypt ? ?
Ghana ? ?
Kenya ? ? ?
Lesotho ?
Malawi ?
Mauritius ?
Morocco ? ?
Mozambique ?
Namibia ?
Nigeria ? ?
South Africa ? ? ?
Tanzania ?
Source Charlemagne Capital
112The Investment Case Why Africa?
Growth is accelerating
Strong long-term growth
Figures are an average for Sub-Saharan
Africa Source IMF, September 2006
113The Investment Case Why Africa?
Africa is upstream of China
US bn
Source CEIC, Deutsche Bank, December 2006
114The Investment Case Why Africa?
What China needs
Source Deutsche Bank, 7 December 2006
115The Investment Case Why Africa?
Africa has to sell
Zambia DRC
Angola Cameroon E. Guinea Gabon Nigeria DRC
Ghana Niger South Africa Zimbabwe
Mauritania South Africa
South Africa
E. Guinea
Source Deutsche Bank, 7 December 2006
116The Investment Case Why Africa?
Re-investing commodity wealth
Self-funded investment growth
Figures are an average for Sub-Saharan
Africa Source IMF, September 2006
117The Investment Case Why Africa?
Rising income levels
Increasing Consumption
Figures are an average for Sub-Saharan
Africa Source IMF, September 2006
118The Investment Case Why Africa?
Inflation moderating
Improving economic stability
excluding Zimbabwe Source IMF, September 2006
119The Investment Case Why Africa?
Improving fiscal balances and reserves
Improving fiscal management
Fiscal Balances are for Sub-Saharan Africa,
excluding grants and shown as of GDP
Reserves are shown as months of imports of goods
and services for Sub-Saharan Africa Source IMF,
September 2006
120The Investment Case Why Africa?
Repaying external debt
Improving governance
Figures are an average for Sub-Saharan
Africa Source IMF, September 2006
121The Investment Case Why Africa?
Case Study Nigeria oil windfall gains
- Excess crude account captures gains above
US40/bbl - Size estimated to be US42bn, equivalent to 35
of GDP - Earmarked for specific infrastructure projects
(rail, roads and ports)
Following Russias example
Source Citigroup, November 2006
122The Investment Case Why Africa?
Case Study South Africa speed of income
redistribution
Real GDP CAGR (95 05) 3.3.
Income redistribution at faster pace
Proportion of population in each category
High relative living standards
Low relative living standards
Growing middle class
Note LSM living standard measure the higher
the number, the better the standard of
living Source SAARF, UBS, January 2006
123CCL investment process applied to Africa
Ongoing portfolio construction
- Screening down
- approx 7 countries
- approx 450 companies
- approx 130 companies
- 50 60 companies
- 20 30 companies
Current coverage South Africa, Egypt, Morocco
Off-shore Africa 70 40 10
Development steps Identifying countries Liquidity
screen Qualitative screen CCL Universe Model
portfolio
Disciplined screening
124The Investment Case Why Africa?
Investable universe initial screening
- Markets must meet threshold criteria including
- Security of ownership
- Currency convertibility
- Custody
- Taxation
- Liquidity
125The Investment Case Why Africa?
Investable universe Geographic breakdown
Companies with a market capitalisation in excess
of US 100mn
Country No. Investable companies
Botswana 10
Cote d'Ivoire 3
Egypt 70
Ghana 10
Kenya 20
Mauritius 10
Morocco 30
Nigeria 30
South Africa 170
Tunisia 10
Zambia 5 10
Zimbabwe 10
Offshore listed 50 100
Total opportunity set 428 483
excludes offshore listed companies Total Market
Capitalisation US 500bn
Large investment universe
Source Bloomberg
126The Investment Case Why Africa?
Investable universe Sector breakdown
Companies with a market capitalisation in excess
of US 100mn
More than just a commodity story
excludes offshore listed companies Source
Bloomberg
127Economic FreedomTha Frazer Institute
128Optimism
129Globalization Quality Products
World Class Production
130Education Jobs Middle Class
131Peraliya, Sri Lanka
132Education Jobs Middle Class
133Globalization Jobs
Source The World is Flat, Thomas Friedman, 2005
134Fewer Conflicts
Balkans
Source Human Security Centre, UBC
135Fewer Conflicts
Central America
Source Human Security Centre, UBC
136Fewer Conflicts
Source Human Security Centre, UBC
137Fewer Conflicts
Caucasus
Source Human Security Centre, UBC
138Emerging Countries Under 10,000 GDP/capita
139(No Transcript)
140Latin America is Elitist
141Government Small is Good. Turkey Mauritius
13.1
Source Global/WDI/Map0602
142Corruption
Ambev buyout by Interbrew
143CALPERS Beauty Scores
- Seven Factors
- Country
- Political Stability,
- Transparency,
- Labor Practices
- Market
- Liquidity/Volatility,
- Regulation/Investor Protection,
- Openness,
- Settlement Proficiency/Transaction Costs
- Scores (1Lowest, 3Highest).
Acceptable Overall 2
144CALPERS Beauty Scores
- Counter-productive.
- Suitability and Opportunity are INVERSLY related
145The Beauty Contest Price/book
146The Beauty Contest Price/Earnings Ratio
147The Beauty Contest ROE PB / PE
148The Beauty Contest Competition for Capital
149The Beauty Contest Competition for Capital
150And the Winner is
151And the Winner is
152And the Winner is.
Source 991214PB PE ROE for Dev and EM 060130
153The Beauty in Emerging Markets
- Diversification means owning things we hate to
hold - Conflicts are diminishing
- Economics are improving (lower taxes, more
incentives) - Education for all
- A rising middle class
- Beauty is in the Eye of the Beholder
154Economic Freedom The Heritage Foundation
Global/HeritiageEconomicFreedomIndex_2005.xls
155The Beauty in Emerging Markets
- Diversification means owning things we hate to
hold - Supply-side Economics are gaining ground
- Outsourcing is accelerating (Western profits from
emerging markets production) - The demographic imperative
- Rising middle class
156Growing Investment
Source World Development Indicators, 2005
WDILiteracy0509
157Poor
Source World Development Indicators, 2005
WDICharts200509
158Rural
Source World Development Indicators, 2005
WDILiteracy0509
159(No Transcript)
160(No Transcript)
161Harsh
162Optimism Fewer Conflicts
- Conflicts
- Sri Lanka Tamil Tigers (ceasefire in 2002?)
- India/Pakistan peace overtures, nuclear risks
- South Korea/North Korea nuclear risks
- Iraq nuclear risks
- Israel/Palestine/Lebanon/Irag - terrorism
- China/Taiwan sword rattling
- Russia/Chechnia terrorism
- Mexico drug wars
- Turkey Kurds
- Spain Basques
- Italy Mafia
- US Al-Qaeda
163Trust is related to income and cultural history
Democracy Trust, Mark Warren, 1999
164The Critical Middle Class
Source World Development Indicators, 2005
WDILiteracy0509
165The Critical Middle Class
Source World Development Indicators, 2005
WDILiteracy0509
166Falling Dependency
167Globalization Rising Middle Class
China consumes a lot. But Chinese are becoming
consumers
168Globalization - Performance
Source Laffer Associates, as of 3/06
169(No Transcript)
170Government Taxes
171Government Taxes Supply-side Economics
- Rise Taxes More tax revenue, less crowding out,
lower interest rates, more growth - Lower Taxes More incentive to work, more
workers, more growth, higher tax revenues
The Laffer Curve
Tax Rate
Tax Revenue
172Lower Taxes Higher Revenues Growth
173- Tax Wedge Marginal Inc Tax Rate (State
Local) (Employee Employer Social Sec)
174- Tax Wedge Marginal Inc Tax Rate (State
Local) (Employee Employer Social Sec)
175Lower Taxes Higher Revenues Growth
176What is Beautiful?GDP droves HDRSome countries
lead, others lag
Source World Development Indicators, 2005
WDICharts200509
177What is Beautiful?Human Development is good but
not for Growth
Source World Development Indicators, 2005
WDICharts200509
178What is Beautiful? Improvement in Human
Development is good
Source World Development Indicators, 2005
WDICharts200509
179What is Beautiful?Human Development is good but
not for Growth
Source World Development Indicators, 2005
WDICharts200509
180What is Beautiful? High Cost of Doing Business
Good?
Source World Bank, World Development Indicators,
2005 WDICharts200509
181What is Beautiful? Lower Taxes are Good!
Zero in Bahamas, Bahrain, Bermuda, Cayman Isl,
Kuwait, Saudi Arabia
Source World Development Indicators, 2005
WDILiteracy0509
182What is Beautiful? Lower Taxes are Good!!
Also Zero in Bahamas, Kuwait
Source World Development Indicators, 2005
WDILiteracy0509
183What is Beautiful? Small Shrinking Government
Source World Development Indicators, 2005
WDILiteracy0509
184What is Beautiful? Not Corruption
Russia
Source The Economist 3/7/02
185What is Beautiful? Improved Schooling for Women
is Beautiful
Some of the worst countries had high growth but
improvement mattered
Source World Development Indicators, 2005
WDILiteracy0509
186What is Globalization? Diversification
187Corruption
Ambev buyout by Interbrew
188 Globalization
189Lower Taxes More Growth Employment
- Tax Wedge
- Marginal Income Tax Rate
- (State Local)
- (Employee Employer Social Sec)
Source OECD
190Small Government
Source Global/WDI/Map0602
191Beauty and the Beast The Age of the Cynics
2000 - ? Some countries learning the wrong
lessons
- Xenophobia, nationalism (Malaysia, Russia, Iran,
Iraq, Cuba) - Isolationism (Malaysia)
- Restrictions on currency and investment flows
(Malaysia) - Competitive devaluations (Brazil)
- Protectionism (China)
- Market Manipulation (Hong Kong)
- Rising crime, drug trade (Mexico)
192Improved Schooling for Women is Beautiful
Source World Development Indicators, 2005
WDILiteracy0509
193Corrupt
but improvement mattered
Some of the most corrupt countries had high
growth
Source World Development Indicators, 2005
WDILiteracy0509
194Small Government
Source World Development Indicators, 2005
WDILiteracy0509
195Tax Cuts
196Growing Investment
Source World Development Indicators, 2005
WDILiteracy0509
197And the Winner is.
198Emerging Countries Opportunity
Population
Gross National Product
Market Cap
Developed (ex U.S.) 11
United States 45
United States 27
United States 5
Emerging 11
Emerging 84
Developed (ex U.S.) 53
Emerging 20
Developed (ex U.S.) 44
Source SP MSCI see additional disclosure As
of 2002
199Frontier Market Select Fund
Demographics are favorable Developed countries
are aging, frontier countries are young
200Globalization Outsourcing Production Services
- Economists and Accountants dont agree on
Globalization For a Dell PC sold in San Diego
Source GaveKal Research, HaverJobs file
201Corruption
- Pakistan Brazil
- at a 30-50 Discount
202Corruption
Source World Development Indicators, 2005
WDILiteracy0509
203Dangerous
- Murder Rates
- Jamaica 59 per 100,000 residents
- Sao Paulo - 66
- South Africa 43 (down 12 since 2001)
- Brazil 24
- Russia 18
- Mexico 14
- New York 8.7
- Washington, D.C. 41.8
- Gary, Indiana - 68
Source Economist 2005