Title: Shoshone Paiute Tribes
1Shoshone Paiute Tribes
2The Duck Valley Indian Reservation
- Approximately 289,820 tribally-owned acres (452
square miles) equally straddling the Idaho/Nevada
border - High Desert elevation 5,300-9,000 feet
- Approximately 1,800 enrolled Tribal members
- Our department currently employs 4 full time
staff and 12 seasonal staff, all Tribal except
for 2 biologists - Livestock ranching agriculture are primary
economic resources and sources of employment
3(No Transcript)
4(No Transcript)
5Current Land Uses
- Ranching Most areas that are accessible to
livestock are grazed - Flood Irrigated Agriculture 13,000 acres along
river and streams - Recreation
6Predominant Habitat Types
- Sagebrush Steppe
- Wetlands (Emergent Marsh)
- Riparian
- On the DVIR, riparian ecosystems are particularly
important areas in terms of the diversity of
sensitive species supported. Even more
important, sagebrush-steppe habitats in direct
juxtaposition to dense concentrations of riparian
habitats are uncommon anywhere, and this rare,
vital habitat sustains several rare and sensitive
species, making the effort to conserve these
habitats essential.
7Lotic Water
- Over 200 natural springs
- 350 miles of waterways, which are major
tributaries to the Bruneau and Jarbidge Rivers
and the South and East Forks of the Owyhee River - 200 miles of intermittent streams being degraded
by livestock proposed grazing ordinance failed
approval by Tribal Council and livestock owners - The East Fork Owyhee is the major drainage of the
Reservation this river is also the major source
of water for ranching and recharge of the
wetlands
8Duck Valley itself is located in the geographic
center of the Reservation and extends 9 miles
wide in a north-south direction over 20 miles.
The related slow-flowing East Fork of the Owyhee
River travels the valley from the southeast to
the northwest.
9East Fork Canyon
10Lentic Water
- Three human-made lakes stocked with rainbow trout
- Numerous small reservoirs/stock ponds
- Approx. 5,440 acres of wetlands in the central
valley, over 640 acres of wetlands in the eastern
highlands - Important wetland complex designated Priority
Conservation Site by The Nature Conservancy
11Protected Areas
Research Natural Areas Wilderness Study
Areas Wild and Scenic Rivers Areas of Critical
Environmental Concern Nature Conservancy Priority
Conservation Sites
Duck Valley Indian Reservation
12- Habitat fragmentation, degradation and loss due
to - Grazing
- Irrigation
- Road construction and maintenance
- Historic mining
- Destruction of biological crusts
- Loss of herbaceous understory in sagebrush steppe
habitat and encroaching exotics
13Habitat Needs
- Enhance, create, and/or restore habitats and
protect from livestock, road, and mining impacts.
- Establish techniques, surveys, and programs to
assess the health, abundance, distribution and
trend of fish, wildlife, habitat, and overall
biodiversity.
14Habitat needs continued
- Acquire lands for improved habitat protection,
restoration, and connectivity. - Develop GIS/data repository for fish and wildlife
information. - Develop seed bank of native forbs, grass and
shrub species for restoration/reseeding of
sagebrush-steppe habitat.
15Habitat Enhancement and Protection
- Shoshone Paiute Tribes
- Habitat, Parks, Fish and Game
- Project 1997-011-00
16Emerging Issues
- Excessive Administrative Tasks in 02-03 budget
modifications took 3 months to pass through COTR
time spent resulted in lost opportunities for
developing work plan for full staff field season
also resulted in unanticipated burden on indirect
staff. - BPA delays in contracting resulted in loss of
FY02 funds - Difficult to develop comprehensive, intensive
sampling plan for enhancements, as many are over
5 hours drive from office.
17Continued.
- YSI meter was broken for several months.
- Wet weather for the start of 03 field season
(wettest April in 30 years!) has precluded
driving to less accessible sites and has slowed
projects further. - Departure of previous biologist resulted in lost
and disorganized data.
18Habitat Enhancement
- GOALS
- 1. Identify and protect spawning areas in streams
and enhance and protect river and stream habitat - 2. Protect and/or enhance natural springs
- 3. Collect water quality and range data
- 4. Outreach and education
19Springs, Streams, and Reservoirs/Riparian Areas
Protected 2001-2003
- Abandoned Gun (fence)
- Bell Creek Headwaters (fence and trough)
- Billy Shaw Creek (partial fence)
- Circle Creek Reservoir (fence and trough)
- Headwaters of Miller Creek (fence)
- Jones Creek (2 road crossings) Jones Flat
Springs - Little Sheep Creek (2 road crossings)
- Lambs Reservoir 8 stock ponds to the west of
Lake Billy Shaw - No-Name Reservoir (fence 5 acres and trough)
- N. Fork Skull Creek (fence spawning areas)
- Parker Spring
- Red Cabin
- Reed Creek Reed Cr. Springs
- Rye Grass
- Skull Creek Spring (flex culvert)
- Spring Creek (flex culvert and trough)
- Sugar Loaf
- Summit Creek (fence riparian area)
- Three Stooges
- Thacker Springs
20Objective 1 Identify and protect spawning areas
in streams enhance and protect river and stream
habitat
- Strategy Increase survival of native trout
increase stability of stream banks increase
water quality
- Deliverables from 2001-August 2002 Actions
- 37 streams/headwaters inventoried
- 15 streams evaluated for spawning habitat and
spawning habitat potential - (based on water quality, substrate composition,
woody debris, organic debris, sediment
entrainment, bank shape, channel shape, riparian
condition, presence of fish barriers, plant
types, algae presence, water odor and
appearance). - 10 streams had Redband trout (Oncorhyncus mykiss
gairdneri) 9 streams with documented spawning
21Streams Supporting Redband Trout
22- 01-02 Deliverables contd
- 3 small reservoirs enhanced
- Stream enhancements installed
- (for example, Miller Creek exclusion fence
started in August 2001 and completed in October
constructed using 256 steel posts, 16 rolls of
barbed wire, 55 cedar posts, and large quantities
of scrap wood for the 11 rock jacks built) - Beaver relocations from irrigation delivery
systems on valley floor to higher elevation
streams - Limited GPS coordinates recorded
23Expectations for September 2002-August 2003
- We have already coordinated with the
Environmental Engineer of the Tribal
Environmental Protection Program (TEPP) in the
restoration of Skull Creek and the North Fork of
Skull Creek (Redband trout habitat and spawning
habitat).
Relocated stream meander in winter months
24North Fork of Skull Creek (6/27/01)
0.06 fish/m2
Water Quality Temp 13.7o C Cond. 122.3 uS D.O.
6.62 mg/l
L 259 m Avg. W 2.06 m
25- Unimproved Roads
- Unimproved backcountry dirt roads on the DVIR
provide access to more than 2/3 of the
Reservations acreage. -
- The eastern third of the Reservation rises to a
high plateau 3,000 feet above the valley floor,
and several of the roads, like the Skull Creek
and North Fork of Skull Creek roads, follow
creeks as they rise to the plateau, resulting in
undeveloped stream crossings, and roads
constructed in or adjacent to the streams
floodplain, causing erosion and high sediment
loads and hydrocarbon pollution in the streams.
26(No Transcript)
27(No Transcript)
28(No Transcript)
29- Skull Creek road is the primary southern access
to the eastern plateau area and crosses Skull
Creek five times and remains within fifty feet of
the streams floodplain for most of its length. - The North Fork Skull Creek road crosses the creek
one time. - Of the six crossings, four are unimproved
(vehicles enter the creek during crossing and no
crossing structure exists). - Three of the four unimproved crossings were
project areas.
30Skull Creek Priority Crossings
Aerial Photo Map
31- Problems
- At each of the 3 crossings addressed, the creek
flowed down the road for 90, 100, and 80 feet
respectively. Vehicles crossing the creek would
remain in the creek for this length. - Common erosion channels travel down the roads
forming six to twelve-inch ruts, and leave the
road forming a small gulley, contributing an
unnatural sediment load in the creeks. - The creeks undercut the roads in other places,
also causing unnatural sediment loads.
32- Strategy
- Reduce nonpoint source pollution such as sediment
loading from unimproved backcountry roads and
vehicular pollution associated with water contact
with automobiles during stream crossings.
33- Actions
- Installation of twelve cross drain/drainage dips
- Improvement of three stream crossings
- one Geoweb based engineered stream crossing
- one stream meander relocation
- installation of two drivable bankfull dams
- one stream crossing relocation
- Work required three laborers, one road inspector,
Environmental Engineer, one backhoe, one dump
truck, one bulldozer and miscellaneous equipment.
- Primary materials for the project were gravel,
local alluvial fill, Geoweb and Geotextile for
the engineered crossing, erosion control
blankets, straw bales and miscellaneous items.
34Geoweb
35(No Transcript)
36Drainage Dip
37Sediment Trapping
38Geo-jute
39North Fork of Skull Creek Crossing 1(after)
From an 80ft. to a 15 ft. crossing reclaimed old
road area grass and willow transplanting
4003 Spring Stubble Height
41Transplanted Willow
42May 03 Growth on Transplanted Willow
43Before
After
44Before
After
45Skull Creek Crossing 1 before improvement
46200 feet upstream of Skull Creek Crossing 1
47Schematic Depiction Crossing 1
48Skull Creek Crossing 1 Completed Project
49Skull Creek Crossing 1
50Skull Creek Crossing 1
51Skull Creek Crossing 1
52- Project assessment
- Proper functioning of the project cannot be
assessed until after spring high water flow. - Monitoring and maintenance of the project will
occur over the next three years and the majority
of conclusions and recommendations will be drawn
from the monitoring results.
53References and Consultation
- Geomorphic characterization and stream state
conditions Applied River Morphology text by Dave
Rosgen and Rosgen course material EPA Rapid
bioassessment protocol (1998). - Native planting restoration and bioengineering
techniques The Riparian Zone Ecology Management
and Restoration Workshop Handbook Soil
Bioengineering Field Book Riparian Ecology and
Restoration Notebook by Chris Hoag and Jon Fripp
(and personal communication). - Engineering and design specs Rick Poore,
Director of Stream-Wise USFS Roads Division,
Elko district office. - Site inspection Don Jankowsky, former road
inspector for the Boise National Forest.
54Owyhee River Restoration
- In cooperation with TEPP and Confluence
Consulting, Inc., we will be developing
conceptual bank stabilization designs for a 3.5
mile reach of the Owyhee River. - The primary objectives of the project are to
reduce sediment contributions caused by unstable
geomorphic conditions, increase riparian
vegetation to improve shade conditions, lower
water temperatures, and improve fish habitat.
55Bank Erosion on the East Fork of the Owyhee
56Manure in Sediments of the E.F. Owyhee
57Bank Erosion and Cutting along E.F. Owyhee
58(No Transcript)
59Assessment Phase
- Assessment will occur during the present
performance period actual restoration activities
will occur in the fall of 2003. - Confluence will provide oversight, guidance, and
training for our staff at no cost to our
department (staff has already attended a
Bioengineering workshop with Chris Hoag and Jon
Fripp in April 03). - The data collection effort will be broken into
two components a geomorphic/channel survey and
a riparian survey.
60Geomorphic /Channel Survey
- Assessment of geomorphic stability based
primarily on field indicators of sediment
transport conditions including - substrate consolidation and composition
- bank failure mechanisms and erosion extent
- bar development
- depositional patterns
- width/depth ratio, channel pattern, and bank
slope
61- Where areas are identified as geomorphically
unstable, the driving forces for sediment
transport imbalance will be determined and each
causal factor will be identified as either a
site-specific or systemic impact. -
- Unstable areas will be described with respect to
rates and trends toward natural recovery to an
equilibrium state. - Rosgen Level I and II stream typing will be
applied to the results of the survey to describe
general channel form for each reach.
62- We will then characterize areas (or subreaches)
that we identify as candidates for restoration in
the field in terms of channel dimensions, channel
cross-section and floodplain dimensions, radii of
curvature, meander wavelengths, and perimeter
materials. - We will map and GPS-locate infrastructure
elements and channel modifications (i.e. profile
discontinuities, bedrock controls, significant
bankline erosion sites, major sediment sources,
diversion structures, and revetments).
63Riparian Survey
- Riparian survey will assess conditions and the
functional capability of the riparian areas. - A hybrid methodology will be developed combining
numerous existing riparian resource methodologies
such as - Classification and Management of Montana Riparian
and Wetland Sites, Monitoring the Vegetation
Resources in Riparian Areas, Environmental
Monitoring and Assessment Program protocols,
Proper Functioning Condition assessments, and
R1/R4 Intermountain Fish and Fish Habitat
Procedures.
64- Riparian condition data will be collected in
selected areas of the reach and used as a
baseline to compare with post restoration
conditions. Riparian communities will be located
with a GPS/GIS system. - Riparian community classification data will be
analyzed to determine the extent of disturbance
to community types to establish a baseline for
monitoring riparian vegetation trends over time.
65- Woody species regeneration will be assessed in a
relatively narrow band directly adjacent to the
channel to predict the trend of riparian
conditions. An index of overall riparian
function will be determined using the following
indicators - species composition, species diversity, presence
of non-native or invasive species, structural
diversity (presence of overstory, shrub, and
groundcover species), extent of canopy cover, and
percent of bare ground.
66Human Activity
- An index will also be developed to understand
whether there are significant human factors that
influence the site. - Based on the extent of activity and the proximity
of this activity from the channel, the condition
of riparian vegetation will be compared in areas
with high and low degrees of human activity to
determine whether these activities appear to be
affecting riparian conditions and, if so, how.
67Restoration Alternatives
- Following the interpretation of this data, a
range of restoration alternatives will be
developed based on priority areas, associated
benefits, and estimated costs. -
68Wetlands Delineation and Management Plan
- In collaboration with TEPP and Shapiro and
Associates, Inc. - Objectives
- Train Tribal staff in wetland delineation process
(primarily according to U.S. Army Corps of
Engineers Wetlands Delineation Manual, 1987)
focusing on the Blue Creek Wetlands - Train staff in reconnaissance level wetland
assessments - Provide data for the creation of a wetlands
database - With the Tribal Council, develop a wetlands
management plan
69- Blue Creek Wetlands are part of The Nature
Conservancy Priority Conservation Site. - Subbasin Assessment noted a need to
- survey and assess condition of redband
populations and habitat in the DVIR, Lower Blue
Creek, North fork Owyhee, and South Fork Owyhee
to develop data sets and assessment resources on
par with information in other portions of the
subbasin
70Protected Areas
Research Natural Areas Wilderness Study
Areas Wild and Scenic Rivers Areas of Critical
Environmental Concern Nature Conservancy Priority
Conservation Sites
Duck Valley Indian Reservation
71Blue Creek Wetlands
72Blue Creek Wetlands
73Blue Creek Wetlands
74Actions
- Locating, groundtruthing, and mapping wetlands
according to soils, vegetation, and hydrologic
assessments. - Determination of wetland community types.
- Gathering data on wetland characteristics.
- Assessment of wetland functions and values and
identification of unique or cultural qualities. - Developing wetlands management plan with Tribal
Council
75More Expectations for Objective 1
- Update GPS/GIS data.
- Train staff (1 staff member already trained) in
Proper Functioning Condition assessments and
focus assessment on streams included in Redband
trout genetics study. - Enhance and protect Blue Creek, Little Sheep
Creek, and Marys Creek and their associated
wetlands - Marys Creek suspected to support Bull trout
76Objective 2 Protect and Repair Natural Springs
- Strategy
- Increase water flow from springs that provide
pool habitat/cold water refuges for trout in late
summer - Improve water quality
- Provide cold, clean water to Owyhee River and
tributaries
77- Deliverables from actions completed 2001-2002
- Springs in 7 areas were protected with fencing,
troughs were installed, and willows were planted - Existing enhancements were maintained with the
help of the Western Shoshone-Paiute Livestock
Association - Existing enhancements were improved with trough
braces and rock jacks
78Maintenance
Rock Jack added
Troughs braced
79(No Transcript)
80Habitat Enhancement Spring Development Project
Locations
81Expectations for 2002-2003
- Collaborate with the Western Shoshone-Paiute
Livestock Association and TEPP to determine
priority springs and protection strategies. - After meetings, 3 springs were determined (Hot
Creek Springs, Cavanaugh Springs, and Jones Flat
Springs Area) - We also discussed strategic placement of drift
fences while utilizing the thick willows as
natural fencing, and we discussed more deliberate
livestock grazing.
82Fawn Creek Road
- Spawning has been documented in Fawn Creek.
- Several springs flow down or across Fawn Creek
Road and enter the creek. - In cooperation with TEPP, we plan on enhancing
the road with culverts/road crossings for these
springs.
83Maintenance and Monitoring
- Maintain completed spring enhancement and
protection projects. - Including inspection and seasonal reconnections
of waterlines fencing and piping repairs
inspection and reseeding of spring area photos. - Update GIS/GPS data.
- Develop monitoring program for protected areas in
order to evaluate trends (including photo points,
vegetation diversity indices, GIS mapping, and
water quality monitoring plan.) - Will also be included in Objective 3.
84Objective 3 Collect water quality and range data
- Strategy
- Create database with water quality, fisheries,
and range habitat information. - Deliverables from actions in 2001-2002
- Initiated relationship with Tribal Natural
Resources department to craft a Range Management
plan - Fisheries and water quality (chemical and
biological) information collected on streams in
association with the Redband trout genetics
project and the TEPP department.
85- 30 areas sampled for water quality
- 10 areas evaluated for substrate, debris, and
sediment entrainment - 10 areas evaluated for bank, channel, and
riparian area health - 10 areas evaluated for fish barriers, aquatic
plants, algae, water odor and appearance and
wildlife presence - 12 sites sampled for salmonid size distribution
and density
86Salmonid Density and Size Distribution
87Expectations for 2002-2003
- Work with staff from the Pacific Northwest
National Laboratory (PNNL) in a partnership where
they are providing us with NASA satellite imagery
and expertise to create maps for use by the
Tribes. These maps may be used for tracking fish
and waterfowl migration, water quality and flow,
water pollution, etc.
88Landsat Imagery(redpasture land)
89- Expectations contd
- In cooperation with TEPP and WSPLA, develop a map
of all range fences on the DVIR. - Fences are all GPS located mapping in progress
- Currently coordinating with TEPP Water Quality
Technician and the BOR to develop and carry out
comprehensive water quality monitoring plan for
streams on the DVIR. - Including water chemistry, biological indices,
macrophyte and macroinvertebrate sampling and
mapping.
90Inorganic Contamination Sampling Event
- Intensive sampling event completed late August in
cooperation with TEPP to assess the inorganic
toxicity of the East Fork of the Owyhee River (on
the DVIR) due to tailings from the upstream Rio
Tinto copper mine below the confluence with Mill
Creek. - Water, sediment, and fish samples were taken in
late August, 2002 - 3-4 rainbow trout were taken at the 8 sample
sites along with background (using electrofishing
and netting techniques)
91(No Transcript)
92Rio Tinto Mine
- Rio Tinto was a prolific copper mine operating
from 1932-1975 - Estimated 12 million cubic yards of tailings
located in the Mill Creek drainage, which is a
tributary of the East Fork of the Owyhee River. - Mine is located approximately 2 miles south of
the DVIR (upriver) - Impacts of the acid mine drainage on the
Reservation have neither been fully characterized
nor studied. - Numerous documentations of fish kills
- Owyhee River is the main source of groundwater
recharge on the Reservation.
93Above Tailings
MILL CREEK
Below Tailings
94Mill Creek
9510 feet above confluence with the EF Owyhee
96Confluence of Mill Creek and the East Fork of the
Owyhee River (high water)
97Water Quality Testing on East Fork of the Owyhee
98Sediment Core Sampling on the East Fork of the
Owyhee
99Fish Sampling Crew
100Objective 4 Outreach and Education
- Strategy
- Increase community involvement and support for
projects through education. - Deliverables from Actions in 2001-2002
- Hosted 15 youth through the Tribal Summer Youth
Program for 6 weeks of employment. - Boy Scouts electrofished streams plus carved,
painted, and erected signs indicating the names
of the major tributaries to the East Fork of the
Owyhee River. - Arbor Day ceremony 2002
101- Hosted several community meetings
- Wrote monthly reports for Tribal Council and
attended monthly Tribal Council meetings - 7 articles written for the Sho-Pai News
- Maintained relationship with WSPLA
- Fostered nascent relationship with TEPP
102Expectations for 2002-2003
- Implement a volunteer bird monitoring program
with after-school youth and community to help
protect vital areas. - Working with USFWS to develop monitoring sheets
and protocols for use in wetlands, open water,
and riparian areas. - DVIR supports several Species of Special Concern
(including Northern harrier (Curcus cyaneus)
Bald eagle (Haliaeetus leucocephalus Federally
Threatened) Greater sandhill crane (Grus
canadensis tabida) Black-crowned nightheron
(Nycticorax nycticorax) American white pelican
(Pelecanus erythrorhynchos) Double crested
cormorant (Phalacrocorax auritus) Trumpeter swan
(Cygnus buccinator) and Western grebe
(Aechmophorus occidentalis)
103- Write articles for local paper.
- Maintain relationship with Boy Scout troupe
leader. - Develop relationship with Girl Scouts.
104- Invited to deliver 3 presentations at an annual
regional agriculture and ranching conference
where we informed the audience about using
gravity-fed water troughs, exclusion fencing of
springs and streams, and general range management
issues, including non-lethal predator control and
livestock protection. - The Tribes local high school FFA (Future Farmers
of America) and 4-H programs attended the
conference as well as local ranchers, regional
ranchers, and regional farmers and veterinarians.
105- The Senior Biologist/Deputy Director was invited
to deliver a presentation at the Idaho Chapter of
the international Wildlife Society annual meeting
to address the topic of Tribal Wildlife
Management - detailed the objectives of the Habitat
Enhancement projects in addition to other
department projects. - The Director was also invited to sit on a panel
to respond to policy-level questions regarding
Tribal Wildlife Management.
106Student Science Fair project
- We helped 4 Shoshone-Paiute sixth-grade students
develop a project for the Northeastern Nevada
Science Fair. - With our assistance, the students crafted a
project correlating water quality and Redband
trout habitat - we helped them with the generation of the project
idea, the scientific process involved, internet
research, the collection of data, the analysis of
data (including an Excel tutorial), and the
project presentation (including a PowerPoint
tutorial).
107(No Transcript)
108- We are excited to report that the students
project, judged by science professionals, won
first place in the Life Sciences Division for all
of Northeastern Nevada! - The students project has also been nominated for
the Discovery Channels Young Scientist Challenge
2003 award (an award of 14,000!). - With the help of the Senior Biologist/Deputy
Director, the students crafted a PowerPoint
presentation delivered at a Shoshone Paiute
Tribes full Tribal Council meeting, and for NRCS
Idaho RCD.
109- With the assistance of several fisheries
biologists, we are researching the construction
and use of fish traps in order to track spawners
in the creeks this spring. The four students
from the Owyhee Combined Schools will be involved
in the data collection to append their 2003
science fair project, and staff from our
department will construct the traps.
110Arbor Day 2003
- Organized free tree planting and maintenance
workshops (one for the community by Bill Moore
and Debbie Cook of Idaho RCD and one for the
staff by Tony Deets of NV Division of Forestry) - Regional businesses and individuals bestowed
enormous support on our ceremony, with donations
of 8 fishing poles, 6 full fishing tackle boxes,
2 tents, 4 camping chairs, and 12 knives (adults
only) for prizes. - At the Arbor Day Ceremony, Ms. Danns 6th grade
class performed Arbor Day Play and the Painted
Horse Drummers and Sweet Sage drummed and
sang. We also had a large attendance by Idaho
and Nevada agencies.
111(No Transcript)