Title: Traditional Project Financings vs. PPP
1Traditional Project Financings vs. PPP
- Roman Fuchs
- Macquarie Capital GmbH
2Traditional Project Finance
- What is Project Finance?
- A financing of a particular economic unit in
which a lender is satisfied to look initially to
the cash flows and earnings of that economic unit
as the source of funds from which a loan will be
repaid and to the assets of the economic unit as
collateral of the loan.
3Key elements of Project Finance
- Cash flow based
- Valuation on cash flow basis
- Risk allocation
- Risk is allocated to those parties involved, who
can handle it best - Non or as little as possible recourse
- No further cash injections apart from the initial
investment needed from the investor/sponsor of
the project - Use of a SPC
- Set up of a Special Purpose Company for the
project - Off-balance sheet financing
- Sponsors can finance projects without taking them
on their own balance sheet as long as stake in
the SPC is below 50
4Public Private Partnership
- What is a Public Private Partnership (PPP)?
- PPP is a relationship between the public and the
private sector in order to provide publicly used
infrastructure more efficiently - PPPs (in the UK referred to as Private Finance
Initiative or PFI) are based on different
contractual structures and cannot clearly be
differentiated with respect to other forms of
cooperation - BOT-Structure (Built, Operate, Transfer)
- The private partner gets a concession to finance
the building, the operation and the maintenance
of the project, which gets transferred back to
the state at the end of the concession (Ownership
stays with the state all the time) - BOOT-Structure (Built, Operate, Own, Transfer)
- Ownership is with the private part for the time
of the concession - BOO-Structure (Built, Operate, Own)
- Ownership goes totally to the private part
5Financing Alternatives of a PPP
- Depending on the degree of state involvement PPPs
can but do not necessarily have to involve
project financing aspects
Project Financing
Public Sector Financing (Public Sector guarantees
debt service to lenders)
-
- In depth evaluation and due diligence from debt
and equity - Optimised technical and economical structure
- Innovative financial engineering
- Risk and quality management
- Close project monitoring
- -
- Higher financing costs
-
- Lower financing costs
- -
- Less detailed project evaluation
- Less optimised technical and economical structure
- Little focus on financial structure
- Risk and quality management no main target
- Looser project monitoring
vs.
Higher financing costs are usually offset by
higher efficiency of the project
6Project Finance in a PPP-Project
- Typically involved parties in a PPP-Project (road
sector)
Awarder of Concession (Public Motorway Authority)
Availability Fee
Concession Agreement
Debt
Equity
Concessionaire (SPC)
Lenders
Sponsors
Debt service
Dividends
Construction Subcontractor
Operation Subcontractor
Maintenance Subcontractor
7Risk Allocation in a PPP-Project
- Schematic risk matrix of a PPP-Project (road
sector)
Risk (examples) Concessionaire Awarder of Concession Shared
Planning X
Land Acquisition X
Ground Contamination X
Increased Costs X
General traffic risk X
Insufficient revenue collection X
Increased inflation X
Default of Concessionaire X
Uninsurable events X
8Cash Flow Risk in Project Finance
- Schematic cash flow diagram
Lenders like to see the worst case cash flows
covering the debt service
9Overview of Macquarie
Global office locations
- Key statistics
- Market capitalisation 11.39 billion1
- Assets under management 82.8 billion2
- Credit rating A1/ A (SP)
- International offices 55
- Employees 8,2002
- History and profile
- Founded 1969 as the Australian subsidiary ofUK
merchant bank Hill Samuel - Listed on the Australian Stock Exchange in 1996
now a top 15 ASX company by market cap - Selective focus on areas and products where
specialist skills deliver value for clients - Entrepreneurial environment combined with strong
risk management - 48 of income from activities outside Australia
Annual net profit (m)
1 As at 16 November 2006 2 As at 31 March 2006
10Macquaries European assets
UK Arqiva Birmingham Airport Bristol
Airport Energy Power Resources (UK) M1-A1 Link M6
Toll Moto NM Renewable Energy Red Bee
Media Stagecoach Steam Packet Wales West
Utilities Wightlink
Denmark Copenhagen Airport European Directories
Finland European Directories
Sweden Arlanda Express Energy Power Resources
(Europe) European Directories
Poland Deep Sea- Container Terminal
The Netherlands European Directories NRE Obregas
Net Netbeheer Haarlemmermeer
Belgium Brussels- Airport
Germany Warnow Tunnel NW Renewable
Energy TanQuid(tank storage business)
France Energy Power Resources (Europe) Autoroutes
Paris-Rhin-Rhone European Directories
Portugal Tagus Crossings
Italy Rome Airport
Spain Itevelesa
As at 5 Oct 2006 the assets listed are managed
on behalf of investors with various direct
stakes held in each Subject to financing and
customary closing arrangements
11Contact
Roman Fuchs Business Development Central Eastern
Europe Macquarie Capital GmbH Wienerbergstrasse
11 East Tower, Floor 31 A-1100 Vienna Direct
Line 43 (0)1 205 300 24 Fax 43 (0)1 205 300
30 Email roman.fuchs_at_macquarie.com Internet www.
macquarie.com