Title: Understanding and assessing neglect
1Understanding and assessing neglect
- Patrick Ayre
- Department of Applied Social Studies
- University of Bedfordshire
- Park Square, Luton
- email pga_at_patrickayre.co.uk
- web http//patrickayre.co.uk
2- Neglect is the persistent failure to meet a
childs basic physical and/or psychological
needs, likely to result in the serious impairment
of the childs health or development. Neglect may
occur during pregnancy as a result of maternal
substance abuse. Once a child is born, neglect
may involve a parent or carer failing to - provide adequate food, clothing and shelter
- protect from physical and emotional harm or
danger - ensure adequate supervision
- ensure access to medical care or treatment.
- It may also include neglect of, or
unresponsiveness to, a childs basic emotional
needs.
3- Neglect is the persistent failure to meet a
childs basic physical and/or psychological
needs, likely to result in the serious impairment
of the childs health or development. Neglect may
occur during pregnancy as a result of maternal
substance abuse. Once a child is born, neglect
may involve a parent or carer failing to - provide adequate food, clothing and shelter
- protect from physical and emotional harm or
danger - ensure adequate supervision
- ensure access to medical care or treatment.
- It may also include neglect of, or
unresponsiveness to, a childs basic emotional
needs.
4- Neglect is the persistent failure to meet a
childs basic physical and/or psychological
needs, likely to result in the serious impairment
of the childs health or development. Neglect may
occur during pregnancy as a result of maternal
substance abuse. Once a child is born, neglect
may involve a parent or carer failing to - provide adequate food, clothing and shelter
- protect from physical and emotional harm or
danger - ensure adequate supervision
- ensure access to medical care or treatment.
- It may also include neglect of, or
unresponsiveness to, a childs basic emotional
needs.
5NEGLECT
- Behavioural
- Constant hunger
- Constant tiredness
- Frequent lateness or non-attendance at school
- Destructive tendencies
6NEGLECT
- Low self-esteem
- Neurotic behaviour
- No social relationships
- Running away
- Compulsive stealing or scavenging
7NEGLECT
- Physical
- Poor personal hygiene
- Poor state of clothing
- Emaciation, pot belly, short stature
- Poor skin and hair tone
- Untreated medical problems
8SIGNIFICANT HARM
- Harm is defined by Children Act 1989
- ill-treatment (including sexual abuse and, by
implication, physical abuse) - impairment of health (physical or mental) or
development (physical, intellectual, emotional,
social or behavioural)
9THE CHILD'S BASIC NEEDS
- basic physical care
- affection
- security
- stimulation of innate potential
- guidance and control
- responsibility
- independence
10Why do parents neglect?
- We need to understand the interaction between
- 3 Ns Nurture, Nature, Now
- Circumstantial factors and fundamental factors
11Why do parents neglect?
- Circumstantial
- Poverty
- Particular relationships
- Lack of skill/knowledge
- Temporary illness
- Lack of support
- Environmental factors
- Fundamental
- Lack of parenting capacity
- Deep seated attitudinal/behavioural/
psychological problems - Long term health issues
- Entrenched problematical drug /alcohol use
12A scale for assessing motivation
- Shows concern and has realistic confidence.
- Shows concern, but lacks confidence.
- Seems concerned, but impulsive or careless
- Indifferent or apathetic about problems
- Rejection of parental role.
13Shows concern and has realistic confidence.
- Parent is concerned about childrens welfare
wants to meet their physical, social, and
emotional needs to the extent he/she understands
them. - Parent is determined to act in best interests of
children - Has realistic confidence that he/she can overcome
problems and is willing to ask for help when
needed - Is prepared to make sacrifices for children.
14Shows concern, but lacks confidence
- Parent is concerned about childrens welfare and
wants to meet their needs, but lacks confidence
that problems can be overcome - May be unwilling for some reason to ask for help
when needed. Feels unsure of own abilities or is
embarrassed - But uses good judgement whenever he/she takes
some action to solve problems.
15Seems concerned, but impulsive or careless
- Parent seems concerned about childrens welfare
and claims he/she wants to meet their needs, but
has problems with carelessness, mistakes and
accidents. Professed concern is often not
translated into effective action. - May be disorganised, not take enough time, or
pays insufficient attention may misread
signals from children may exercise poor
judgement. - Does not seem to intentionally violate proper
parental role shows remorse.
16Indifferent or apathetic about problems
- Parent is not concerned enough about childrens
needs to resist temptations, eg competing
demands on time and money. This leads to one or
more of the childrens needs not being met. - Parent does not have the right priorities when
it comes to child care may take a cavalier or
indifferent attitude. There may be a lack of
interest in the children and in their welfare and
development. - Parent does not actively reject the parental role.
17Rejection of parental role
- Parent actively rejects parental role, taking a
hostile attitude toward child care
responsibilities. - Believes that child care is an imposition, and
may ask to be relieved of that responsibility.
May take the attitude that it isnt his or her
job. - May seek to give up the responsibility for
children - (Magura et al,1987)
18The effects of neglect
- Howe identifies 4 types of neglect
- Emotional neglect
- Disorganised neglect
- Depressed or passive neglect
- Severe deprivation
- Each is associated with different effects and
implications for intervention
19Emotional neglect
- Sins of commission and omission
- Closure and flight avoid contact, ignore
advice, miss appointments, deride professionals,
children unavailable - However, may seek help with a child who needs to
be cured - Intervention often delayed
20Emotional neglect parents
- Cant cope with childrens demands
avoid/disengage from child in need dismissive or
punitive response - Six types of response
- Spurning, rejecting, belittling
- Terrorising
- Isolating from positive experiences
- Exploiting/corrupting
- Denying emotional responsiveness
- Failing medical needs
21Emotional neglect children
- Frightened, unhappy, anxious, low self-esteem
- Precocious, streetwise
- Withdrawn, isolated, aggressive fear intimacy
and dependence - Behaviour increasingly anti-social and
oppositional - Brain development affected difficulties in
processing and regulating emotional arousal
22Disorganised neglect
- Classic problem families
- Thick case files
- Can annoy and frustrate but endear and amuse
- Chaos and disruption
- Reasoning minimised, affect is dominant
- Feelings drive behaviour and social interaction
23Disorganised neglect carers
- Feelings of being undervalued or emotionally
deprived in childhood so need to be centre of
attention/affection - Demanding and dependant with respect to
professionals - Crisis is a necessary not a contingent state
24Disorganised neglect carers
- Cope with babies (babies need them) but then
- Parental responses to children unpredictable
driven by how the parent is feeling, not the
needs of the child - Lack of attunement and synchronicity
25Disorganised neglect children
- Anxious and demanding
- Infants fractious, fretful, clinging, hard to
soothe - Young children attention seeking exaggerated
affect poor confidence and concentration
jealous show off go to far - Teens immature, impulsive need to be noticed
leads to trouble at school and in community - Neglectful parents feel angry and helpless
reject the child to grandparents, care or gangs
26Depressed neglect
- Classic neglect
- Material and emotional poverty
- Homes and children dirty and smelly
- Urine soaked matresses, dog faeces, filthy
plates, rags at the windows - A sense of hopelessness and despair (can be
reflected in workers)
27Depressed neglect carers
- Often severely abused/neglected own parents
depressed or sexually or physically abusive - May have learning difficulties
- Passive helplessness response to demands of
family life - Have given up both thinking and feeling
28Depressed neglect carers
- Listless and unresponsive to childrens needs and
demands, limited interaction - Lack of pleasure or anger in dealings with
children and professionals - No smacks, no shouting, no deliberate harm but no
hugs, no warmth, no emotional involvement - No structure poor supervision, care and food
29Depressed neglect children
- Lack interaction with parents required for mental
and emotional development - Infant Incurious and unresponsive moan and
whimper but dont cry or laugh - At school isolated, aimless, lacking in
concentration, drive, confidence and self-esteem
but do not show anti-social behaviour
30Severe deprivation
- Eastern European orphanages, parents with serious
issues of depression, learning disabilities, drug
addiction, care system at its worst - Children left in cot or serial caregiving
- Combination of severe neglect and absence of
selective attachment child is essentially alone
31Severe deprivation children
- Infants lack pre-attachment behaviours of
smiling, crying, eye contact - Children impulsivity, hyperactivity, attention
deficits, cognitive impairment and developmental
delay, aggressive and coercive behaviour, eating
problems, poor relationships - Inhibited withdrawn passive, rarely smile,
autistic-type behaviour and self-soothing - Disinhibited attention-seeking, clingy,
over-friendly relationships shallow, lack
reciprocity
32Capturing chronic abuse
- Judging the quality of care is an essential
component of any assessment but how well do we do
it? - Judgements subjective and prone to bias
- Intangible Difficult to capture and compare
- High threshold for recognition
- Neglect is a pattern not an event
33Capturing chronic abuse
- Judging the quality of care is an essential
component of any assessment but how well do we do
it? - Judgements subjective and prone to bias
- Intangible Difficult to capture and compare
- High threshold for recognition
- Neglect is a pattern not an event
34Our image of assessment
35The reality of assessment?
36Capturing chronic abuse
- Judging the quality of care is an essential
component of any assessment but how well do we do
it? - Judgements subjective and prone to bias
- Intangible Difficult to capture and compare
- High threshold for recognition
- Neglect is a pattern not an event
37The pattern of neglect
38The pattern of neglect
39The pattern of neglect
40The pattern of neglect
41The pattern of neglect
42Cumulativeness
43Failure of cumulativeness
44Information handling
- Picking out the important from a mass of data
- Interpretation
- Distinguishing fact/opinion too
trusting/insufficiently critical - Mistrusted source
- Decoyed by another problem
- False certainty undue faith in a known fact
- Discarding information which does not fit
- First impressions/assumptions
- Department of Health (1991) Child abuse A study
of inquiry reports, 1980-1989, HMSO, London
45Whats the problem?
- Chronic abuse and the principle of cumulativeness
- Files very long and badly structured
- Patterns missed and chronic abuse overlooked
- The problem of proportionality
- Acclimatisation
46Assessment Pitfalls
- Parents behaviour, whether co-operative or
uncooperative, is often misinterpreted - Not enough weight to information from family
friends and neighbours - Not enough attention is paid to what children
say, how they look and how they behave - Attention is focused on the most visible or
pressing problems and other warning signs are not
appreciated - When faced with an aggressive or frightening
family, professionals are reluctant to discuss
fears for their own safety and ask for help - In Cleaver, H, Wattam, C and Cawson, P Assessing
Risk in Child Protection, NSPCC, 1998
47Serious Case Reviews
- Great disquiet over assessment practice
- Failure to give sufficient weight to relevant
case history - Facts recorded faithfully but not always
critically appraised - Guidance and thresholds
- Protection plans omit objectives and outcomes
48Assessment Practice
- Use of trained staff
- Assessment of male carers
- Maintenance of a wholly child-centred approach
- Too much mouth and ears, not enough eyes
- Formal assessment of risk
49Risk assessment
- The dangers involved (that is the feared
outcomes) - The hazards and strengths of the situation (that
is the factors making it more or less likely that
the dangers will realised) - The probability of a dangerous outcome in this
case (bearing in mind the strengths and hazards)
- The further information required to enable this
to be judged accurately and - The methods by which the likelihood of the feared
outcomes could be diminished or removed.
50Bias and Balance
- Include strengths and weaknesses
- It is your job to make judgements but
- avoid empty evaluative words like inappropriate,
worrying, inadequate - Give evidence for descriptive words like cold,
dirty and untidy - Beware the danger of facts
51Bias and Balance
- Born in 1942, he was sentenced to 5 years
imprisonment at the age of 25. After 5
unsuccessful fights, he gave up his attempt to
make a career in boxing in 1981 and has since had
no other regular employment
52Seeing the whole picture
Kouao always dressed immaculately. Her clothing
and jewellery seemed expensive and her hair was
very well done. She did not in any way look
destitute, contrary to what she always claimed.
In contrast, Victoria was poorly dressed. I
cannot recall exactly what she wore but there
were times when she did not seem to be dressed
appropriately. She always appeared to look as if
she was in hand-me-down clothes. I thought she
looked shabbily dressed
53Seeing the whole picture
54(No Transcript)
55The danger of snapshots
56Drawing conclusions and making recommendations
- Summarise the main issues and the conclusions to
be drawn from them. (The facts do not necessarily
speak for themselves it is your job to speak for
them.) - Draw conclusions from the facts and
recommendations from the conclusions - Explain how you arrived at your conclusions (Have
you demonstrated the factual/theoretical basis
for each?)
57Conclusions and recommendations
- In drawing conclusions be aware of the extent and
limitations of your own expertise. - Conclusions may be supported by research (Dont
go outside expertise be careful with new or
controversial theories be aware of counter
arguments)
58Wirral assessment tool for neglect
- Based on the Graded Care Profile by Dr OP
Shrivastava - GCP provides
- Framework for making assessment
- Baseline measurement
- An element of objectivity
- Judgement about care
- Reliable standardised evidence
59When do you make a GCP assessment?
- Concerns about parenting
- Child exhibiting problems
- Children in need of protection
- Children in need
- Devising a programme of intervention
- Any other parenting concerns
60GCP users
- Health visitors
- School nurses
- Social workers
- Family centre workers
61GCP uses
- Pre-referral assessments
- Snapshot assessments
- Contribution to CAF assessments
- Contribution to Core Assessment (parenting
capacity) - Self-assessment (parents and carers)
- Young persons assessment of parenting
- Tool for setting goals and assessing progress
- Tool to facilitate discussion
62Why choose GCP?
- Child focused
- User friendly
- Common language
- Promotes partnership
63Why choose GCP?
- Evaluates strengths as well as weaknesses
- Allows progress to be assessed
- A relatively objective measure
- Allows help to be targeted where needed
64Domains of Care
Stimulation Approval Disapproval Acceptance
Sensitivity Responsivity Reciprocity Overtures
Self actualisation
Esteem
Love and belongingness
Present absent
Safety
Physical needs
Nutrition. Housing, Clothing, Hygiene Health
Maslow, A. 1954
65What to observe
Nutrition Housing Clothing Hygiene Health
Quality, Quantity, Preparation, Organisation,
A. PHYSICAL B. SAFETY C. LOVE D. ESTEEM
66Grades of Care
Grade 1 Grade 2 Grade 3 Grade 4 Grade 5
Level of care All childs needs met Essential needs fully met Some essential needs met Most essential needs unmet Essential needs entirely unmet/hostile
Commitment to care Child first Child priority Child/carer at par Child second Child not considered
Quality of care Best Adequate Equivocal Poor Worst
Wirral rating No concern No concern Recommend prevention support Child protection Child protection and legal strategy meeting
67Scoring
- Rating 5 25
- Use on every child in the family
- Use with different carers
- Complete with the parent/carer
- Use information, observation, records
68Scoring
- Score as actually fits the manual
- DO NOT JUSTIFY BY REASONS
- If there is a score of 20 or 25, this overrides
any other scores - Scores between 5 and 15, record the one which
crops up most - If there is an even split, the highest score is
entered
69Scoring
- Complete individual scores in the manual
- Transpose to the record sheet
- Agree action, targets and timescales
70A
AREAS
PHYSICAL CARE
Sub-areas
1
?
Items
a
b
c
d
5
15
10
15
2
?
c
a
b
10
20
10
3
?
c
a
b
15
5
10
4
15
5
?
d
a
b
c
15
15
10
10
71Scoring
- Score as actually fits the manual
- DO NOT JUSTIFY BY REASONS
- If there is a score of 20 or 25, this overrides
any other scores - Scores between 5 and 15, record the one which
crops up most - If there is an even split, the highest score is
entered
72A
AREAS
PHYSICAL CARE
Sub-areas
1
?
Items
a
b
c
d
5
15
10
15
2
?
c
a
b
10
20
10
3
?
c
a
b
15
5
10
4
15
5
?
d
a
b
c
15
15
10
10
73A
AREAS
PHYSICAL CARE
Reference Sheet
Sub-areas
1
15
Items
a
b
c
d
5
15
10
15
2
20
c
a
b
10
20
10
3
15
c
a
b
15
5
10
4
15
5
15
d
a
b
c
15
15
10
10
74Record sheet
75(No Transcript)
76Targeting Items of Care
Targeted Areas Current Score Target Score Timescale Reviewed Score
1
2
3
4
5
77Unique Advantages
- Common language, common reference
- Objective measure child focussed
- Effective tool to promote partnership assessments
and planning with parents - User friendly
- Comprehensively covers all areas of care
- Child and carer specific
78What helps in working with neglect
- Proactive assessment
- Addressing causes not symptoms
- An ecological framework
- Multidisciplinary assessment
- Understanding histories and patterns
79What helps in working with neglect
- Matching interventions to identified needs
- Clear objectives and timescales
- Work with parents
- Work with children in a resilience framework
80Substance use and neglect
- Experimental drug users
- Recreational drug users
- People who use legal substances
- People who are dependent on illegal drugs or
alcohol - But we focus on the stage when the use of drugs
or alcohol is having a harmful effect on a
persons life
81Some statistics
- Between 50 and 90 of families on social
workers child care caseloads have parent(s) with
drug, alcohol or mental health problems - Glasgow 1998/9 40 of Child Protection Orders
cited drug abuse - Dundee Child protection conferences involving
parents with problems over drug or alcohol use
rose from 37 in 1998/9 to 70 in 2000
82Effects vary, but
- Substance misuse may become central preoccupation
- Reduce or alter appetite
- Reactions to pain and discomfort dulled
- Self-neglect
- Social relationships narrow
- Trouble with money, housing and the law
- Poor physical and mental health
- Interpersonal conflict and poor family
relationships
83Effects on children
- Parental substance misuse alone is neither a
necessary nor sufficient cause of problems in
children (Mountenay, 1998) - International literature on the children of drug
users does not support an assumption that child
abuse and neglect automatically follow when a
parent uses drugs (Hogan,1998) - But, families need comprehensive assessment and
active support to promote resilience and repair
damage
84Effects on children
- Alcohol and/or substance misuse greatly increase
the likelihood of family problems (Sher 1991
Zeitlin, 1994) - Substance use can become the central focus of the
adults lives, feelings and social behaviour. - CAMH services report substantial risk of poor
childhood mental health (Mountenay, 1999) - Poor long-term outcomes for children (Rutter and
Rutter, 1992)
85Effects on children
- I hated weekends when mum had all her friends
round drinking all night. - Sarah daughter of problem drinker
- She was just always dead moody, she was always
in her bed all the time and she would never go
out and buy food and she would never have money
to go out and get it. - (Barnard 2002)
- the children of problem drinkers forgotten
children, a hidden tragedy, and or unseen
casualties (Wilson 1982)
86Specific effects (mainly US Studies)
- High risk of maltreatment, emotional or physical
neglect or abuse, family conflict and
inappropriate parental behaviour Famularo,
Kindscherff and Fenton, 1992 Wasserman and
Levanthal, 1993, Barlow, 1996). - Exposed to drug-related activity and associated
crime (Hogan, 1998) - Inconsistent and lukewarm care, ineffective
supervision and overly punitive discipline
(Kandel, 1990 Boyd, 1993).
87Specific effects (mainly US Studies)
- More likely to
- display behavioural problems (Wilens et al,
1995), - experience social isolation and estrangement from
family and peers, and stigma (Kumpfer and De
Marsh, 1986), - misuse substances themselves when older (Hoffman
and Su, 1998 McKeganey 1998) - In the longer term isolation, difficulties with
change and learning to have fun (Barlow, 1996)
88Pre-birth, infancy and pre-school
- Risk of physical harm pre-birth
- Neglect and injury through drugged state of
parent, access to drugs - Inappropriate emotional care through unhappiness,
tension, irritability, preoccupation - Cognitive and emotional development affected by
lack of stimulation and inconsistent/unpredictable
behaviour, unstable environment
89Pre-birth, infancy and pre-school
- Poor contact with other children
- Materially deprived environment
- Self-esteem and positive sense of identity
affected by physical and emotional neglect - Experience violence
- Where parents behaviour is particularly
unpredictable and frightening, symptoms of PTSD
90Pre-birth, infancy and pre-school
- Baby Adele was carried along the harbour wall by
her father who was under the influence of
alcohol. Neighbours thought this carried the risk
of dropping her in the water. - (Scottish Executive 2002)
- My parents started giving me alcohol when I was
1 (year old) to put me to sleep. I got taken into
hospital to have my stomach pumped. - Helen, aged 12
91Primary school
- Symptoms of extreme anxiety and fear of hostility
- Boys more quickly exhibit behavioural problems
(but girls equally affected) - Self-blame and poor self-esteem
- Academic attainment and social development
affected by neglect and poor attendance, poor
concentration - Shame and embarrassment lead to isolation
- Young carers
92Primary school
- I used to feel angry when my Mum was on drugs
cause I used to think how could this have
happened to me? I was just sad all the time and
then I would get angry. And we would have
arguments all the time. - Anne, aged 11
- I used to get really embarrassed at school when
mum turned up drunk to collect me. I knew that I
would have to make the tea when I got in. - Billy, aged 9
93Secondary school
- Puberty without parental support
- Increased risk of conduct disorders, bullying and
sexual aggression - Beyond parental control and increased risk of
injury by parents - Socialised into substance misuse
94Secondary school
- I knew they loved me but they just didnt care
that I was there and I needed stuff as well - Elaine, aged 14
- At school, if your pals know your mas on drugs
you get called a junkie - (Aberlour 2002)
95Protective factors
- Sufficient income
- A consistent caring adult
- Regular monitoring and respite
- Refuge from violence
- Regular school/nursery attendance
- Sympathetic and vigilant teachers
- Organised out of school activities
96The significant harm threshold
- The threshold is probably passed when
- Parental drug and alcohol use is adversely
impacting on the childs health and development - There is no one parental figure able to provide a
stable secure environment for the child - There is no evidence that parental behaviour will
change within a timeframe congruent with the
needs of the child - (Luton LSCB Safeguarding Inter-Agency
Procedures, 2006)
97When enough is enough
- When a parent consistently places procurement and
use of alcohol or drugs over their childs
welfare and fails to meet a childs physical or
emotional needs, the outlook for the childs
health and development is poor. Problem alcohol
or drug using parents themselves acknowledge this
and it is the duty of professionals to act in the
childs best interests when parents cannot. - (Getting our priorities right, 2003)
98Referral triggers
- Use of the family resources to finance the
parents dependency, characterised by inadequate
food, heat and clothing for the children - Children exposed to unsuitable caregivers or
visitors, e.g. customers or dealers - The effects of alcohol leading to an
inappropriate display of sexual and/or aggressive
behaviour - Chaotic drug and alcohol use leading to emotional
unavailability, irrational behaviour and reduced
parental vigilance
99Referral triggers
- Disturbed moods as a result of withdrawal
symptoms or dependency - Unsafe storage of drugs and/or alcohol or
injecting equipment - Drugs and/or alcohol having an adverse impact on
the growth and development of the unborn child - (LSCB Safeguarding Inter-Agency Procedures,
2006
100Assessment
- Generic
- CAF
- GCP (assessment of parenting)
- Specialist substance misuse and/or child
protection assessment
101Assessment principles
- Focus on the child
- Consider outcomes for the child, not the intent
of the parent - Focus more on the childs lived experience than
on specific incidents - Adults management of their own lives is a good
indicator of their ability to look after a child - Take full account of historical information
- Information from a variety of sources is better
than information from one
102Working together
- Complex network of intervention
- Support parents and parenting
- Stabilise/reduce substance misuse
- Reduce risk and harmful effects on children
- These objectives may not always be compatible,
especially with regard to timescales
103Substance misuse workers vs child care workers
- Mutual incomprehension and misunderstanding
- Working on the same case but not working jointly
- False expectations and assumptions
- Abdicating responsibility (both ways)
- Need for interpreters
104Working with parents
- It is good practice to work in partnership with
parents - Professionals should be open and honest with
parents about the problems and risks they
perceive - Working with parents as partners does not mean
their wishes determine decisions, but that their
views are sought and taken into account.
105Working with parents
- It is important to recognise that
- Parents will often hide the extent of their
problem for fear of the consequences - They may find it very hard to change, despite the
consequences - This means testing and checking their accounts