333

1
Hörmann perimeter protection systems
GOOD REASONS AND COMPETITOR COMPARISON PERIMETER
PROTECTION SYSTEMS BOLLARDS
2
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Good reasons
Compact and flexible fitting

• In bollards with integrated electric and
  hydraulic operators, all functional components
  are compactly fitted in the bollard unit
• Easy and quick maintenance thanks to the
  integrated hydraulic system equipped with
  biodegradable oil (standard). The integrated
  hydraulic system requires only small oil
  quantities, which poses far less of a risk to the
  environment.
• Biologically degradable oil is also available as
  an option to reduce the environmental risk to
  zero
• Electromechanical environmental friendly
  bollards available both in the Security as in the
  High Security range reduces maintenance time too.
  
• A further advantage is the fact that the control
  can be installed up to 80 meters away from the
  bollard when connected to a power / connection
  cable

3
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Good reasons
Fast and perfect service

• Very fast and simple initial start-up
• 100 final inspection of all products before
  delivery, all systems are assembled before
  delivery and all functions are tested according
  to requirements
• Spare parts ready in 2 working days from order
  confirmation

4
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Good reasons
Matching bollard versions

• For a customized combination of bollards from the
  Security Line and High Security Line, all bollard
  cylinders are identical in appearance
• This means that fixed, semi-automatic and
  automatic bollards can be perfectly combined by
  choosing matching bottom plates Matching
  appearance of bollards enables multiple bollards
  installations.
• Ensuring a harmonious overall appearance
• Different cylinder material and finishing
  available painted steel (any color on request)
  brushed or painted stainless steel, stone.
• Safety and high visibility due to LEDs,
  reflecting strips, buzzer.

5
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Good reasons
One-Stop-Shop, fast and unbureaucratic
Hörmann offers the complete range of perimeter
protection systems, from simple barriers, barrier
systems, bollards and road blockers to complex
parking ticket machines and accessories Everythin
g from a single source!
6
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Good
reasons
Individual control concepts

• A control allows complete control concepts
  involving several bollards, for example, to be
  combined. This concept enables master and slave
  relationships to be configured between the
  bollards
• The control is connected by means of
  maintenance-friendly quick-connecting terminals.
  These facilitate fitting and help avoid the need
  for maintenance in the future
• In addition, The control unit can be easily
  expanded (master slaves) and integrated with
  further control systems, such as card readers,
  key selectors, induction loops detector, thus
  granting highest configuration flexibility.
  Terminals already equipped with samples of wires
  to simplify the wiring connections
• Prepared for online connection, enabling remote
  control and administration via web server
  operation as well service via mobile devices

7
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Good reasons

• Our competitors generally do not supply rebars
  and brackets
• The costs are passed on to the civil engineering
  company when preparing the quotation
• Bending or welding a reinforcement according to
  instructions can only be carried out by
  specialists in accordance with standards and
  therefore costs a lot of time and money
• 10 meters of cable are always included as
  standard. The connection can be extended up to
  50/80 meters depending on the model and
  configuration
• Samples are left in the control unit to
  facilitate the connection of the wires

8
Hörmann Perimeter Protection Systems Advantages
and arguments for a Hörmann bollard

1. Customer-specific configuration fittings and
   settings are already made in the factory
2. 100 final test before delivery, reduced
   configuration time on site
3. Completely pre-assembled, low installation costs
   on site
4. Easy and fast maintenance due to the integrated
   hydraulic system biodegradable oil as an option
   without surcharge
5. Safety and high visibility due to LEDs,
   reflecting strips and acoustic warning signal.
   Automatic cut-off stops lifting if the bollard
   encounters an obstacle (Security Line)
6. The control unit can be easily extended for
   further control systems, such as card readers,
   key switches and induction loops
7. Prepared for online connection, enabling remote
   control and administration via web server
   operation as well service via mobile devices
8. Full range of crash-tested high security bollards
   available in different configurations
9. Security and High Security bollards with
   integrated electromechanical operator are
   particularly environmentally-friendly and low
   maintenance
10. Maximal installation flexibility as the control
    unit can be installed up to 80 meters away from
    the bollard
11. Matching appearance of different bollard
    combinations (Security and High Security Line,
    fixed, semi-automatic and automatic bollards)
    result in a harmonious overall look
12. Different cylinder materials and finishings
    available painted steel (any RAL color on
    request,) brushed or painted stainless steel

9
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards
High security bollards HÖRMANN A 275-M50-1200
H FAAC J355 HA M50 EFO
HÖRMANN A 275-M50-900 H CAME Urbaco One 50 EVO
OO BFT OAK 1200.12 light vern EFO
10
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards

• FAAC J 355 HA M50 EFO
• Only 12 LEDs, limited visibility
• No CE mark for the overall system, machinery
  directive 2006/42/EC not mentioned

11
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards

• FAAC J 355 HA M50 EFO
• Hydraulic pump only IP55 because the pump is
  installed in the bollards foundation box, this
  can lead to malfunctions

12
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards

• FAAC J 355 HA M50 EFO
• Bollard diameter of 355 mm looks very bulky and
  is not visually attractive to urban planners.
• With a diameter of 275 mm, the Hörmann bollard is
  more attractive and more elegant. Nevertheless,
  the values for the certificates are achieved.
• The FAAC does not indicate a number of cycles
  (Hörmann 2000 / day)

13
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards

• FAAC J 355 HA M50 EFO
• The reinforcement cannot be ordered at the same
  time, plans are not clear, struts and the housing
  must be welded, only welders with a special
  technical training are allowed to do this
• Load class C250 (25 t)
• Hoermann D400 (40 t)

14
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards

• FAAC J 355 HA M50 EFO
• Very poor finish on the cylinder (surface)
• Poor finish of weld seams on the base
  construction and foundation box
• Cables not included in the scope of delivery
• The system is not tested beforehand
• Strength class (concrete) B45 to achieve the
  certificates

15
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards

• FAAC J 355 HA M50 EFO
• Longer fitting time, because
• the installation frame for connection to the
  foundation box is delivered individually

16
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards

• FAAC J 355 HA M50 EFO
• Foundation box made of individual parts and
  riveted ? does not look sturdy ? Strength when
  filling the liquid concrete questionable
• Foundation boxes from Hörmann have a sturdier
  design

17
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards

• FAAC J 355 HA M50 EFO
• Longer fitting time, because
• the foundation work
• is more complex in preparation
• Especially as the foundation also extends up to
  3000 mm in the horizontal position
• Hörmann offers compact foundations centred around
  the foundation box, which is fully assembled
  in the factory

18
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards

• FAAC J 355 HA M50 EFO
• Longer fitting time, because
• The components are not yet prepared, only
  individual components are supplied
• The customer must assemble the control and
  accessories himself
• No cables supplied

19
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards

• FAAC J 355 HA M50 EFO
• Longer fitting time, because
• The components are not yet prepared, only
  individual components are supplied
• The customer has to connect the capacitor to the
  bollard himself

20
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards

• CAME / Urbaco One 50 EVO

• Bollard diameter 325 mm? looks very large and is
  not visually attractive
• Hörmann actually achieves even higher impact
  loads with a diameter of 275 mm
• Hörmann 2000000 J
• Came 1776000 J
• No indication of cycles / day (Hörmann 2000)
• No indication of impact energy without
  destruction (Hörmann 700000 J)
• The total weight of 1100 kg is also higher than
  our equivalent Hörmann product M50-900 (approx.
  880 kg)
• In case of power failure, the bollard can only be
  lowered manually with an external hydraulic unit

21
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards

• CAME / Urbaco One 50 EVO

• The system is not tested beforehand
• The control (Siemens Logo) is still to be
• programmed
• Instructions are a mixture of French and English
• Very loud during travel and stops hard in the
  end-of-travel position (increased wear?)
• Reinforcement not available, galvanized
  foundation box must be installed separately from
  the reinforcement
• Bollards without reflective stripes

22
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards

• CAME / Urbaco One 50 EVO

• The foundation box has a very robust design, made
  of galvanized 6 mm steel and the first signs of
  rust on the weld seams are already visible
• Bollard raising time 5 7 seconds (Hörmann
  approx. 4 seconds)
• Bollard lowering time approx. 5 seconds (Hörmann
  approx. 3 seconds)
• 400 Volt connection required, only from 3
  bollards at Hörmann

23
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards

• CAME / Urbaco One 50 EVO

Came makes claims in the brochures that cannot be
verified. They advertise a replaceable sleeve in
case of collision damage, for example. However,
the damage is usually more severe and further
components have to be replaced.
24
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards

• CAME / Urbaco One 50 EVO

When the stainless steel version is selected,
only the cylinder sleeve is supplied in stainless
steel. Bollards together with the foundation box
(galvanised sheet steel and the bollard base
element made of steel) have an electrolytic
effect in the ground and corrosion is
unavoidable.
25
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards

• CAME / Urbaco One 50 EVO

26
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards

• CAME / Urbaco One 50 EVO

They advertise that 2 crash tests were carried
out in immediate succession with the same
bollard. However, this is not required in any
standard / directive. Our equivalent Hörmann
product was also still fully functional after one
crash test!
27
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards

• CAME / Urbaco One 50 EVO

• The hydraulic pump must be fitted at the side in
  the foundation box

28
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards

• CAME / Urbaco One 50 EVO

• Reinforcement not available, galvanized
  foundation box must be installed separately from
  the reinforcement

29
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards
OO BFT OAK 1200.12 light vern EFO

• The reinforcement cannot be ordered at the same
  time
• Plans for the reinforcement are not clear
• The system is not tested beforehand, EFO could
  not be adjusted
• No indication of standards and directives

30
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards
OO BFT OAK 1200.12 light vern EFO

• No indication of JOULES under without
  deformation
• Hydraulic unit is fitted next to the bollard
• The LED light can hardly be seen in daylight

31
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards
OO BFT OAK 1200.12 light vern EFO
Component delivery only ? longer fitting time The
customer must assemble all individual parts into
one machine
32
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards
OO BFT OAK 1200.12 light vern EFO

• The system is not tested beforehand
• EFO could not be adjusted
• Reflective stripes, supplied separately, without
  E mark

33
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards
OO BFT OAK 1200.12 light vern EFO

• Hydraulic unit is installed next to the bollard
  
• ? Longer hydraulic hoses mean increased oil and
  water binding is possible
• ? Viscosity becomes worse

34
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards
OO BFT OAK 1200.12 light vern EFO

• Bollard raising time approx. 5 seconds (Hörmann
  approx. 4 seconds)
• Bollard lowering time approx. 4 seconds (Hörmann
  approx. 3 seconds)
• Impact loads
• Hörmann 2000000 J
• BFT 2100000 J
• 2000 cycles / day (Hörmann 2000)
• (all information from the BFT product
  documentation)

35
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards
OO BFT OAK 1200.12 light vern EFO

• The finish is mediocre (weld seams for example)

36
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards
Traffic bollards HÖRMANN A 275 600 / 800 H
FAAC / J 275/600 (800) HA V2
37
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards
FAAC / J 275 HA V2

• The foundation box is delivered as a kit (2
  persons need approx. 45 minutes for the
  preparations)
• Plastic seal for LEDs not tight ? Problem area
  for moisture
• Connecting leads are not included in the scope of
  delivery
• Component delivery only
• The system is not tested beforehand

38
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards
FAAC / J 275 HA V2

• Only steel attachment pieces for the bollard as
  an end stop, therefore no fine adjustment of the
  lowered bollard possible

Hörmann uses variable attachment pieces
39
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards
FAAC / J 275 HA V2

• Fine adjustment not possible in the bollard
  bottom end-of-travel position

40
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards
FAAC / J 275 HA V2

• The fitting bracket for the plastic magnet limit
  switch breaks easily

41
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards
FAAC / J 275 HA V2

• The bollard lowers relatively quickly and has a
  soft stop just before the bottom end-of-travel
  position
• Eyebolts to lift the bollard are included in the
  scope of delivery

42
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards
Traffic bollards HÖRMANN A 275 600 / 800 H
BFT / Pillar B 275/800.6 C Li
43
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards
BFT / Pillar B 275/800.6 C Li

• Component delivery only, meaning longer fitting
  time
• The system is not tested beforehand
• No main switch present
• The bollard cable inlet could cause problems when
  casting in concrete

44
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards
BFT / Pillar B 275/800.6 C Li

• LED lighting very weak difficult to see
• CE mark on the instructions but no further
  details
• The control must be fully connected and
  programmed

45
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards
Traffic bollards HÖRMANN A 275 600 / 800 H
CAME / Urbaco G6 EVO
46
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards
CAME / Urbaco G6 EVO

• Wiring must be carried out on site in advance

47
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards
CAME / Urbaco G6 EVO

• The system is not tested beforehand
• Control (Siemens Logo) still to be programmed,
  not ready for operation

48
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards
CAME / Urbaco G6 EVO

• Foldable foundation box simple transport but
  not a solid design
• Reflective stripes only 30 mm wide (Hörmann 55 mm
  ? easier to see)

49
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards
CAME / Urbaco G6 EVO

• Possible risk of slipping due to the smooth
  bollard cover
• Excavation work is inadequately described in the
  instructions, only small sketches
• The bollard lighting is a little faint due to
  internal LED light strip

50
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards
CAME / Urbaco G6 EVO

• Cast steel base construction ? load class E 600
  (60 tonnes) ? durability and quality?
• Hydraulic pumps from the same supplier as Hörmann

51
Hörmann perimeter protection systems Competitor
comparison of bollards
CAME / Urbaco G6 EVO

• Cast steel base construction ? load class E 600
  (60 tonnes) ? durability and quality?
• Statement from the CAME sales documentation
• The Monobloc bollard head, housing and cover
  are made of monobloc cast iron with an average
  thickness of 11 mm, without weld seams or wearing
  parts. The particularly resistant bollard head,
  cover and housing have a 10-year warranty even
  after a 55 km/h impact from a 2.5 tonne vehicle.
  G6 EVO bollards with a long service life
  withstand frequent impacts, vandalism, rain,
  frost, sand, dust, solvents. Proven reliability
  of 4500000 operating cycles without malfunction
  or replacement (1200 operating cycles / day over
  10 years)....