Title: Medical Marijuana: Pros and Cons A
1Medical Marijuana Pros and ConsA Prescription
for Trouble?
- Elizabeth Libby Stuyt, MD
- University of Colorado, Department of Psychiatry
- Medical Director, Circle Program
- Colorado Mental Health Institute at Pueblo
- 2012 Colorado Behavioral Healthcare Council
- Annual Training Conference, Sept 28, 2012
2Conflicts
- The Circle Program is now funded in part by
Medical Marijuana Tax proceeds
3Cannabis
- Complex alkaloid mixture of more than 400
compounds derived from the Cannabis sativa plant - 60 different compounds described with activity on
the cannabinergic system - Most abundant cannabinoids are
- Delta-9 tetrahydrocannabinol (most psychoactive)
- Cannabidiol
- Cannabinol
4Cannabinergic system
- Two main cannabis receptors
- CB1present throughout CNS
- Hippocampus
- Cortex
- Olfactory areas
- Basal ganglia
- Cerebellum
- Spinal cord
- CB2 located peripherally,
- linked with immune system
- Spleen
- macrophages
5(No Transcript)
6History of Marijuana
- 6000 BC Cannabis seeds used as food in China
- 4000 BC Textiles made of hemp in China
- 2727 BC first recorded medicinal use in Chinese
Pharmacopoeia - 1400 BC to AD trade moves product through
India, Mediterranean countries, Europe numerous
medicinal uses reported
7History of Marijuana
- 1378 Emir of the Ottoman Empire makes the first
edict against eating hashish or smoking cannabis
1st War on Drugs - 1798 Napoleon declared total prohibition on
marijuana after realizing much of the Egyptian
lower class were habitual smokers - 1868 Egypt 1st modern country to outlaw
cannabis ingestion - 1890 Hashish made illegal in Turkey
8History of Marijuana
- Introduced to North America in 1600s by Puritans
Hemp for ropes, sails, clothing cannabis a
common ingredient in medicines, sold openly in
pharmacies - 1937 Marijuana Tax Act transfer of cannabis
illegal throughout US except for medicinal and
industrial use, expensive excise tax and detailed
logs required - 1969 found to be unconstitutional since it
violated 5th Amendment privilege against
self-recrimination
9(No Transcript)
10History continued
- 1970 Controlled Substance Act classified
cannabis as having - High abuse potential
- No medical use
- Not safe to use under medical supervision
- 1975 FDA establishes Compassionate Use Program
for Medical Marijuana Glaucoma, Multiple
Sclerosis, Cancer - 1986 Dronabinol placed into Schedule II by DEA
- 2003 Canada 1st country in world to offer
medical marijuana to patients
11Compassionate Use not based on any research
- Glaucoma - 1 cause of blindness
- 1992 American Academy of Ophthalmologys
Committee on Drugs no scientific verifiable
evidence that the use of marijuana is safe and
effective in the treatment of glaucoma - 1997 NEI no studies have demonstrated that
marijuana can safely and effectively lower IOP
any more than a variety of drugs on the market
12Glaucoma
- 1999 Institute of Medicine although IOP can
be reduced by using cannabinoids and marijuana,
the effect is too short lived and requires too
high doses. - There are too many side effects to recommend
lifelong use in the treatment of glaucoma - Would have to smoke 10-12 joints per 24 hours to
maintain low IOP through out the day
13Indications
- Dronabinol (Marinol) and nabilone (Cesamet)
indicated for chemotherapy-induced nausea and
vomiting - Dronabinol (Marinol) approved for HIV-associated
anorexia - Sativex (oromucosal spray) conditionally approved
for neuropathic pain in multiple sclerosis and
cancer pain - Herbal smoked marijuana found to be safe and
effective for HIV-associated disorders
14Canada
- Four cannabinoid products available
- Herbal cannabis extract, Sativex, delta-9-THC
and cannabidiol in oromucosal spray - Dronabinol synthetic delta-9-THC, Marinol
- Nabilone synthetic derivative of delta-9-THC,
Cesamet - Herbal form of cannabis medical marijuana
15Research Issues
- MJ is a Schedule I drug a barrier to conducting
prospective RCTs, DB w/ placebo - Studies are short - two weeks average, ranging
from a few hours to one year - Most studies conducted with oral TCH preps rather
than smoked cannabis - Most studies exclude anyone with a history of
major psychiatric disorder other than depression
and/or history of substance abuse - Most studies done to date
- Short in length (average two weeks)
- Small N (lacking power)
- Retrospective in nature
- Confounded by uncontrolled variables
- Concomitant tobacco use
- Comorbid illnesses
16Studies of Effects on Pain
- Lit review of cannabinoids given by any route for
treatment of pain Campbell et al. BMJ
20013231-6 - 9 RCTs, 222 patients, 5 trials cancer pain 2
chronic non-malignant pain 2 post-operative
pain none evaluated cannabis - Cannabinoids are no more effective than codeine
in controlling pain and have depressant effects
on the CNS that limit their use. In acute
postoperative pain they should not be used.
Before cannabinoids can be considered for
treating spasticity and neuropathic pain, further
valid randomized controlled studies are needed.
17Side Effects of Cannabis
- Most of our knowledge about the negative effects
of marijuana come from recreational use - Literature review of safety studies of medical
cannabinoids over past 40 years 23 RCTs (median
exposure to cannabinoids 2 weeks, range 8 hrs to
12 months) Wang et al. CMAJ 2008171669-1678
18Side Effects
- 4779 adverse events reported in those assigned to
the intervention - 96.6 were not serious
- 164 serious events no different from controls
(RR) 1.04 - Rate of nonserious events higher among those
assigned medical cannabinoids than controls
(RR)1.86 dizziness most common event
19Studies with Smoked Cannabis
- Double-blind, placebo controlled, crossover trial
of smoked cannabis for the short term treatment
of neuropathic pain associated with HIV five
study phases over 7 weeks five days of active
or placebo smoking with washout periods - Participants had documented HIV, neuropathic pain
refractory to a least two previous analgesics, 5
or higher on pain scale (Ellis et al.
Neuropyschopharmacology 200934672-680)
20Studies of Smoked Cannabis
- Four smoking sessions per day, titrating dose
(1-8 THC) to achieve maximum tolerable dose - Exclusion criteria
- Current substance use disorder
- Lifetime history of dependence on cannabis
- Concurrent use of medication with cannabinoids
- Previous psychosis with or intolerance to
cannabinoids
21Results
- significantly reduced neuropathic pain intensity
compared to placebo - 46 with cannabis reported a 30 reduction in
pain versus 18 with placebo - Another study with almost identical outcomes
52 vs 24, gt30 reduction in pain with 3 smoking
sessions/day (Abrams et al. Neurology
200768515-521) - All patients were required to have prior
experience smoking marijuana so they would know
how to inhale and what neuropsychological effects
to expect
22More Studies of Smoked Cannabis
- Ware et al. CMAJ. 2010E694-E701.
- N21
- Inclusion Criteria
- Outpatients with gt 3 month hx neuropathic pain
- Pain caused by physical trauma or surgery
- Pain intensity gt 4 (0 to 10 scale)
- Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled,
four-period crossover design - THC concentration 0, 2.5, 6 or 9.4
- Three daily dosages x 5 days
- 9 day washout period.
- Participants advised not to drive a vehicle or
operate heavy machinery while on study drug
23Ware et al. CMAJ. 2010E694-E701(cont)
- Average daily pain intensity
- 5.4 on 9.4 THC cannabis
- 6.1 on Placebo(0 THC)
- (p0.023difference 0.7, 95 CI 0.02-1.4)
- No difference observed between 2.5, 6, 0
- The reduction is modest when compared with that
from other drugs for neuropathic pain such as
gabapentin or pregabalin - A joint with a 9.4 THC content would impair
the majority of us
24Dose-dependent effects of smoked cannabis on
Capsaicin-induced pain and hyperalgesia in
healthy volunteers (Wallace et al.
Anesthesiology. 2007107785-796)
- Randomized, double-blinded, placebo-controlled,
crossover design - High dose training session, 15 subjects
- 100 mg capsaicin injected intradermally ventral
forearm spontaneous pain - Stroking and von Frey hair stimulation elicited
pain - Low dose 2 THC, medium dose 4THC, high dose 8
THC
25Results
- Capsaicin injections induced spontaneous and
elicited pain in all subjects - No difference in pain perception between any of
the cannabis doses and placebo during early
(right arm) course - Low dose did not differ from placebo at any time
point - During late course (left arm) medium dose
subjects reported decreased pain sensation, high
dose subjects reported increased perception of
pain consistent with other reports that chronic
delivery of cannabinoids can cause thermal
hyperalgesia
26So To Review
- Marijuana (smoked/oral) used as a therapeutic,
not recreational agent, is a drug as defined by
the FDA - All new drugs must be scientifically evaluated
before they may be allowed to enter the stream of
interstate commerce - The drug does not have to be proven superior to
already approved drugs, its benefits must
outweigh the risks when used for the purpose for
which it has been approved
27The fact that it is a botanical does not preclude
scientific investigation
- Digitalis purpurea fox glove - CHF
- Papaver somniferum opium poppy
- Atropa belladonna nightshade -IBS
- Ephedra sinica ephedrine - hypotension
- Salix alba willow tree - ASA
- Taxis brevifolia Pacific Yew tree breast
cancer
28DEA Scheduling Drugs depends on
- Does the drug have a currently accepted medical
use in the United States? - What is the drugs safety under medical
supervision? - What is its addiction liability?
- Is there a potential for significant diversion
for illegal use? - Are individuals using it on their own initiative
or only on physicians prescription? - Is the drug similar in its pharmacology to other
controlled drugs?
29(No Transcript)
30Rocky Mountain HighColorado
- November 2000
- Coloradoans passed Amendment 20
- Colorado Department of Public Health and
Environment was tasked with implementing and
administrating the Medical Marijuana Registry
program - March 2001
- Colorado Board of Health approved rules and
regulations - June 2001
- MMJ Registry began accepting applications
for Registry Identification Cards.
31The Flood Gates Opened
- February 2009
- Obama administration indicated that Medical
Marijuana prosecution would have low priority - October 2009
- Obama administration will not seek to arrest
medical marijuana users and suppliers as long as
they conform to state laws - Applications increased dramatically
- September 2009 3,523 applications
received/month - December 2009 10,585 applications received/month
32The Passage of Amendment 20
- Storefront Medical Marijuana dispensaries
sprouted like weeds!
33MMJ A Recession Proof Industry
- Marijuana Growers
- Caregivers
- Legal
- Doctors making recommendations ()
- Grow Lights
- Vaporizers
- Pipes
- Edibles
- Advertising (Westword has gone green)
- Festivals
- Delivery Services
34There are more medical marijuana dispensaries in
Denver than Starbucks and liquor stores
combinedThe Denver Post
35September 30, 2009 June 30, 2012
- 19,691 new patient applications received
- 17,356 patients with valid ID cards
- 73 male, average age 40, 8 minors lt18
- 57 in the Denver/metro area
- 67 have designated primary care-giver
- Over 800 different physicians have signed for
patients in Colorado
- 184,002 new patient applications received
- 99,960 patients with Valid ID cards
- 68 male, average age 42, 47 minors lt18
- 56 in the Denver/metro area
- 54 have designated primary care-giver
- Over 900 different physicians have signed for
patients in Colorado
36Conditions (as of June 2012)
Condition of Patients Percentage
Cachexia 1,215 1
Cancer 2,583 3
Glaucoma 1,021 1
HIV/AIDS 632 1
Muscle Spasms 17,286 17
Seizures 1,708 2
Severe Pain 93,679 94
Severe Nausea 11,567 12
37Either our state is experiencing an epidemic of
severe pain in youthful males or..Amendment
20 is being exploited by recreational users
38Rules and Regulations
- Patient will be deemed to have established an
affirmative defense to such allegation
(possession of marijuana) where - Patient was previously diagnosed by a physician
as having a debilitating medical condition - Patient was advised by his or her physician, in
the context of a bona fide physician-patient
relationship, that the patient might benefit from
the medical use of marijuana in connection with a
debilitating medical condition
39Conditions considered debilitating
- Cachexia
- Severe Pain
- Severe Nausea
- Seizures
- Persistent Muscle Spasms
- Any other medical condition approved by the state
health agency
40Lobbying for New Conditionsunsuccessful so far
- Opioid Dependence
- PTSD
- Bipolar Disorder
- Anxiety Disorders
- Depression
- Tourettes Disorder
- Asthma
- Atherosclerosis
- Crohns Disease
- Diabetes Mellitus
- Hepatitis C
- Hypertension
- MRSA
- Rheumatoid Arthritis
41Rules and Regulations
- Patient may engage in the medical use of
marijuana with no more marijuana than is
medically necessary to address a debilitating
medical condition - No more than 2 ounces and no more than six
plants, 3 or fewer being mature - No patient shall engage in medical use of
marijuana in plain view of, or in a place open
to, the general public
42Problems with the physicians
- In the fall of 2009 _at_ 900 doctors had written
approval letters (7 of licensed MDs) - 15 doctors 72 of forms
- 5 doctors 50 of forms
- One doctor signed 3,500 in a two day period
43SB 109 - 2010
- Defines a bona fide relationship
- Physician must have an unrestricted medical and
DEA license - Addresses physician conflict of interest
physician can not be employed by the dispensary - Allows CMB to examine care of providers
- Two physicians need to independently examine
those lt 21.
44Implications
- The vast majority of these patients dont have
debilitating illnesses - The majority of the patients are young males who
will be exposed to the long term effects of
cannabis exposure - Studies conducted are all short term
- Therefore their risks may be the same as for
recreational users and/or addicts
45Therefore Physicians Recommending Medical
Marijuana
- Will need to get a thorough history - medically,
psychiatrically and substance abuse keep a
chart and have a patient/physician relationship - Will need to attempt to decide what level of
marijuana use is most appropriate - Will need to recommend patients not drive etc.
when under the influence - Will need to follow patients closely for side
effects and unintended consequences
46Marijuana use and Cancer risk
- Marijuana smoke contains several of the same
carcinogens and co-carcinogens as tobacco smoke - Benzoapyrene, a procarcinogenic polycyclic
aromatic hydrocarbon, is present in marijuana tar
at higher concentrations than in tobacco tar - Marijuana smoking involves inhalation of 3 times
the amount of tar as tobacco smoke
47Cancer Studies involving Marijuana
- Studies are small in number and are retrospective
in nature - Confounded by concomitant use of tobacco
- Confounded by underreporting of marijuana use
because such use is often illegal
48Cannabis use and risk of Lung Cancer Aldington et
al. Eur Respir J. 200831280-286
- Case-controlled study of lung cancer in adults lt
55yrs of age in New Zealand - 79 cases of lung cancer and 324 controls
- Risk of lung cancer increased 8 for each
joint-yr (1 joint/day for one year) of cannabis
smoking after adjustment for confounding
variables including tobacco - Risk increased 7 for each pack-yr tobacco
- Long-term cannabis use increases risk of lung
cancer in young adults
49Head and Neck Cancers
- Retrospective, case-controlled study, 173 proven
cases of head and neck cancer and 176 controls
matched with respect to age, sex, race,
education, tobacco, alcohol use - Risk of cancer 2.6 fold greater in cannabis users
than non-users - 3-fold greater increase in those lt 55 yrs
- Zhang et al. Cancer Epidemiol Biomark Prev
199981071-1078.
50Other Cancers
- In a cohort study among non-tobacco smokers,
ever-marijuana smokers had increased risk for
prostate cancer - RR3.1, and cervical cancer -
RR1.4 Sidney et al. Cancer Causes Control
19978722-728. - Another cohort study found an increased risk of
malignant primary adult-onset glioma for
ever-marijuana smokers RR1.9 Efird et al. J
Neurooncol 20046857-69
51Metabolism of Marijuana
- Massive first pass metabolism via the oral route
only 10-20 reaches systemic circulation
unchanged takes 30 60 minutes to achieve an
effect key side effect on CNS can be dysphoria
rather than euphoria - Via the lungs onset of action within seconds
high experienced with serum concentration of 3
ng/ml, produced by as little as 2-3 mg D9THC,
average joint contains 0.5 1.0 g of cannabis
52Routes of Administration
- Where theres smoke, theres harm, There is no
future in smoking marijuana as a conventional
medicine Janet Joy PhD - Until there is an alternative, for a small
segment of the population there is a modest
clinical benefit of smoked marijuana - Sound theoretical reasons for intrathecal or
epidural cannabinoids may produce spinal cord
analgesia without effects on cerebral receptors
that are associated with psychotropic effects
53Marijuana and Cognitive Impairment
- Use of 4 joints or more per week resulted in a
decrement in mental test performance, subjects
who smoked regularly for a decade or more did the
worst Messinis et al. Neurology 200666737 - Long-term marijuana users were impaired 70 of
the time on a decision making test, compared to
55 for short-term users and 8 for non-users
54Marijuana and Cognitive Impairment
- Heavy marijuana use (daily for at least one
month) is associated with residual
neuropsychological effects even after a day of
supervised abstinence from the drug Harrison et
al. JAMA 1996275521 - Unknown whether this is due to residue of drug in
the brain, withdrawal effects or frank neurotoxic
effect of the drug
55How Drugs of Abuse affect the Learning and Memory
part of the Brain
56(No Transcript)
57(No Transcript)
58Natural Rewards Elevate Dopamine Levels
59Effects of Drugs on Dopamine Levels
Source Di Chiara and Imperato
60Effects of Drug Use on the Hippocampus
- Drugs of abuse are potent negative regulators of
adult neurogenesis in the hippocampus - Chronic administration of opiates, THC, ethanol
or nicotine decreases hippocampal function,
decreasing ability of adult brain to adapt to new
information
61Regional Brain Abnormalities Associated with
Long-term heavy Cannabis Use Arch Gen Psychiatry
200865694-701
- 15 long term (gt10 years) and heavy (gt5 joints
daily) cannabis using men compared with 16 age
matched non using controls by MRIs of brains - Cannabis users had bilaterally reduced
hippocampal and amygdala volumes p.001 - Increase in positive symptoms (psychotic) plt.001
- Significantly worse performance on measures of
verbal learning plt.001
62Multiple Sclerosis and Cannabis A cognitive and
psychiatric study
- 10 subjects with MS and current cannabis users
compared with 40 subjects with MS who did not use
cannabis - psychiatric diagnosis higher in cannabis users
p0.04 - Slower mean performance time on SDMT (index of
information processing speed, working memory and
sustained attention) in the cannabis users
p0.006 - Neurology 200871164-169
63Marijuana and Driving
- Laboratory tests and driving studies show that
cannabis may acutely impair several
driving-related skills in a dose related fashion - Effects between individuals vary more than for
alcohol because of tolerance, differences in
smoking technique, and different absorptions of
THC Sewell et al. Am J Addictions
200918185-193. - More pronounced with highly automatic driving
functions less with complex tasks that require
conscious control opposite from that seen with
alcohol
64Effects of Marijuana Intoxication and Pilot
Performance Am J Psychiatry 19851421325-1329
- Ten experienced licensed private pilots trained
for 8 hours on a flight stimulator landing task - Each smoked a THC cigarette (19 mg)
- 24 hours later their mean performance on the
flight task showed trends toward impairment in
all variables, some tasks showed significant
impairment - Despite the deficits, the pilots reported no
awareness of impaired performance
65Marijuana and Mental Illness
- Study in Australia tracked 1600 girls for 7 years
Arseneault et al. BMJ 20023251212 - Those who used marijuana every day were 5 times
more likely to suffer from depression and anxiety
than non-users - Teenage girls who used the drug a least once a
week were twice as likely to develop depression
than those who did not use - Cannabis use increased the risk of developing
schizophrenia symptoms specific to cannabis and
early onset prior to age 15
66Risk of Psychosis
- Increased by 40 in people who have used cannabis
Cohen et al. Australian New Zealand J Psychiatry
200842357-368. - Dose-response effect leading to an increased risk
of 50-200 in the most frequent users - Approximately 14 of psychotic outcomes in young
people would not have occurred if cannabis had
not been consumed
67Early Cannabis use associated with psychosis
related outcomes in young adults Arch Gen Psych
201067
- Sibling pair analysis within a prospective birth
cohort in Australia - 3801 young adults cannabis use and 3
psychosis-related outcomes (nonaffective
psychosis, hallucinations, and Delusional
Inventory score) - Early cannabis use is associated with
psychosis-related outcomes in young adults
68Marijuana and Schizophreniadouble-edged sword
- Low doses may improve frontal lobe functioning by
acutely increasing blood flow to cortices
concerned with cognition, mood and perception
increasing availability and utilization of
dopamine - Continued use depresses cerebral flow and high
doses augment mesolimbic dopamine release,
opposing therapeutic effects of antipsychotic
drugs and exacerbating psychosis - It also suppresses PFC dopamine utilization
resulting in cognitive dysfunction
69Spice
- Synthetic cannabinoids AM694 and HU210 found in
Spice products are 500 to 600 times more potent
than the THC found in traditional marijuana - The THC in high potency marijuana and Spice
products are potentially harmful to embryonic
development as early as 2 weeks after conception - Utero exposure to THC linked to anencephaly,
ADHD, Depression, Aggression
70Rats exposed to nicotine as adolescents
self-administer more nicotine than rats exposed
as adults Levin ED et al. Psychopharm
2000169141-149
71Rats First Exposed to Nicotine in Adolescence
Show Greater Sensitization to Cocaine Than Rats
First Exposed as Adults
Activity level after cocaine administration was
measured by counting the number of times in 10
minutes each rat crossed light beams projected in
a grid across its cage.
Sources Collins et al, 2004, Levin et al, 2003,
NIDA Notes v19.2
72Marijuana and Addiction
- Approximately 10 of regular marijuana users
become addicted to it - But this is old data, based on marijuana with
less THC concentrations - Some medicinal marijuana blends, ie Connie
Chung strain contain 20 times more THC than
marijuana found 40 years ago - Compared with 15 for alcohol, 32 for nicotine
and 26 for opiates
73The number of adults with substance use disorders
is trending upward and expected to double by the
year 2020
74Colorado ranks 5th in the nation for adolescent
marijuana use.
75(No Transcript)
76Pros and Cons of Marijuana
- Not associated with death
- Not as addicting as other drugs
- Modest benefit demonstrated for small segment of
the population in short term use
- Marked negative cognitive effects
- Very dangerous to adolescent brain development
and occurrence of mental illness - Cancer risk
- Driving impairment
77Whats the going rate?
- One joint weighs _at_ 0.9 grams with 3.56 THC
(Abrams study) - 0.9 g 0.03 oz
- ¼ oz 7.1 g
- 1 oz 28 g
- 1 oz 31 joints at 3 joints per day need 3 oz
per month - 900/month
78The Hippocratic Oath
- First.do no harm
- The practice of medicine is a privilege. not a
right!
79Malignant versus Non-malignant
- There is definitely a place for Medical Marijuana
when people are suffering with terminal
conditions - Cachexia appetite stimulant
- Nausea secondary to chemotherapy
- Pain mild improvement
- Neither opioid medications nor medical marijuana
is the answer for chronic, non-malignant pain
80Physician Motives
- Financial incentives and/or personal political
views should not influence treatment
recommendations - Conflicts of interest ethically/legally
proscribed - Investment in dispensaries
- kickbacks for referrals
81Societal Costs
- Public Safety
- Cognitive impairment in safety sensitive
positions - Workplace accidents
- Driving and Accidents
- National Transportation Safety Board
- Studied 182 fatal truck accidents in 1999
- Just as many accidents were caused by drivers
impaired by MJ as by drivers impaired by Etoh - Increased criminal activity?
- A large percentage of those arrested for crimes
test positive for MJ - Nationwide 40 of adult males tested positive for
MJ at the time of their arrest
82Societal Costs
- Sending the wrong message to children?
- Soda pot
- Edibles (colorful cookies, cupcakes, candy)
- Its organic, green, natural
- Wellness ads (promoting MJ)
- Case Example Peanut Butter spiced with MJ
83Case Vignette Denver Post December 2009
- 44-year-old female, grandmother and advocate for
medical marijuana used the drug for chronic
back pain most of her life - Gave her 3-year-old grandson a peanut butter
cookie made with cannabis butter - The next day she had trouble rousing the boy and
called an ambulance - Police seized the jar of cannabis butter and the
boy had the drug in his system - A week later the grandmother took her own life
84In the End Prevention is Key