2005 ACS Census 2000 Comparisons

1
2005 ACS Census 2000 Comparisons

• Prepared for the October 11, 2006
• Census Information Center, State Data Center, and
  Business and Industry Data Center Training
  Conference

2
What do you need to consider when comparing data
from the 2005 ACS with Census 2000 data?
3
Two factors to consider

• Interview and residence rules what is the
  target population?
• Time period and reference period what period of
  time are the data describing?

4
ACS Target Population

• Housing unit population of the United States and
  Puerto Rico
• Current residents

5
ACS Target Population

• Whenever possible, compare household population
  to household population
• When you dont have estimates for the household
  population for 2000, assess the likely impact of
  the GQ population

6
Residence Rules

• Must work for all types of areas
• Must take into account changes in populations
  over the course of the year

7
Goal of residence rules

• Resident of the sample address if a person
• Lives there year round
• Lives there more than 2 months but not year round
• Is living there now with no other place to live
• Is away now for 2 months or less

8
Goal of residence rules

• Not a resident of the sample address if a person
• Lives there 2 months or less with another
  residence
• Is away now for more than 2 months

9
Would the residence rules include
10
Would the residence rules include
11

• ACS data will describe a population similar to a
  census usual resident population if the area
• has a relatively stable population throughout the
  year
• includes seasonal populations who only stay for
  short periods of time (2 months or less)
• includes trivial numbers of long-term seasonal
  populations

12

• ACS data will describe a population that differs
  from a census usual resident population
• if the area includes a large proportion of
  long-term seasonal populations
• if the population of the area changed
  dramatically in the course of the year

13
What to expect in 2005
14
ACS produces period estimates

• They describe the characteristics of an area over
  a specific time period
• Contrast with point-in-time estimates that
  describe the characteristics of an area on a
  specific date

15
Weighted Census 2000 Sample 2000 ACS Housing
Units by Response Week
16
How do the reference periods used in the
questions on the ACS impact the interpretation of
results?
17
Reference Periods

• ACS uses the interview date as the single
  reference point, or as the end of a reference
  period, for all data collection
• The Census 2000 sample did too, except for
  income, migration, and agricultural sales

18
Questions with no specific reference period

• Most ACS questions do not stipulate a period of
  time that should be referenced
• Interpretation is yearly average since the data
  are collected each month and averaged across
  months

19
Questions with a specific reference period
relative to interview date

• Other questions specify a period of time relative
  to the date of interview
• Interpretation is still a yearly average but
  covering a slightly different period of time than
  the calendar year

20
So, what does all this mean about making
comparisons back to Census 2000?
21
Comparisons with Census 2000

• Four reports by Bureau staff compared single-year
  data from the ACS with Census 2000 at national
  level
• Two staff reports and four reports by outside
  researchers compared three-year averages from the
  1999-2001 ACS test sites with Census 2000 at
  county and tract levels

22
Comparisons with Census 2000

• Please refer to this website for results of these
  comparisons and analysis of the differences
  between the ACS and Census 2000
• www.census.gov/acs/www/advMeth/Reports

23
Its OK to compare when

• The target populations are the same or similar
• if tables include the same universe
• if areas have small GQ populations or
  insignificant seasonal populations

24
Its OK to compare when

• The questions havent changed significantly or
  the reference period is essentially the same

25
Questions?

• Deborah.H.Griffin_at_census.gov
• [phone]