Title: Cost Principles Seminar
1Cost Principles Seminar
National Contract Management Association Southern
Nevada Chapter May 30, 2008
Randall K. Gibson, Director of Compliance,
NPS rgibson26_at_csc.com
2Computer Sciences Corporation
- CSC has about 90,000 employees in 80 countries
worldwide - In April 1959 - One Hundred Dollars and a Dream
- In the fiscal year ending March 38, 2008, Revenue
was 16.5 billion - FY 2007 Revenue from Continuing Operations
- 24 Department of Defense
- 11 Civil Agencies
- 1 Other U.S. Federal
- 36 Total U.S. Federal Government
- 26 U.S. Commercial
- 28 Europe
- 10 Other International
- 64 Total Global Commercial
2
3North American Public Sector
- IT, business operations and specialized
engineering services for government clients
throughout North America - Headquartered in Falls Church, Virginia, CSC NPS
serves government clients across North America - NPS has approximately 26,000 employees in more
than 600 locations worldwide. - Annual revenue is approximately 5.1 billion
(FY06).
3
4Plan for the Day
- Applicability and Scope of FAR Part 31.2
- General Cost Principles
- Allowability
- Reasonableness
- Allocability
- Selected Areas of Cost
- Overview of the 46 Cost Principles
- Focus on Selected Cost Principles
- Government Audit Rights
- Relationship of FAR to CAS
4
5Federal Acquisition Regulation
- FAR 31.000 Scope of part - This part contains
cost principles and procedures for - whenever cost analysis is performed
- the determination, negotiation, or allowance of
costs when required by a contract clause.
5
6Federal Acquisition Regulation
- Part 31 - Cost Allowability Generally
- Allowable
- Reasonable, allocable, CAS/GAAP compliant,
contract terms compliant, FAR compliant - Allocable
- Incurred for contract, can be distributed in
reasonable proportion to benefits received,
necessary for operation of business - Reasonable
- Prudent person in conduct of competitive business
- Government makes no presumption of reasonableness
- If cost challenged by Government, burden of proof
on contractor to establish
6
7Federal Acquisition Regulation
- Part 31 Specific Areas of Cost
7
8Federal Acquisition Regulation Part 31
Specific Areas of Cost
8
9Total Cost
- FAR 31.201-1 Composition of total cost
- sum of the direct and indirect costs allocable to
the contract, incurred or to be incurred - plus any allocable cost of money pursuant to
31.205-10, - less any allocable credits.
- allowable costs to the Government are limited to
those allocable costs which are allowable
pursuant to Part 31
9
10Total Cost By Cost Element
10
11FAR 31.202 Direct Costs
- Direct cost means any cost that is identified
specifically with a particular final cost
objective. - No contract shall have allocated to it as a
direct cost any cost, if other costs incurred for
the same purpose in like circumstances have been
included in any indirect cost pool to be
allocated to contracts. - For reasons of practicality, the contractor may
treat any direct cost of a minor dollar amount as
an indirect cost if the accounting treatment - (1) Is consistently applied to all final cost
objectives and - (2) Produces substantially the same results as
treating the cost as a direct cost.
11
12FAR 31.203 Indirect Costs
- After direct costs have been determined and
charged directly to the contract or other work,
indirect costs are those remaining to be
allocated . - No contract shall have allocated to it as an
indirect cost any cost, if other costs incurred
for the same purpose, in like circumstances, have
been included as a direct cost of that or any
other contract. -
13Indirect Cost expense pool
- Accumulate indirect costs by logical cost
groupings with due consideration of the reasons
for incurring such costs.
13
14Indirect Cost base
- The base selected shall allocate the grouping on
the basis of the benefits accruing to contracts. - For contracts other than those subject to full or
modified CAS coverage, the base period for
allocating indirect costs shall be the
contractors fiscal year used for financial
reporting purposes in accordance with generally
accepted accounting principles.
14
15Allocability
- FAR 31.201-4 Determining allocability
- If it is assignable or chargeable to one or more
cost objectives on the basis of relative benefits
received or other equitable relationship. - A cost is allocable to a Government contract if
it - Is incurred specifically for the contract
- Benefits both the contract and other work, and
can be distributed to them in reasonable
proportion to the benefits received or - Is necessary to the overall operation of the
business, although a direct relationship to any
particular cost objective cannot be shown.
15
16Allowability
- FAR 31.201-2 Determining allowability A cost is
allowable only when the cost complies with all of
the following requirements - Reasonableness
- Allocability
- Standards promulgated by the CAS Board, if
applicable, otherwise, generally accepted
accounting principles and practices appropriate
to the circumstances. - Terms of the contract
- Any limitations set forth in this subpart
16
17Allowability
- FAR 31.201-2 - Determining allowability -
- Contractor is responsible for accounting for
costs . . ., including supporting documentation,
adequate to demonstrate that costs claimed have
been incurred, are allocable to the contract, and
comply with applicable cost principles . . .. - The contracting officer may disallow all or part
of a claimed cost that is inadequately supported.
17
18FAR 31.201-3 Reasonableness
- A cost is reasonable if,
- It does not exceed that which would be incurred
by a prudent person in the conduct of competitive
business. - No presumption of reasonableness shall be
attached to the incurrence of costs. - If an initial review of the facts results in a
challenge, the burden of proof shall be upon the
contractor to establish that such cost is
reasonable.
18
19Reasonableness
- Depends upon a variety of considerations and
circumstances, including - (1) Whether it is the type of cost generally
recognized as ordinary and necessary for the
conduct of the contractors business or the
contract performance - (2) Generally accepted sound business practices,
arms-length bargaining, and Federal and State
laws and regulations - (3) The contractors responsibilities to the
Government, other customers, the owners of the
business, employees, and the public at large and
- (4) Any significant deviations from the
contractors established practices
19
20FAR 31.201-5 Credits
- The applicable portion of any income, rebate,
allowance, or other credit relating to any
allowable cost and received by or accruing to the
contractor shall be credited to the Government
either as a cost reduction or by cash refund.
20
21FAR 31.201-6 Accounting for Unallowable Costs
- Expressly unallowable or mutually agreed to be
unallowable, including mutually agreed to be
unallowable directly associated costs, shall be
identified and excluded from any billing, claim,
or proposal applicable to a Government contract. - Costs that specifically become designated as
unallowable or as unallowable directly associated
costs of unallowable costs as a result of a
written decision furnished by a contracting
officer shall be identified if included in or
used in computing any billing, claim, or proposal
applicable to a Government contract. -
21
22Accounting for Unallowable Costs
- Directly Associated
- A directly associated cost is any cost that is
generated solely as a result of incurring another
cost, and that would not have been incurred had
the other cost not been incurred.
22
23Accounting for Unallowable Costs
- The practices for accounting for and presentation
of unallowable costs must be those described CAS
405, Accounting for Unallowable Costs.
23
24Accounting for Unallowable Costs
- Statistical sampling is an acceptable practice in
accounting for and presenting unallowable costs
provided the following criteria are met - (i) The statistical sampling results in an
unbiased sample that is a reasonable
representation of the sampling universe. - (ii) Any large dollar value or high risk
transaction is separately reviewed for
unallowable costs and excluded from the sampling
process. - (iii) The statistical sampling permits audit
verification.
24
25Accounting for Unallowable Costs
- A penalty is imposed by 10 U.S.C. 2324(a) through
(d) and 41 U.S.C. 256(a) through (d). The
penalty can be assessed against contractors which
include unallowable indirect costs in - (1) Final indirect cost rate proposals or
- (2) The final statement of costs incurred or
estimated to be incurred under a fixed-price
incentive contract. - The penalty assessable for all contracts in
excess of 650,000 - except fixed-price contracts without cost
incentives or any firm-fixed-price contracts for
the purchase of commercial items.
25
26FAR 31.201-6 Accounting for Unallowable Costs
- When unallowable costs, including directly
associated costs, would normally be part of an
indirect cost allocation base, they remain in the
base - Unallowable costs are removed from the indirect
expense pool for purposes of computing indirect
expense rates.
26
27FAR 31.205-6 Compensation for personal services
- One of the largest components of cost incurred
- The cost principle is the longest and most
detailed of the FAR cost principles. - Defines the term compensation to include all
remuneration paid currently or accrued, in
whatever form and whether paid immediately or
deferred, for services rendered by employees to
the contractor. - Compensation includes payments made or to be made
in the future in the form of cash, corporate
securities, such as stocks, bonds, and other
financial instruments, and other assets,
products, or services.
27
28FAR 31.205-6 Compensation for personal services
- General Criteria
- Criteria 1. Must be for work performed in the
current year and may not represent a retroactive
payment for work performed in prior years
exceptions include severance pay, deferred
compensation, pensions, and other postretirement
benefits - Â
- Criteria 2. In total must be reasonable for the
work performed. Factors the ACO may consider in
analyzing the reasonableness of compensation
include conformity with the compensation
practices of other firms (i) Of the same size
(ii) In the same industry (iii) In the same
geographic area and (iv) Engaged in similar
non-Government work under comparable
circumstances. Upon challenge by the Government,
the burden of proof is with contractor(FAR
31.201-3(a))?
28
29FAR 31.205-6 Compensation for personal services
- General Criteria
- Criteria 3. Must have been paid in accordance
with an established compensation plan or
practice followed so consistently as to imply, in
effect, an agreement to the payment. - Â
- Criteria 4. No presumption of allowability
exsists where the contractor has made a major
revision to its compensation plan or practice,
without having notified the cognizant ACO of the
change and provided the Government an opportunity
to review it. - Criteria 5. Costs that are unallowable under any
other cost principle are not considered allowable
simply because they constitute compensation.
29
30FAR 31.205-6 Compensation for personal services
- Criteria 6 Compensation costs for certain
individuals give rise to the need for special
consideration.
30
31FAR 31.205-6 Compensation for personal services
- Differential Pay principle expressly permits the
cost of differential pay when services are
performed in a foreign country - including expenses associated with housing, cost
of living adjustments, transportation, bonuses,
additional Federal, State, local or foreign
income taxes resulting from the foreign
assignment - Bonuses and Incentive Compensation Government
auditors often assert that the bonus or incentive
compensation was not paid pursuant to an
agreement entered into before the services where
performed, as required by the principle.
31
32FAR 31.205-6 Compensation for personal services
- Severance Pay
- defined as payment in addition to regular
salaries and wages by the contractor to workers
whose employment is being involuntarily
terminated, is allowable - Provided it is reasonable and required by law,
employer-employee agreement, an established
policy that effectively constitutes an implied
agreement, or the circumstances of the particular
employment - If, however, the employee is employed by a
replacement contactor under substantially equal
conditions of employment and with credit for
prior service, or if the employee is employed by
an affiliate of the contractor, the severance pay
is unallowable.
32
33FAR 31.205-6 Compensation for personal services
- All backpay is unallowable unless it is for work
performed but underpaid. - Corporate Securities (1) The securities must be
valued at their fair market value on the
measurement date, which is defined as the first
date the number of shares awarded is known, and
(2) any accruals for the cost of the securities
before issuance to the employees must take into
account the possibility that the employees
interest in the accruals might be forfeited. - Any compensation that is calculated , valued, or
based on changes in the price of corporate
securities is unallowable.
33
34FAR 31.205-6 Compensation for personal services
- Pensions.
- There are two basic types of pension plans
defined benefit and defined contribution. - Subject to the cost limitations and exclusions in
paragraphs (j)(2) through (8) of the cost
principle, pension costs incurred under either
type of plan are allowable provided they are
measured, allocated, and accounted for in
compliance with CAS 412 and 413. - To be allowable in the current year, pension
costs must be funded by the time for filing of
the Federal income tax return, including any
extensions - Pension payments must be paid pursuant to a
good-faith agreement entered into before the work
or services are performed and according to the
terms and conditions of an established plan - The Government has a right to share in the
reversion of pension funds resulting from either
the termination of an overfunded defined benefit
pension plan or other constructive receipt of
pension funds
34
35FAR 31.205-6 Compensation for personal services
- Post-retirement Benefits Other Than Pensions
- Must be reasonable and incurred pursuant to law,
employer-employee agreement, or an established
policy of the contractor. - Costs must be funded by the time set for filing
the contractors Federal income tax return.
35
36FAR 31.205-6 Compensation for personal services
- Deferred Compensation
- To allowable, it must, be based on current or
future services and be measured, allocated, and
accounted for in compliance with CAS 415. - requires that the cost of deferred compensation
be (a) measured by the present value of future
benefits to paid, and (b) assigned to the cost
accounting period in which the contractor incurs
an obligation to compensate the employee.
36
37FAR 31.205-6 Compensation for personal services
- Special Rules for-Business Acquisitions golden
parachutes and golden Handcuffs that are paid
in connection with business acquisitions are
unallowable. - Fringe Benefits the cost principles proscribe
the costs of employee rebate and purchase
discount plans the portion of the costs of
company-furnished automobiles related to personal
use by the employee, including home-to-work
transportation and the costs of membership in
social dining, and country clubs.
37
38FAR 31.205-6 Compensation for personal services
- Limitations on Highly Compensated Employees.
- Costs of compensation of a senior executive in
excess of the benchmark compensation amount
determined applicable for the contractor fiscal
year by the Administrator, Office of Federal
Procurement Policy (OFPP) are unallowable - Senior executive means -- Effective January 2,
1999, the five most highly compensated employees
in management positions at each home office and
each segment of the contractor, whether or not
the home office or segment reports directly to
the contractors headquarters.
38
39FAR 31.205-1 Public relations and advertising
costs
- Allowable public relations costs include the
following - 1) Costs specifically required by contract.
- 2) Costs of
- Responding to inquiries on company policies and
activities - Communicating with the public, press,
stockholders, creditors, and customers and - Conducting general liaison with news media and
Government public relations officers, to the
extent that such activities are limited to
communication and liaison necessary to keep the
public informed on matters of public concern - 3) Costs of participation in community service
activities (e.g., blood bank drives, charity
drives, savings bond drives, disaster assistance,
etc.)? - 4) Costs of plant tours and open houses
- 5) Costs of keel laying, ship launching,
commissioning, and roll-out ceremonies, to the
extent specifically provided for by contract.
39
40FAR 31.205-1 Public relations and advertising
costs
- The only allowable advertising costs are those
that are - (1) Specifically required by contract, or that
arise from requirements of Government contracts
and that are exclusively for - (i) Acquiring scarce items for contract
performance or - (ii) Disposing of scrap or surplus materials
acquired for contract performance. - (2) Costs of activities to promote sales of
products normally sold to the U.S. Government,
including trade shows, which contain a
significant effort to promote exports from the
United States. However, such costs do not include
the costs of memorabilia (e.g., models, gifts,
and souvenirs), alcoholic beverages,
entertainment, and physical facilities that are
primarily used for entertainment rather than
product promotion or - (3) Allowable in accordance with
31.205-34Recruitment costs)?
40
41FAR 31.205-7 Contingencies
- The allowability of the cost of contingencies
depends upon whether the pricing is being done
retroactively or prospectively. - Contingencies are generally unallowable for
historical costing purposes, such as
retroactively determining the adjustment due for
previously performed work. - On the other hand, contingencies are not
unallowable for estimating and forward pricing
purposes. Contingencies that may arise from
known and existing conditions, the effects of
which can reasonably be foreseen and estimated,
are allowable and should be included in the
estimated cost. Contingencies that cannot
reasonably be measured must be excluded from the
estimate but disclosed separately to permit
appropriate contractual coverage, such as through
insurance costs or a re-opener clause.
41
42FAR 31.205-8 Contributions or donations
- Contributions or donations, including cash,
property and services, regardless of recipient,
are unallowable, except as provided in
31.205-1(e)(3).
42
43FAR 31.205-10 Cost of Money
- Facilities capital cost of money is the imputed
cost of investment income forgone when a
contractor commits its resources to capital
assets used to perform a contract. - FCCM must be measured, assigned, and allocated to
contracts in accordance with CAS 414, and cost of
money as an element of capital assets under
construction must be measured and added to the
cost of capital assets under construction in
accordance with CAS 417 - For FCCM only, the estimated cost of money must
have been specifically identified and proposed in
cost proposals relating to the contract under
which the cost is to be claimed.
43
44FAR 31.205-11 Depreciation
- Contracts subject to CAS 409, must comply with
that standard. - Contracts not subject to CAS 409, except as
otherwise provided by paragraphs (g) and (h) of
the principle, allowable depreciation costs are
limited to the amount used for financial
accounting purposes, and must be determined in a
manner consistent with the contractors
depreciation policies and procedures followed in
the same segment on non-Government business. - No depreciation is allowed on property that has
been fully depreciated by the contractor or any
of its divisions, subsidiaries or affiliates
under common control. - Â
44
45FAR 31.205-13 Employee morale, health, welfare,
food service, and dormitory costs and credits
- Costs incurred on activities designed to improve
working conditions, employer-employee relations,
employee morale, and employee performance (less
income generated by these activities) are
allowable. - Some examples of allowable activities are
- (1) House publications
- (2) Health clinics
- (3) Wellness/fitness centers
- (4) Employee counseling services and
- (5) Food and dormitory services, for the
contractors employees at or near the
contractors facilities.
45
46FAR 31.205-13 Employee morale, health, welfare,
food service, and dormitory costs and credits
- Costs of recreation are unallowable, except for
the costs of employees participation in company
sponsored sports teams or employee organizations
designed to improve company loyalty, team work,
or physical fitness.
46
47FAR 31.205-13 Employee morale, health, welfare,
food service, and dormitory costs and credits
- The allowability of food and dormitory losses are
determined by the following factors - (i) Losses from operating food and dormitory
services are allowable only if the contractors
objective is to operate such services on a
break-even basis. - (ii) Losses sustained because food services or
lodging accommodations are furnished without
charge or at prices or rates which obviously
would not be conducive to the accomplishment of
the above paragraph (d)(1)(i) are not allowable,
except that - (iii) A loss may be allowed to the extent that
the contractor can demonstrate that unusual
circumstances exist such that even with efficient
management, operating the services on a
break-even basis would require charging
inordinately high prices, or prices or rates
higher than those charged by commercial
establishments offering the same services in the
same geographical areas.
47
48FAR 31.205 - Entertainment
- Costs of amusement, diversions, social
activities, and any directly associated costs
such as tickets to shows or sports events, meals,
lodging, rentals, transportation, and gratuities
are unallowable. - Costs made specifically unallowable under this
cost principle are not allowable under any other
cost principle. - Costs of membership in social, dining, or country
clubs or other organizations having the same
purposes are also unallowable, regardless of
whether the cost is reported as taxable income to
the employees.
48
49FAR 31.205-23 Losses on other contracts
- An excess of costs over income under any other
contract is unallowable.
49
50FAR 31.205-32 Precontract Costs
- Precontract costs are generally allowable
provided they satisfy the circumstances
prescribed by the cost principle.
50
51FAR 31.205-33 Professional and Consultant Service
Costs
- Except when incurred in any of the circumstances
listed in paragraph (c) of the principle and as
may be limited by other applicable cost
principles, the costs of professional and
consultant services are generally allowable when
reasonable in relation to the services rendered
and not contingent upon recovery of the costs
from the Government.
51
52FAR 31.205-33 Professional and Consultant Service
Costs
- Paragraph (e) imposes 4 additional requirements
to support the allowability of retainer fees. - Paragraph (f) requires that be allowable, fees
for professional and consultant services must be
support by evidence of the nature and scope of
the services furnished.
52
53FAR 31.205-41 Taxes
- With seven listed exceptions, taxes that are
required to be paid and are paid or accrued in
accordance with generally accepted accounting
principles are allowable. - The following types of costs are not allowable
- (1) Federal income and excess profits taxes.
- (2) Taxes in connection with financing,
refinancing, refunding operations, or
reorganizations - (3) Taxes from which exemptions are available to
the contractor directly, or available to the
contractor based on an exemption afforded the
Government, - (4) Special assessments on land that represent
capital improvements - (5) Taxes (including excises) on real or personal
property - (6) Any excise tax
- (7) Income tax accruals designed to account for
the tax effects of differences between taxable
income and pretax income as reflected by the
books of account and financial statements.
53
54FAR 31.205-42 Termination costs
- Contract terminations generally give rise to the
incurrence of costs or the need for special
treatment of costs that would not have arisen had
the contract not been terminated. - The cost principle addresses elements peculiar to
termination situations and are to be used in
conjunction with the other cost principles in
Subpart 31.2 - Common items. The costs of items reasonably
usable on the contractors other work shall not
be allowable unless the contractor submits
evidence that the items could not be retained at
cost without sustaining a loss.
54
55FAR 31.205-42 Termination costs
- Initial costs. Initial costs, including starting
load and preparatory costs, are allowable. - Loss of useful value. Loss of useful value of
special tooling, and special machinery and
equipment is generally allowable, with listed
provisions. - Rental under unexpired leases. Rental costs under
unexpired leases, less the residual value of such
leases, are generally allowable when shown to
have been reasonably necessary for the
performance of the terminated contract, if -- - (1) The amount of rental claimed does not exceed
the reasonable use value of the property leased
for the period of the contract and such further
period as may be reasonable and - (2) The contractor makes all reasonable efforts
to terminate, assign, settle, or otherwise reduce
the cost of such lease.
55
56FAR 31.205-42 Termination costs
- Alterations of leased property. The cost of
alterations and reasonable restorations required
by the lease may be allowed when the alterations
were necessary for performing the contract. - Settlement expenses, including the following, are
generally allowable - (i) Accounting, legal, clerical, and similar
costs reasonably necessary for -- - (A) The preparation and presentation, including
supporting data, of settlement claims to the
contracting officer and - (B) The termination and settlement of
subcontracts. - (ii) Reasonable costs for the storage,
transportation, protection, and disposition of
property acquired or produced for the contract. - (iii) Indirect costs related to salary and wages
incurred as settlement expenses in (i) and (ii)
normally, such indirect costs shall be limited to
payroll taxes, fringe benefits, occupancy costs,
and immediate supervision costs. - Subcontractor claims. Subcontractor claims,
including the allocable portion of the claims
common to the contract and to other work of the
contractor, are generally allowable.
56
57FAR 31.205-46 Travel
- Costs for transportation, lodging, meals, and
incidental expenses. - (1) Costs for transportation may be based on
mileage rates, actual costs incurred, or on a
combination thereof, provided the method used
results in a reasonable charge. - (2) Except as provided in subparagraph (a)(3) of
this subsection, costs incurred for lodging,
meals, and incidental expenses shall be
considered to be reasonable and allowable only to
the extent that they do not exceed on a daily
basis the maximum per diem rates in effect at the
time of travel as set forth in the - (i) Federal Travel Regulations
- (ii) Joint Travel Regulation
- (iii) Standardized Regulations
57
58FAR 31.205-46 Travel
- In special or unusual situations, actual costs in
excess of the above-referenced maximum per diem
rates are allowable provided that such amounts do
not exceed the higher amounts authorized for
Federal civilian employees
58
59FAR 31.205-46 Travel
- Airfare costs in excess of the lowest customary
standard, coach, or equivalent airfare offered
during normal business hours are unallowable
except when such accommodations require
circuitous routing, require travel during
unreasonable hours, excessively prolong travel,
result in increased cost that would offset
transportation savings, are not reasonably
adequate for the physical or medical needs of the
traveler, or are not reasonably available to meet
mission requirements. - However, in order for airfare costs in excess of
the above standard airfare to be allowable, the
applicable condition(s) set forth above must be
documented and justified.
59
60Audit Rights and Access
- Audit and Records Negotiation (FAR 52.215-2)?
- Contract Terms and Conditions Required to
Implement Statues or Executive Orders
Commercial Items - Requirements for Cost or Pricing Data or
Information Other Than Cost or Pricing Data - Allowable Cost and Payment (FAR 52.216-7)
included in cost-reimbursement contracts other
than facilities contracts regardless of dollar
value. - Payments Under Time-and-Material and Labor-Hour
Contracts required in TM and LH contracts.
60
61Audit Rights and Access
- Economic Price Adjustment Labor and Material
included in negotiated, fixed-price contracts
that provide for an economic price adjustment on
the basis of labor and material. - Progress Payments included in fixed price
contracts under which the Government will provide
progress payments based on costs. -
- Performance-Based Payments included in
contracts under which the Government will provide
performance-based payments. - Advance Payments and Advance Payments Without
Special Account included in contracts under
which the Government provides advance payments.
61
62Audit Rights and Access
- Government audit rights and access are frequently
obtained by mandatory contract terms and
conditions - Many include
- Right to examine and audit all records and other
evidence sufficient to reflect properly all costs
claimed . . .. - Right to examine . . . those records, which
include books, documents, accounting procedures
and practices, and other data, regardless of type
and form . . .. - Shall permit any authorized representative of
the Government to examine and make copies of any
documents, papers, or records relating to
compliance . . ..
62