Title: Pauline Interpretation of Christianity: ROMANS Tuesday April 5
1Pauline Interpretation of ChristianityROMANS
Tuesday April 5
2Todays Schedule
- 410-515 Apocalyptic/Messianic interpretation
1 Thessalonians and Romans Web, Patte, Pauls
Faith and the Power of the Gospel, 122-154
232-295 - 515-630
- Â JULIANNE SNAPE On ch. 12
- STEPHEN STAGGS On ch. 12
3Â JULIANNE SNAPE Rom 12, -Offering Ourselves to
God
- Formal Respondent Arden Henderson
- Other Respondents
- Karney Carney
- Madeleine St Marie
- Jonathan Baynham
- Amy Lentz
- Derek Axelson
4STEPHEN STAGGS Rom 12, Darkened Mind
Transformations
- Formal Respondent Jeremy Snow
- Other Respondents
- Julie Carli
- Ross Stackhouse
- Jason Jones
- Murielle Wyman
- Iris Ankrom
5Next Week Romans 13
- JULIE CARLI
- Â
- Â
- Respondent
- Â
- Â
- Murielle Wyman
- Â
- Â
- Â
- Â
- Â
- MADELEINE ST.MARIE
- Â
- Respondent
- Â
- Â
- Jason Jones
- Â
6Galatians 13-4(Review)
- Grace to you and peace from God our Father and
the Lord Jesus Christ, 4 who gave himself for
our sins to set us free from the present evil
age, according to the will of our God and Father - Christ died for our sins he died to set us
free (NRSV) or rescue us (NIV, NAB) or
deliver us (KJB) from the present evil age - When? In the PRESENT.
7Gospel Freedom from bondage to idols. Which
Idols? (Review)
- Galatians 48 Formerly, when you did not know
God, you were enslaved to beings that by nature
are not gods. - Hellenistic religions as Idols
- The Other Gospel which is not a Gospel
idolatry 49 how can you turn back again to
the weak and beggarly elemental spirits? How can
you want to be enslaved to them again? - Surprisingly 43-5 So with us while we were
minors, we were enslaved to the elemental spirits
of the world. 4 But when the fullness of time
had come, God sent his Son, born of a woman, born
under the law, 5 in order to redeem those who
were under the law, so that we might receive
adoption as children. - Paul equates his former Pharisaic Convictions
with an idolatry (enslaved to the elemental
spirits of the world) - 51 For freedom Christ has set us free. Stand
firm, therefore, and do not submit again to a
yoke of slavery.
8What is Idolatry for Paul? (Review) Pagans as
typical sinners/idolaters
- Romans 118 18 For the wrath of God is revealed
from heaven against all ungodliness and
wickedness of those who by their wickedness
suppress the truth. 19 For what can be known
about God is plain to them, because God has shown
it to them. 20 Ever since the creation of the
world his eternal power and divine nature,
invisible though they are, have been understood
and seen through the things he has made.
Cosmological revelation
9What is Idolatry for Paul? (Review) Pagans as
typical sinners/idolaters
- Romans 132 They know God's decree, that those
who practice such things deserve to die-- yet
they not only do them but even applaud others who
practice them. (Cosmological/natural distinction
between good and evil)
10What is Idolatry for Paul?Pagans as typical
sinners/idolaters
- Rom 121 So they are without excuse 21 for
though they knew God, they did not honor him as
God or give thanks to him, but they became futile
in their thinking, and their senseless minds were
darkened. 22 Claiming to be wise, they became
fools 23 and they exchanged the glory of the
immortal God for images resembling a mortal human
being or birds or four-footed animals or
reptiles. - 24 Therefore God gave them up in the lusts of
their hearts to impurity, to the degrading of
their bodies among themselves . 26 For this
reason God gave them up to degrading passions.
28 God gave them up to a debased mind and to
things that should not be done. 29 They were
filled with every kind of wickedness, evil,
11What is Idolatry for Paul? (Review) Pagans as
typical sinners/idolaters
12Idols are not (Review)
- Idols are NOT the absolutization of something
worthless! - Idolatry is not worshipping a stone or piece of
wood. - Idolaters are not stupid!
- Idols have power because the idolaters know that
the revelations upon which they are built are
TRUE, and holy, Just and good
13Gospel Freedom from bondage to idols does NOT
mean
- Freedom from idolatry does NOT involve rejecting
the true revelation that was absolutized and
trapped in the idol - This is what happens when one makes another idol
by taking another revelation to be a complete and
final - so much so that one does not need the true
revelation trapped into the idolatry
14The true revelations trapped in idols remain true
revelations
- These revelations must be freed from bondage
- Creation remains a much needed revelation of
Gods eternal power and divine nature
creation wait for its freedom from bondage
(819-21) - Torah remains a much needed revelation of Gods
covenants, etc. waits for its freedom from
bondage
15What is Idolatry for Paul? (Review) Paul the Jew
as typical sinner/idolater
- Romans 76-12 7 What then should we say? That
the law is sin? By no means! 12 So the law is
holy, and the commandment is holy and just and
good.
16What is Idolatry for Paul? (Review) Paul the Jew
as typical sinner/idolater
- Romans 77-11 What then should we say? That
the law is sin? By no means! Yet, if it had not
been for the law, I would not have known sin. I
would not have known what it is to covet
evpiqumi,a desire I f the law had not said,
"You shall not covet." Ouvk evpiqumh,seijÃ… not
desire 8 But sin, seizing an opportunity in the
commandment, produced in me all kinds of
covetousness. evpiqumi,a desire Apart from the
law sin lies dead. 9 I was once alive apart from
the law, but when the commandment came, sin
revived 10 and I died, and the very commandment
that promised life proved to be death to me. 11
For sin, seizing an opportunity in the
commandment, deceived me and through it killed
me.
17What is Idolatry for Paul? (Review) Paul the Jew
as typical sinner/idolater
18What is Idolatry for Paul? (Review) Paul the Jew
as typical sinner/idolater
- Romans 712-13 So the law is holy, and the
commandment is holy and just and good. 13 Did
what is good, then, bring death to me? By no
means! It was sin, working death in me through
what is good, in order that sin might be shown to
be sin, desire and through the commandment
might become sinful beyond measure. - desire leads to absolutization of that which is
not absolute some thing GOOD a revelation
from God Holy, Just, and Good - But NOT complete and final revelation
19What is Idolatry for Paul?Paul the Jew as
typical sinner/idolater
- Romans 715-23 I do not understand my own
actions. For I do not do what I want, but I do
the very thing I hate. 16 Now if I do what I do
not want, I agree that the law is good. 17 But
in fact it is no longer I that do it, but sin
that dwells within me. 18 can will what is
right, but I cannot do it. 19 For I do not do
the good I want, but the evil I do not want is
what I do. - 21 So I find it to be a law that when I want to
do what is good, evil lies close at hand. 22 For
I delight in the law of God in my inmost self,
23 but I see in my members another law at war
with the law of my mind, making me captive to the
law of sin that dwells in my members.
20Idol whatever (including the Gospel) might be
the good thing that we absolutize
21Christ destroying The power of the Idol whatever
it might be
- Romans 82-3 2 For the law of the Spirit of life
in Christ Jesus has set you free from the law of
sin and of death. 3 For God has done what the
law, weakened by the flesh, could not do by
sending his own Son in the likeness of sinful
flesh, and to deal with sin, he condemned sin in
the flesh, - 2 Corinthians 520 So we are ambassadors for
Christ, since God is making his appeal through
us we entreat you on behalf of Christ, be
reconciled to God. 21 For our sake he made him
to be sin who knew no sin, so that in him we
might become the righteousness of God.
22Christ destroying the power of the
idolcondemning sin in the flesh
23The power of bondage of the idol implodes with
the power of the Gospel
- sending his own Son in the likeness of sinful
flesh, according to sin, he condemned sin in the
flesh Rom 83 - manifested Son of God with power according to
the spirit of holiness by resurrection from the
dead, Jesus Christ our Lord, 5 through whom we
have received grace and apostleship 14-5 - the gospel is the power of God for salvation to
everyone who has faith, to the Jew first and also
to the Greek. 17 For in it the righteousness of
God is revealed from faith to faith evk pi,stewj
eivj pi,stin 116-17
24F/T Resurrection not abandoned by God
Vindicated by God
-
Glorified, with God - ÃŽ
- I
- life I life .. Raised from
death - not abandoned by
God - I I
- I________Death_________ I
- Rom 14 manifested Son of God with power
according to the spirit of holiness by
resurrection from the dead - proof that Christs death is meaningful he
died for us, for our sins
25NC/P Resurrection Christ at the right hand of
God, Sharing Gods Power
- __ at the right hand of
God has Power - I
- ÃŽ
- Life life. Raised from death
- I I
- I_____Death_________ I
- manifested Son of God with power according to
the spirit of holiness by resurrection from the
dead, Jesus Christ our Lord, through whom we
have received grace and apostleship - Christ, now with power (at the right of God),
call believers (Paul called to be an apostle,
set apart for the gospel of God Romans called
to be saints (11, 7) to participate in the
ministry of the Gospel, in order that the
Gentiles might glorify God for his mercy (15-9)
26A/M Resurrection back with us in life
defeating powers of evil
- __ at the right hand of
God__ - I
- ÃŽ
I - Life Raised from death .
Parousia -
back with us in life -
When? Ongoing! - I since the
Resurrection - I__ Death _ I
- manifested Son of God with power according to
the spirit of holiness by resurrection from the
dead, Jesus Christ our Lord, through whom we have
received grace and apostleship 14-5 - 1 Corinthians 1524 Then comes the end, when he
hands over the kingdom to God the Father, after
he has destroyed every ruler and every authority
and power. what the risen Christ is doing now - Christ is alive, acting in our midst, defeating
the powers of evil NOW
27A/M The Crucified Jesus is the One whom
believers should recognize as the true
authority/power now at work in their present as
the Resurrected Christ
- ???st?? ??est?! Christ Is Risen! Christ is
alive and kicking - Faith in the resurrection is NOT a believing
that a belief about what happened 2000 years
ago and what will happen in the eschatological
future - an impossible belief, because it is necessarily
nebulous. - Rather faith in the resurrection is a hope
solidly grounded in present reality, in the
believers present experience of transforming,
freeing, loving manifestations of the Resurrected
One ... Â - of which believers are the beneficiaries,
sometimes. - But also, and especially and primarily,
manifestations of the Resurrected One which
believers can recognize (through the CORRECTIVE
GLASSES OF SCRIPTURE) when others, around
them, are transformed, freed, loved and loving in
the very heart of situations of need, when they
should have been crushed by suffering, grief, and
oppressions of all kinds. Â
28A/M The Body of Christ (121-One whom believers
should recognize as the true authority/power now
at work in their present as the Resurrected Christ
- The body of Christ (125 we, who are many, are
one body in Christ) are Christ-for-other people - playing the same role as Christ. How?
- By being Christ-crucified for others present
your bodies as a living sacrifice, holy and
acceptable to God, which is your spiritual
worship 121 - How? By entering the world of others... The
idolatrous world of others always idolatrous
(because we are human). And when in this
idolatrous world - Do not be conformed to this world (122)
- Not conforming to this world not serving the
idolatry of this world - NOT SINNING as Christ did not sin NOT serving
idols!!!
29A/M The Body of Christ (121-One whom believers
should recognize as the true authority/power now
at work in their present as the Resurrected Christ
- The body of Christ are Christ-for-other people
- Not conforming to this world not sinning not
serving the idolatry of this world. - HOW?
- By being transformed by the renewing of your
minds, so that you may discern what is the will
of God-- what is good and acceptable and
perfect. (122) - recognizing what is the true revelation, the
true gift from God, that people in this world
have transformed into an idol. SO AS TO AFFIRM IT - NOT rejecting (throwing away) ALL of this world
as if everything was wrong in this idolatry - Christ and Culture in Paradox (in H. Richard
Niebuhr, Christ and Culture, categories) The
Church is in the world, though it is not of the
world - Christ the body of Christ can affirm a part of
the culture there is something in the culture
which is good and acceptable and perfect -- - But must reject another part of culture which is
oppressive, unacceptable, and evil the
idolatrous part of culture.
30Faith for Apocalyptic Reading
- Faith seeing, recognizing, discerning the
manifestations of God, and submitting to their
authority/power - Recognizing positive (partial) revelations from
God (in bondages in their idols) - in Creation
- in Torah
- in whatever is good and acceptable and perfect in
the (idolatrous) world. without conforming to
this idolatrous word - In the Roman Imperial authority (and its idolatry)
31Faith involves Recognizing positive (partial)
revelations from God (in bondages in their idols)
- Romans 122 Do not be conformed to this world,
but be transformed by the renewing of your minds,
so that you may discern what is the will of God--
what is good and acceptable and perfect. - Romans 131 Let every person be subject to the
governing authorities for there is no authority
except from God, and those authorities that exist
have been instituted by God. - Romans 114 I am indebted to I received
revelation from God from both Greeks and
barbarians, both the wise and the foolish
32Faith for Apocalyptic Reading
- Faith Recognizing positive (partial)
revelations from God - in the idols made our of the good gifts from God
in Creation, Torah, the world, by Greek and
barbarians, educated and uneducated - Recognizing iconoclastic (partial) revelations
from God - In Christ crucified, cursed by the Law, sinning
against sin AND manifested Son of God by
resurrection from the dead, - And in Christ-like people (those ïn Christ
the body of Christ)
33In Christ crucified, cursed by the Law, sinning
against sin AND manifested Son of God
- Galatians 313-14 Christ redeemed us from the
curse of the law by becoming a curse for us-- for
it is written, "Cursed is everyone who hangs on a
tree"-- 14 in order that in Christ Jesus the
blessing of Abraham might come to the Gentiles,
so that we might receive the promise of the
Spirit through faith.
34Recognizing iconoclastic (partial) revelations
from God
- 1 Thessalonians 11 Paul, Silvanus, and Timothy,
To the church of the Thessalonians in God the
Father and the Lord Jesus Christ Grace to you
and peace. - 2 We always give thanks to God for all of you and
mention you in our prayers, constantly 3
remembering before our God and Father your work
of faith and labor of love and steadfastness of
hope in our Lord Jesus Christ.
35Recognizing iconoclastic (partial) revelations
from God 1 Thess
- 14 For we know, brothers and sisters beloved by
God, that God has chosen you, - 5 because our message of the gospel came to you
not in word only, but also in power and in the
Holy Spirit MANIFESTIONS OF GOD and with full
conviction - 6 And you became imitators of us and of the Lord,
for in spite of persecution you received the word
with joy inspired by the Holy Spirit,
36Recognizing iconoclastic (partial) revelations
from God 1 Thess
- 17 so that you became an example ( a type) to
all the believers in Macedonia and in Achaia. . - 9 others report what kind of welcome we had
among you, and how you turned to God from idols,
to serve a living and true God, 10 and to wait
for his Son from heaven, whom he raised from the
dead-- Jesus, who rescues us from the wrath that
is coming.
37Next week 3 Characteristics of Pauls Faith for
Apocalyptic Reading
- Pauls Faith as
- A Radical Charismatic Faith a divine gift and
belief in Gods gifts today to EVERY BELIEVERS
(recognize the measure of each of our faith)
not hierarchy free climbers - An Eschatological Faith seeing God at work in
the end-of-time today - A Typological Faith recognizing these
interventions of God, because they are of the
same type (fulfillments) of Gods previous
interventions (in Jesus, HB, etc.) - And how the three work together
38I appeal to you by the mercies of God, to present
your bodies as a living sacrifice (121-2 15)
- Forensic/Theological I exhort/admonish you,
demand from you that, as a response to Gods
forgiveness (mercies) - You sacrifice yourself for God and others
- This is Gods will that the believer should
implement - in imitation of Christ (as ethical model) who
sacrificed himself for us on the cross - demanding that one separates oneself from the
world (not conforming to the world) - Note a duty for individual Christians, so I
use the singular (Greek is plural)
39I appeal to you by the mercies of God, to present
your bodies as a living sacrifice (121-2 15)
- Covenantal/Pastoral I call you to join us to
carry out the mission of God ( the mercies of
God) - Parakalw/ "calling to one's side,"
- Carrying out this mission necessarily involves
risks it is offering ourselves as sacrifice - Because a life in faith communities characterized
by love and justice, - avoiding worldly behavior, honor/shame system
that engenders competition with others that
generates injustice and oppression
40I appeal to you by the mercies of God, to present
your bodies as a living sacrifice (121-2 15)
- Apocalyptic/Messianic I encourage and comfort
you - Parakalw/ comforting, encouraging,"
- Reminding you that Gods mercies ( what is
good, acceptable, perfect 122) are manifested
around you - Encouraging you to discern Gods mercies and to
join Gods on-going liberating action - Freeing others from bondage to sin and idolatry,
as Christ did - refusing to serve the idols,
- thus idolaters will persecute you, crucify you,
- a sacrifice through which (some) of the idolaters
will be saved (freed from their idolatry)
41Romans 125 we, who are many, are one body in
Christ,
- Romans 123-7 I say to everyone among you not to
think of yourself more highly than you ought to
think, but to think with sober judgment, each
according to the measure of faith that God has
assigned. eka,stw wj o qeo.j evme,risen
me,tron pi,stewjÃ… - 4 For as in one body we have many members, and
not all the members have the same function, 5 so
we, who are many, are one body in Christ, and
individually we are members one of another. 6 We
have gifts that differ according to the grace
given to us prophecy, in proportion to faith
kata. th.n avnalogi,an th/j pi,stewj 7 ministry,
in ministering the teacher, in teaching 8 the
exhorter, in exhortation the giver, in
generosity the leader, in diligence the
compassionate, in cheerfulness.
42Romans 123-8 we, who are many, are one body in
Christ,
- Forensic/Theological Exhortation to participate
humbly in the body of Christ, - To have a loving relationship with others (129)
- using for others the gifts one has received from
God (124-8) - imitating Gods/Christ love for us
- in the same way that God loved/loves us even if
we are not worthy of Gods love so we should
love others, whatever might be their attitude
toward us
43Romans 123-8 we, who are many, are one body in
Christ,
- Covenantal/Pastoral Being called to be ONE body
of Christ, - Being this inclusive people of God is an integral
part of its mission - This community life manifests/exemplifies Gods
love and thus Gods justice for the rest of
society - by acknowledging the gifts that others have,
and affirming them as gifts from God that you
do not have, and that you must receive through
other members of the community (124-8)
44Romans 123-8 we, who are many, are one body in
Christ,
- Apocalyptic/Messianic Encouragement to discern
the body of Christ (123-10) - by acknowledging the gifts that other members
of the community received, and affirming them as
gifts from God that you do not have, and that
you must receive through others (124-8). - not to think of yourself more highly than you
ought to think (123) - acknowledging others as worthy of honor
(1210) because they are bearers of gifts of God
for you (124-8) - genuine love (129), considering others as
better than yourself, precisely as you consider
Christ (they are part of the body of Christ)
45Pondering your leaders THEME and PASSAGE in
Romans
- what would be different in the teaching of
this passage on this theme for your own context - List and explain these differences--which should
become clearer as you progress in the
understanding of your own THEME and PASSAGE. - The point is to help your leader recognize other
plausible interpretations of the same text and
its theme... how changing context helps see other
things in the text - You might or might not have the same overall
perspective (Forensic/Theological
Covenantal/Pastoral or Apocalyptic/Messianic) as
your leader. - same perspective how is her/his theme
complement your own? - different perspective how is her/his theme in
tension with your own? How would you understand
her/his theme from YOUR different perspective?a\
46Â JULIANNE SNAPE Rom 12, -Offering Ourselves to
God
- Formal Respondent Arden Henderson
- Other Respondents
- Karney Carney
- Madeleine St Marie
- Jonathan Baynham
- Amy Lentz
- Derek Axelson
47STEPHEN STAGGS Rom 12, Darkened Mind
Transformations
- Formal Respondent Jeremy Snow
- Other Respondents
- Julie Carli
- Ross Stackhouse
- Jason Jones
- Murielle Wyman
- Iris Ankrom
48Forensic/Theological Interpretation Slave (in
11 616-23)
- F/TÂ Slave Someone who unconditionally submits
to the will and authority of a master. Like the
OT figures total, humble submission to Gods
will - Slave of sin  due to lack of the proper
teaching (knowledge) and will.  Paul speaks of
a willful slavery that can be voluntarily
shifted from one master to another by individual
believers. - 616-23 obedient slaves (616) one who
freely and voluntarily chose to submit to a
master (sin or righteousness) - How does one conceive of a voluntary slavery?
 It is the most difficult interpretation - But not impossible one reads the you plural
in Greek as referring to a singular individual
or a bunch of individuals. - F/T interpretation of many people in Western,
Enlightenment cultures, especially of people who
feel in control of their lives.
49New Covenantal/Pastoral Interpretation Slave (in
11 616-23)
- NC/PÂ Slave Someone who, although in a low
status, is a member of a household as a
socio-economic unit, and who, as a servant, acts
in the name of his/her master for the sake of the
household Someone totally defined by his/her
mission in the name of a master and for the sake
of the household. - Obedience Accepting ones mission and
carrying it out - Like the OT figures who accept a special role
given to them by God who has chosen them for a
special mission and sends them to speak and act
in Gods name. - A connotation further suggested, for the
Romans, by the phrase slave of Christ (11)
that brings to mind slaves of Caesar slaves
of the household of Caesar, acting in the name of
and with the authority of Caesar Jewett - In 616-23 The metaphors slavery to sin and
Slavery to righteousness/justice brings to mind
the image of a group of people (plural you)
under the power of a master who escaped to take
refuge under the protection and at the service of
another master.Â
50Apocalyptic/Messianic Interpretation Slave (in
11 616-23)
- A/M Slave  Someone who is owned by a master,
thus in bondage, totally at the mercy of this
master Slave worthless, powerless, in an
abject situation, with a shameful status. - Obedience involuntary submission to a master
acknowledging that one is powerless in view of
the superior power of the master - Like the OT figures as an instrument through
whom God acts, with a prophetic function, despite
the unworthiness and lack of ability of that
persona connotation further suggested, for the
Romans, by the phrase slave of Christ (11)
that brings to mind slaves of Caesar people
upon whom Caesar has life and death power and who
are instruments through whom Caesar acts
51Apocalyptic/Messianic Interpretation Slave (in
11 616-23)
- In 616-23Â slavery as metaphor for people
totally under the power of someone of something,
here sin (e.g., addiction all forms of
addiction and of systemic evil), and are
hopeless as long as someone (the Messiah, or a
Christ-like person or community the body of
Christ) intervenes and rescues the slaves (free
them redemption) - Yet former addicts always remain
recovering-addicts in need of on-goingÂ
redemptive empowering by Gods Justice thus slave
to God, 622, depending on Gods empowering
justice). - Humans are unable to function on their own they
can only pass from one sphere of power (the power
of sin) to another sphere of power (Gods sphere
of Gods justice)  Käsemanns and Byrnes
commentary Â
52Forensic/Theological view of Sanctification in
617-23 121-3
- F/TÂ Sanctification is self-centeredÂ
transformation of the individual into a saint,
through the work of the spirit in that
individual. - Instead of following evil inclinations being
slave/servant of sin - One follows good inclinations (including love
toward others, etc.) being slave/servant of
righteousness and righteous causes.  - Sanctification freeing oneself from evil
inclinations and pursuing good inclinations - Sanctification occurs when I am personally
willing and have the moral strength (morally
empowered) to follow good inclinations and NOT to
commit sins transgressions that anger/dishonor
God.Â
53New Covenantal view of Sanctification in 617-23
121-3
- NC/PÂ Sanctification is community-centered one
is a saint by participating in the collective
vocation of the community and participating in
the rituals of the community, glorifying God and
bringing about the glorification of Gods name. - Sanctification Being slave of Justice (of God)Â
acting (together with the community) in the
name of and with the authority of our master, the
God of Justice, and thus demonstrating/manifesting
the justice of God, as Christ did. - Being slave to sin is acting with the authority
of worldly masters, bringing about injustice,
oppression, and other evil. - Sanctification occurs when justice and love of
God is manifested in society by the Christian
community
54Apocalyptic/Messianic view of Sanctification in
617-23 121-3
- A/MÂ Sanctification is other-centered being a
saint 1) being freed from idolatry 2) being
Christ-like for others - 1) Being freed from idolatry
- By being a member of the body of Christ
- By being indebted to people who are other than we
are (including in the body of Christ) and who
bring gift to us from God - Being constantly freed from idolatry by
acknowledging the good gifts that others bring to
us from God thus preventing us from viewing the
gifts we have received as absolute ( from
falling back into idolatry) welcoming others as
Christ-like bearers of gifts of God for us - 2) Being Christ-like for others, that occurs when
I (and other members of the body of Christ) offer
myself as a living sacrifice and become
Christ-like for others