????????Imagined Concubinage

1
????????Imagined Concubinage

• ???
• ???????

2
????

• Keith McMahonMisers, Shrews, Polygamists
• ???????????????
• ?????????????
• ????????????????(typology)

• ????????(??)????????????
• ??????(1983)
• ??????(1986)
• ???????(1985)

3
Keith McMahon, Misers, Shrews, Polygamists

• What fiction represents is the aspiration to
  polygamy, and, at the very least, the caricature
  of what such situations were probably like. (KM,
  1995 17)
• ????????????????,????????????????????

4
???????????

• ???????????,????????,??????????,??????????????????
  ??????????????
• ????????,?????????,???????

5
Misers(???)

• ??????/??????????????,?????????????/????
• ????????????????????????,?????????????????????????
  ???,?????????????,???????????????????

6
Shrews and Sluts(?????)

• ??/???????,???????????,????,????,??????????,?????,
  ?????????????????????????,?????,?????????,????????
  ??????????????????????,??????,???????????

7
????

• ???????(????????????)
• ???????,?????????,???????????????,??????,????,????
  ???,????,???,??????
• ??????????,????????-??????????

8
monogamous love and idealized femininity

• ??????,??????,??????????????????,?????????????????
  ????
• ???????,?????????????????????(???),??????????,????
  ?????

9
???????????

• ??????????????,?????????????????????????????
• ???????,?????????,??????????????,???????
• ???????????,????????????

10
??????????-?

• ??????????????????,?????,???????,???????????,?????
  ???????????????
• ???????????????,?????????????,????????,????????
• ???????????????????,??????????,?????????????????,?
  ????????????

11
?????/???????

• ?????????,??,????,????
• ????????????,??,?????????,??????????????????????
• ?????,??????????,??????,??????

12
?????????

• Although polygamy has now been outlawed and
  almost entirely shamed out of existence in China,
  what still remains in its aftermath? This is a
  question I believe must be asked in all studies
  of gender and sexuality in twentieth-century
  China (just as similar questions must be asked
  about what of the slave past remains in
  contemporary race relations in the United States,
  or what of opium-trading colonialism remains in
  current Euro-American interactions with China).
  (Keith McMahon, Misers, Shrews and Polygamists,
  Duke 1995, p. 7)

13
gifts versus things

• ??????????????????????????????????????????????????
  ???????????(??)????????????(1991239)
• ????????????????????????????,??????????????,?????
  ??????????????????????,??????????????????
  (1991240)

14
????????

• ?????,??????????????????????,?????????????????????
  ??,????????????????????????????,??????????????????
  ??????? (??,1991250???????)

15
???(1983)

• ????????????????????????????????????????????????
  ??,???????,?????????????,?????????????,???????????
  ?????,??????????????,??????????????? (6)

16
??,??,????

• ??????????,????????????????,?????,???????,?????,?
  ????????????????????????????,????,????????,??????
  ???,?????,???????,??????,????????!???????,??????,
  ???????????????????????????? (49-50)

17
?????

• ???????,????????,????????????????????????????????,
  ???????????,????,????????????????????,??????????
  ,?????,????????????????????????????????,?????,????
  ??!?(62)

18
????

• ???????,?????,????????????????????,???????????????
  ???????????????????????,????,???????,?????????!?
  ?????,??????????????,???,??,?????,??????,???????
  (73)

19
????vs????

• ???????????????,????????????????,?????????????????
  ???????????(????????,35)

20
??????(1986)

• ?????,???????????????,??????????????????????????(8
  7)

21
??????

• ????,????,??????,??????????????????,???,??????????
  ???????,????????,?????,?????,???????????????????,?
  ???????????,????????,????(25)

22
??

• ?????,?????????,?????????????????????????????????
  ?????????,???????????????????????????(36)

23
????

• ??????????????????,?????????????????,???????????,
  ????????????,???????????????(?????????????)?

24
????????

• ??,?????????????????????????????????,?????,???????
  ?????????(61)

25
?????????

• ??,??????,???????????????????????,?????????,??????
  ??????,????,???????????????,???????,??????????,???
  ????????,?????,??????????????????????????,???????
  ?????(???29)

26
?????

• ???,????,??????,????????????,??????????????,??????
  ?,???????????,????????????,?????,?????????????,???
  ?????,??????????????!??!?????????????!??????!??
  ?????!????????,????????????????,?????,???,?????,
  ??????????????????,????,?????????????(????68

27
??????????

• ??????????,??????????,????????,???????????,???????
  ??????????????????????????????,??????????????????
  ,??????,??????????????,?????,????(??????110)

28
??

• ????,??????????????????????????,?????????????????
  ??(??????111)

29
????????

• ???????????????????????????????????????,??????????
  ???????,???????????????????,??????????,??????????,
  ??????????,????,????????,???????????????-?????????
  ???,???????????,??????????(???,??????,?????91-92
  )

30
?????????

• ???????????????,??????????????,??????????????????,
  ???????????????,??????????????,???????????????????
  ???

31
???????

• ?????????????,???????????,?????????,???????,??????
  ???????,?????????????????????????????,????,???????
  ???????????????,??????????????????,???????,???????
  ?????(??????239)
• ??????????????????-??????????????,???,????????????
  ?????!(???????-???198514-15)

32
only a particular form of perversion

• the heterosexual woman whose fantasies entail
  a man who is wholly faithful to her, and who,
  only while he is wholly faithful, does she find
  sexually attractive, but whom upon showing any
  sexual interest in another woman heaven forfend
  that it be another man immediately is rendered
  sexually unacceptable to her well like the
  heterosexual male above whose sexual fantasies
  are almost wholly circumscribed by photographs of
  female movie stars!, her sexual condition
  seems only a particular form of a socially
  proscribed perversion one that I could even,
  for a while, see myself getting behind.
  Certainly, it would be no more difficult than
  getting off on someone licking my sneakers. (And
  it would be, for me, a lot easier than getting
  off on female movie stars or most male one, for
  that matter.) (Samuel R. Delany,
  Aversion/Perversion/Diversion in Negotiating
  Lesbian and Gay Subjects, p. 30)

33
?????????

• ???,????????(?????)?????????
• ?????????,???????????????/???????????????????,????
  ?????????????????????????(???,lt?????????gt,???????
  ?-???????????,123?)