Title: James Wong, CA, CBV
1Planning Through The Crisis. A Succession
Planning Perspective.
By James Wong, CA, CBV Director of Succession
Planning BMO Harris Private Banking
2Agenda
- Succession process revisited
- Impact of the current financial crisis/economy
slowdown on succession planning and planning
through the crisis - Overview of business valuation.
3Overview
- 2 of every 3 Canadian entrepreneurs over 50 years
old have not commence their succession - Long-term structural changes in Canadian
businesses caused by increasing globalization - Weak global economy expected to persist through
2009 and into 2010 - Generally lower business valuations
4Succession is a process and not an event
- Set new goals and vision for owners and their
family. Distinguish between need to have and
want to have - Establish open communication amongst stakeholders
(family members, senior management, etc.) - Review estate plans in the context of succession
plans - Assess the current state of business through a
SWOT analysis - Economic landscape
- Business continuity needs in both soft and hard
capital - Estimate business value and assess adequacy of
retirement funds - Establish target timelines
- Consider tax planning opportunities
- Identify and review succession options
- Select and plan an exit strategy
5Succession Planning Timeline
6Impact of Current Economic Crisis on Succession
Planning
- General reduction in business valuation
- Tighter financial markets
- Reduced profitability
- Changes in internal business profile
- Change in future business landscape
- Increase foreign competition
- Consolidation
- Volatile Canadian currency
- Increase dependency
- Redistribution of business resources
- Tighter financing
- Reallocation of business focus.
7Navigating Through Trouble-Waters
- Remain focused on personal and family objectives
- Re-evaluate succession objectives in light of
external (and internal) business changes - Revisit timeline based on objectives and overall
changes in business outlook - Proactively respond to changes in business
outlook - Improve balance sheet (e.g. inventory and AR
turns) - Reduce customer/supplier dependency
- Control overhead expenses (operational leverage)
- Reallocate business resources (e.g. from
manufacturing to distribution)
8Navigating .. (Continued)
- Evaluate net asset value against capitalized
value of the business - Maintain and secure lines of credit even if the
credit is not presently required - Consider tax planning in light of lower business
valuation - Tools
- Increase communication amongst stakeholders
- Assistance from trusted advisors
- Consider succession facilitator
9Importance of Business Valuation
- A business valuation exercise will assist in
business strategic planning by highlighting key
business value drivers - Business valuation provides key input to
- Personal financial planning i.e. an estimate of
the value of equity in the family business - Tax planning and
- Insurance planning
10Valuation Definitions
- Fair market value (FMV)This term is commonly
used in notional valuations and usually applies
to the equity of a business. A common definition
of FMV is The highest price, expressed in terms
of money or moneys worth, obtainable in an open
and unrestricted market between informed and
prudent parties, acting at arms length and under
no compulsion to transact. - Enterprise Value (EV)This term is often used
in sale of business transactions. EV refers to
the value of the business as supported by all
sources of financing, including debt financing.
EV is therefore equal to FMV of equity and debt
i.e.EV FMV of equity plus debt.
11Business Valuation Essentials
- Value is driven by
- Level of sustainable cash flow
- Level of business risk usually expressed in terms
of required capitalization rate or multiple. - Basic valuation models
Cash Flow _________________ Capitalization Rate
- growth
Value
or
Cash Flow X Capitalization Multiple Value
12Business ValuationCapitalization Multiple Model
13Business Valuation DCF Model
14Business Valuation - General Capitalization
Multiples
- Normalized EBITDA Multiple Ranges
- Manufacturing - 4 to 6 times
- Distribution (wholesale) - 3 to 4 times
- Services contracting - 1 to 2 times.
- Reported earnings plus/minus non-economic and
non-recurring items. - EBITDA Earnings before interest, taxes,
depreciation and amortization.
- General factors that influence choice of
multiple - Volatility of earnings
- Exclusivity (technology, licenses, contracts,
etc.) - Diversification of customer base
- Competitive landscape
- Security of critical supplies (material and
labour) - Underlying collateral (TAB)
- General economic conditions.
15Valuation by Industries
- General valuation multiples have weakened by half
to one-time of EBITDA in the last 12 months - Global financial crisis in the US has affect
smaller to medium size private business
valuations, particularly those dependent on
leverage - Select industries are still strong, particularly
those driven by demographic trends - The growth in health and healthcare related
businesses are driving strong multiples 5 times
for healthcare products distribution company - Funeral homes 5 to 6 times EBITDA or 7,000 to
10,000 per call - Food manufacturing multiples north of 6 times
EBITDA are common - Security services 36 times monthly recurring
revenue - Auto-parts related businesses continue to
struggle and multiples remain low - Professional services (engineering, consulting,
etc.) have traditionally low multiples (1.5 to 3
times) and unique transition structures required
as there is high percentage of personal goodwill - Increasing trend towards to import and
distribution versus manufacturing
16Divestiture Process
- Key is in selecting appropriate intermediary or
investment banker (IB) to represent the seller
of the business - Fees range between 2 (EV over 50MM) and 10 (EV
less than 3MM) - Approximately 4 to 6 month process see FAS
timeline. More difficult divestiture could take
up to 12 months.
17Valuation FAQs (as asked by business owners)
- What are the main factors considered in a
business valuation?The main factors considered
in a business valuation are (i) the estimated
future sustainable cash flow, (ii) the stability
of the cash flow, and (iii) the growth prospects
of the cash flow. - How is future cash flow estimated? Future cash
flow is usually estimated based on the business
recent historical earnings. Earnings are
adjusted for non-cash items, such as
depreciation, and actual cash outflows that are
not included in earnings such as capital
expenditure, to estimate cash flow. - How far back do valuators look to estimate future
cash flow? It depends on several factors. If
earnings are relatively stable and are expected
to remain stable, then a simple average of the
last 3 to 5 years would generally suffice. If
however, earnings are volatile, selection of the
base period is more complex. A simple average of
historical earnings may not suffice and therefore
may require detail analysis and projection of
future earnings.
18Valuation FAQs - continue
- What are the most common valuation models that
are used to value privately held
business?Models that are based on
capitalization of cash flow are the most common
models. Amongst capitalization models, multiple
of cash flow model is most common because of its
simplistic and intuitive approach. - How reliable are rules of thumb in valuing
businesses?Rules of thumb should be used with
caution. Rules of thumb can give a broad
indication of valuation, however are more
commonly used to corroborate other mainstream
valuation models. - How are multiples chosen in multiple of cash flow
models?Multiples are a direct reflection of
business risk. Higher multiples are generally
chosen where cash flow is expected to be stable
and where growth is expected. Where there is
more uncertainty in future cash flow,
particularly if cash flow could decline, lower
multiples are chosen.
19Valuation FAQs - continue
- What is the difference between enterprise value
and fair market value of equity? Enterprise
value pertains to the value of the business that
is supported by both debt-finance and equity.
Equity is therefore equal to enterprise value
less debt. - Why do the ultimate transaction prices of
business sales sometimes vary significantly from
their valuations?Valuations are often prepared
without reference to any specific buyer. Some
buyers have special or strategic reasons to pay a
premium, and the price, if negotiated, may
reflect some of this premium.
20Q A