Exercise in the Treatment of Depression

1
Exercise in the Treatment of Depression

• Sean T. Mullendore
• Major, USAF, MC
• Primary Care Sports Medicine Fellow

2
Dx Mild-Moderate Depression Rx Exercise 3-5X
per week. RF 8???

• Sean T. Mullendore
• Major, USAF, MC
• Primary Care Sports Medicine Fellow

3
Objectives

• Scope of problem
• Depression defined
• Evidence of exercise to treat depression
• Proposed mechanisms of effect
• Limitations of evidence/application
• Bottom line

4
Scope of Problem Depression

• Prevalence between 5-10 of adults in primary
  care in U.S.
• 2-3X have depressive symptoms without DSM-IV
  criteria
• Women affected 2X as often as men
• Depressive disorders are 4th most important cause
  of disability worldwide
• Mild-moderate major depressive disorder ranks 2nd
  to ischemic heart dz for years of life lost due
  to premature death/disability

5
Depression Presentations/Risk Factors

• Presentations
• Multiple medical visits
• Multiple somatic complaints
• Work/relationship dysfunction
• Sleep disturbance
• Volunteered c/o stress or mood disturbance

• Risk Factors
• Family/personal hx
• Chronic medical illness
• Major life change
• Stressful life event(s) involving loss

6
Depression Screening Tools

• SIGECAPS
• Validated instruments as adjuncts to clinical
  interview
• Beck Depression Inventory (BDI)
• Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression (HAM-D)
• Quality Improvement for Depression Scale (QIDS)

7
Depression Defined

• Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
  Disorders, 4th Edition Text Revision (DSM-IV TR)
• 5 or more symptoms present during same 2-week
  period
• At least 1 symptom either
• Depressed mood OR
• Loss of interest/pleasure

8
Other Disorders to Consider

• Dysthymia
• Adjustment disorder with depressed mood
• Bipolar disorder
• Substance abuse
• Overtraining/staleness

9
(No Transcript)
10
Descriptive Cross-Sectional Data

• Camacho et al, Am J Epidemiol 1991
• Participant activity levels depressive sxs
  measured in 1965, 1974, 1983
• Significant risk for depression at 1974 follow-up
  if inactive at baseline
• Changes in exercise habits between 1965-1974 may
  have changed risk of depression in 1983 (i.e.
  more active less depression and vice versa)

11
Descriptive Cross-Sectional Data

• Bäckmand et al, Int J Sports Med, 2001
• Male athletes representing Finland from 1920-1965
  with controls classified as healthy at age 20
• 5 athlete groups endurance, power/combat,
  power/individual, team, shooting
• Questionnaires completed in 1985 1995
• Finding Referents more depressed than endurance
  and team sport athletes

12
Descriptive Cross-Sectional Data

• Bäckmand et al, Int J Sports Med, 2003
• Former elite male athletes surveyed by
  questionnaire in 1985 1995
• Findings
• Low levels of physical activity significantly
  increased risk of depression
• Increase of 1 MET-unit (hour/day) statistically
  decreased risk of depression by 8

13
Randomized Controlled Trial

• Blumenthal JA et al, Arch Intern Med , 1999
• InfoPOEMs level of evidence 1b
• 156 depressed older patients randomly assigned to
  1 of 3 groups
• Supervised aerobic exercise at 70-85 of heart
  rate reserve for 30 minutes on 3 days per week
• Zoloft Rx at 50 mg to 200 mg daily
• Both aerobic exercise and Zoloft Rx
• Primary outcomes scores on Hamilton Rating
  Scale for Depression (HAM-D) and Beck Depression
  Inventory (BDI)

14
Blumenthal JA et al (Contd)

• Findings at 4 months
• All 3 groups achieved comparable significant
  remission of MDD based on DSM-IV criteria
• 60.4 in exercise group
• 68.8 in Zoloft group
• 65.5 in exercise Zoloft group
• Patients on Zoloft Rx alone responded faster
• Among patients receiving combination tx, those
  with less severe MDD responded more quickly to
  exercise Zoloft than those with more severe MDD

• Bottom line
• Exercise walking or jogging at 70-85 of
  maximum aerobic intensity is as effective as
  Zoloft therapy in treating mild MDD
• Zoloft therapy had a faster initial response than
  exercise in improvement of MDD symptoms

15
Systematic Review

• Lawlor et al, BMJ, 2001
• Outcomes mean differences in effect size in BDI
  score between exercise no treatment and between
  exercise cognitive therapy
• 72 potentially relevant studies 56 were excluded
  from analysis

16
Lawlor et al (Contd)

• Findings
• Exercise c/w placebo intervention or as adjunct
  to standard treatment
• Effect size was significant at -1.1 (-1.5 to
  -0.6)
• Exercise c/w standard treatments
• Effect size was not significant at -0.3 (-0.7 to
  0.1)
• Aerobic and non-aerobic exercise have similar
  effect

• Limitations
• Most studies of poor quality
• When exercise c/w placebo/adjunct, studies were
  found to be heterogeneous
• None of participants exercised alone

• Bottom line
• Effectiveness of exercise in reducing sxs of
  depression cannot be determined because of a lack
  of good quality research

17
Best Evidence (so far) DOSE trial

• Dunn et al, Am J Prev Med, 2005
• InfoPOEMs level of evidence 1b
• 80 adults w/ mild-moderate depression randomly
  assigned to 1 of 5 treatment groups
• 7 kcal/kg/week (low dose) performed on 3 or 5
  days/week
• 17.5 kcal/kg/week (high dose) performed on 3 or 5
  days/week
• flexibility exercise control performed on 3
  days/week
• Subjects exercised individually in rooms under
  supervision by laboratory staff
• Primary outcome score on 17-item Hamilton
  rating scale for depression (HRSD17)

18
Dunn et al (Contd)

• Findings
• Adjusted mean HRSD17 scores at 12 weeks
• Reduced 47 for high dose exercisers
• Reduced 30 for low dose exercisers
• Reduced 29 for controls
• No main effect of exercise frequency
• Remission rates at 12 weeks comparable to other
  treatments for MDD
• NNT (for clinically relevant response) in high
  dose exercise 5
• NNT (for clinically relevant response) in 3
  day/week low dose exercise 7

• Bottom line(s)
• Both high low-dose aerobic exercise are
  effective as monotherapy in the treatment of mild
  to moderate MDD
• Exercising 3 times per week is at least as
  effective as 5 times per week

19
(No Transcript)
20
Proposed Mechanisms of Effect Physiological

• Monoamine hypothesis
• Regulation of hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal
  (HPA) axis
• Endorphin hypothesis

21
Monoamine Hypothesis

• Exercise enhances brain aminergic synaptic
  transmission
• Animal models show effects on CNS levels of
  noradrenaline with exercise
• Human models show effects on plasma/urine levels
  of monoamines
• Limitations
• Plasma data are poor estimate of CNS amine levels

22
HPA Axis Imbalance

• HPA axis may be hyperactive in depression
• Depressed patients have
• Higher basal cortisol levels
• Non-suppression of endogenous cortisol with
  dexamethasone administration
• Exercise delays HPA axis response to stress
  (animal models)
• Exercise-trained subjects exhibit hyposensitive
  HPA axis response to exercise challenge (human
  models)
• Limitations
• Not all depressed patients exhibit HPA axis
  hyperactivity

23
Endorphin Hypothesis

• Exercise leads to surge of ß-endorphin
• ß-endorphins reduce pain and potentiate euphoric
  state
• Unclear if ß-endorphins directly alter mood state
  or indirectly facilitate improved mood through
  energy conservation during exercise
• Limitations
• Same as central amine hypothesis (i.e. plasma
  data poor estimate of central ß-endorphin levels)

24
Proposed Mechanisms of Effect Psychological

• Distraction hypothesis
• Self-efficacy theory
• Mastery hypothesis
• Social interaction

25
Distraction Hypothesis

• Diversion from unpleasant stimuli or painful
  somatic complaints leads to improved affect
  following exercise sessions
• 28 yo female w/ moderate depression, ADHD,
  bulimia
• Although the exercise helps me feel connected to
  my body, at the same time, it is also an escape
  from everything that is occurring in my life at a
  particular timeIf I am truly exerting myself, it
  is not possible to dwell on anything outside of
  the present moment. It is a mental nap.

26
Self-Efficacy Theory

• Confidence in ones ability to exercise is
  strongly related to ones actual ability to
  perform the behavior
• Exercise poses challenging task for sedentary
  subjectsuccessfully adopting regular exercise
  may produce improved mood and enhanced ability to
  handle events that challenge ones mental health

27
Mastery Hypothesis

• Depression may result as response to loss of
  control over ones body
• Control of challenging pursuit (e.g. exercise)
  instills sense of independence and success
• As exerciser gains mastery of physical skills,
  they may take this feeling of control into
  everyday life

28
Social Interaction Theory

• Social relationships and mutual support provided
  to one another by co-exercisers account for
  beneficial effects of exercise on mental health

29
(No Transcript)
30
Limitations

• Good, quality research is lacking
• Lack of adequate allocation concealment
• Subjects volunteers rather than clinical subjects
• Few studies intent-to-treat
• Subjects not motivated to exercise screened out
• No true control group
• If exercise subject to FDA approval, would NOT
  receive approval for treatment of depression

31
Limitations

• Overall long-term adherence to exercise program
  is poor at 50
• Simply suggesting/recommending that a depressed
  patient begin exercise often proves futile

32
Limitations

• When prescribing exercise to depressed
  patients, consider caveats
• Anticipate barriers
• Keep expectations realistic
• Introduce feasible plan
• Accentuate pleasurable aspects
• State specifics
• Encourage adherence

33
Summary

• True effectiveness of exercise in reducing
  symptoms of depression cannot be determined
  because of limitations of available research
• BUT
• Exercise may be an effective therapy for mild to
  moderate major depressive disorder
• Aerobic and non-aerobic exercise appear to have
  similar effect

34
Summary

• Exercising 3 times per week is at least as
  effective as 5 times per week
• Walking or jogging at 70-85 of maximal aerobic
  intensity is probably as effective as drug
  therapy for treating mild depression
• Aerobic exercise at a dose consistent with
  ACSM/public health recommendations may be an
  effective treatment for mild to moderate
  depression

35
Questions?
36
References

1. Blumenthal JA, Babyak MA, Moore KA, et al.
   Effects of exercise training on older patients
   with major depression. Arch Intern Med
   19991592349-2356.
2. Dunn AL, Trivedi MH, Kampert JB, Clark CG,
   Chambliss HO. Exercise treatment for depression.
   Efficacy and dose response. Am J Prev Med
   2005281-8.
3. Herman S, Blumenthal JA, Babyak M, et al.
   Exercise therapy for depression in middle-aged
   and older adults predictors of early dropout and
   treatment failure. Health Psychology
   200221(6)553-563.
4. Lawlor DA, Hopker SW. The effectiveness of
   exercise as an intervention in the management of
   depression systematic review and meta-regression
   analysis of randomised controlled trials. BMJ
   20013221-8.

37
References

1. Brosse AL, Sheets ES, Lett HS, Blumenthal JA.
   Exercise and the treatment of clinical depression
   in adults, recent findings and future directions.
   Sports Med 200232(12)741-760.
2. Paluska SA, Schwenk TL. Physical activity and
   mental health, current concepts. Sports Med
   200029(3)167-180.
3. Pollock KM. Exercise in treating depression
   broadening the psychotherapists role. J Clin
   Psychol/In Session 200157(11)1289-1300.
4. Scully D, Kremer J, Meade MM, et al. Physical
   exercise and psychological well being a critical
   review. Br J Sports Med 199832111-120.
5. Bäckmand H, Kaprio J, Kujala U, Sarna S.
   Personality and mood of former elite male
   athletes a descriptive study. Int J Sports Med
   200122215-221.

38
References

• Bäckmand H, Kaprio J, Kujala U, Sarna S.
  Influence of physical activity on depression and
  anxiety of former elite athletes. Int J Sports
  Med 200324609-619.
• Dimeo F, Bauer M, Varahram I, et al. Benefits
  from aerobic exercise in patients with major
  depression a pilot study. Br J Sports Med
  200135114-117.
• Institute for Clinical Systems Improvement
  (ICSI). Major depression in adults in primary
  care. Bloomington (MN) ICSI 2004 May.
• Kessler et al. The epidemiology of major
  depressive disorder. JAMA 2003289(23)3095-3105
• Murray CJL, Lopez AD. The global burden of
  disease study. Lancet 1997 May349(9063)1436-1442
  .

39
References

1. Camacho TC, Roberts RE, Lazarus NB, et al.
   Physical activity and depression evidence from
   the Alameda County Study. Am J Epidemiol 1991 Jul
   15134(2)220-231.