Title: Texas ASCDs Boot Camp for Curriculum Administrators
1Texas ASCDs Boot Camp for Curriculum
Administrators
2GUIDING QUESTIONS
- What is curriculum?
- Whats wrong with using the Texas Essential
Knowledge and Skills (TEKS) as a district/campus
curriculum? Why arent they sufficient? - How do you use the TEKS as a framework for
developing district/campus specific curriculum? - What are some processes for developing district
or campus-specific curriculum within the TEKS
framework? - What really is alignment?
- How do you create and structure knowledge and
skills within a curriculum document? - What are the options and processes for designing
units of instruction?
3WHAT IS CURRICULUM?
4Differences Between Curriculum and Instruction
How
Why
What
5The WHAT Content Standards--the stuff
- Knowledge
- Concepts Cognitive Curriculum
- Data/Facts
- Skills
- Attitudes
- Values Affective Curriculum
- Beliefs
- Judgments
- Strength
- Endurance Psychomotor Curriculum
- Coordination
6The WHY Performance Standardsthe result,
outcome, objective, etc.
- What we want students to do with the stuff.
- The complexity or sophistication with which we
want students to do something with the
stuffthe Application / Analysis / Synthesis /
Evaluation of Blooms.
7HOW?
- The instruction
- What the teacher will do to teach
- What the students will do to learn
- Instructional activities
- The organization and sequence of content and
activities. - The processes through which the students will
learn the curriculum.
8Our Focus--Cognitive Curriculum Texas Essential
Knowledge and Skills
- Knowledge
- Concepts
- Data/Facts
- Cognitive Skills
WHAT?
9Negotiable vs. Non-negotiable
The WHAT is non-negotiable. The WHY is
non-negotiable.
- The HOW is negotiable within limits
- The children learn what that are supposed to
- learn.
- They are treated with courtesy and dignity.
- The paint generally stays on the walls.
- The teacher is accountable for students learning
- the curriculum.
10Common Errors in Curriculum Development
- Lining up the TEKS and then assuming you have an
aligned curriculum - Trying to do too many of the steps at one time
- The checklist phenomenon--writing instruction and
backloading curriculum - Beginning with horizontal alignment
11Major Elements of Curriculum Development
- Vertical alignment of each sequence of student
expectations, including the articulation of
specific content standards - Organizing the aligned student expectations into
bundles--into rational, coherent units of
instruction, including time lines (e.g., by
6-weeks or by a discrete number of days) - Creating exemplar instruction for all or some
percentage of the units of instruction
12Whats Wrong With The Texas Essential Knowledge
and Skills As A Curriculum Document?
- The TEKS are a framework for curriculum
developmentNOT the curriculum. - The TEKS are broad expectations for student
learning (The student is expected to.). - The TEKS lack specificity.
- The TEKS are not organized into rational,
coherent units of instruction with recommended
time lines
13Such as and Including
- The content standard for student expectations is
articulated in the such as and including
statementsthe specific academic content (the
What) that students will learn. - Such as means that the given content is
negotiable. - Including means that the given content is
non-negotiable.
14The Case for Specificity
- Assumption
- Every Student Expectation should have an
including . . . statement.
15The Critical Questions
- Are both the content standard and performance
standard sufficiently specific that - 1. Would a new teacher know exactly what
- students are supposed to learn and at what
level - they are to demonstrate that learning?
- 2. Could a test item writer construct a test
item that - would be aligned with that learning?
16ENGLISH LANGUAGE ARTSStandard 1 Specificity
Third-Grade (105 Student Expectations)
Unique Examples
17ENGLISH LANGUAGE ARTSStandard 1 Specificity
Seventh-Grade (138 Student Expectations)
Unique Examples
18ENGLISH LANGUAGE ARTSStandard 1 Specificity
Twelfth-Grade (121 Student Expectations)
Unique Examples
19ELA mechanics TEKS--without examples/specification
sa lined up curriculum
20Science TEKS--without examples / specifications
a lined up curriculum
21ELA mechanics TEKS--with examples /
specificationsan aligned curriculum
22Science TEKS--with examples / specificationsan
aligned curriculum
23The TEKS are disjointed (i.e., they are arranged
in strands, not in coherent units of
instruction.
24Texas History Strands
- History
- Geography
- Economics
- Government
- Citizenship
- Culture
- Science, technology, and society
- Social studies skills
25STEP 1 Vertical Alignment (Scope)
- WHY?
- Assure Equity
- Provide a Rational System
- Reduce Gaps and Unproductive Redundancies
26Equity
- Quality Assurance To The Community
- The State of Texas says, through TEKS It
doesn't matter whether you live in Highland Park,
El Paso, Houston, San Antonio, or The Rio Grande
Valley. The State of Texas guarantees that your
10th grader will have the opportunity to learn
"X." - Your ISD must say It doesn't matter which
attendance zone (campus) you live in. Our ISD
guarantees that your 4th grader will have the
opportunity to learn "X" It doesnt matter whose
7th grade Texas History class you are in, you
will have the opportunity to learn x.
27Rational System
- Is your district a confederacy of independent
school districts or a single system? - We Are Either
- a rational system, with a vertically-aligned
curriculum for all campuses or - an irrational system in which no one part knows
(or cares) what other parts of the system are
doing.
28Alignment Makes Education in Your I.S.D. a System
- continued
- Teachers Are Part of a System
- Schools cannot be one-room schools located
side-by-side along a common hallway. - Teachers are not independent subcontractors--we
have a responsibility to deliver the goods.
(knowledge and skills) that the system says we
are to deliver.
29Reduce Gaps and Unproductive Redundancies in
Knowledge and Skills
- Critical In Mathematics
- Do we progress through division in a rational
way, based on TEKS? - Do we know at what grade level division using
two-digit divisors is taught? - What prerequisite skills must be mastered before
teaching division using two-digit divisors? At
what grade level are those skills introduced and
mastered?
30Reduce Gaps of Knowledge and Skills - continued
- Desirable In Literature
- Are we teaching literature, or are we reading
stories? - There are six sub-sets of the short story
- Satire
- Historical
- Mystery
- Gothic
- Science Fiction/Fantasy
- Realistic
31Reduce Gaps of Knowledge and Skills - continued
- Desirable In Literature (continued)
- Which kinds of short stories do we want students
to read as they advance through the curriculum? - At which grade level will that particular kind of
short story be introduced? - Will that particular kind of short story be
studied again? If so, at what grade levels? - Do we use a consistent set of language, 12-K in
teaching the critical attributes of that genre of
literature? If "character" is one of those
attributes, do all teachers, 12-K, use the same
set of language in teaching character (e-g..
types of characters protagonist, antagonist,
narrator, foil, stenotype?
32Reduce Gaps of Knowledge and Skills - continued
- Desirable In Literature (continued)
- Do we consciously choose, teach, and emphasize
specific comprehension strategies (e.g.
monitoring when comprehension breaks down, making
connections?) - Are we using expository and narrative reading as
models for writing (e.g. problem/solution
organization, sequential, order of importance).
33Reduce Unproductive Redundancies
- How many time do students need to read
Charlottes Web or James and the Giant Peach? - How many times do they need to do the plant
unit? - How many times do they need to make Pilgrim hats
and Pilgrim collars? - Do all students need to spend the 1st six weeks
reviewing the previous years instruction?
34Aligned vs. Lined Up
- Until the district addresses the
- issue of specificity, it can only
- produce a lined-up curriculum,
- not an aligned curriculum.
35The Universe of Possibilities
- In determining
- the specific content standard,
- it is desirable that someone at the table
- know the universe of possibilities
- a real content expert.
36ELA mechanics TEKS--without examples/specification
s
37The Universe of Punctuation
Thirteen Punctuation Marks
- quotation marks (9 rules)
- hyphen (7 rules)
- dash (4 rules)
- parentheses
- brackets
- ellipsis dots
- period (2 rules)
- question mark (3 rules)
- quotation mark (1 rule)
- comma (23 rules)
- colon (4 rules)
- semicolon (6 rules)
- apostrophe (2 rules)
38The Universe of Comma Rules
- items in a series
- city/state
- day/year
- quotations
- greeting of a letter
- nominative of address
- compound sentence
- complex sentence
- compound/complex sentence
- with Sr., Jr., Ill, etc.
- two adjectives that modify same noun
- Appositive
- with, too, also, yes, wall, etc.
- with yes, no, why, well, etc used at the
beginning of a sentence
- phrases in a series
- inverted names in a list
- to separate name from academic degree
- to set off contrasted words, phrases, clauses
- to set off transitional words or expressions
- introductory prepositional phrase
- introductory participial or absolute phrase
- restrictive and nonrestrictive clauses
- to set off words, phrases, and clauses that would
otherwise be unclear
39Taxonomy of Literature
40Taxonomy of Literature
- No pattern or reoccurrence of rhythm, rhyme,
meter sentence form
- Reoccurrence of
- rhythm, rhyme,
- meter verse form
41Taxonomy of Literature
- Not completely factual
- Plot
- Setting
- Character
- Mood
- Theme
- Conflict
- Point of View
42Taxonomy of Literature
- Theme (explain
- nature or human
- nature)
43Taxonomy of Literature
- Not completely factual
- Plot
- Setting
- Character
- Mood
- Theme
- Conflict
- Point of View
- Theme
- (ridicule, scorn
- failings of
- individual or
- society)
- Theme
- (explains
- history)
- Plot, setting
- characters
- based on
- history
- Mood
- (suspense)
- Plot (structure
- to solution)
- Theme (romance,
- adventure)
- Characters(idealized)
- Setting (improbable ornonrealistic)
- Characters (frequently exaggerated)
- Plot, setting,and charactersare all plausible
44REPRESENTING TEXT GRAPHICALLY
45
45REPRESENTING TEXT GRAPHICALLY
46
46How Do You Accomplish Vertical Alignment?
- Alignment document is a technical, quality
control documentnot a document from which
teachers plan daily/weekly instruction. - Configuration of Design Teams 12-K teacher teams
with a facilitator who has a deep knowledge of
the discipline and the grade level (Exception
social studies which may be K-3, 4-7, 5/8/U.S.
History, 6/World History/World Geography. - Facilitator may be
- District content specialists
- External to the district (ESCs, district
collaboratives/co-ops) - Teachers who are content experts
- Someone must be an expert at group facilitation
47How Do You Accomplish Vertical Alignment?
(continued)
- Task Define/give specific examples of the TEKS,
sufficient that a teacher new to the profession
or to your school district would know precisely
what to teach and a test item writer would know
what to test. - The TEKS performance standards (the verbs) rarely
need changing at this stage. - The content standards are frequently vague and
need definition. - In defining a content standard, the best
definitions will come by beginning with the
universe of possibilities. (Thats why so much
content expertise is needed in the process.)
48Caveats
- K-8 vertical alignment and 9-12 vertical
alignment are rather straightforwardthe TEKS
frameworks are identical and charts like the
science and math charts from the Dana Center
line up the TEKS. - Alignment of grades K-8 with grades 9-12 is
somewhat problematic.
49Alignment between K-8 and 9-12
- 9-12 fragments into discrete, sometimes
disconnected courses (e.g., Algebra I and
Geometry Biology and Chemistrysome TEKS
alignment others do not) - K-12 alignment is challenging except in terms of
aligning big concepts and/or unless a
discipline (e.g., chemistry) asks the question
What foundation experiences do we want students
to have somewhere in the K-8 science journey?--a
whole different process.
50A Possible Role for 9-12 Teachers in the K-8
Alignment Process
- A physics expert can sometimes be helpful in
- advising the K-8 team on the universe of
- possibilities for each TEKS as well as the
- foundation experiences in physics concepts.
- Caveat Beware the danger of the we-know-
- what-we-are-doing-and-you-dont
- phenomenon.
51Alignment of Process Skills
- Aligning process skills like those in science and
social studies should probably be left to the end
as you begin Step 2, bundling of student
expectations--unit construction and time lines. - The process skills take on meaning and
specificity only when applied to other academic
content.
52Step 2 Bundling Student Expectations to
Create Rational Coherent Units of Instruction
- The vertical alignment document produced in Step
1 was a technical, quality control document. - It was not the document that teachers will use to
plan daily/weekly instruction. - The individual student expectation now must be
bundled into rational, coherent units of
instruction with a time line (6-weeks, discrete
number of days).
53Putting the Aligned Student Back Together What
will be frontloaded to drive the unit?
- History
- Geography
- Economics
- Government
- Citizenship
- Culture
- Science, technology, and society
- Social studies skills
54Putting the Aligned Student Back Together What
will be frontloaded to drive the unit?
- Reading
- Literary Elements Response
- Writing
- Thinking
- Listen/Speaking
- Viewing/Representing
55Activity
- What are all of the issues which must be
considered and addressed in designing a unit of
instruction? - Answer the question for yourself.
- Find a Learning Buddy
- Pair share to compare and contrast your responses.
56Unit Template
57Why include The Language of Instruction
- Consistency of instruction
- Critical for economically disadvantaged and
second language learners
58Adding The Language of Instruction
- Example Unique instructional vocabulary that the
district wants all math teachers to use. - Example Big Concepts and their critical
attributes around which the district wants to
build curricular units at each grade level. - Example TAKS language
59Critical Attributes in Concept-Based Curriculum
- Those things (i.e., characteristics, traits)
about the concept that never change. - Those things (i.e., characteristics, traits)
about the concept that make it different/unique
from other concepts. - -Madeline Hunter
- Example mammal
60So what?
- Why are critical attributes important?
- Why should they be included in the Language of
Instruction as part of a curriculum document?
61Identifying and Teaching The Critical Attributes
of A Concept (or Skill) Are Essential Because.
- The concept remains abstract for many learners
unless it can be made more concrete. - Generating examples/non-examples in a meaningful
way depends on critical attributes. - The critical attributes are the generalizations,
principles, and rules that Jacobs, Tomlinson,
Garmston, McTighe, and others talk about. - Adds depth, complexity, connectivity, and
consistency of language.
62CHANGE
- CRITICAL ATTRUBUTE
- a characteristic of all change
- I. All change involves the alteration of one or
more of the attributes ofthe original. - A. The alteration of some attributes is
through elimination. - B. The alteration of some attributes is
through addition - C. The alteration of some attributes is
through rearranging - D. The alteration of some attributes is
through modification - II. All changes have one or more causes.
- A. The causes of some change are
controlled/uncontrolled - B. The causes of some change are internal
- C. The causes of some change are external
- D. The causes of some change are
known/unknown
DISTINGUISHING ATTRIBUTES characteristics that
makes one change different from other changes
63CHANGE
- CRITICAL ATTRUBUTE
- a characteristic of all change
- DISTINGUISHING
- ATTRIBUTES characteristics that makes one
change different from other changes
- III. Change occurs according to a process.
- A. Some change processes are cyclical.
- B. Some change processes are linear.
- C. Some change processes are incremental
(steps/degrees). - IV. All changes have one or more effects.
- A. The effects/results/consequences
- of some changes are unknown.
- B. The effects /results /
- consequences of some changes
- are predictable / unpredictable.
- C. The effects of some changes are
- preventable/ not preventable.
- D. The effects of some changes are
- positive, negative, or neutral.
Working draft from Parkland HS, Ysleta ISD, El
Paso
64Identifying Critical Attributes of a Concept
There is a seven-step, inductive process for
identifying the critical attributes. The process
will fill in the blanks of the template below.
These are the process steps for forming
generalizations (an inductive thinking process.)
- I. All (concept) have/are _______.
- A. Some (concept) have/are_____
- B. Some (concept) have/are_____
- C. Some (concept) have/are_____
- II.. All (concept) have/are _______
- A. Some (concept) have/are_____
- B. Some (concept) have/are_____
- C. Some (concept) have/are_____
- III. All (concept) have/are _______.
- A. Some (concept) have/are_____
- B. Some (concept) have/are_____
- C. Some (concept) have/are_____
- IV. All (concept) have/are _______
- A. Some (concept) have/are_____
- B. Some (concept) have/are_____
- C. Some (concept) have/are_____
65In general, units of instruction will be built
around the teaching learning of concepts and
cognitive skills.
What are cognitive skills?
- Analytical Thinking Skills cognitive processes
that deepen understanding. (Examples
categorizing, classifying). - Critical Thinking Skillsthinking skills that
are used to analyze and evaluate data and
evidence in order to develop, judge the
effectiveness of, or respond to an argument or
position. (Examples inductive thinking,
determining bias, judging the accuracy of
information). - Executive Processes cognitive processes that
are involved in synthesizing, generalizing, and
applying knowledge. Examples summarizing,
metacognition, generalizing). - Creative Thinking Skills skills that are
involved in creative production.
(Tomlinson, Carol Ann et al. The Parallel
Curriculum, National Association for Gifted
Children and Corwin Press, 2002.)
66Even though we talk about concepts and skills
as two distinct issues, behind every skill there
is a concept. A skill usually involves
following process steps and/or rules.
2 / 3 ? 1 / 2 _____
67Activity - Concepts Behind the Skills
- Find a Learning Buddy.
- Discuss Why do you invert and multiply? Whats
the concept behind the skill?
68What we have to know to teach any skill,
including critical thinking
- Critical Attributes of the Concept (traits,
characteristic) and - Critical Attributes of the Skill (process steps,
rules)
69Conclusion The Concept
- a statement
- about an individual person, place, thing, or
event that - can be supported by accurate information.
70A conclusion can either take the form of a fact
statement or an opinion statement.A fact
conclusion George Washington was the first
President of the United States. An opinion
conclusion George Washington was a good
President.
71The Skill Process Steps for Validating A
Conclusion (deductive process)
- Hypothesize or take a given conclusion.
- Gather data through research, observation, and/or
experimentation. - Verify the accuracy (and sometimes objectivity)
of the data. - Determine whether or not there is sufficient data
to support the conclusion you started with. - Note Sufficiency is typically determined by
the - stakes involved in accepting and/or acting on
the conclusion.
72Everything that is not isolated data or a skill
is a concept. Different Kinds of Concepts
What are concepts?
731. Fluffy Concepts
bears bluebonnets apples
- Concepts that are not central themes / concepts
of a discipline. - Connect activities.
- Contributes no depth or complexity or
connectivity to learning.
742. Discipline Specific Concepts
- "Concepts that exist only or primarily within a
discipline. - Can be the central themes and concepts of the
discipline. Examples - revolution (history)
- polarity (science)
753. Minor Themes/Concepts
- Concepts that exist in more than one discipline,
but not in all. - Concepts that are central themes/concepts in
more than one discipline. Examples - Conflict (literature, history)
- Ratio/Proportion (sciences, mathematics)
764. Universal Themes/Concepts
- Concepts that exist in all disciplines.
- Concepts that are central themes/concepts in all
discipline. Examples - Patterns
- Structure
- Systems
- Change
- Relationships
- Balance/Equity
77In each of the models, taken as a pure model,
one of these kinds of concepts is frontloaded and
becomes the organizing principle for the unit.
Discipline Parallel
Multidisciplinary Interdisciplinary
Problem Specific Discipline
Based
Discipline Specific Concept
Minor Theme
UniversalConcept
Real WorldProblem
Discipline Specific Concept
or Parallel Data/Facts
78For Discipline-Specific Curriculum
Discipline Parallel
Multidisciplinary Interdisciplinary
Problem Specific Discipline
Based
- A discipline specific concept is front-loaded
(e.g., a literary genre). - A cognitive skill (e.g., drawing conclusions).
- The rest of the unit is built around that concept
or cognitive skill
79English Language Arts
Math
Science
Social Studies
Binomial Equations
Determining Point Of View
Magnetism
The U.S. Constitution
80 Discipline Specific Unit
Unit
Frontload
Backload
WHAT? Discipline Specific Concept
Critical Attributes of
the Concept WHY?
Performance Standards HOW?
Cognitive Skill(s) Critical Attributes of the
Skill(s) Instruction (teacher / learner
activities) Resources Student Products Assessment
TEKS
Does differentiation go in adistrict curriculum
document?
81What gets Frontloaded?
Discipline Parallel
Multidisciplinary Interdisciplinary
Problem Specific Discipline
Based
OPTION 1 Parallel (complimentary) Data/Facts
from one discipline
82Parallel Discipline (Facts / Data)
Social Studies
Language Arts
Science
Math
Red Badge of Courage
U.S. Civil War
??
??
83Parallel Disciplines Unit
Unit
Frontload
Backload
WHAT? Data/Facts From One
Discipline
WHY? Performance Standards HOW?
Data/Facts from a Second Discipline Cognitive
Skills Critical Attributes of the
Skill(s) Real-world issues (problem, question,
discrepant event) Instruction (teacher / learner
activities) Resources Student Products (sometimes
common) Assessment
84Parallel Discipline Minor Theme
Discipline Parallel
Multidisciplinary Interdisciplinary
Problem Specific Discipline
Based
OPTION 2 A Minor Theme
85Parallel Discipline Minor Theme
Language Arts
Math
Social Studies
Tools to analyze and/or report data dealing with
culture
Culture
Culture
Math cannot teach the concept "culture" because
culture is not a central theme/concept in
mathematics.
86Parallel Disciplines Unit
Unit
Frontload
Backload
Facts/Data from each discipline that are
examples of the concept Cognitive
Skills Critical Attributes of the
skill(s) Tools from other disciplines Instructi
on (teacher / learner activities) Resources Stude
nt Products (sometimes common) Assessment
WHAT? Minor Theme Concept
Critical Attributes of the
Concept
WHY? Performance Standards HOW?
87Multidisciplinary
Discipline Parallel
Multidisciplinary Interdisciplinary
Problem Specific Discipline
Based
For Multidisciplinary Curriculum Minor
theme/concept
88Multidisciplinary
Social Studies
Language Arts
Science
Math
Tools to analyze and/or report data dealing with
conflict
Conflict
Conflict
Conflict
89Multidisciplinary Unit
Unit
Frontload
Backload
WHAT? Minor Theme Concept
Critical Attributes of the
Concept
WHY? Performance Standards HOW?
Facts/Data from each discipline that are
examples of the concept (means to an end, but
not an end unto itself) Cognitive
Skills Critical Attributes of the
skill(s) Instruction (teacher / learner
activities) Resources Student Products Assessment
90Interdisciplinary
Discipline Parallel
Multidisciplinary Interdisciplinary
Problem Specific Discipline
Based
For Interdisciplinary Curriculum Universal
theme/concept
91Interdisciplinary
Social Studies
Language Arts
Science
Math
Patterns
Patterns
Patterns
Patterns
92Interdisciplinary Unit
Unit
Frontload
Backload
WHAT? Universal Theme Concept
Critical Attributes of the
Concept
WHY? Performance Standards HOW?
Facts/Data from each discipline that are
examples of the concept Cognitive
Skills Critical Attributes of the
skill(s) Instruction (teacher / learner
activities) Resources Student Products (may be
common) Assessment
93Problem Based
Discipline Parallel
Multidisciplinary Interdisciplinary
Problem Specific Discipline
Based
For Problem-Based Curriculum A complex question,
problems, or discrepant event
94Problem Based
Real-world IssuesComplex Question, Problem, or
Discrepant Event
Social Studies
Language Arts
Science
Math
Real-world Issue
Real-world Issue
Real-world Issue
Real-world Issue
95Problem Based continued
- Real-world issues may be
- Real
- Plausible, hypothetical
- Real-world problems must be
- Relevant to the student interest
- Be plausible
- Require knowledge and skills from all four
disciplines
- Example
- Designing city park
- Future Problem Solvers
96Problem Based Unit
Unit
Frontload
Backload
WHAT? Complex Problem,
Question Discrepant Event
WHY? Performance
Standards HOW?
Concepts, Facts, Data, Tools from each discipline
that contributes to answering the questions,
solving the problem, or explaining the discrepant
event Critical Attributes of the Concepts and
skill(s) from the set above Instruction
(teacher / learner activities) Resources Student
Products (may becommon) Assessment
97Activity Reflection
- 1. Pair with a Learning Buddy.
- 2. Individually, reflect on this question
What have been your experiences with designing
Discipline-Based, Parallel Disciplines,
Multidisciplinary Interdisciplinary, and
Problem-Based units of instruction. - How does what you have seen/heard today
- conform with your prior learning and experience
- conflict with your prior learning and experience
and - inform your future work with these models?
- 3. Discuss your reflections with your Learning
Buddy.
98REFLECTION ON THE DAY.
99REFLECTION ON THE DAY - continued