Title: Nicholas Hann
1PPPs in North America A private sector
partners perspective
- Nicholas Hann
- Managing Director
Macquarie North America Ltd. December 6, 2006
2Contents
31.
- Public Private Partnerships
4Infrastructure Investment Paradigm Shift
Private investment in infrastructure is growing
as alternatives to government funding become
increasingly necessary
- Governments have traditionally been the prime
facilitators of infrastructure investment - In recent years, however, pressure to lower taxes
and still provide services has forced governments
globally to reorder their priorities - Role of government evolving to that of regulator
of assets rather than provider of services - This trend is likely to continue, providing
ongoing opportunities for private sector
investment in infrastructure assets - Secondary market is growing
- Government infrastructure investments as a of
total outlays in OECD countries¹
Source National Accounts, OECD ¹ 1997 figures
are the most recent available. The OECD is
publishing these results again in 2004
5Infrastructure Sub-Sectors
- Expanding the definition of infrastructure
- Over the past decade, the term infrastructure has
been applied to an increasing number of assets - The Infrastructure Investment Spectrum
6Why the Shift to PPPs?
- Governments have successfully decreased deficits
and debt, in part, by cutting infrastructure
investment, despite - Increasing need for investment due to population
growth and demographic factors - Desire to improve efficiencies in the public
procurement process - Aging capital stock and needed investment in key
infrastructure - Because it
- Encourages whole life costing approaches
- Encourages innovative solutions to meet schedule
and performance requirements - Focuses all stakeholders attention on value for
money - Results in the management of risk in a
transparent manner - Rewards performance consistent with the
objectives of the project - Refocuses the investment decision from an asset
to a service allows the private sector to
determine the mix of capital and operating inputs
required to produce the desired service
7PPPs Deliver!
- Recent UK Treasury study into PPP projects
showed - 89 coming in on time or early
- No cost overruns on construction borne by public
sector - Noting
- 70 of Non-PPP were delivered late, and
- 73 ran over budget
- UK National Audit Office Study of Highway PPPs
found savings of - 19 on capital costs
- 34 on operating costs
- 17 overall lifecycle savings
- Reasons for cost savings in UK PPPs
- Transfer of whole life responsibility to
private sector - Transfer of risk to private sector
- Broader competition (not just contractors, but
also operators, suppliers) - Reduction in scope for claims against governments
- Economies of scale in project management, design,
construction, operation
Source HM Treasury July 2003
8Why do PPPs Bring these Benefits?
- Transfer whole life responsibility to private
sector (not just construction) - Transfer of risk to private sector
- Each party manages risks they are best able to
handle - Creates incentives for private sector to perform
- Public sector has ability to penalize for poor
performance replace poor service - Right to terminate contract
- Broader competition
- Reduction in scope for claims against governments
- Clear accountability
- Economies of scale in project management, design,
construction, operation - Note key differences
- Traditional Government specifies design
- PPP Government specifies outcome or service
9Government Attitude in the United States
- There are many politicians who support the
privatization of tollroads in the USA.. - I want to be very clear on where the Bush
Administration stands on public-private
partnerships (PPP). We like them, we want to
encourage them, and we support them. Mary
Peters, US Secretary of Transportation (Former
Federal Highway Administrator) December 2004 - "Our goal is to encourage states to experiment
and innovate, to become the laboratories of
democracy and show us and each other how to work
with the private sector to build roads that open
faster, require less repair work later, and give
us safer, smoother rides at less cost. US
Secretary of Transportation (Norman Mineta) - "We've got a major shortfall between the amount
of money available and the infrastructure needs
of this state, so we're going to look at every
option, from tolling, to asset sales. Governor
of Indiana (Mitch Daniels) - It makes sense that when you take over a
business that's struggling you look at ways to
leverage your assets. There's a lot of assets the
state has. New Jersey Governor (Richard Codey
- On leasing the NJ Turnpike) - "This transaction, which is the first of its kind
in the nation, fulfills Mayor (Richard) Daley's
continued commitment to pursue innovative
financing techniques, and has provided Chicago
taxpayers with an unprecedented single, up-front
payment of 1.83 billion that we will use to
invest in our people and protect Chicago's
taxpayers both today and in the future." City
of Chicago Chief Financial Officer (Dana R.
Levenson)
10Report to Congress on Public Private Partnership
January 2005
- Report is very pro, private investment and
involvement in transportation projects. - Supportive of Design Build as a procurement
method quoting cost savings of between 6 to 40 - Key Recommendations
- Tolling Allow States to Toll the Interstate /
Variable Pricing Initiatives - Private Activity Bonds Allow issue of up 15bn
of private Activity Bonds (Tax-Exempt Bonds that
allow private equity investment), for new build
projects - Environmental Streamlining Defined Timeframe for
process / Permits - TIFIA Amendments lower threshold (100m to
50m) - Design Build Lower threshold for use
- Commercialization of Rest Areas
- Debt Service Reserve Allow Federal Grant Funds
to be used for debt service reserves
US Department of Transportation, Report to
Congress on Public Private Partnerships - January
2005, 197 Page Report
11Since thenLegal environment has developed
Indicates states with a broad PPP legal framework
Indicates states likely to enact PPP legal
framework in future
Indicates states with a limited PPP legal
framework
12Since thenSuccessful examples have shown PPPs
are a reality
- ILLINOIS Chicago Skyway
- INDIANA Indiana Toll Road
- TEXAS Trans-Texas Corridor
- VIRGINIA Pocahontas Pkwy, Capital Beltway, I-95
- OREGON PDA development of 3 projects
VIRGINIAN PILOTJUNE 5, 2006
CHICAGO SUN TIMESOCTOBER 28, 2004
THE INDIANAPOLIS STARMAY 24, 2006
13Since then Concession model has shown real
benefits
TRADITIONAL PROCUREMENT
CONCESSION MODEL
RevenueEfficiencies
ADDITIONAL Infrastructure EconomicDevelopment Jo
bs
CAPEXEfficiencies
OPEX Efficiencies
VS.
Equity
Additional Debt
Standalone Bonding Capacity
Standalone Bonding Capacity
Examples
14Government Attitude in Canada
- Federal Government now embracing P3 model
- British Columbia P3s now well established.
Recent announcement by Provincial Government that
all capital projects with a Provincial
contribution of more than 20m must be considered
for P3 delivery. - Ontario Infrastructure Ontario currently
progressing over 50 Alternate Service Delivery
projects - Quebec current P3 transactions in roads,
hospitals and social infrastructure - Alberta successful P3 Projects in roads
expanding into hospitals, schools and water
treatment - Atlantic Canada - Successful P3s in roads and
social infrastructure
15Key Trends Infrastructure Funds
- Focus on yield has driven private sector
investment in infrastructure - Pension funds typically have very long dated
liabilities which are well matched by
infrastructure assets - Peculiar to Canada has been the development of
the income trust sector which has a particular
focus on infrastructure assets now with its tax
advantages taken away - There is a growing base of infrastructure
investors globally - Traditional players (dedicated funds,
construction groups etc) - Pension funds
- Private equity
- Retail
There is now a sophisticated and diverse global
market for investment in infrastructure and
funding new infrastructure
- Specialized Infrastructure Investment Funds now a
significant feature of market - As much as 150 billion of funds raised globally
- Infrastructure and PPPs increasingly seen as a
distinct asset class with low correlation to
other investment - 145bn of MA activity in sector in 2006 (up 180
from 2000) - Concerns over high multiples paid for assets
(27.5x EBITDA for London City Airport) - Low rates of return on investment (PPP
transactions trading in the UK secondary market
at IRRs below 6) - Reducing cost of equity for public sector
sponsors
16Key Trends Strong and Maturing Credit Markets
- Canadian transactions initially done largely in
European bank market due to inability to obtain
committed finance at bid - European banks increasingly providing better
financing than traditional tax exempt municipal
bond markets in US - Canada now has maturing debt markets
- Choice of European bank, monoline insurance,
bought bond deals, private placements - Credit rating agencies making huge effort better
to understand construction risk in PPPs - Cost of debt and flexibility of terms is falling
- Concerns emerging over high levels of leverage
(debt to EBITDA multiples increasingly above 20x)
17Key trends Government Approaches
- Volume of transactions increasingly stretching
the market for Design-Builders and Facility
Managers - Increasingly jurisdictions are competing for
human resources and capital to drive projects - Increasing shortage of high quality advisors to
Government - Market is increasingly becoming global
- Investors gravitating to efficient (quick and
cost effective) procurement processes and larger
projects - Governments increasingly
- Standardising documentation
- Improving procurement processes
- Simplifying transactions
- Bundling smaller projects to create larger ones
18Macquaries Road Experience in North America
19 20Chicago SkywayPress
21Chicago SkywayOverview of Transaction
- Tolls (Passenger Vehicle)
- Increase at greater of CPI, GDP per capita and 2
- 2004 2.00
- 2005 2.50
- 2008 3.00
- 2011 3.50
- 2013 4.00
- 2015 4.50
- 2017 5.00
- Overview of Transaction
- City of Chicago sold a 99yr concession for the
Chicago Skyway - Competitive process involving 5 qualified parties
- Cintra-Macquarie consortium was the successful
bidder - Final Sales proceeds of 1.83 billion (49 x 2005
EBITDA) - Process run by Goldman Sachs
- First privatization of an existing toll road in
the U.S. - Financing structure used taxable debt (no
tax-exempt debt)
22Chicago SkywayOverview of Asset
- Overview of Asset
- Built in the 1950s
- 7.8 miles in length
- 3 lanes in both directions
- Mostly elevated structure
- Completion of a 300m rehabilitation project
expected in 04 - Manual tolling (no electronic tolls)
- EBITDA (2002) US33 m
- Understated due to construction rehabilitation
program - Average Passenger Vehicles per day 50,000
Chicago Skyway
23Chicago SkywayOverview of Process
- Overview of Process
- City appoints Goldman Sachs to act as sell side
advisor - RFQ issued March 2004
- City selects qualified bidders in 5 bidders
qualified (out of 10 responses) May 2004 - Qualified bidders provided with access to data
room June 2004 - Bidders provide indicative bid and comments on
concession agreement July 2004 - Final and binding bids submitted October 2004
- Successful bidder announced October 2004
- Concession agreement signed October 2004
- Financial close expected January 2005
- Details on the City of Chicago website
www.cityofchicago.org/Skyway
24- SR-125 (San Diego California)
25SR-125
- Franchise originally granted in 1990 part of
California States freeway plan since 1959 - Key delays were environmental, legal and prior to
grant of concession to private sector, lack of
finance - 35 year concession
- Macquarie acquired interest in September 2002
- Transaction financed May 2003
- Critical government involvement
- Federal USDOT TIFIA Loan
- State Caltrans granted franchise and land
acquisition - County San Diego / SANDAG project
construction 138 million - City Chula Vista undertook Master
Planning arranged developer land
donations
- Funding structure (at start of operations)
- Numerous community and environmental commitments
- Project currently under construction
- Toll road opening scheduled for October 2006
26SR-125Overview of Transaction
- Overview of Transaction
- Located in San Diego California
- Total cost 900 million
- Green field toll road, under construction, due to
complete in 2006 - Significant congestion reliever
- Strong demographic growth
- First ever TIFIA concessional loan for a private
toll road development in the USA
27SR-125Overview of Asset
- Overview of Asset
- SR125 South Toll Road
- 18km in length 4 lanes wide in most sections
- 35 year concession from date of road opening
- Flexible toll setting based on demand
- Estimated opening is in 2006
- Designed to reduce congestion on Interstates 5
and 805 - Reduce congestion on local arterial roads in
Chula Vista and Bonita - Serve existing and future development in the
South Bay and Otay Mesa Area
28SR-125Overview of Process
- Overview of Process
- EGIS / PB Consortium awarded concession by
Caltrans 1989 - Delays due environmental and permitting
issues 1993 to 2000 - TIFIA application approved 2000
- Macquarie Infrastructure Groups purchased
majority of EGIS / PB interest in company Sep
2002 - Financial Close / Ground breaking May 2003
- Anticipated opening Mid 2006
- Concession ends Start of Operations 35yrs
- Financial Close was reached within six months of
Macquarie Infrastructure Groups purchase of the
project
29- HIGHWAY 407 (Ontario, Canada)
30Highway 407 ETRHistory of Transaction
- History of Transaction
- 1998/99 Advised a consortium, included the
Infrastructure Trust of Australia (predecessor to
the Macquarie Infrastructure Group (MIG)) among
other international and Canadian institutions and
pension funds, on the acquisition of the highway
from the Province of Ontario. - valuation, due diligence, managing independent
advisors. negotiating the construction contract
for 39km of tolled highway - Although the bid was not successful, Macquarie
arranged 3.5 billion of committed capital. - 2001 Advised MIG on the 1.2 billion acquisition
of 40 of Cintra Concesiones de Infraestructuras
de Transporte S.A. (Cintra), the largest single
shareholder of 407 International Inc. which owns
407 ETR. - valuation and due diligence, managed external
technical advisors, assisted with negotiations. - co-led underwriting of A1.7 billion of equity
- 2002 Advising MIG on the 493 million acquisition
of a 16 interest in 407 International Inc. - deal origination, valuation, due diligence,
negotiation, managing advisors and documentation.
- co-lead the underwriting of A1.0 billion of
equity, including a A200 million placement to
Ontario Teachers Pension Plan Board. - 2002 Advising Cintra on the acquisition of 5.8
of 407 International Inc., for 178 million. - deal origination, valuation, due diligence,
negotiations, managing advisors and documentation
31Highway 407 ETROverview of Transaction
- Overview of Transaction
- Concession
- 99 Year concession Ending 2098
- Time to Deliver
- Extensions opened and operational within 28
months, 4 months ahead of required deadline - Cost to Deliver
- Construction costs of extensions equal to 500
million - 3.1 billion sale price, proceeds used to pay
down debt
- Economic Impacts
- Over 350 employees at 407 ETR
- Significant development of commercial and
residential property around the road where only
rural land existed previously - Private Sector Involvement
- Design, construction, financing of two extensions
plus maintenance and operations of entire road - Transfer of all associated risks including toll
revenue, operations, maintenance, and
construction of extensions
32Highway 407 ETROverview of Transaction Cont
- Public Policy Goals
- Congestion relief for Highway 401
- Barrier free access
- Off balance sheet, off credit
- Proceeds from sale
- Public Acceptance
- Servicing over 300,000 customers on average
weekdays - Growing customer base of over 4.8 million people
- Over 500,000 transponders in use
- User Fees (January 1, 2002 for vehicles with
transponders) - Passenger vehicles 11.5 cents per km
- Recreational vehicles 23.0 cents per km
- Trucks 34.5 cents per km
- Service Improvements
- Relief of congestion on major 400 series highways
- One of the safest highways in North America
33Highway 407 ETROverview of Asset
- Overview of Asset
- Largest Highway Privatization in the world
- 108 kilometre Multi-lane, toll highway
- 40 interchanges
- Lane width varies between 4 8 lanes in each
direction. - Opened to public traffic in June 1997
- Tolling commenced in October 1997
- Designed to be a congestion reliever to Highway
401, one of the busiest highways in North America
(over 400,000 vehicles per day at its busiest
points). - Uses a barrier free transponder electronic
tolling system. - 500,000 transponders in circulation for use on
the Highway.
34- Detroit Windsor Tunnel (Linking US and Canada)
35Detroit Windsor TunnelOverview of Transaction
- Overview of Transaction
- January 200 - Macquarie North American
Infrastructure Inc. (a wholly owned subsidiary of
the Global Infrastructure Fund (GIF)) acquired
Detroit Windsor Tunnel shares from DCTC owners. - The acquisition of DCTC was funded by US53.5
million of senior debt supplied by WestLB,
subordinate debt originally supplied by Macquarie
Bank Limited, and equity provided by GIF. - DCTC currently holds a concession over the US
side of the tunnel which grants it the right to
collect toll revenue in return for maintaining
and operating the tunnel. DCTC also operates and
collects revenue from the Canadian side on behalf
of the City of Windsor.
36Detroit Windsor TunnelOverview of Asset
- Overview of Asset
- Opened to public traffic November 3, 1930
- one of only two road links between Detroit, USA
and Windsor, Canada. - Primary link between the downtown core of both
cities - Mainly used by light vehicles and buses.
- Average vehicle crossings per day 20,000
- Second busiest border crossing between the USA
and Canada - About 100 employees maintain the tunnel, collect
tolls and provide administrative support.
Tunnel Specifications Tunnel 5,160 feet long
(1,573 meters) with a height clearance of 13 feet
2 inches (4 meters). Roadway 22 feet wide (6.7
meters) and allows for two lanes of traffic in
opposite directions Maximum depth of the roadway
beneath the river surface i75 feet (22.8
meters). Construction took 26 months and cost
23,000,000.
37 38Dulles Greenway
- Overview of Asset
- Equity acquired by Macquarie Infrastructure Group
- 50 year concession
- 4 lanes, 58 miles
- Enterprise Value 750 m
- Chequered past, but performing well experiencing
strong growth
39 40Sea to SkyCase Study
- Overview of Asset
- Upgrade of existing road between Vancouver and
Whistler - 105km in length 2 and 3 lanes in most sections
- 25 year concession from financial close
- Construction must be completed by 2009, prior to
Winter Olympics - Operation and Maintenance for 25 years
- Availability, safety and traffic payments
- Overview of Transaction
- Located in Vancouver B.C.
- Upgrade of an existing road
- Capital cost of C600MM
- Shadow toll
- Project is being procured as a Public Private
Partnership by Partnerships BC - Macquarie selected as preferred proponent and
reached financial close in June 2005
41Contacts
NICHOLAS HANN Managing Director Tel (604)
605-1779 Fax (604) 605-1634 Emailnicholas.hann_at_m
acquarie.com
1055 Dunsmuir Street Four Bentall Centre Suite
2664 Vancouver, BC