Title: The Natural Killer Cell Neoplasms: Can we overcome treatmentresistance
1The Natural Killer Cell Neoplasms Can we
overcome treatment-resistance?
2Case
- The patient is a 31-year-old Mexican male with a
PMH of rheumatic fever anemia who presents with
midepigastric pain, bloating, nausea, vomiting
and fever for 3 days. - CBC WBC 89 / Hgb 14 / Hct 40 / Plt
133 - Diff 10 Polys / 2 Bands / 8 Lymphs / 3
Monos / 77 Others - AST 464 GGT 496 TB 3.6 Uric Acid 8
Coags - wnl - ALT 450 AP 438 DB 2.3 LDH 2660
Cr 1.0 - Peripheral Smear Medium - large size lymphoid
cells with variable amounts of basophilic
cytoplasm, convoluted nuclei, condensed chromatin
and multiple nucleoli. Some with small
azurophilic cytoplasmic granules. Morphology
c/w either NK-cells or atypical (T-LGLs).
3Further workup
- Flow cytometry 52 variably-sized cells
- CD2 / sCD3- / CD3? / CD4- / CD5- / CD7-
(partial) / CD8(small subset CD10- / CD11b- /
CD16 / CD33(partial dim) / CD38 / CD45 /
CD56(subset) / CD57- / CD45RO(variably / CD34- - TdT- / MPO- / TIA
- T-cell receptor gamma ? germline configuration
- Bone marrow 63 Atypical lymphocytes similar to
those seen in the peripheral smear. - numerous histiocytes with hemophagocytosed RBCs
- MPO and NSE negative
- EBV negative
- CSF cytology negative
- Cytogenetics 49,XY, complex cytogenetics with
del(6)(q21q23)
4Normal NK cell development
Suggests overlap In Phenotypic
Functional characteristics
Common lymphoid progenitors
Tripotential cells T/NK/DC common progenitors
Bright CD56 Dim/neg CD16 Produce ? cytokines
Dim CD56 Bright CD16 ?cytokine production
Oshimi, K. British J of Haematology, 2007.
5WHO Classification of NK cell neoplasms
- Blastic NK-cell lymphoma
- Thought to originate from plasmacytoid dendritic
cells (CD56/CD4) - Extranodal NK/T-cell lymphoma (former aliases
include polymorphic reticulosis, lethal midline
granuloma, midline malignant reticulosis,
angiocentric lymphoma) - Nasal type (Arising from the upper aerodigestive
Tract) - Non-nasal type (Arising from an extranodal
location) - Aggressive NK-cell leukemia
6Extranodal NK/T-cell lymphoma clinical features
- Median age 50-60 years MgtF
- Seen primarily in East Asians, Mexicans, South
Americans with a Native American heritage - Consists of 3-9 of malignant lymphomas in
various Asian countries - Fever, malaise, weight loss occur at
presentation - Bone marrow blood involvement occur
- CNS involvement in 7 at presentation (direction
invasion or mets) - CD56 is a neural adhesion molecule, therefore, NK
cells have an affinity for nerve tissues - Associated with hemophagocytic syndrome
7Extranodal NK/T-cell lymhoma nasal versus
non-nasal
- Nasal presentation
- Nasal, paranasal, upper aerodigestive tracts
involved gt80 of cases - Most often limited stage at presentation
- Nasal lesions present with mass, nasal
obstruction, epistaxis and local invasion of
surounding tissues - Metastasizes to same areas from where non-nasal
form arises - Median survival lt 12 months
- Non-nasal presentation
- May arise from skin, Gl tract, testis, soft
tissues other organs - Patients with intestinal lesions may develop
perforation/bleeding - Poorer prognosis in non-nasal form
stage-for-stage when compared to nasal form - Median survival lt 4 months
8NK/T-cell lymphoma diagnosis staging
- Histology ? medium-sized lymphoid cells with
cytoplasmic azurophilic granules cells are
perivascular and exhibit angioinvasion leading to
tissue necrosis and coagulation - CD45sCD3-cCD3?CD56, negative CD13, CD33, CD19
CD20) - Cytotoxic granule-associated proteins, granzyme
B, TIA-1 and perforin - Germ-line configuration of TCR and IGH
- EBV almost always present in tumor cells
- Diagnosis often difficult due to massive necrosis
from vascular occlusion - Ann Arbor system difficult to apply to NK/T-cell
lymphoma that involves primarily extranodal sites - IPI for aggressive B-cell neoplasms seems
inadequate to predict prognosis
9Aggressive NK-cell leukemia Clinical features
- MF
- Median age 30-40 years
- Disseminated at presentation often with fever,
jaundice, weight loss, hepatosplenomegaly, and
lymphadenopathy - Homophilic binding of CD56 to tissues expressing
high levels of this neural cell adhesion molecule
(skin, testes, GI tracts, neural tissue) may
explain its propensity to disseminate widely - Common complications include liver dysfunction,
DIC, hemophagocytic syndrome - Rapidly progressive, poor prognosis
- Median survival lt2 months
10Aggressive NK cell leukemia diagnosis
- Morphologically slightly immature lymphocytes,
pale cytoplasm, azurophilic granules, fine
nuclear chromatin occasional nucleoli - sCD3-, CD3?/-, CD56,
- CD16-/ CD57-
- Germ-line configuration of TCR and IgH
- Cytotoxic granule-associated proteins, granzyme
B, TIA-1 and perforin - EBV found in tumor cells
- Common chromosomal aberration del 6q
11NK cell leukemia is refractory to treatment
- Exhibits a relentless progressive course, often
resistant to traditional chemotherapy - Multi-drug resistance gene called P-glycoprotein
is expressed by NK cells - Encodes for protein expressed on cell membrane
allowing cytotoxic drugs to be extruded - Vinca alkaloids anthracyclines rendered
ineffective
12Treatment of NK/T-cell LymphomaLocalized Disease
13Studies involving chemotherapy and XRT for
localized disease
14Primary XRT Alone for the Treatment of Localized
Disease
- Retrospective review of 92 pts with Stage I/II
angiocentric lymphomas (T/NK-cell T-cell
lymphomas) - Treated with 40-60 Gy involved-field XRT with
median f/u 56 months - Initial response rapid with 66.3 CR PR 17.4
- Patterns of recurrence 50 local recurrence,
10.9 regional failure, 25 systemic failure - In general, T/NK-cell lymphomas were more
aggressive - OS 40.1 DFS 37.8
Kim et al. J Clin Onc, 2000.
15What do we know about XRT in NK/T- cell lymphomas?
- XRT is an important modality for localized
disease - Outcomes
- ORR Ranged from 60-80
- CR 40-80
- 5-year OS 40-59
- Doses ranged from 30-60 Gy
- Local relapses dosages lt45-50 Gy
- Initial response rate high, but relapses are
frequent ? 17-77 (50 most common) - Most treatment failures occurred within 1st year
- Systemic relapses occurred in 25-30 of pts
treated with XRT alone - gt1/2 systemic relapses are NOT associated with
local recurrences (many early stage pts actually
have more disseminated disease) How do we
recognize these patients? - Non-nasal lymphomas are usually advanced at
presentation and early-stage disease disseminates
rapidly. XRT used only as adjunctive or
palliative use.
16Radiation versus chemotherapy as initial treatment
- You et al ? Retrospective study examining XRT
(54-60 Gy) versus chemotherapy as initial
treatment - 46 patients received initial ? XRT (n6) vs chemo
(n40) - Chemo pts further stratified into salvage XRT
(n18) chemo alone (n22) - Median f/u 56.9 months
- 5-year OS and FFS are superior in the intended
radiotherapy group as compared to the intended
chemotherapy group - Authors recommended front-line use of XRT
- Only a small number of patients evaluated in a
retrospective fashion - OS / FFS for XRT alone were high compared to
other studies - Did not seem to see high rate of relapse with XRT
alone as in previous study
17Treatment outcomes according to modality
Included intended RT Group (n6) those Salvaged
with RT (n18)
Primary XRT group Had superior OS FFS
Included chemo only Group chemo pts Salvaged
with XRT
Small sample size Likely contributed to Inflated
OS/FFS? 40 59 in other studies
18Outcome of receiving XRT versus never receiving
XRT
5-year OS 49.7 versus 23.0
5-year FFS 48.7 versus 23.0
19Can sequential CHOP XRT effectively treat
localized disease?
- Localized intermediate to high-grade NHL can be
cured by CHOP followed by XRT ? this regimen was
examined in localized NK/T-cell lymphoma - Ribrag et al ? Retrospective study of 20 pts
compared front-line XRT versus front-line
CHOP/COP - Front-line treatment followed by chemo or XRT in
some pts - Front-line XRT ? CR 100 Front-line chemo
? CR 33.3 - Median survival front-line XRT not reached
front-line chemo 35 months - Suggested that XRT after chemo may be less
effective - Kim et al ? Prospective study of 17 pts receiving
CHOP x 4 cycles followed by IF XRT (45 Gy) - CR 58 3-year OS 59
- Planned sequential chemoradiotherapy was
completed in only 35 due to PD on CHOP/COP - 2 pts received comcominant XRT Chemo due to
bleeding from tumor site - Authors concluded CHOP prior to IF RT is NOT a
satisfactory regimen for localized disease
20Treatment of NK/T-cell LymphomaLocalized
Advanced disease
21IMEP a new regimen for advanced disease
- Lee et al prospective study of 26 patients, all
stages - IMEP x 6 cycles (ifosfamide, MTX, etoposide,
prednisolone) as first-line treatment - Group A Localized disease (Stage I/II) ? 16
patients - XRT (45-54 Gy) or salvage chemo ONLY given to
those who relapsed, progressed, or had residual
disease - Group B Extranasal disease (Stage III/IV) ? 10
patients - Included disseminated primary nasal disease
primary extranodal disease - Those who relapsed were given 2nd line chemo
22Survival data after IMEP chemotherapy
Group A ? OS (3 yr) 80.4 Median Survival
Not reached
- Median f/u 24.6 months
- Group A ? CR 79
- 2 pts with PR received RT ? both had CR
- Cummulative CR after IMEP /- XRT was 93
- Group B ? CR 13
- No distinction between those with primary nasal
or those with extranasal disease in this study - Of those in CR 64 relapsed received RT
Group B ? OS (3 yr) 30 Median Survival 2.7 mo
23Conclusions about IMEP chemotherapy
- IMEP may be superior to CHOP as first-line chemo
- With CHOP CR 59-63, OS (2-3 years 50 range)
for Stage I/II disease - IMEP /- XRT gt CR 93 3-year OS 80.4
- Due to high rate of local failure, XRT should be
done routinely after chemo - Those with Stage III/IV disease showed no benefit
over doxorubicin-based regimens - A phase II study planned in Korea with IMEP XRT
24Salvage Chemo with IMVP-16/Pd
- Kim et al ? Prospective, phase II study of
IMVP-16/Pd (similar to IMEP) with relapsed or
refractory disease after receiving an
anthracycline-based regimens - 32 pts Stage I/II 15 Stage II/IV 17
- Front-line chemo
- CHOP 46.9
- COPBLAM-V 53.1
- Previous chemosensitivity
- Sensitive 46.9
- Refractory 53.1
- Outcomes (after 59 month follow-up)
- CR 37.5, ORR 43.8
- Median TTF 3.7 months
- OS 8.2 months
- 5-year OS 24.8
25IMVP-16/Pd shows activity in chemosensitive
patients
- Sensitivity to 1st line chemo was most important
predictor of CR rate, TTF, and OS - CR duration was longer in chemosensitive patients
(not statistically significant due to small
patient number) - Age, B symptoms, stage, LDH, IPI were not
statistically significant predictors of outcome - IMVP-16/Pd showed promise in chemosensitive
patients but poorly salvaged refractory patients
26L-asparaginase as a salvage regimen
- Yong et al (2001) ? Retrospective study examining
37 patients with NK/T-cell lymphoma - Patients treated with CHOP x 2 cycles ?
- CHOP Responders (n10) ? Received CHOP x 6 more
cycles local XRT - CHOP Refractory patients (n27) ? received
either L-asparaginase-containing regimen XRT
(n14) OR salvage regimen (w/o L-asparaginase)
XRT (n13) - CHOP Responders (70 Stage I/II IPI 1-2 CR
100, 2-year OS 100) - CHOP Refractory (82 Stage III/IV IPIgt2 B
symptoms, angioinvasive dz CR 26 2-year OS
20) - L-ASP Group ? CR 50 2-year OS 50.8
- No L-ASP Group ? CR 0 2-year OS 0
27L-asparaginase for CHOP refractory disease
- Yong et al (2003) ? Prospective study of 18
patients with disease deemed refractory to CHOP - All pts treated with regimen containing
L-asparaginase (6000 IU/m2), dexamethasone, and
vincristine (1-6 cycles) XRT - Stage II 38.9 Stage III/IV 61.1
- Results comparable to 2001 retrospective study
with a CR 55.6, 5-year OS 55.6 - Yong et al (2006) ? Retrospective study of 46
patients with NK/T-cell lymphoma - Initially treated with CHOP to stratify into
CHOP-sensitive and CHOP refractory groups - 71.7 FAILED CHOP (SD / PD) ? received
L-asparaginase-based treatment (n33) XRT - Stage I/II 58.7 Stage III/IV 41.3
- 5-year OS 86.3 (Stage I/II) 38.3 (Stage
III/IV)
28P-glycoprotein a predictor for CHOP resistance?
- 12 specimens were examined by immunohistochemical
staining for anti-P-glycoprotein antibody and
anti-GSTp antibody - For CHOP failure ? 7/8 were P-gp and 5/6 were
GST p antibody - For CHOP responders ? 4 specimens were negative
for both P-gp GST p antibody
29Other promising regimens
- SMILE
- Dexamethasone, MTX, ifosfamide, L-asparaginase,
etoposide - 6 stage IV relapsed/refractory pts
- ORR 67, CR 50
- Bortezomib CHOP
- 13 pts Stage III/IV T cell/NK cell lymphoma
- ORR 61.5, (only 3 ENKLs)
30Does IPI accurately reflect prognosis in
NK/T-cell lymphoma?
- The prognostic impact of IPI (International
Prognostic Index) on NK/T-cell lymphomas is
controversial - Previous studies have mixed results on its
relevance - Lee et al ? multicenter, retro-spective review of
262 pts with NK/T-cell lymphoma - Upper Extra-upper aerodigestive tract
NK/T-cell lymphoma (UNKTL EUNKTL) - Localized vs disseminated
31A new prognostic model is suggested
32Predicting OS in NK/T-cell lymphoma IPI versus
new prognostic index
International Prognostic Index
Proposed Prognostic Index
(p0.0614)
(p0.8304)
IPI does not discriminate well between low and
low-intermediate groups (p0.0614)
high-intermediate and high groups (p0.8304)
33Treatment of Aggressive NK-cell Leukemia (ANKL)
- Due to its rarity, there are mostly case reports
and small case series in the literature - Suzuki et al ? Retrospective review of 22 cases
of ANKL from 19 collaborating institutions - 13 received anthracycline/anthraquinone-containing
regimens - CR 13 PR 3 relapse in all but one
- Median survival 58 days
- Presence of B symptoms, IPI category,
therapeutic response were significant prognostic
factors - No standard treatment regimen is used or
recommended - Some case reports have recommended
L-asparaginase-based regimens - Allogeneic HSCT has been tried with only a few
successful cases reported
34Autologous Stem Cell Transplant
35Autologous HSCT
- Au et al ? Retrospective study, 18 pts of all
stages with chemoresponsive disease - ASCT in CR1 / CR2 showed significant DFS
(p0.0027) and OS (p0.0034) over NR/PR group - DFS (3-year) 71 (CR1) OS (3-year) 59
(CR1/CR2) - No significant difference in DFS or OS b/w those
treated in CR1 or CR2 - Trend toward improved DFS (p0.052) and OS
(p0.064) for those with ASCT in CR1 versus no
ASCT
36Autologous HSCT (continued)
- Kim et al ? Retrospective study of 16 pts, all
stages - Estimated OS (2-year) 71.3 RFS 25.8
- Trend toward better survival in those who
received ASCT compared to historical controls
(p0.091) (2-year OS in control 56.5) - Benefit to ASCT in those with
- ASCT in CR compared to ASCT with PR/NR (p0.049)
- Stage III/IV disease (p0.001)
- Poorest risk groups NK IPI 3,4 AND EUNKTL had
more prolonged survival with ASCT (not
statistically significant, p0.055 or p0.056)
37Allogeneic Stem Cell Transplant
38Allogeneic HSCT shows promising results
39Survival data after Allogeneic SCT
- Median f/u 34 months
- 2-year PFS 34, OS 40
- Median time from SCT to progression 1.8 months
- ORR
- CST 52 versus RIST 60
- TRM
- CST 30 versus RIST 20
- Relative risk for PFS Multivariate analysis was
statistically significant for - stem cell source (BM vs PB )
- Age (gt40 vs lt40)
- Dx (extranodal vs others)
OS (2 yr) 40
40Conclusions about Allogeneic HSCT
- Promising results for Allo-HSCT in this patient
population - Of note, 19/28 had active Stage IV disease at the
time of SCT - PFS NOT affected by
- Sex
- Stage at time of HSCT
- Chemosensitivity at time of HSCT
- CR versus active disease at time of HSCT
- Type of conditioning regimens
- The use of TBI in conditioning regimens
- Donors
- Acute GVHD
- Study may lack power due to small sample size
- TRM was lower in RIST, and RR was equivalent
- Ultimate timing of Allo-SCT NOT clear
41Conclusions
- Common resistance to chemo
- Poor drug delivery due to tissue necrosis and
angiodestruction - Frequent expression of P-glycoprotein phenotype
- For localized disease
- XRT is important for initial treatment
- XRT alone leads to high rates of relapse
(including systemic relapse) - IMEP may be more effective than CHOP in localized
disease - Not clear whether XRT needs to be given prior to
chemotherapy - For advanced disease
- IMEP CHOP are minimally effective, especially
in chemo-refractory pts - L-asparaginase-containing regimens have shown
promise for refractory / relapsed disease
(whereas IMEP did not)
42Yet More Conclusions
- May be able to stratify patients into CHOP
responders versus CHOP refractory - Autologous transplant
- May be most effective in those in CR1 (or CR2)
- Trend toward improved survival with ASCT compared
to none - May be beneficial in those with most advanced
disease (Stage III/IV, NK IPI 3 4, and EUNKTL
pts) - Allogeneic transplant
- Promising treatment option, especially for
advanced disease patients - Reduced intensity regimens may be equally
effective and associated with less treatment
mortality. - More prospective, randomized trials are needed
43Case revisited
- Initially he received HyperCVAD 1A
- Complicated by neutropenic fever
- Upon count recovery he had leukemic cells appear
in the peripheral blood worsening transaminitis
and increased LDH - Repeat bone marrow showed 50 leukemic cells
- Adult ALL BFM protocol started (Daunorubicin 60
mg/m2 IV D1, 2, 3 Vincristine 1.4 mg/m2 IV D1,
8, 15, 22 PEG-Asparaginase 2000 U/mr IV D15
Prednisone 60 mg/m2 PO D1-28 Methotrexate 12
mg IT D 8, 15 - Pt discharged home but returned 2 weeks later
with nausea, vomiting, and fever - He was febrile to 40.1, hypotensive, tachycardic
to 140, hypoglycemic in the 20's - WBC was 70, LDH 6,000, and LFT's 500s, a TB 7
- He eventually coded several times and passed away
about 60 days after initial presentation
44Resources
- Kim et al. Angiocentric Lymphoma of the Head and
Neck Patterns of Systemic Failure After
Radiation Treatment. J Clin Oncol. 18 2000,
54-63. - Ribrag, V. Early Locoregional High-dose
Radiotherapy is Associated with Long-term Disease
Control in Localized Primary Angiocentric
Lymphoma of the Nose and Nasopharynx. Leukemia.
2001 15 1123-1126. - Kim et al. CHOP followed by involved field
radiation is it optimal for localized nasal
NK/T-cell lymphoma? Annals of Oncology. 2001
12 349-52. - You et al. Radiation therapy versus chemotherapy
as initial treatment for localized nasal natural
killer (NK)/T-cell lymphoma a single institute
survey in Taiwan. Annals of Oncology 15 618-625,
2004. - Kim et al. Effective second-line chemotherapy for
extranodal NK/T-cell lymphoma consisting of
etoposide, ifosfamide, methotrexate, and
prednisolone. Annals of Oncology. - Matsumoto et al. Successful treatment with
Erwinia L-asparaginase for recurrent natural
killer/T cell lymphoma. Leukemia Lymphoma. 44
879-82, 2003. - Ando et al. Selective apoptosis of natural
killer-cell tumours by L-asparaginase. British
Journal of Haematology. 130 860-68, 2005. - Obama et al. L-asparaginase-Based Induction
Therapy for Advanced Extranodal NK/T-Cell
Lymphoma. International Journal of Hematology.
78 248-250, 2003. - Yong et al. L-Asparaginase-Based Regmien in the
Treatment of Refractory Midline Nasal/Nasal-Type
T/NK-Cell Lymphoma. International Journal of
Hematology. 78 163-7, 2003. - Kim et al. High-dose chemotherapy with autologous
stem cell transplantation in extranodal NK/T-cell
lymphoma a retrospective comparison with
non-transplantation cases. Bone Marrow
Transplantation. 37 819-824, 2006.
45Resources
- Au et al. Autologous stem cell transplantation
for nasal NK/T-cell lymphoma a progress report
on its value. Annals of Oncology. 14
1673-1676, 2003. - Liang et al. Autologous bone marrow
transplantation for primary nasal T/NK cell
lymphoma. Bone Marrow Transplantation. 19
91-93, 1997 - Murashige et al. Allogeneic haematolpoietic stem
cell transplantation as a promising treatment for
natural killer-cell neoplasms. British Journal
of Haematology. 130 561-567, 2005. - Oshimi, Kazuo. Progress in understanding and
managing natural killer-cell malignancies.
British Journal Haematology. 139 532-554, 2007. - Suzuki, R et al. Aggressive natural killer-cell
leukemia revisited large granular lymphocyte
leukemia of cytotoxic NK cells. Leukemia. 18
763-770, 2004. - Hasserjian, R Harris, N. L.. NK-cell lymphomas
and leukemias A spectrum of tumors with
variable manifestations and immunophenotype. Am
J Clin Pathol. 127 860-868, 2007. - Kwong, Y. L. Natural killer-cell malignancies
diagnosis and treatment. Leukemia. 19
2186-2194, 2005. - Cheung, M. et al. Natural killer cell neoplasms
A distinct group of nighly aggressive
lymphomas/leukemias. Seminars in hematology.
40 221-232, 2003. - Lee et al. Phase I study of proteosome inhibitor
bortezoib plus CHOP I patients with advanced,
aggressive T-cell or K/T-cell lymphomas. Annals
of Oncology. 2008. - Yamaguchi, M et al. Phase I study of
dexamethasone, methotrexate, ifosfamide,
L-asparaginase, and etoposide (SMILE)
chemotherapy for advanced-stage, relpased or
refractory extranodal natural killer (NK)/T-cell
lymphoma and leukemia. Cancer Science. 99
1016-1020, 2008.
46Resources
- Wu, X et al. A clinical study of 115 patients
with extranodal natural killer/T-cell lymphoma,
nasal type. Clinical Oncology. 20 619-625,
2008. - Suzuki, R et al. Hematopoietic stem cell
transplantation for natural killer-cell lineage
neoplasms. Bone Marrow Transplantation. 37
425-431, 2006. - Lee, K-W et al. First-line ifosfamide,
methotrexate, etoposide, and prednisolone
chemotherapy XRT is active in stage I/II
extranodal NK/T-cell lymphoma. Leukemia and
lymphoma. 47 1274-1282, 2006. - Lee, J. et al. Extranodal natural killer T-cell
lyphoma, nasal-type a prognostic model from a
retrospective multicenter study. Journal of
Clinical Oncology. 24 612-618, 2006. - Yong, W. et al. Midline NK/T-cell lymphoma
nasal-type treatment outcome, the effect of
L-asparaginase based regimen, and prognostic
factors. Hematological Oncology. 24 28-32,
2005. - Obama, K. et al. L-asparaginase-based induction
therapy for advanced extranodal NK/T-cell
lymphoma. International Journal of Hematology.
2003. - Jaccard, A. et al. L-asparaginase-based
treatment of 15 western patients with extranodal
NK/T-cell lymphoma and leukemia and a review of
the literature. Annals of Oncology. 2008. - Ando, M. et al. Selective apoptosis of natural
killer-cell tumours by L-asparaginase. British
Journal of Haematology. 130 860-868, 2005. - A special thanks to Pooja Paranjpe