Title: Evidence-Based Approach to Hospital Preparedness
1Evidence-Based Approach to Hospital Preparedness
- Robert Powers RN, BSN, EMT-P
- Emergency Preparedness Coordinator
- WakeMed Health and Hospitals
- Raleigh, NC
2Objectives
- Describe the impact disasters can create in a
community and on a healthcare system - Discuss research findings from recent disasters
- Identify overall lessons learned from past
disaster events and their specific application to
hospital planning
3Evidence-Based Medicine
- The Center for Evidence-Based Medicine explains
that EBM is the conscientious, explicit, and
judicious use of current best evidence in making
decisions about the care of individual patients. - It relies on research findings to support
treatment methods -
www.cebm.net/glossary.asp
4Disaster Research
- Application of available disaster research to
clinical treatment - Strongest EBM method is the randomized,
double-blind, placebo-controlled trial - Look to guidance from clinical reports of
disaster events and apply it to our disaster
planning
5Applied EBM
- Rather than purely using opinions, we want the
research incorporated into expert opinions - Either validating or revealing possible errors in
those opinions
6Application Difficulties
- No standard terminology
- No standard method of collection
- Records lost or incomplete
- Gaps in research
- Retrospective in nature
7Disaster Planning Issues
- Contamination/Exposure issues
- Chemical
- Emerging Infectious Diseases
- Surge
- Immediate impact
- Gradual impact
- Communication
- Evacuation
8Contamination-Tokyo Subway
- 0755- Attack occurs
- 0816- Notification of a gas explosion
- 0828- First patients arrives at St.Lukes
- 0900-TMFD identifies chemical as acetonitrile
- 0940- University MD calls advises to suspect
sarin - 0940- Found low cholinesterase levels
- Started using 2-PAM
- 1100- Police analysis identifies chemical as
sarin. Hospital learns this from TV news. -
Okumura AEM 1998
9Contamination-Tokyo Subway
- St Lukes Hospital
- In chapel, 45.8 workers there developed
signs/symptoms of exposure (38/83) - In ICU, 38.7 workers (12/31)
- 23 of 472 reporting staff members developed
signs/symptoms of exposure - 1 nurse admitted (with nausea/headache)
- 135 EMS workers out of 1364 developed acute
symptoms (9.9) -
Okumura AEM 1998
10Contamination-Tokyo Subway
- Keio University Hospital
- 40 minutes in resuscitation room
- 11 of 15 MDs symptomatic
- Dim vision, rhinorrhea
-
-
Nozaki ICM 1995
11Contamination-SARS
- Toronto-
- During first wave, 73 of those contracting SARS
were healthcare workers (51) - During second wave, 29 were healthcare workers
(39) - Taiwan-
- 33 cases were healthcare workers
-
MMWR Taiwan 2003 -
www.sars.ca
12Contamination-U.S.
- ATSDR Hazardous Substances Emergency Events
Surveillance (HSEES) - Study of US events from 16 reporting states
- When hospital decon was needed
- 10 events with 52 patients total in rural
settings - 82 events with 889 patients total in urban
settings -
Berkowitz PDM 2004
13Contamination-U.S.
- Urban events
- 377 patients from public
- 170 patients were first responders
- 342 patients were healthcare workers
-
Berkowitz PDM 2004
14Contamination-U.S.
- Rural events
- 11 patients from public
- 29 patients were first responders
- 12 patients were healthcare workers
- Berkowitz PDM 2004
15Contamination-U.S.
- HCWs
- 23 rural
- 38 urban
- First responders
- 56 rural
- 19 urban
-
Berkowitz PDM 2004
16Contamination-HCWs
17Contamination-Hospital Planning
- Whether the event is small or large, the hospital
stands to have a quarter of its ED staff exposed. - Not only is the hospital now operating with
decreased staffing numbers, but the staff have
become patients and increased the patient load
18Contamination-Hospital Planning
- Staff education on procedures for dealing with
potentially contaminated patients - Proper removal of patient to decon area
- Proper PPE education for staff
- Proper assessment of patient in need of isolation
or decontamination
19Contamination-Hospital Planning
- Staff must have rapid access to decontamination
equipment - Decontamination must be able to occur rapidly
(Scaleable)
20Contamination-Hospital Planning
- Staff must have rapid access to the PPE they need
- Staff must have adequate amounts of PPE
- The Japanese government budgeted for 4 PPE suits
per hospital after the Tokyo Subway event - Lack of N95 compliance in Toronto
21Contamination-Hospital Planning
- Staff must be aware of on-going events worldwide
and aware of any changes that need to take place
at triage - Toronto-SARS
- Medical staff were originally unaware of events
taking place in Hong Kong and China - Lack of health alerts concerning SARS
- Didnt know to ask pertinent questions at triage,
e.g. travel history
22Contamination-Hospital Planning
- Staff education on WMD signs and symptoms
- Cant wait on lab results or reports from the
scene - Staff should not feel any repercussions for
jumping the gun when there are suspicions of
contamination
23Surge
- Immediate impact on hospitals
- Explosive and Chemical events
- Gradual impact on hospitals
- Infectious disease events
24Surge
- Istanbul bombing
- Single hospital study TERSH hospital
- 418 patients total/16 hospitals
- 184 patients in first hour at TERSH
- 88 (48) by EMS
- 28 (15) admitted
- 18 (10) to OR
- 7 (4) critically injured
-
Rodoplu PDM 2004
25Surge-Oklahoma City Bombing
- Study of 13 hospitals
- 388 total patients
- 48 were pediatric patients
- First patients arrived within 15 minutes
- Peak at 60-90 minutes
- Within 3 hours, 227 patients at hospitals
- 33 arrived by EMS
-
Mallonee JAMA
1996 -
Hogan AEM 1999
26Surge-Oklahoma City Bombing
- Median ED stay was 55 minutes
- 63.6 patients went to 5 major hospitals within
1.5 miles of the explosion site - 72 (18.6) admitted
- 158 were seen by a private MD
-
Mallonee JAMA 1996 -
Hogan
AEM 1999
27Surge-London Bombing
- Study of Royal London Hospital
- Approx. 700 patients total event
- 194 total patients at Royal London
- First patient 120 minutes after first blast
- 90 mins later peaked with 95 patients
- Over in 2 hours
- 27 admits
- 8 ICU admissions
-
Mohammed PDM 2006
28Surge- NYC 9/11
- St Vincents Hospital
- First patient 114 minutes after first plane
- Around 300 patients in first 2 hours
- NYU Downtown Hospital
- 350 patients in first 2 hours
- 448 patients total for first day
- 24 admitted
- 12 ICU patients
- 5 to OR
-
Kirschenbaum CCM 2005 -
Cushman J Trauma 2003
29Surge-Egyptian Border Bombing
- Yoseftal Hospital
- First patient arrived in 32 minutes
- 168 patients total
- 50 in first 2 hours peaks in 2 hours
- 2 admissions
- 1 to OR
- 23 evacuated to trauma center
-
Leiba PDM 2004
30Surge-Tsunami
- Patong Hospital Thailand
- Around 700 patients in first 2 hours
- 59 patients over next 22 hours
- 1.4 admission rate
- 5.1 evacuated to secondary hospital
-
Leiba PDM 2006
31Surge-Tokyo Subway
- 5500 patients went to 280 medical facilities
- 1046 admitted to 98 hospitals
- 20 admitted to ICUs
- 688 transported through EMS coordination
- 452 via ambulance
- 236 via minivans
- 25 of patients transported by taxi
- 2 of 3 cardiac arrests arrived via private
vehicle -
Okumura AEM 1998 -
Pangi BCSIA 2002
32Surge-Tokyo subway
- St Lukes Hospital
- Closest hospital to half of the affected subway
stations and the most heavily impacted hospital - 0755 Attack occurs
- 0816 Notice of a gas explosion
- 0828 First patient arrives
- On foot
- Has visual complaints
- 0840 First ambulance arrives
- 0843 First cardiac arrest arrives by pov
-
Okumura AEM 1998
33Surge-Tokyo Subway
- St Lukes Hospital
- 641 total patients first 24 hours
- 500 patients in the first 90 minutes
- 107 with moderate symptoms admitted
- 4 ICU admits
-
Okumura AEM 1998
34Surge
35Surge-Admissions
36Surge-ICU
37Surge Planning
- Variance in first patient arrival time
- 15-90 minutes after event
- May or may not have time to begin set-up before
patients arrive - May or may not have notification of an event
- Some of this time is spent determining there has
been an event - London bombings 17 minutes before notified of a
suspected event and another 19 minutes before a
major incident declared - This time while events are sorted out decreases
chance of early notification by public safety
38Surge Planning
- 50 to 70 of patients arrive via other methods
than EMS - The critical patients are not able to self-direct
themselves to area hospitals so tend to be the
ones EMS transports - Ones self-referring tend to be the ambulatory,
walking wounded - EMS needs to plan for measures that can rapidly
gather and transport these walking wounded
patients to farther hospitals
39Surge Planning
- Supplies should be in place and ready to go for
initial impact - Close storage
- No vendors necessary to bring supplies
- Disaster plan should be able to be implemented
immediately - Existing staff is well-versed and able to
implement disaster plan
40Surge
- Triage should be aimed at rapidly sorting these
patients and relocating them to MTA away from the
ED - Rapid triage system
- Keep it simple
- Initially surge manpower into extra triage
stations to rapidly process incoming walking
wounded
41Surge Planning
- MTA area
- Rapid set-up
- Staff from areas outside ED
- Large setting
42Surge Planning
- Temporary Surge Admission Area or Holding Area
- Hold these patients during peak period
- Prioritize resources for incoming ICU or OR
patients during peak period
43Surge-Treatment
- Advanced Airway Procedures
- 2 bus bombings
- 52 patients
- 42 intubated
- 2 open-air bombings
- 190 patients
- 7 intubated
- Oklahoma City
- 388 patients
- 2 intubated
- 1 surgical airway
- Hogan AEM
1999/Halpern PDM 2003
44Surge-Intubations
45Surge Planning-Respiratory
- Respiratory Therapy should be incorporated into
the plan - ED MDs and Anesthesia have other roles
- Surge airway supplies should be rapidly available
46Hospital Services- Radiography
- Oklahoma City bombing
- 45 of 265 patients
- Manchester
- 50 of 208 patients
- Bologna bombing
- 43 of 107 patients
-
-
Halpern PDM 2003
47Hospital Services
- Oklahoma City bombing
- 19 of patients had CT Scan
- Chi-Chi Earthquake- Taiwan
- 30 of 95 patients with crush syndrome needed
hemodialysis -
Hogan AEM 1999 -
Chan PDM
2006
48Hospital Services Planning
- Almost half of patients from an explosive or
collapse event will need x-ray - Services such as CT, dialysis and the lab will be
impacted - These departments need to be involved in hospital
disaster planning
49Hospital Services Planning
- Utilize portable x-ray machines
- Plan for a prioritization of all these services
beforehand
50Surge-Field Teams
- Deployment of personnel from hospital to the
scene - Tokyo
- NYC
- London
51Surge-Field Teams
- Tokyo- St Lukes Hospital
- Sent 8 MDs, 3 nurses
- No emergency procedures performed
- London
- Sent MD teams to various scenes
- Arrived 30-40 minutes after bombing
- Only Grade-I Trauma Center in London
- Patients arriving at hospital 20 minutes after
bombing -
Okumura AEM 1998 -
Mohammed PDM
2006
52Surge-Field Teams
- NYC
- Chelseas Pier Triage Area
- Group of MDs from NYU Downtown Hospital
- No critical patients
- Bellevue had MD teams at WTC site
- No critical patients
- Minor cuts and bruises
-
Cushman J Trauma 2003
53Surge-Field Teams
- Limited value
- Late arrival/Leaving nearby hospitals
- Utilize hospitals farther away if extended scenes
- Have a developed plan not ad hoc
54Surge-Crowds
- Large number of non-patients at hospital
- Seeking shelter and food
- Seeking information about family members
- Plan must address these arrivals
55Surge-Gradual Impact
- SARS
- Toronto
- Hong Kong
- Taiwan
56Surge-Toronto
- Toronto- Scarborough Grace Hospital
- 3/7/03 Mr. T patient seen in ED 2 other patients
exposed (16 hours in ED in Obs bed) - 3/16 Mrs. M at ED 7 visitors and 1 patient
exposed - 3/17 Mr. M intubated in ICU 3 nurses and 1 MD
exposed - 3/21-4/1 Average 8-10 staff members sick a day
- 3/26 Hospital closed due to staffing shortages
- 6/5 ED re-opened
-
-
www.sars.ca
57Surge-Toronto
- Toronto
- 3/23 Re-commissioned TB hospital with 25
isolation beds - 3/26 Opened first SARS assessment center
-
-
www.sars.ca
58Surge-Toronto
- Canadas HSC
- Study noted patient volume decreased during SARS
outbreak - 133 baseline patient visits per day
- Broke down SARS into 3 periods and found patient
volume down an average of 36 patients per day
(27) -
Boutis CMAJ 2004 -
59Surge-Toronto
- SARS I (3/7-4/19)
- 144 SARS cases
- 128 suspected
- 247 total admissions
- 29 of 144 admitted to ICU (20)
- 20 of those 29 received ventilators (14 overall)
- SARS II (5/23-6/4)
- 74 SARS cases
-
www.sars.ca -
Booth
JAMA 2003
60Surge-Toronto
- 375 total cases March-June 2003
- Southern Ontario population 11 million
- 10-20,000 quarantined in Ontario
- Surviving patients 74 discharged by Day 14
- Median stay 10 days
- Peak of 8 probable cases per day
-
Booth JAMA 2003
61Surge-Hong Kong
- Feb-June 2003
- 1755 probable SARS cases
- Hong Kong area population 110 million
-
Lau EID 2004
62Surge-Hong Kong
- 138 SARS patients at Prince of Wales Hospital
during period of outbreak from March 11-25 - 32 admitted to ICU (23)
- 19 on ventilators (14)
- Median stay 22.1 days
- Median stay for intubated patients 26.8 days
-
www.sarsreference.com -
Lee NEJM
2003
63Surge-Taiwan
- March-July
- 668 total SARS admissions
- Peak approx. 15-25 probable cases per day during
period 4/20-5/25 - 22 million population
-
McDonald EID 2004
64Surge-Taiwan
- National Taiwan University Hospital
- 270 SARS patients
- Maximum admits in 24 hours was 12
- Overall bed occupancy decreased 48
- ED visits decreased 37
-
Chen EID 2004
65Surge-Taiwan
- National Taiwan University Hospital
- SARS screening unit established
- 3/15-4/22 median 6 patients screened a day
- 4/23-5/12 median 36 patients screened a day
- 4/23-5/12 754 patient screened with 63 admitted
-
-
Chen EID 2004
66Surge-Taiwan
- China Medical University Hospital, Taiwan
- ED visits 33.4 lower during outbreak
- 15 hospitals in Taiwan studied
- Overall bed occupancy decreased 20
-
Chen BMC 2006 -
Chen Med Care
2005
67Surge Planning
- Fever clinics
- Kept hospitals functioning by screening prior to
entrance - Assessed patients while minimizing transmission
potential - Prevented ED overcrowding
- At hospitals or coordinated with public health
- Construct or retrofit
68Surge Planning
- N95
- Canada hospitals non-compliant
- North York Hospital 2-day supply
- 4/2/03 Staff were required to wear N95 at all
times while at work - Taiwan issues with private company and individual
hording of masks - Hospitals should increase par levels, lessen
dependence on outside vendors
69Surge Planning
- Gradual increase of patients
- Involves regional planning
- Canada stopped hospital transfers from taking
place at certain hospitals
70Surge Planning
- Plan on surging in place or regional planning to
identify a location - Identify an area
- Supplies
- Staffing
- Incorporation into planning and drills
71Surge-ED visits
72Surge-Hospital Occupancy
73Surge Planning
- Shortages of ED and ICU staff
- Decrease in other admissions can help in finding
additional staff and supplies - Plan to close general non-isolation beds and
re-assign staff to newly created surge isolation
co-horts
74Communications
- Istanbul bombings
- Complete city phone and cell phone system failure
- Tulane Hospital- Katrina
- Complete failure to communicate caused an
inability to implement their disaster plan -
-
Gray Urban 2006 -
Rodoplu
PDM 2006
75Communications
- London bombings
- Mobile networks failed
- In-coming calls blocked phone lines
- Pager system went offline
- St Lukes Hospital- Tokyo Subway
- Communications were jammed
- Yelling down halls to communicate
-
Mohammed PDM 2006 -
Okumura AEM 1998 -
76Communications
- Tokyo EMS
- Couldnt communicate with hospitals as a result,
couldnt get permission to intubate - Couldnt acquire hospital availability
information - Forced to attempt communication through public
telephone lines -
Okumura AEM
1998
77Communications
- St. Vincents Hospital- NYC 9/11
- No public telephone services
- No cell phone services
-
Kirschenbaum CCM 2005 -
78Communications Planning
- Hospitals have an over reliance on communication
systems and computer-based systems - Relatively small events, e.g. bombings, are going
to cause a failure in the local communication
system
79Communications Planning
- Large scale events are going to disrupt the
infrastructure that supports both civilian and
medically-utilized communication systems - Emergency dispatchers will be overwhelmed with
incoming calls - Surviving hospital communication systems will be
overwhelmed with incoming calls from the
community
80Communications Planning
- Must have basic back-up plans in place
- 2-way radios not reliant on outside systems
- Runners
- Disaster plans that can be implemented without
the requirement of extensive communication
81Communications Planning
- Plans for EMS that are not dependent on
communication to implement - standing orders for MCIs
- regional transportation pre-plan in place for
MCIs
82Hospital Evacuation
- Northridge Earthquake
- 6 hospitals evacuated within 24 hours of
earthquake - 5 of which had non-structural damage only (water
damage and loss of power) - 1 with suspected structural damage evacuated
emergently clearing ambulatory patients first - Hospital evacuated via stairs
- Flashlights, manual ventilations
- Carried patients with blankets, backboards and
mattresses - Schultz NEJM 2003
83Hospital Evacuation- Katrina
- Charity/Tulane
- Hospitals evacuated ambulatory/stable patients
ahead of the storm - Generators in basement flooded at Charity
- Power loss, flooding, loss of communications
- Individual hospitals working out their own
evacuation processes -
Gray Urban 2006
84Hospital Evacuation
- Tulane evacuation 4 day process
- ICU patients evacuated first
- Patients carried to garage then to roof landing
pad by truck - Spinal boards needed for patient movement had to
be brought up from storage in Baton Rouge - 2 patients with 500 lb heart pumps
- 2 bariatric patients each over 600 lbs.
-
Gray Urban 2006
85Hospital Evacuation
- Houston
- Flooding in basement caused failure of electrical
switchgear to emergency generators - Over 31 hours
- 169 patients discharged
- 406 transferred by ground and air
- Backboards utilized for pt movement 5 neonates
strapped to one board -
-
www.semp.us
86Hospital Evacuation Planning
- Hundreds of people seeking shelter
- Evacuating critical first or last
- Planning must be regional and involve local EM
- Accessibility of needed supplies
- Plans for refueling generators
87References
- Berkowitz Z, Horton DK, Kaye WE. Hazardous
substances releases causing fatalities and/or
people transported to hospitals
Rural/agricultural vs. other areas. Prehosp
Disast Med 200419(3)213220. - Booth C, et al. Clinical Features and Short-term
Outcomes of 144 Patients with SARS in the Greater
Toronto Area. JAMA 4 June 2003 289(21)
2801-2809. - Boutis K, Stephens D, Lam K, Ungar W, and Schuh
S. The impact of SARS on a tertiary care
pediatric emergency department. CMAJ 2004 171
(11)1353-8. - Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine.
www.cebm.net/glossary.asp - Chan YF, Alagappan K, Gandhi A, Donovan C, Tewari
M, Zaets SB Disaster management following the
Chi-Chi Earthquake in Taiwan. Prehosp Disast Med
200621(3)196202. - Chen W, Cheng Y, Chung Y, Lin C. The Impact of
the SARS Outbreak on an Urban Emergency
Department in Taiwan. Medical Care Feb. 2005
43(2)168-172. - Chen, Yee-Chun et al. SARS in Hospital Emergency
Room. Emerging Infectious Diseases May 2004
10(5) 782-788.
88References
- Chen YC, Chen MF, Liu SZ, Romeis J, and Lee YT.
SARS in Teaching Hospital, Taiwan. Emerging
Infectious Diseases Oct. 2004 10 (10)
1886-1887. - Cushman James, Pachter H, and Beaton H. Two New
York City Hospitals Surgical Response to the
September 11, 2001 Terrorist Attack in New York
City. Journal of Trauma. Jan. 2003
54(1)147-155. - Gray, Bradford and Hebert, Kathy. Hospitals in
Hurricane Katrina Challenges Facing Custodial
Institutions in a Disaster. The Urban Institute.
2006. http//www.urban.org/publications/411348.htm
l - Halpern P, Ming-Che T, Arnold J, Stok E and Ersoy
G. Mass-Casualty, Terrorist Bombings
Implications for Emergency Department and
Hospital Emergency Response (Part II).
Prehospital and Disaster Medicine. 2003 18 (3)
235-241. - Hogan D, Waeckerie J, Dire D and Lillibridge S.
Emergency Department Impact of the Oklahoma City
Terrorist Bombing. Annals of Emergency Medicine.
August 1999 34 (2) 160-167. - Kirschenbaum L, Keene A, ONeill P, Westfal R,
and Astiz M. The experience at St.Vincents
Hospital, Manhattan, on September 11, 2001
Preparedness, response, and lessons learned.
Critical Care Medicine 200533(1) Supplment. - Lau J, Tsui H, Lau M, and Yang X. SARS
Transmission, Risk Factors, and Prevention in
Hong Kong. Emerging Infectious Diseases. April
2004 10(4)587-592.
89References
- Lee, Nelson et al. A Major Outbreak of Severe
Acute Respiratory Syndrome in Hong Kong. New
England Journal of Medicine. 15 May 2003
348(20)1986-1994. - Leiba A, Blumenfeld A, Hourvitz A,Weiss G, Peres
M, Laor D, Schwartz D, Arad J, Goldberg A, Levi
Y, Bar-Dayan Y Lessons learned from cross
border medical response to the terrorist bombings
in Tabba and Ras-el-Satan, Egypt on 07 October
2004. Prehosp Disast Med 200520(4)253257. - Leiba A, Ashkenasi I,Nakash G, Pelts R, Schwartz
D, Goldberg A, Levi Y, Bar-Dayan Y. Response of
Thai hospitals to the Tsunami disaster. Prehosp
Disast Med 200621(1)s32s37. - Mallonee S, Shariat, S, Stennies G, Waxweiler R,
Hogan D, and Jordan F. Physical Injuries and
Fatalities Resulting from the Oklahoma City
Bombing. Journal of the American Medical
Assocation.August 1996 276 (5) 382-387. - McDonald LC et al. SARS in Healthcare
Facilities, Toronto and Taiwan. Emerging
Infectious Diseases May 2004 10(5)777-781. - Mohammed AB, Mann HA,Nawabi DH,Goodier DW, Ang
SC Impact of Londons terrorist attacks on a
major trauma center in London. Prehosp Disast
Med 200621(5)340344. - Okumura T, Suzuki K, Fukuda A, Kohama A, Takasu
N, Ishimatsu S, and Hinohara S. The Tokyo Subway
Sarin AttackDisaster Management. Academic
Emergency Medicine June 1998 Vol 5 (6) pp.
613-628
90References
- Nozaki H et al. Secondary Exposure of Medical
Staff to Sarin Vapor in the Emergency Room.
Intensive Medical Care. December 1995 Vol 21 (12)
pp. 1032-1035 - Pangi, Robyn. Consequence Management in the 1995
Sarin Attacks on the Japanese Subway
System.BCSIA Discussion Paper ESDP-2002-01, John
F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard
University, February 2002. - Rodoplu U, Arnold JL, Tokyay R, et al
Mass-casualty terrorist bombings in
Istanbul,Turkey, November 2003 Report of the
events and the prehospital emergency response.
Prehosp Disast Med 2004(19)2133145. - The SARS Commission. Spring of Fear.
http//www.sars.ca - SARS Timeline. http//www.sarsreference.com/sarsre
f/timeline.htm - Schultz, Carl H, Koenig K, and Lewis R.
Implications of Hospital Evacuation after the
Northridge, California, Eathquake. NEJM 3 April
2003 348(14)1349-1355. - http//www.semp.us/biots/biot_216.html Lessons
Learned from a Hospital Evacuation during
Tropical Storm Allison. May 21,2005