ASON Routing Solutions Design Team status

1
ASON Routing Solutions Design Team status

• draft-dimitri-ccamp-gmpls-ason-routing-eval-00.txt
  
• John Drake ltjdrake_at_calient.netgt
• Chris Hopps ltchopps_at_procket.comgt
• Lyndon Ong ltlyong_at_ciena.comgt
• Dimitri Papadimitriou (DTL) ltdimitri.papadimitriou
  _at_alcatel.begt
• Jonathan Sadler ltjonathan.sadler_at_tellabs.comgt
• Stephen Shew ltsdshew_at_nortelnetworks.comgt
• Dave Ward ltdward_at_cisco.comgt

2
Evaluation Item - Objective

• Evaluate existing routing protocols against the
  ASON routing requirements documented in
  ltdraft-ietf-ccamp-gmpls-ason-routing-reqtsgt as a
  joint effort of the CCAMP WG and ITU-T SG15
• Evaluation by close examination of applicability
  scenarios (to be elaborated)
• The result of the evaluation of these scenarios
  is an integral part of the output of the design
  team

3
Evaluation Item - Status

• A first cut has been produced (available at
  http//www.olddog.co.uk/draft-dimitri-ccamp-gmpls-
  ason-routing-eval-00.txt
• Includes a ToC of requirements to be evaluated as
  DT outcome
• No scenarios available yet (need to be produced)
  input from user community ?
• August04 first CCAMP WG document of Evaluation
  of existing IETF routing protocols against ASON
  routing requirements including evaluation
  scenarios

4
Next Steps

• Once produced evaluation document will be liaised
  to SG15/OIF to solicit input
• Then enter into protocol work
• to be developed with full consultation with the
  "owning" working group since DT is expected to
  interact with other IETF WGs as appropriate
• gt protocol must be presented to and discussed
  with the owning working group which must be given
  the opportunity to comment and suggest alternate
  solutions

5
For the record
6
ASON RS DT - Charter

• Evaluate existing routing protocols against the
  ASON routing requirements that were documented in
  ltdraft-ietf-ccamp-gmpls-ason-routing-reqtsgt as a
  joint effort of the IETF CCAMP Working Group and
  ITU-T SG15
• Evaluation to be produced by a close examination
  of applicability scenarios. The result of the
  evaluation of these scenarios is an integral part
  of the output of this design team
• The design team will then move on to the design
  of extensions to the IETF routing protocols as
  appropriate in close collaboration with the
  corresponding Working Groups (such as the OSPF,
  IS-IS and IDR WGs)
• Consideration should also be given to the
  exclusion of protocol
• elements or procedures that are not appropriate
  or relevant in
• the ASON routing scenarios that the team
  describes.
• Finally, the design team is responsible for
  drafting liaison
• statements from the CCAMP WG to the ITU-T SG15
  and OIF regarding
• GMPLS ASON routing solutions, as well as for
  drafting replies to
• liaisons received from the ITU-T SG15 and OIF.
  Note that no Liaisons
• drafted by the design team will be sent or
  replied to without
• approval from the CCAMP WG chairs, ADs and rough
  consensus of the
• CCAMP WG.
• Standard design team disclaimer this design team
  has no special
• status in the CCAMP WG. Any documents they
  produce are subject to
• the usual WG procedures. Individuals are
  encouraged to interact

7
ASON RS DT - Charter

• Responsible for drafting liaison statements from
  the CCAMP WG to the ITU-T SG15 and OIF regarding
  GMPLS ASON routing solutions, as well as for
  drafting replies to liaisons received from the
  ITU-T SG15 and OIF
• Note that no Liaisons drafted by the design team
  will be sent or replied to without approval from
  the CCAMP WG chairs, ADs and rough consensus of
  the WG
• Subject to the Standard design team disclaimer

8
ASON RS DT - Timeline

• June04 send Liaison to ITU-T SG15 and OIF
• July04 first draft of "Evaluation of existing
  IETF routing protocols against ASON routing
  requirements including evaluation scenarios"
• August04 first CCAMP WG document of "Evaluation
  of existing IETF routing protocols against ASON
  routing requirements including evaluation
  scenarios"
• August04 send Liaison to ITU-T SG15 and OIF
  soliciting input on above WG document
• September04 first drafts of protocol-specific
  "Protocol extensions and usage procedures for
  ASON"
• October04 first CCAMP WG protocol-specific
  documents on "Protocol extensions and usage
  procedures for ASON"
• October04 send Liaison to ITU-T SG15 and OIF
  soliciting input
• December04 CCAMP WG Last Call (incl. Routing WG
  Last Call)
• Janvier05 hand off documents to IESG

9
ASON RS DT - Interactions

• The DT is expected to interact with other IETF
  working groups as appropriate. Protocol
  extensions are not to be developed without full
  consultation with the "owning" working group
• Therefore, while protocol extensions are
  developed within CCAMP, they must be presented to
  and discussed with the owning working group which
  must be given the opportunity to comment and
  suggest alternate solutions.
• This may include the IS-IS, OSPF and IDR working
  groups

10
ASON RS DT - Members

• Members (alphabetical order)
• John Drake ltjdrake_at_calient.netgt
• Chris Hopps ltchopps_at_procket.comgt
• Lyndon Ong ltLyOng_at_ciena.comgt
• Dimitri Papadimitriou (DTL) ltDimitri.Papadimitriou
  _at_alcatel.begt
• Jonathan Sadler ltjonathan.sadler_at_tellabs.comgt
• Stephen Shew ltsdshew_at_nortelnetworks.comgt
• Dave Ward ltdward_at_cisco.comgt