Preliminary analysis of presentations

1
Preliminary analysis of presentations

• Arve Meisingset
• Telenor RD

2
Comments
Categorisations of ASN.1, TTCN and UML are missing
3
Open Distributed Processing
SDL
MSC
URN
Core?
SDL
SDL
Core
eODL
Core
MSC
URN(UCM)
?
Some?
4
Phases
URN
Some
URN
MSC
Core
eODL?
MSC
SDL
URN?
Core
eODL?
SDL
MSC
eODL
Core
MSC
SDL
Core
SDL
URN
MSC
Core
URN
Some
Some
eODL?
5
Scale of granularity
?
Core
?
MSC
eODL
URN
Core?
eODL
SDL
MSC
Some?
SDL
MSC
6
Media
Some?
SDL?
Some
 MSC?
Some
Some?
Some
 MSC
SDL
 MSC
eODL
Core
7
Application areas and Usages
eODL
eODL
Core?
eODL
Core
 MSC
URN
SDL
?
SDL
 MSC
URN
Core
eODL
Some?
eODL
?
8
Language categories
eODL
Core
SDL
MSC
URN
Core
?
MSC
Some?
?
Core?
9
Structures and Implementations
eODL
Core?
SDL
URN
eODL
SDL
Core
MSC
URN(UCM)
SDL
MSC
Some?
eODL
URN
MSC
Core
SDL
10
Schema types
eODL
Core
SDL
Some
eODL
Core?
eODL?
SDL?
eODL
11
Levels and constraints
eODL
Core
SDL
eODL
SDL
Core
eODL
12
Usage granularity
eODL
URN
SDL
MSC
eODL?
SDL
URN
MSC
MSC
URN
SDL

URN
SDL
URN
MSC
13
Usages Closeness, intention,scenario and
collaboration
eODL
SDL
?
?
Core
Core?
MSC?
URN(GRL)
Core
eODL?
SDL
MSC
URN
Core
?
SDL
URN(UCM)
MSC
Core
?
?
14
Summary
Need more responses and validation. Some need
for coordination of languages both use and
mappings. The languages do not have focus on
- technology - end user perspectives and
use - management - data and media All the four
points are essential to Telecom Operators. These
conclusions may not be surprising. The Tile
architecture seems to serve the role as an
analysis tool, but needs better definitions and
requirements, as concluded in the first workshop