Title: Western UGPR OATTRATE REVISION PROCESS
1Western UGPROATT/RATE REVISION PROCESS
- ADVANCED NOTICE MEETING
- (Introduction)
- Lloyd A. Linke
- Operations Manager
- Upper Great Plains Region
- Western Area Power Administration
- June 10, 2008
- Sioux Falls, South Dakota
2Today's Meeting
- No formal proposals at this time
- Inform parties of what we plan to do later this
year - The Tariff and Rates are two separate processes
and we will have two presentations today - Tariff
- Rates
- Proposing a separate Western Tariff for the Upper
Great Plains Region to incorporate Market
Integration Transmission Service (MITS)
3Western UGPROATT REVISION PROCESS
- ADVANCED NOTICE MEETING
- Presented by
- Steve Sanders
- Operations and Transmission Advisor
- Upper Great Plains Region
- Western Area Power Administration
- June 10, 2008
- Sioux Falls, South Dakota
4Agenda
- Meeting Objectives
- Background
- Midwest ISO (MISO) Module F Background
- Transmission Issues
- Proposed Development of Separate UGPR Open Access
Transmission Tariff (OATT) - Potential OATT Timeline
- Questions Comments
5Meeting Objectives
- Informal meeting with UGPRs Transmission
Customers and other Interested Parties - Provide initial information regarding the
proposed development of separate OATT for UGPR to
accommodate participation by Westerns UGPR in
the Midwest ISO (MISO) filed Module F, Part III,
if Western so chooses - Outline next steps
- Solicit initial comments and feedback
6Background
- Current Operations Environment
- MAPP/MISO Seams Operating Agreement (SOA)
provides for coordination of transmission
services and operations between MAPP members and
MISO and other neighboring Transmission Providers - MISO has tendered its termination notice for the
SOA - Congestion Management for Westerns UGPR
east-side region currently occurs under standard
NERC Transmission Loading Relief (TLR) - MISO currently provides Reliability Coordination
(RC) services to UGPR under a bilateral agreement
7Background
- UGPR Concerns With Current Operations Environment
- UGPRs Merchant and other MAPP members have found
it increasingly difficult to get transmission
service - UGPRs Merchant and other MAPP members have
encountered an increasing number of TLR
curtailments of transactions - The non-Market neighbors of UGPR are shrinking
making it more difficult for UGPRs Merchant to
obtain necessary power supply during UGPRs
current drought conditions - It is difficult for non-Market entities to
maintain power purchases from MISO during TLR
8Background
- Westerns UGPR is Evaluating Participation in the
MISO Market - UGPRs Merchant is currently evaluating a
proposal by MISO to allow participation in the
MISO Markets for entities outside their
Transmission Tariff footprint as an option to
address some of the current operating concerns - The Merchants evaluation is being done via a
separate informal public process - Details at the following URL www.wapa.gov/ugp/Pow
erMarketing/MISOSeams/Default.htm
9Background
- Westerns UGPR is Evaluating Various Potential
Options - UGPRs Merchant has noted it is evaluating the
following Alternatives identified to date - MISO Part II - Interconnected Operations and
Congestion Management Service - MISO Part III - Market Coordination Service
- Other - such as joining the Southwest
- Power Pool (SPP).
- UGPRs Transmission is evaluating replacement
options for SOAs with neighboring Transmission
Providers (TPs)
10MISO Module F Background
- MISO Western Markets Proposal (Module F)
- MISOs Western Markets Proposal was filed with
FERC on 3/4/08 as a proposed addition to the MISO
Tariff (Module F). Links to MISOs postings are
available on UGPRs OASIS (MISO Seams Proposals
Folder) at URL www.oatioasis.com/wapa/index.html - MISO has indicated that non-RTO entities wanting
to have a Seams Operating Agreement with MISO
will need to sign up under Module F (Part II or
Part III), as the SOA is now imbedded in those
MISO service offerings - Intended to promote MAPP members joining MISOs
Energy and Ancillary Services Markets by not
requiring entities to place their transmission
facilities in MISO to participate in the Markets
11MISO Module F Background
- MISO Module F Three New MISO Service Offerings
- Part I - Reliability Coordination Service
- Part II - Interconnected Operations and
Congestion Management Service - Part III - Market Coordination Service
12MISO Module F Background
- Part I MISO Reliability Coordination Service
- Basically almost identical replacement of the
existing MAPP/MISO Bilateral Agreement for RC
Services - Included in Module F because MISO requires Part I
service to be taken if an entity wants Part III
service
13MISO Module F Background
- Part II - MISO Interconnected Operations and
Congestion Management Service - Entity taking service is a Congestion Management
Customer (CMC) - Primarily a replacement for the MAPP/MISO Seams
Operating Agreement to address coordination
between the MISO Market and the non-market areas - Includes Reciprocal Coordination of flowgates
- Includes limited Generation Redispatch option
between MISO and CMC to address specific
flowgates where the entities have difficulty
achieving their assigned TLR relief obligations
14MISO Module F Background
- Part III - MISO Market Coordination Service
- Entity taking service is a Market Coordination
Customer (MCC) - Allow participation in the MISO Market for
entities outside the MISO Transmission Tariff
footprint - MCC retains its own OATT, and continues to
provide transmission service on its own
transmission facilities - MCC includes its generation and load into the
MISO Energy and Ancillary Services Markets, and
its generation and load are dispatched by MISO in
the same manner as other generation in Market - MISO assumes Balancing Area (BA) responsibilities
for the MCCs BA
15MISO Module F Background
- Part III - MISO Market Coordination Service
(Contd) - The MCC is eligible to receive Auction Revenue
Rights (ARR) and Financial Transmission Rights
(FTR) and fully participate in the Market - MISO dispatches the MCCs generation on a 5
minute basis, and the energy deliveries between
the MCC and MISO footprints are provided via a
newly proposed Market Integration Transmission
Service (MITS) - The MCC is required to take Part I (Reliability
Coordination Services) from MISO - Part III also includes the Seams Operating
Agreement provisions between MISO and the MCC
16MISO Module F Background
- Market Integration Transmission Service (MITS)
- Designed to accommodate transactions within a
single energy market over separate transmission
footprints - Existing OATT transmission service products will
not accommodate the 5 minute dispatch and
transactions between the MCC and MISO - A new product is needed, that is..
- An Hourly Firm product so MCCs dispatch is Firm
- Charged on After-the-Fact, hourly integrated
basis - Not scheduled nor tagged
- MITS will provide the necessary vehicle for
market flows to/from MISOs transmission system
to the MCCs transmission system. MITS will be
needed in both the MISO and MCC Transmission
Tariffs
17UGPR Transmission Issues
- Transmission Related Impacts if Westerns UGPR
Chooses to Take MISO Part III - Market
Coordination Service - What doesnt change
- UGPR still retains its own OATT, and will
continue to provide transmission service on the
Integrated System (IS) under the UGPR OATT - UGPRs existing transmission service customers
will continue to take UGPR OATT service - Network Customers will still take UGPR Network
Service - UGPR will still evaluate and grant service under
its OATT. For example, for NITS customers, UGPR
will evaluate and grant new Designated Network
Resources (DNRs) based upon UGPR OATT
requirements and procedures
18UGPR Transmission Issues
- Transmission Related Impacts if Westerns UGPR
Chooses to Take MISO Part III - Market
Coordination Service (Contd) - What does change
- ALL generation and load inside the UGPR WAUE BA
will be placed inside the MISO Market unless it
is moved to its own BA - MISO will assume BA responsibility for WAUE
- Ancillary Services (Regulation, Spin and Non-Spin
Operating Reserves) will be provided by the MISO
Ancillary Services Market (ASM) for UGPRs WAUE
BA footprint
19UGPR Transmission Issues
- Transmission Related Impacts if Westerns UGPR
Chooses to Take MISO Part III - Market
Coordination Service (Contd) - UGPRs Tariff will need to change
- UGPRs existing OATT will have to be revised to
include MITS - Many existing tariff provisions of Point-to-Point
(PTP) and Network Integration Transmission
Service (NITS) would need to be revised to be
compatible with the MISO Market operation
requirements - However, Transmission and Ancillary services
tariff provisions in the UGPR WAUW BA will likely
be unchanged west system cannot be included in
the MISO Market as Module F doesnt allow it
20UGPR Transmission Issues
- A revision of the UGPR OATT will be Necessary to
Allow Westerns UGPR to Take MISO Part III -
Market Coordination Service, if it so chooses - UGPRs Transmission is still evaluating whether
any OATT revisions are necessary to allow Western
to take MISO Part II service - UGPRs Transmission has been active in reviewing
the MISO filing, and submitted comments to FERC
on the filing and also in identifying impacts
that will have to be addressed if UGPR chooses to
take MISO Part III service
21Proposed OATT Revision Approach
- Creation of Separate Western UGPR OATT to be
Utilized to Provide Service Over the UGPR/ Basin
Electric/ Heartland Integrated System (IS), based
upon Westerns general OATT - Reasons
- Need to incorporate significant new provisions to
accommodate UGPRs participation as an MCC under
MISOs Module F, Part III - Provide necessary flexibility for UGPR to
implement OATT changes required to maintain
coordination and consistency with MISO Module F
provisions, and the numerous expected MISO FERC
future filings
22Proposed OATT Revision Approach
- Maintain Coordination with Westerns general OATT
- Closely tied to Westerns general OATT terms due
to Westerns statutory and other regulatory
requirements - UGPR will continue to coordinate closely with
other Western Regions regarding OATT changes and
OATT policies and business practices - UGPR OATT will be updated with FERC Order 890
provisions, implemented by Western, at same time
as Westerns general OATT is updated - Other Western required changes will be made to
UGPR OATT coincident with revisions to the
Westerns general OATT
23UGPR OATT Development Overview
- Proposed UGPR OATT Requires Revisions to the
Existing Western General OATT in Three Primary
Areas - Revisions to Westerns general OATT so it applies
only to UGPR - Addition of a new MITS, and revisions to existing
provisions to allow UGPR to utilize MISOs Part
III - Market Coordination Service over the IS
footprint in the east-system - Revisions, as necessary, to Rate Schedules (Rate
changes described in separate presentation)
24UGPR OATT Revisions (Slide 1)
- Expected Revisions Necessary to Convert Westerns
General OATT to a Separate UGPR OATT - Revise OATT Title
- Define Transmission Provider as UGPR
- Remove other Western Region references (e.g.
Attach K) - Remove any non-UGPR Region-specific tariff
provisions - Revise and tailor tariff service agreements and
request submission provisions to apply to UGPR
25UGPR OATT Revisions (Slide 2)
- Additions to accommodate MISOs Part III - Market
Coordination Service - Inclusion of new transmission service called
Market Integration Transmission Service (MITS)
to allow generation and load in the WAUE BA
served under the UGPR OATT to be dispatched in
the MISO Markets
26UGPR OATT Revisions (Slide 3)
- UGPR Proposed Market Integration Transmission
Service (MITS) - UGPR MITS needs to be compatible with the MISO
MITS and address MCCs requirements outlined in
MISOs Module F filing - UGPR Transmission has posted its latest
conceptual MITS Principles and issues list on
its OASIS at URL - www.oatioasis.com/WAPA/WAPAdocs/MITS-Principles-2
007-1126.pdf - (Portions of document to be presented)
- More work is required to finalize the MITS
provisions, comments appreciated
27UGPR OATT Revisions (Slide 4)
- Other OATT Revisions
- MISOs Part III - Market Coordination Service is
NOT compatible with all the existing UGPR OATT
Transmission Service provisions of Part II
(Point-to-Point) and Part III (Network
Integration) for the portion of the IS in the
MISO Market - Changes likely required to
- Restrictions on use of service, Operations of
Network Resources, Redispatch provisions,
Transmission Constraints, Curtailment provisions,
Cost of Redispatch, Losses, etc. - Ancillary Services Schedules 3, 5, and 6 need to
be reviewed
28UGPR OATT Revisions (Slide 5)
- Next Steps
- UGPRs Transmission is developing, in
coordination with its Integrated System
transmission partners, a proposed UGPR OATT,
redlined from Westerns existing general OATT - Redline may be impacted by FERC ordered
modifications to MISOs Module F filing - Existing transmission service tariff provisions
for the west-side system will be maintained - The proposed UGPR OATT and redlined comparison to
Westerns existing general OATT will be made
available for review with the Federal Register
Notice (FRN)
29UGPR OATT Revisions (Slide 6)
- Sources of Information
- Information related to UGPRs OATT revision
process will be posted on UGPRs OASIS under the
Folder named - UGPR 2008 OATT Revision/Rate Adjustment
-
- at the following URL www.oatioasis.com/wapa/inde
x.html
30 Potential OATT Revision TimeLine
31Points of Contact (For Questions)
Lloyd A. Linke Operations Manager Upper Great
Plains Region P.O. Box 790 Watertown, SD
57201-0790 Telephone (605) 882-7500 Email
lloyd_at_wapa.gov Steve Sanders Operations and
Transmission Advisor Upper Great Plains
Region P.O. Box 35800 Billings, MT
59107-5800 Telephone (406) 247-7436 Email
sanders_at_wapa.gov
32Questions
Any Questions or Comments Today?
33Written Comments
- Please send written comments to
- By Email UGPOATT_at_wapa.gov
- By Correspondence
- Steve Sanders
- Operations and Transmission Advisor
- Western Area Power Administration
- Upper Great Plains Region
- P.O. Box 35800
- Billings, MT 59107-5800
34- Thank you for your participation in this process!!