Title: Walgreen Co. (WAG)
1Walgreen Co.(WAG)
- Matthew McDonnell
- Contributions by James Herr
14-September-2006
2Company Overview
- Founded in 1901 by Charles Walgreen
- 1st store in Chicago
- Currently 5,251 stores operating in 45 states and
Puerto Rico - Median store age is approx. 5.4 years old
- 131, 400 employees as of 11/30/2005
- Avg. years of experience for store managers is
12.6 years - Goal is to have 7,000 stores by 2010
3Company Overview
- David Bernauer
- Chairman of the Board since 2003
- Chief Executive Officer since 2002
- President and Chief Operating Officer from
1999-2003 - Has been with Walgreens since 1966
- Jeffrey Rein
- President and Chief Operating Officer since 2003
- Has been with Walgreens since 1974
- George Eilers replaced by Kevin Walgreen,
great-grandson of Charles Walgreen, as Senior VP
of Store Operations (Southern Region) in early
2006 due to Mr. Eilers retirement - Eilers had been with Walgreens for 46 years
- Kevin Walgreen has been with company since 1979
- William Rudolphsen
- Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer
since 2004 - Has been with Walgreens since 1977
Source Data Walgreen Co. Jan. 11, 2006 Annual
meeting and www.walgreens.com
4RCMP Position
- Own 1000 shares in Walgreens
- Purchased at 25/share on 10/06/1999
- Cost Basis is 25,000
- Stock is now trading at 49.31/share
- Valued at 49,310
- Represents 13.75 of portfolio MV
- Gain of 24,310, or 97.24
5Macroeconomic Overview- General Economy
- Earlier this summer, the markets trended downward
due to a number of factors - Uncertain economic outlook stemming from repeated
releases of conflicting economic indicators - Repeated non-official statements made by Federal
Reserve Board members regarding the health of the
economy, possible future actions - See May 1, 2006 on-air comments by CNBC reporter
Maria Bartiromo - Continuing political uncertainty and worries
regarding oil supplies as violence increased in
Iraq and Iran defied US and UN fueled higher
energy prices and muted hampered US and world
equity markets
6Macroeconomic Overview- General Economy
- Since mid-July, the markets have trended somewhat
higher on high volume but gains have not been
substantial - The market as a whole currently feels that a
pause in interest rate hikes is indeed likely - One of the leading inhibitors for better
performance remains continued uncertainly
regarding the health of the economy stemming from
conflicting economic indicators - See Friday, September 8, 2006 release of cost of
wages and economic growth
7Macroeconomic Overview- Trailing 6 Month Market
Performance
8Macroeconomic Overview- Demographics
- Aging Population
- Around 36 million people are 65
- 12.6 of the total U.S. population
- 17.6 live in Florida
- By 2030, there will be almost 72 million people
65 - Retirement of Baby Boomers
- Currently, around 77 million Baby Boomers
representing almost 27 of the population - Over 50 of Baby Boomers live in CA, TX, NY, FL,
PA, IL, OH, MI, NJ - Americans begin to start taking more drugs in
their early 50s
Source Data www.metlife.com
9Macroeconomic Overview- Political
- Medicare Part D prescription drug program
- In effect as of January 1st, 2006
- Prescription Drug coverage
- Covers both generic and prescription drugs for
those who qualify for Medicare - Designed to protect those with high drug costs
- May allow pharmaceutical industry to create new
drugs that are safer and more effective - At this point it is too early to tell how the new
plan will affect Walgreens, as the kinks are
being resolved
10Drug Store Industry
- Decreasing customer loyalty
- Relationship with customers deteriorating
- Customers now have more convenient or
economically viable options - Generic drugs seen as a low-cost alternative to
name-brand prescription and non-prescription
medications Mail order threat - Walgreens is combating the mail order threat by
offering customers a choice between 90-day mail
order prescriptions and 90-day at retail option,
known as Advantage90 - Advantage90 is currently offering prescriptions
at 10 discount to 90-day mail orders
Source Data Walgreen Co. Jan. 11, 2006 Annual
meeting
11Drug Store Industry
- Highly Competitive Industry
- Competition with other drugstore chains,
independent drugstores, mail order prescription
providers, internet pharmacies - Other competitors include various grocery stores,
mass merchants, and dollar stores - Main competitors
- CVS Corp. (CVS)
- Recently purchased 700 stand alone Sav-On and
Osco drugstores through its 9.7 billion buyout
of Albertsons Inc. - This move will give CVS a significantly greater
Midwest foothold - Rite Aid Corp. (RAD)
- Partial competitor
- Wal-Mart (WMT)
- Pharmaceutical more than grocery department
- In FY 2004, Pharmaceuticals were 9 of Wal-Marts
sales - In total, about 6 billion/year (25) less in net
sales than Walgreens
Source Data Wal-marts 2004 10-K
12Porters 5 Forces Drug Store Chains
13Competitors
Source Yahoo! Finance available at
http//www.finance.yahoo.com
14Interesting Facts
- Earnings
- The average grocery store earns 12/ sq. ft.
- The average drug store chain earns 20/sq. ft.
- Wal-Mart earns 26/sq. ft.
- Walgreens earns 46/sq. ft.
- Prescriptions (average per store)
- Grocery stores fill 131 prescriptions/day
- Mass retailers fill 143 prescriptions/day
- Chain drug stores fill 180 prescriptions/day
- Walgreens fills 263 prescriptions/day
- Walgreens fills more prescriptions than all
grocery stores combined!
Source Data Walgreen Co. Jan. 11, 2006 Annual
meeting
15Strategy
- Enter new markets
- Dense up existing markets
- Organic store growth
- Relocate
- Remodel
- Invest heavily in high-tech store and
distribution systems which drive service up and
costs down - An agile elephant Must continue to find ways
to leverage the benefits of scale without losing
the ability to react quickly to changes in
customer needs - Healthcare offerings beyond that of a traditional
pharmacy - Offer an online drugstore web site totally
integrated with our retail stores - Attract and maintain top talent
Source data www.walgreens.com
16Strategy
- Growth, Growth, Growth!
- Walgreens is currently increasing their net
stores operated by approximately 1 store per day - The company, which currently operates 5,156
stores, plans to operate at least 7,000 stores by
2010 - All this expansion is funded by cash flow from
operations, as opposed to long-term debt or
equity issuances
17Innovations
- Introduced freestanding stores in early 1990s
with drive thru pharmacies - Today, more than 80 of Walgreen Co.s stores
have drive thru pharmacies - Nation-wide 1 hour photo service
- Available at more than 98 of stores
- New Digital Photo Service
- Allows you to upload your photos at home and pick
them up at any Walgreens store 1 hour later! - Much time and effort has been put into this
project so that they stay ahead of competition - Touch tone prescription refills
Source data www.walgreens.com
18Innovations
- Largest private user of satellite technology
- Second only to the United States government
- Today, 125 million people live within 2 miles of
a Walgreens - Walgreens plans to increase their business by
investing in prime locations, technology, and
customer service initiatives
Source data www.walgreens.com 2005 10-K
19Products
Source data Walgreen Co. 2005 10-K
20Walgreens Locations by State
Source data www.walgreens.com
21Positioning
- Walgreens well positioned for Baby Boomer era
- Top 5 states with largest number of stores
- 1 Florida with 673 stores
- 2 Texas with 530 stores
- 3 Illinois with 500 stores
- 4 California with 419 stores
- 5 Arizona with 223 stores
- Over 50 of Baby Boomers live in FL, TX, IL, CA,
NY, PA, OH, MI, NJ
Source Data www.metlife.com
22New Workings
- Medicare Part D prescription drug program
- Walgreens has recently integrated a program into
their computer system that lets the pharmacists
look at a patients list of drugs and match the
patient with the Medicare drug program that will
be most cost-effective for them - Best of all, its free!
- New Acquisitions
- Walgreens recently acquired SeniorMed, an
assisted living prescription business in hope
that it will give them a big boost in a
business area where they had previously lost
customers - In addition, WAG is now partnered with TakeCare
and InterFit to operate small clinics in WAG
stores
Source Data Walgreen Co. Jan. 11, 2006 Annual
meeting
23New Workings
- Dial-A-Pharmacist (in 14 languages)
- Automatically connects a patient with a Walgreens
pharmacist somewhere in USA who speaks that
particular language - Highway Signs
- New Federal Regulations are allowing 24-Hour
pharmacies to put up signs on major highways
(Just like McDonalds and Shell) - Walgreens already has 7 put up in Illinois
- Solar powered roofs
- Walgreens will begin to start using solar powered
roofs in 100 of their stores - These will allow each store to generate 20-50 of
its own electricity.
Source Data Walgreen Co. Jan. 11, 2006 Annual
meeting
24Porters 5 Forces Drug Store Chains
25SWOT Analysis
265 Year Performance
2710 Year Performance
Adjusted for stock splits and dividends
2820 Year Performance vs. SP 500
295 Year Performance vs. SP 500
305 Year Performance vs. Competitors
31Walgreens vs. Portfolio
32Correlation Matrix
Note Table assumes equal-weighted portfolio
33Fit With RCMP PortfolioAppraisal Ratios
- Appraisal ratio
- Risk-adjusted measure of excess returns
provided by a security -
- alpha/(std error2)
-
- Suggests user add (short) the security if alpha
is significant and appraisal ratio is greater
than alternatives
34Appraisal Ratios
Note alpha for all 3 securities above is not
positive with 95 certainty but is significant at
slightly lower levels of confidence
Source Data Yahoo! Finance
35Relative Multiple Analysis
- Growth Implied by PEG Ratios
- Here we see that the market has already priced
significant growth into Walgreen stock. - Unless the firm can grow almost 18 annually ad
infinum, the stock will likely undergo a
correction.
Source Data Yahoo! Finance
36Relative Multiple Analysis
- Here we see that Walgreens P/E Ratio is high not
only to the market but also its industry. - This serves as additional evidence of the
significant premium the market has placed on
the firms stock.
37Valuation Process of a DCF
- To refresh, intrinsic value of a firms common
equity is determined as follows - Forecast free cash flow over a period of X years
and a terminal value via
FCF final period(1LT growth
rate)/WACC-LT Growth Rate - Calculate WACC via (weke)wdkd(1-tax rate)
- Discount all cash flows and arrive at enterprise
value viaS1N FCF i/(1WACC)i - Subtract LT debt from enterprise value
- Divide by common shares outstanding to get price
per share
38Valuation Step 1 Forecasting Free Cash Flows
39Valuation Step 2 Calculating WACC
- Sensitivity to WACC is a major issue for most DCF
models, and is of extraordinary importance when
modeling Walgreen Co. - I will revisit this topic later in the
presentation - Since WAG is 100 equity, WACCke. Below is ke
(and thus, WACC) calculated via CAPM
40Valuation Step 3 Finding Enterprise Value
41Steps 4 5Subtract LT Debt and Divide by
Shares Outstanding
- Step 4 Subtract LT Debt
- This step is not necessary as the firm is 100
equity - Step 5 Divide by Shares Outstanding
42 43Accounting Rules vs. Economic Reality
- WAG only owns approximately 18 of its store
base. What about the other 82? - They are leased. These leases are
structured/accounted for as operating leases. - This means that although these leases (and other
minor off-balance sheet obligations) carry
significant future commitments (26.078 billion),
these commitments are not counted as liabilities
on the firms balance sheet. - So are these commitments LT debt?
- Liabilities
- probable future sacrifices of economic benefits
arising from present obligations of a particular
entity to transfer assets or provide services in
the future as a result of past transactions or
events FASB Concept Statement 6, paragraph 5 - Answer YES! These are (economic) liabilities!
44Accounting for Significant Off-Balance Sheet
Liabilities
- The most precise method of accounting for these
operating leases would be to back the costs of
rent out of Selling, Operating, and
Administrative Expenses (SOA) and restate the
firms financials as if they owned the stores - This would entail separating interest expense,
depreciation, and amortization - In addition to restating the firms financials,
the analyst would need to calculate a new WACC,
estimating a weight and cost of debt - Unfortunately, the firm does not provide nearly
this level of information so we must pursue
other, less precise methods
45Adjusting ROE An ad hoc solution
- Although academic theory holds that a firms
value is not affected by its capital structure1,
this is not the case in reality - Modigliani and Millers theory does not account
for, among other things, taxes or the increasing
marginal barrowing rates associated with
increasing leverage - Therefore, investors should demand a return in
excess of the ke-derived WACC we used earlier to
compensate them for the risk associated with
WAGs quasi-leverage
1. For more information, see The Cost of
Capital, Corporation Finance and the Theory of
Investment.F Modigliani, MH Miller . The
American Economic Review. 1958. American Economic
Association
46CAPM, ROE, and Everything In-Between
- Below we have 2 measures of ke CAPM, and ROE
47CAPM, ROE, and Everything In-Between
- Below is a matrix listing possible combinations
of WACC and LT Growth and the corresponding stock
prices
48Importance of ROE Sensitivity
- The stocks current price of approximately 49.00
is supported only when assuming unrealistically
high LT Growth or an unrealistically low WACC
(i.e. CAPM ke or below). - Due to the risk associated with the firms LT
(economic) debt, I do not feel CAPM WACC is an
appropriate measure and thus WACC must be
adjusted upward to account for this risk. - THESE TWO FACTORS PRODUCE SIGNFICANT DOWNSIDE
RISK FOR THE STOCK PRICE
49Recommendation
- I recommend that 50 or 500 shares of WAG be sold
at the market - I feel WAG is currently trading at a
significantly inflated price that, in the long
term, cannot be sustained - Why not sell it all?
- WAG currently has considerable momentum, having
beaten analyst EPS estimates for 3 consecutive
quarters. Retaining some portion of the stock
exposes us to the potential upside of continued
momentum - Walgreen has always traded at a premium price
and thus, we cannot know if, when, and to what
degree these premiums will evaporate
50Negating Scenarios
- WAG posts a Q4 that beats analyst consensus
- Although I feel such a scenario is unlikely due
to both heightened expectations and the firms
Q1-Q3 margins, such an accomplishment would no
doubt propel stock price in the short-term - CVS posts poor results and/or fails in new
initiatives - As WAGs main (and only real) competitor, a CVS
failure will allow WAG to increase pricing power
and will decrease pressure to expand - WAG makes a key unexpected acquisition into a
business line in which CVS does not operate - With competition within the drug store industry
becoming increasingly competitive, any
opportunity for a player to enter a profitable
business area in which the other does not operate
will give the firm a first mover advantage, as
well as pricing power not available in the
duopoly environment.
51