AIMING HIGHER ANELUN UWCH

1
AIMING HIGHER ANELUN UWCH THE 3rd PROWESS
INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE
Prof Sara Carter University of Stirling
2
Gender, Entrepreneurship and Business Finance
The relationship between banks and entrepreneurs
in the UK

• Professor Sara Carter,
• Centre for Entrepreneurship,
• University of Stirling, Scotland
• The 3rd Prowess Annual International Conference
  8th February 2006, Cardiff

3
Womens Enterprise in the UK

• Women are under-represented in self-employment
  and business ownership, despite policies to
  increase rates of participation
• 1995 900,000 self-employed women
• 7 of economically active women
• 26 of self-employed population
• 2005 970,000 self-employed women
• 7 of economically active women
• 26 of self-employed population
• UK SME Ownership
• 15 women-owned
• 35 jointly owned by men and women
• 50 men-owned
• Treasury goal to increase women-owned businesses
  from 15 to 20

4
Womens Enterprise in USA

• 10.6 million firms are at least 50 owned by a
  woman or women
• 48 of all privately-held firms are at least 50
  owned by a woman
• employ 19.1 million people
• generate 2.5 trillion in annual sales
• Growth between 1997-2004
• growth in number of women-owned firms twice all
  firms (17 v 9)
• employment expanded at twice rate of all firms
  (24 v 12)
• number of women-owned firms with employees grew
  by 28, three times growth rate of all firms with
  employees
• Source Centre for Womens Business Research,
  Washington DC

5
Women Owned Businesses

• Younger and smaller
• More likely to be sole traders and start in
  business on their own
• Lower average sales turnover and less likely to
  be VAT registered
• More likely to operate from home
• Lower average employment profile
• More likely to have additional part-time
  employment
• Less likely to own more than one business
• Concentration in traditionally female sectors,
  retail, business services, personal services
• Relatively lower inflows and potentially higher
  (unexplored) outflows from self-employment

6
Constraints on Womens Enterprise

• Finance is main constraint affecting womens
  ability to start and grow a business
• Women start businesses with
• lower levels of overall capitalisation
• lower ratios of debt finance
• 1/3 the starting capital used by men
• personal savings and informal finance sources
• no VC and business angel investment
• Women pay significantly higher margins on term
  loans than male owned businesses 2.9 v 1.9
  over base (Fraser, 2005)
• Start up capitalization has enduring effect on
  business survival and performance

7
Researching Women and Finance

• Q. Why is there a bi-modal funding profile?
• A1. Structural dissimilarities
• A2. Supply side discrimination
• A3. Demand side risk aversion
• Research finds
• No evidence of bank discrimination
• (Fay and Williams 1993 Fabowale et al 1995
  Haines et al 1999 )
• Given same starting resources, women and men
  perform equally well
• (Watson 2003 McMahon 2005)
• Residual concerns of unfair treatment by banks
  and perceptions of patronising attitudes, but
  banks now employ women as loan officers

8
New Research Focus

• The lending criteria used by bank loan officers
• The lending processes used by bank loan officers
• The personal constructs held by bank loan
  officers of male and female entrepreneurs
• The capitalization and performance of male- and
  female-owned businesses
• The relationship between financial and
  non-financial capitals

9
Supply Side stages 1-3

• Individual interviews with male and female bank
  lending staff using business plan (ascribed to
  Jack or Emma) to explore lending criteria
• 2. Focus groups with bank lending staff to
  discuss business plan and lending criteria (3
  male FG, 3 female FG), to explore lending
  processes
• 3. Post-focus group individual personal
  construct interviews (using Kellys Repertory
  Grid technique), to explore perceptions of
  entrepreneurs

10
Demand Side stages 4-6

• 4. Telephone interviews with 100 business owners
  (50/50 male/female), business services sector,
  less than 3 years old, central Scotland, for
  comparative analysis of entrepreneurs
• 5. Depth personal interviews with 30 matched
  pairs of business owners, using structured
  questionnaire (previously developed questions and
  scales), to elicit access and use of various
  capitalization
• 6. Post interview individual personal construct
  interviews (Kellys Repertory Grid technique)

11
1. Lending Criteria

• Similar criteria used to assess male and female
  business plans
• Male applicants questioned more on the business
  proposition, financial history, and personal
  characteristics
• Female applicants questioned more on whether
  sufficient research undertaken
• Some differences in criteria by male and female
  loan officers
• Male loan officers focused more on commitment of
  applicant (esp. when female)
• Female loan officers focused more on marital
  status of applicant (esp. when male), meeting
  applicant to make sure they fit the plan
• Searching for proxies that indicate
  trustworthiness and business acumen
• Evidenced by gut instinct and feeling
• Individualised decision making of bank loan
  officers
• one guy could fund a project, another would
  reject it

12
2. Lending Processes

• Female loan officers
• The business plan, size of loan, terms of loan,
  difficulty in accessing good deals from
  introducers and brokers
• I did actually get a deal from an accountant and
  it was absolute rubbish. He gave me the rubbish
  one that nobody would do I know he has access to
  so many good quality clients and he doesnt give
  me many of those (female)
• All we do really is we put the whole proposal
  together and then it gets emailed off to the
  credit team. The decision lies with them
  (female)
• Male loan officers
• Rapport with applicant, gut instinct, developing
  relationship with credit sanctioners
• You assume if you put something in, there will
  be someone in that team will pick it up and you
  do have a working relationship with them (male)
• The bank is here to make money, so we need to do
  deals. So, thats why when we talk about
  negotiation its a realisation of the need to
  generate income (male)

13
3. Personal Constructs

• Wide range of constructs held by bank officers,
  focused on character
• 1st Round Tests
• Statistically significant gender differences
  observed in 20 / 325 constructs
• (10 male, 10 female)
• 2nd Round Tests
• Detailed multivariate analyses confirmed no
  evidence of systematic gender differences in
  constructs held by bank loan officers of business
  owners
• No gender differences (21/35 grids)
• Unsystematic differences on some constructs
  (13/35) (6 female, 7 male)
• Systematic differences but not construct
  differences (1/35) (1 male)
• Systematic and construct differences (0/35)

14
4. Capitalization and Performance of Male and
Female Entrepreneurs

• Sex differences after controls for sector,
  business age and location
• Capitalization Male mean 18.6k, Female mean
  6.4k. More women (21) than men (5) used external
  finance. But, 17/21 women had external investment
  under 500, 4/5 men had external investment over
  1,000
• Industry focus men more likely to work in
  management and business consultancy, women in
  business services
• Ownership 90 women, 66 men started as sole
  traders, men more likely to start with co-owning
  spouse and also to employ spouse in firm
• Size men twice as likely to employ additional
  staff, more likely to report higher sales
  turnover, more likely to serve company clients
  rather than individuals

15
5. Relationship between Financial and
Non-Financial Capitals

• Human capital
• Educational qualifications identical
• Age women mean 41 v men mean 51
• Work experience women mean 11 years v mean 22
  years
• Gross household income identical
• Earnings prior to start-up women mean 32.3k v
  men mean 46.3k
• Social capital
• Women active weak-tie networkers, but dependent
  on friends and family
• Men strong locally-embedded ties within industry
  sector
• Symbolic capital
• Credibility problems affect 30 women vs no men

16
Initial Conclusions

• Clear capitalization performance differences by
  men and women entrepreneurs
• No deliberate discrimination by banks
• Focus on character of loan applicants is
  integral to lending process
• But, gender differences in lending decisions are
  subtle, engrained and unconscious
• Loan officers negotiate outcomes that suit
  their world view
• Gender continues to be an important, but hidden
  variable in acquisition of debt finance
• Different experiences of male and female bank
  loan officers
• Importance of internal networking and
  negotiations (often as a male dynamic) as an
  unspecified and unseen element of the lending
  process
• Difficulties of women in accessing deals
• Supply-side and demand side factors interact to
  co-produce the lending decision the aspirations
  and expectations of women entrepreneurs and the
  perceptions of bank lending staff of women
  business-owners and female-type businesses
  both affect the loan decision

17
Gender, Entrepreneurship and Business Finance
The relationship between banks and entrepreneurs
in the UK

• Professor Sara Carter,
• Centre for Entrepreneurship,
• University of Stirling, Scotland
• The 3rd Prowess Annual International Conference
  8th February 2006, Cardiff