The Truth About Jenin - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

1 / 27
About This Presentation
Title:

The Truth About Jenin

Description:

British military expert David Holley tells the BBC why he thinks there was not a ... BBC, April 29, 2002. No Jenin massacre' says rights group ... – PowerPoint PPT presentation

Number of Views:82
Avg rating:3.0/5.0
Slides: 28
Provided by: mot8
Category:
Tags: bbc | jenin | truth

less

Transcript and Presenter's Notes

Title: The Truth About Jenin


1
Presents
2
The Truth About Jenin
3
Oy Vay! Massacre!500 Palestinians were Killed!
4
Really 500?Are you sure?
5
Positive?
6
100???
7
The Israelis claim it was only 50 or so. Most of
them terrorists who died in fierce battle.
8
Fierce battle? Its so banal! Massacre is much
juicier! We have to sell newspapers, you know.
Darn those Israelis! Trying to kill us a good
story. We wont let them!
9
Lets play it up!Lets find some eyewitnesses!
"Kamal Anis, a labourer" (Times), "Kamal Anis,
28" (Telegraph), "A quiet, sad-looking young man
called Kamal Anis" (Independent) - and the same
handful of victims - "A man named only as Bashar"
(Telegraph), "the burned remains of a man,
Bashar" (Evening Standard), "Bashir died in
agony" (Times). You'd think with so many
thousands massacred there'd be a bigger selection
of victims and distraught loved ones, wouldn't
you? But apparently not.
Mark Steyn, letter to the editor of Daily
Telegraph,(Filed 20/04/2002)
10
The Israeli army butchered us!Oh, yeah?
Tabaat Mardawi, a senior member of Palestinian
Islamic Jihad who surrendered to Israeli forces
in Jenin "It was like hunting ... like being
given a prize. I couldn't believe it when I saw
the soldiers," he said. "The Israelis knew that
any soldier who went into the camp like that was
going to get killed." He added "I've been
waiting for a moment like that for years."
(An interview with captured terrorist Tabaat
Mardawi On CNN, April 23, 2002)
11
Did I see tens of people killed? Frankly, no.
Israel Defense Forces spokesmen have said that
the decision to use infantry to spearhead the
attack rather than using air power and
artillery stemmed from a desire to limit
civilian casualties, even at the risk of higher
IDF casualties.
(An interview with captured terrorist Tabaat
Mardawi On CNN, April 23, 2002)
Israels casualties in Jenin were the highest of
all West bank fighting 23.
12
Palestinian officials claim hundreds died in what
they are calling a massacre
Mardawi said there were about 100 Palestinians in
the battle -- 60 to 70 fighters from the camp and
20-30 members of the Palestinian security forces.
That figure is not so different from what Israel
has said. The Israel Defense Forces has said as
many as 200 fighters were in the camp but that
about 100 surrendered during the fighting.
(An interview with captured terrorist Tabaat
Mardawi On CNN, April 23, 2002)
13
We had more than 50 houses booby-trapped around
the camp.
Israeli soldier in Jenin near a booby trap
cooking gas canister filled with explosives and
wired for remote control operation
"Of all the fighters in the West Bank we were the
best prepared," Omar says. "We started working on
our plan to trap the invading soldiers and blow
them up from the moment the Israeli tanks pulled
out of Jenin last month." Omar and other
"engineers" made hundreds of explosive devices
and carefully chose their locations.
(An interview with Omar, the bomb maker, who
escaped From Jenin, Al Ahram Egyptian weekly,
April 24, 2002)
14
we placed the bombs about four meters apart
throughout the houses - in cupboards, under
sinks, in sofas."
According to Omar, everyone in the camp,
including the children, knew where the explosives
were located so that there was no danger of
civilians being injured. It was the one weakness
in the plan.
(An interview with Omar, the bomb maker, who
escaped From Jenin, Al Ahram Egyptian weekly,
April 24, 2002)
15
Jenin camp was Totally Devastated
A ruined house in Jenin
16
Totally Devastated?
Aerial photo of Jenin camp after the battles red
circle shows actual area of ruined houses. Many
houses collapsed from Palestinian explosive
charges.
17
Folks, we promised a Massacre. We cant lose
face. Lets do something!
  • The Palestinians in Jenin have begun moving
    bodies buried in the cemetery next to the
    government hospital prior to operation "Defensive
    Shield" into a "mass grave" of casualties of the
    operation - facing the old cemetery. 26
    Casualties from operation "Defensive Shield" are
    buried in the grave. The bodies recently added,
    those from the hospital cemetery, bring the
    number up to 50 bodies. This in order to display
    a larger number of Palestinian casualties that
    were allegedly killed during the fighting in the
    camp.
  • Israeli Army Report, April 26, 2002

18
50 bodies? Thats all? Where are the 500 you
promised?
  • 26 Casualties from operation "Defensive Shield"
    are buried in the grave. The bodies recently
    added, those from the hospital cemetery, bring
    the number up to 50 bodies. This in order to
    display a larger number of Palestinian casualties
    that were allegedly killed during the fighting in
    the camp.

19
Oh, well... Lets stage a Funeral!
  • 2.5.02 the IDF is exposing for the first time
    footage filmed from above, and in it, an on-film
    testimony of the Palestinian's preparations for
    UN committee's visit to Jenin. In this segment,
    you see a staged funeral of a Jenin victim that
    the Palestinians organized. This footage was
    filmed three days ago, on April 28, 2002 at
    around 1900 and it is very clear and easy to see
    that the body has apparently "resurrected" and
    that the whole funeral is actually one big
    charade.

Dead body on stretcher
20
Hey, Ahmed, come play dead for a minute, will
you?
dead man approaches stretcher
21
Come, Come, it wont hurt. Its for the Cause!
dead man gets closer
22
Now climb onto the stretcher, yes, thats fine.
dead man climbs onto stretcher
23
Atta boy! Can we begin the procession now?
dead man lying on stretcher
24
What the experts say
  • British military expert David Holley tells the
    BBC why he thinks there was not a massacre in the
    Jenin refugee camp and why he believes Israel is
    right to challenge the UN fact-finding mission.
    Mr Holley, who is a Major in the British
    Territorial Army and a military adviser to
    Amnesty International, visited Jenin at the
    weekend.
  • "What we have got here is possibly 54 bodies
    found so far, with possibly 20 or 30 unaccounted
    for but we can't really verify these figures
    until the whole site is cleared.
  • "Talking to people and talking to witnesses, even
    very credible witnesses, it just appears there
    was no wholesale killing.
  • "Clearly the... civilians who died in the battle
    were caught in crossfire
  • BBC, April 29, 2002

25
No Jenin massacre says rights group
  • The campaigning group Human Rights Watch has
    completed a report into the Israeli army's
    operation in the Palestinian town of Jenin.
  • The report says there was no massacre as the
    Palestinians have claimed
  • BBC, May 3, 2002

26
And even the UNis backing down
  • Terje Roed-Larsen, the U.N. Middle East envoy
    who described a horrifying scene last week after
    a visit to the Jenin refugee camp My reaction is
    that I have been totally misrepresented in parts
    of the Israeli media, evidently quoting me
    wrongly, saying that I stated that there was a
    massacre in Jenin. I said nothing of the sort.

Terje Larsen in a CNN interview, April 22, 2002
27
Next weekThe Jews used Moslem babies blood
in making Matzo for Passover!
Stay tuned.
Questions? Comments? Please mail them to
mottimorell_at_bezeqint.net
Write a Comment
User Comments (0)
About PowerShow.com