Title: AMM Mexican Steel Conference
1NAFTA Steel Roundtable
- AMM Mexican Steel Conference
- Monterrey, Mexico
- January 29, 2008
- Thomas A.Danjczek
- Steel Manufacturers
Association
2Outline
AMM Mexican Steel Conference
- SMA
- Consolidations
- China
- NAFTA
- Policy Implications
- Unknowns
- Conclusion
3SMA
AMM Mexican Steel Conference
- The Steel Manufacturers Association (SMA)
- 35 North American member companies
- 30 U.S., 3 Canadian, and 2 Mexican
- 126 Associate Members
- Suppliers of goods and services to the steel
industry - SMA member companies
- Operate 125 steel recycling plants in North
America - Electric Arc Furnace (EAF) steelmakers using
recycled steel
4SMA
AMM Mexican Steel Conference
- Production capability
- EAF steel producers accounted for over 60 of
U.S. production in 2007 - SMA represented over 70 of all U.S. steel
production in 2007 - Recycling
- SMA members are the largest recyclers in the U.S.
- EAF steel producers are the largest recyclers in
the world - Last year, the U.S. recycled over 75 million tons
of steel - Growth of SMA member companies
- Highly efficient users of labor, energy, and
materials - Modern plants producing world class quality
products
5Steel Consolidating, But Still Fragmented
AMM Mexican Steel Conference
TOP 15 Represent 36 of Global Production
Source IISB
6Active Consolidation Within NAFTA
AMM Mexican Steel Conference
- Recent Key NAFTA Announcements
- ArcelorMittal-Dofasco
- USS-Stelco, USS-LoneStar
- Gerdau-Chaparral, Gerdau-MacSteel
- Ternium-Grupo Imsa
- SSAB-IPSCO
- Essar-Algoma, Essar-Minnesota, Evarz-Claymont
- Emerging Downstream Focus
- Nucor-Harris, Nucor-Barker, Gerdau-Enco
- Extending to Scrap
- Sims-Metal Management, Steel Dynamics-OmniSource
7Consolidation Opportunities Risks
AMM Mexican Steel Conference
- Potential Benefits
- Access to Capital, Technology
- Deeper Customer Relationships
- Facility Optimization / Strategic Fit
- Industry Sustainability
- But Benefits Are Undermined By Prevailing Risks
- Global Overcapacity
- Subsidies and Other Trade Distortions
8New Capacity Outpaces Consumption Growth
AMM Mexican Steel Conference
Announced Steel Capacity Vs. Projected
Consumption 2007 2010 (Million Metric Tonnes)
Announced Steel Capacity Increases By Region
(2006 2012)
Compound Annual Growth Rates Capacity 6.83
Demand 4.65
Capacity Multiple Sources Nucor
Analysis Demand IISI projections thru 08 6
increase 09 10
9China Worlds Most Subsidized Industry
AMM Mexican Steel Conference
More than 50 billion in subsidies
State-owned enterprises account for 91
percent of Chinas largest steel groups
7.5 billion in debt-to-equity swaps in 2000
Chinese steelmakers regularly obtain preferential
loans from state-owned banks
An additional 6 billion in announced
subsidies during 2000
2005 steel policy commits China to further
subsidies, micromanagement
Manipulation of key raw materials markets,
including coke and ferroalloys
Support from local and provincial governments unco
ntrolled by central government
Inadequate protection of workers rights and
enforcement of environmental standards
Chinese steel producers enjoy government assistanc
e with energy and other input costs
10China Worlds No. 1 Is Government Directed
AMM Mexican Steel Conference
Top 20 Chinese Steel Producers Government
Control Vs. Private Ownership
Top 20 Capacity 210 Million Tons
2007 Projected Global Production
Australian Government Predicting China Will Reach
1B Tons by 2015, CISA says 2020.
11China Is the Worlds Largest Exporter
AMM Mexican Steel Conference
Source CISA, 2007 Data Annualized
Source China Customs, 2007 Data Annualized
12China Bashing
AMM Mexican Steel Conference
- China has NOT become the worlds largest steel
producer by accident, or by operation of free
markets, or comparative advantage - China is NOT a low-cost steel producer
- China has reached its position through a
combination of subsidies, mandates, and planned
intervention - In finished goods containing steel, Chinas
exports are expanding by approximately 30 percent
per year - Imbalance cannot go on forever
- Chinese steel market is still reliant on exports
to absorb overproduction - Chinese steel industry is overbuilt and
underdemolished
13AMM Mexican Steel Conference
What Harm
U.S. Imports of Auto Parts and Vehicle Bodies
from China, Value and Share
14Raw Materials Governments Still Intervening
AMM Mexican Steel Conference
- Governments (e.g. China, India) Continue to
Intervene in Key Raw Materials Markets For Steel - Iron Ore
- Coke
- Ferroalloys
- Refractory Materials
- Export Tax Manipulations / Restrictions
- Distortions Created NAFTA Competitiveness
Negatively Impacted
15China Central To Current NAFTA Cases
AMM Mexican Steel Conference
- Key NAFTA Steel Trade Cases (Ch. 72 Ch. 73)
- MayNovember 2007
Finding renewed against China on October 10, 2007
16Example - Canada China Growing Value, Market
Share
AMM Mexican Steel Conference
Source World Trade Atlas / AISI.
17AMM Mexican Steel Conference
NAFTA
-Came into effect on Jan. 1, 1994 -One of the
most significant trade events of the 90s -A
trade agreement between three nations -United
States, Canada, and Mexico -Population 426
million -Total GDP 13 trillion -Total Trade
700 billion
18AMM Mexican Steel Conference
Potential Effects of NAFTA
-Prices and wages -Labor markets and
jobs -Imports and exports -State and the local
economy
19AMM Mexican Steel Conference
NAFTA Conclusion
-General consensus that NAFTA had negligible
effect on U.S. employment -Trade may lead to wage
inequality through an increase in earnings gap
between skilled and the unskilled -Little
evidence that NAFTA-induced trade
liberalization -Evidence more in favor of net
trade correction due to NAFTA
20Role of NAFTA Governments
AMM Mexican Steel Conference
- Defending the Market From Abuse
- Eliminating market interventions and distortions
by all governments - Enforcing compliance with trade agreements and
competition law - Maintaining and enforcing trade remedy laws
- Assisting trading partners with understanding /
adopting best practices
21Immediate Focus
AMM Mexican Steel Conference
- Treat China as NME in AD Cases, and Fully Apply
CVD Law to NMEs - Promote NAFTA Manufacturing in FTAs
- Enhanced Government Information Sharing Across
Jurisdictions on Trade Remedy Practice and
Experience
22AMM Mexican Steel Conference
Unknowns
-Value of the RMB??? -JCCT Steel Dialogue where
goal is to promote transparency with better
decisions??? -European Union antidumping
investigation and targets??? -Energy cost and
interest rate impacts??? -Rising freight
costs??? -Chinas restrictive policy of foreign
ownership participation??? -Chinas enforcement
of environmental regulations??? -U.S.
legislation??? -Trade actions??? -When will China
play by market rules???
23AMM Mexican Steel Conference
Conclusion
- Consolidations helping ,overcapacity still a risk
- Trade distortion still a problem, U.S. Congress
disappointed - Need aggressive policy measures to prevent China
from causing a major crisis. To date, only trade
cases have had an impact. - Its still a cyclical business with demand,
scrap, freight, inventories, etc. - Finished goods containing steel are a major
concern - China, China, China everything else is still
only an embellishment - Still reasons for meaningful optimism due to
North American steel industry resiliency. North
American steel facilities, for the most part, are
technologically advanced, cost competitive,
environmentally acceptable, and are a key
component of the North American infrastructure.