Title: Mold: Definition, Procedures and Regulations
1MoldDefinition, Procedures and Regulations
- Ralph P. Jesse
- Environmental Protection Specialist
- USDA ARS - MWA
- 1815 North University Street
- Rm. 2014
- Peoria, IL 61604
- 309-681-6644
- ralph.jesse_at_mwa.ars.usda.gov
2Objectives
- Basic understanding of fungal biology
- Procedures for investigation and abatement
- Regulations and guidelines
3Mold In Buildings
- WHAT is mold?
- WHO is affected?
- WHERE is the mold?
- WHEN is mold a problem?
4Mold - What Is It?
- Microscopic Fungi (living, naturally occurring
organism) - The Kingdom fungi includes mushrooms, yeast, and
mold - Mold and fungus or fungi can be used
interchangeably - Does not have chlorophyll
- Present in almost every commercial building /
public building / school / home - Includes Stachybotrys toxic black mold
5- What Does Mold Need To Grow?
-
- Ubiquitous microorganism present in ambient air
- Nutrient source such as organic substrates,
cellulose fibers, wood products - Water / moisture source hydrophilic
- Oxygen
- Proper temperature and relative humidity
6- What Types Of Materials Will Mold Grow On?
-
- Just about anything
- All it needs is water and a nutrient source
- Primarily cellulose containing products
- Ceiling tiles
- Drywall
- Wood
- Glass
- Metal
- Concrete block
- Plastic
7- Types of Molds
- There are over 30,000 known species of mold
- Known allergens
- Molds ? mycotoxins
- Disease - Mycotoxicosis
- Common toxigenic species in buildings include
- gt Pennicillium
- gt Aspergillus
- gt Cladosporium
- gt Chaetomium
- gt Stachybotrys
8Mycotoxin Producing Molds
- Stachybotrys chartarum Aspergillus fumigatus
- Aspergillus flavus / parasiticus Aspergillus
versicolor - Fusarium moniliforme Fusarium graminearum
- Fusarium sporotrichioides Paecilomyces varioti
- Penicillium ochraceus Penicillium brevicompactum
- Penicillium aurantiogriseum Penicillium expansum
- Penicillium crustosum Trichoderma viride
- Penicillium verrucosum Memnoniella echinata
- Molds requiring urgent risk management, AIHA
Guide 96
9Stachybotrys Is It Really That Bad?
- Stachybotrys chartarum (S. chartarum) is a
toxigenic fungi and so are many other molds - Exposures to S. chartarum can make some people
sick and so can exposures to other molds - Infants in environments with S. chartarum
contamination may be at higher risk - Other molds like Aspergillus, Penicillium,
Fusarium and Alternaria are more common and just
as important - The CDC recommends not according a higher status
to S. chartarum
10Stachybotrys Under A Microscope
11Mycotoxins
- Powerful chemical released by fungi to help in
competition for food - Contained in the spores, viable or nonviable
- Penicillin, Satratoxin, Trichothecenes,
Aflatoxins originally studied as feed and food
poisons (i.e. peanuts) - Explain some, but not all of hazardous properties
of mold
12Who Is Affected?
- Virtually anyone exposed to airborne mold can
react to various properties of viable and
nonviable mold spores. - Asthmatics and others with allergy to mold will
react at lower exposure levels. - There may not be a no-effect level for some of
these individuals. - Heavily exposed individuals run the risk of
serious illnesses, beyond the toxic and allergic
reactions farmers, renovation and demolition
workers, and abatement workers. - Infants and susceptible individuals (e.g. persons
with compromised immune systems, living with HIV,
cystic fibrosis and the aged) will likely react
at lower concentrations and require special
attention.
13Health Effects
- Long known to exacerbate allergies, asthma, etc.
- Unresolved issue
- Does it cause (versus worsen) condition?
- Are effects permanent?
- General belief that removal of person from
mold-infested environment alleviated condition - Evidence now suggests
- Some conditions caused by mold
- Some such conditions may be permanent
14- Health Effects cont.
-
- Mycotoxin exposure
- Microbial VOCs
- Respiratory system asthma and pnuemonitis
- Impaired immune system function toxicosis
- Severe headaches, chronic fatigue, muscle pain
- Skin irritation and dermatitis
- Cold and flu-like symptoms
- Individual responses to exposure affects people
differently - Pre-existing medical conditions such as
allergies, persons with weakened or compromised
immune systems
15Where Does Mold Come From?
- Always present in the ambient environment
- Abundant in soil, rotting vegetation and potted
plants - Spores and mold fragments are easily transported
through the air - Need moisture, acceptable temperatures and food
source to live and multiply
16Where Are There Problems?
- In any building where damp conditions exist or
have existed homes, schools, offices,
apartments, barns, etc.
17Geographic / Regional Problem Areas
- The Hot Zone Southeastern US and Gulf Coastal
States are major problem areas - Regions where basements and high water tables
coexist - Inland areas with a history of flooding
- Most coastal areas
18When Does Mold Contamination Become A Problem?
- Growth on or within walls, ceiling tiles, and
rugs that exceeds 10 ft2 in extent - Growth in HVAC systems and ducts
- When asthmatics, immune-compromised and other
sensitive occupants are present - Serial episodes of mold contamination in the same
area / building - When the problem is not taken seriously
19The Biology Of Mold
- Fungi can be identified to genus or species level
(i.e. Aspergillus vs. Aspergillus versicolor) - We need to know the species to properly assess
risk - Mold serves an important purpose in nature, its
the major mechanism for recycling nutrients - Supports other species
- Spores vary in size - 2 - 60 µm
20The Biology Of Mold
- Gets nutrition through releasing enzymes into the
surrounding media and absorb back nutrients - Reproduces by forming and broadcasting spores
- Colonies can reproduce in 5 - 10 days
- A colony 1 diameter 400,000,000 spores
- Spores viable for decades or longer
21Ecology Of Mold In Buildings
- Temperature of 5 - 38o C
- Nutrients
- soil
- dirt
- cellulose in paper, carpet backing, cork, pipe
wrap, etc. - Water water them and they will grow!
- condensation in humid rooms, crawlspaces,
tunnels, closets - damp basements
- wet sections in air-conditioning ducts
- leaky roofs
22Relative Humidity ? 60
- Associated w/ overgrowth of biologicals
- Ventilation systems
- Carpet, wall spaces, insulation
- Ceiling tiles, window seals
- ? upper airway moisture
- Allows dust H2O soluble toxic chemicals to
dissolve - can cause upper airway irritation, inflammation,
cough
23When Does Mold Occur?
- Mold colonizes when moisture and food source
exist - Construction materials create food source
- Use of paper and wood products in construction
materials - Add water (leaking pipes / flooding / damaged
roof) mold colonization
24Investigating and Testing to Assess the Extent of
the Problem
25IAQ Investigation Protocol
- Requires systematic approach
- complex
- potential causes
- Objectives
- Gather info. about bldg.
- Signs symptoms of those w/ health complaints
- Locate ID potential causes
- Determine work relatedness of illnesses
- Remediate by removing / isolating source
26IAQ Investigation Plan
- Questionnaires for employee complaints
- Diary
- Walk-through
- Sampling procedures
- Remediation protocols
27IAQ Influenced by
- Temperature
- Humidity
- Air movement
- Ventilation
Hotel
28 Municipal office building
Private office building
Family health center
Public school
29Sources Causes of Poor Indoor Air Quality
- Chemical
- Biological
- Physical
- Psycho-social
30Biological Sources
- Epithelial cells
- Pet dander
- Human skin particles
- Dust mites
- Insects ( insect parts)
- Roaches
- Pollen
- Mold / Fungus
- Bacteria
- Viruses
- By-products of microbes
31Biological Sources
- Standing water / damp areas
- Humidity / microbial growth / trigger illness
allergies - Humidity / dust mite growth ? causes asthma /
allergies
32Protocol for Inspection
- Interviews with occupants and building staff
- Reported symptoms, periodicity and location
- History of water damage
- Walk-through
- Visual colonies
- Ventilation
- Remember standard IAQ parameters CO2, CO, RH, T,
VOCs, etc. - Mold tests and reports
- Communication
33- Investigation
- Initial Assessment
- Visual inspection
- Evidence of water damage
- Moisture measurements
- Mold growth
- Air and / or surface sampling not always
- Determine extent of impacts
- Photographic documentation
- Final report summarizing findings
34Conduct Walk-Through and Investigation
- Learn history of building
- Review construction documents
- as-built drawings
- HVAC installation and operation information
- Review maintenance history
- Review reported employee complaints
- Inspect all areas believed to be impacted
- Low key approach if no prior complaints have been
received - Photographic / video documentation of existing
conditions
35Non-Invasive Inspection
- Borescope
- FLIR - Thermal Imaging and Infra-red Cameras
- Moisture meter Protimeter
- Flashlight
36Invasive Inspection
- 50 of mold problems may be hidden from view
- Concealed problems within wall cavities, ducts,
beneath carpets and tiles etc. - Holes can be cut for visual inspection, air
samples, sample probes
37Hidden Mold
38(No Transcript)
39(No Transcript)
40(No Transcript)
41(No Transcript)
42(No Transcript)
43(No Transcript)
44(No Transcript)
45(No Transcript)
46Handling a Pervasive Problem
- If widespread (beyond common areas) develop
communication plan for disclosure to occupants - Develop an overall strategy (e.g. aggressive
assessment, remediation and repair usually the
best approach) - Assemble the rest of team needed to implement
strategy
47Assemble Team
- After initial investigation, assessment and
formulation of testing / sampling strategy, team
may also include - Architect / Engineer
- Remediation Contractor
- Third party Environmental Consultant
- HVAC Professional
- Medical Professionals
- Allergist
- Epidemiologist
- Pulmonary Physician
- Microbiologist
48 Communication
- Assess risk asap and review regularly
- Keep all stakeholders informed
- Provide clear and accurate briefing
- Know your comfort zone and seek advice if unsure
- Be proactive
49Assess and Evaluate Potential Illness Impacts
- Determine likelihood of impacts based on sampling
data - Develop a strategy for handling illness claims
- To evacuate / relocate or not?
- Must be based on sound scientific and medical
information and principles
50Sick Buildings versus Sick Occupants
- SBS - Sick Building Syndrome a collection of
health complaints or symptoms that do not fit a
case-definable disease, such as headache, eye
irritation, scratchy throat, itchy skin, cough,
etc. - BRI - Building-Related Illness a collection of
signs and symptoms that fit a case-definable
disease, such as new onset asthma, Legionnaires
disease, humidifier fever, tuberculosis, etc.
51How Do You Know If Your Building Has Made Them
Sick?
- Has there been an objective medical evaluation?
- What is their illness?
- Does it seem plausible given the history of the
building? - Is it supported by mainstream science?
- Have you considered other causes?
- Do they have a history of claims?
52Assess the Source and Scope of the Problem
- Identify all affected areas
- Identify all impacts
- Property damage
- Scope of remediation / repairs
- Illness
- Identify all sources of water intrusion
- Identify water and mold pathways
- Roof and building envelope
- Basements
- Pipe chases
- HVAC systems
- Air Handlers
- Ducts
53Water Moisture Sources
- Leaks from hot water tanks
- Sewage backflows
- Condensation
- high relative humidity
- temperature
- high air holds more moisture
- low surfaces (e.g. pipes, windows, etc.)
- Flooding from water line breaks
- Sprinkler head breaks
- Infiltration through other building construction
materials
54Water Moisture Sources cont.
- Poor building maintenance practices
- Slow neglected leaks in plumbing fixtures
- Water and moisture from housekeeping and
janitorial activities - HVAC system components such as chillers, cooling
coils, condensate lines, drain pans, etc. - Other sources such as icemakers, refrigerators,
sinks, toilets, lab operations, drinking water
fountains, etc.
55- Water Intrusion Control Prevention
- Moisture control and water intrusion prevention
is the single most critical element and
preventing mold growth inside buildings. - Immediate drying, cleaning, and / or removal of
water damaged building materials must be
performed within 48 hours of the initial water
damage in order to prevent mold growth. - Sources of water intrusion should also be
identified and corrected as soon as reasonably
possible or the mold will return.
56(No Transcript)
57(No Transcript)
58Drying Procedures
- Four General Principles of Drying
-
- Excess Water Extraction Removal
- Evaporation Air Movement
- Dehumidification
- dehumidifier
- humidistat-controlled exhaust fan
- Temperature Control
59(No Transcript)
60(No Transcript)
61Mold Monitoring and Assessment
62Monitoring and Testing for Mold
- Sampling and / or testing should be conducted
after the initial meeting, walk-through and
occupant interviews - The choice of sampling and / or testing methods
should have a logical connection to observations
and occupant health complaints
63Air, Bulk and Surface Sampling
- Some tests
- Air samples
- culturable
- non-culturable
- Bi-air cassette does both
- Tape, bulk, swab water samples direct
microscopic examination, qualitative assessment
64Sterile Swabs
65Types of Biological Samples
- Air
- Viable or Culture-based
- Employs the use of an Andersen (or similar)
sampler - Results usually reported as colony forming units
per cubic meter of air (CFU/m3) - Non-viable or Non-culture-based
- Employs the use of a spore trap sampler
- Results usually reported as particles per cubic
meter of air (particles/m3)
66Bioaerosol Sampling
- Fungi and bacteria by impactor / culture plate
methods (i.e. Andersen sampler) - Requires sanitary handling
- 28.3 Liters (1 cubic foot) per minute
- Predominant individual genera and / or species
identified - Relative prevalence
- Indoor / outdoor ratio
67Types of Biological Samples
68Types of Biological Samples
69(No Transcript)
70(No Transcript)
71The BioCassetteTM
72Types of Biological Samples
- Non-viable or Non-culture-based
- Bulk sample, Dust sample, Soil sample, Swab
sample, Tape sample, Water sample, Wipe sample - Results usually considered qualitative
- Can reveal types of fungi present and whether
these fungi are reproducing by the presence or
absence of fruiting structures, etc.
73Bioaerosol Sampling
- Analysis by non-culture-based methods (e.g. spore
trap, Air-O-Cell cassette) - Identification and quantitation of (non-viable)
particulate matter, including fungal spores,
hyphae, etc. - Predominant individual genera and / or species
identified - relative rank or relative prevalence
- indoor / outdoor ratio
74Non-Viable Air Sampling
- Zefon Air-O-Cell Sample Cassette
- Collects all airborne spores, pollen, fibers and
other particulates - 15 Liters per minute (Lpm)
- Collected particles are analyzed by microscopic
direct examination - Mold spores identified to genera level
- Laboratory turn around quick and results can be
useful for final clearance
75Types of Biological Samples
76Zefon Air O - Cell
77Types of Biological Samples
- Bulk Samples
- Viable or Culture-based
- Results reported as CFU per gram of sample
- Non-viable or Non-culture-based
- Direct visual examination yields quick turnaround
time, but results are preliminary and qualitative - May understate the number of different types of
fungi present
78Importance of QA / QC Practices and Procedures
- Laboratory selection and evaluation
- Sample chain of custody
- Choosing the correct sampling method
- Equipment pre- and post-calibration
- Blanks
- Documentation
79Interpreting Lab Reports
- Disparity in opinion regarding what count is
normal / acceptable - Ask the lab
- US Non Residential Buildings 1993 - 2000 samples,
75 of which yielded fungal counts less than 178
cfu/m3 - Species present and comparison with outdoor
mycoflora more important than absolute numbers
80Abatement of Mold Contamination
81Remediation and Abatement
- Develop scope of work
- Prepare written remediation protocols
- Qualified contractors
- Third-party Environmental Consultants
- Removal and decontamination
- Final visual inspections and verification
clearance testing (typically air surface
samples)
82Remediation and Abatement
- Develop a remediation plan first
- The key to mold control is moisture control
- Remember to address the source of the moisture
problem - Remember to check for high humidity and
condensation problems as well as actual water
leaks, maintenance issues, and HVAC system
problems
83Remediation and Abatement
- Protect the health and safety of building
occupants and abatement workers - Consult with safety and health professionals
- Contractors should be using personal protective
equipment and containment as appropriate
84Mold Cleanup
- The purpose of a abatement should be to mitigate
mold while preventing human exposure and
minimizing damage to building materials and
furnishings - All mold contamination must be cleaned up
- Dead mold is still allergenic and some dead molds
can be toxic
85Biocides
- Biocides are toxic to molds and often are toxic
to humans as well (e.g. bleach, Sporicidin) - Some biocides are considered pesticides and, in
some jurisdictions, only registered pesticide
applicators may apply these products - ACGIH discourages use
- Alternative - detergent
- Post-remediation sampling for hazardous
ingredients from MSDS
86Project Monitoring
- Why should you monitor?
- Documentation of remedial efforts, including
conditions before, during and after efforts - Management of liability
- Gather data for future evaluation and use
87Project Monitoring
- Monitoring Points
- Prior to commencement of abatement activities
(initial assessment) - At abatement commencement
- During abatement
- After completion of abatement
- Often abatement companies will sample during the
activities - Be sure to formulate a legally defensible
sampling strategy
88Quality Controlof the Abatement Project
- The principal quality assurance performance
indicator is documentation that the precipitating
water or moisture sources have been identified
and eliminated. - from Final Report of AIHA Microbial Growth Task
Force (May 2001)
89Quality Controlof the Abatement Project
- Other recommended key QA performance indicators
are - Documenting appropriate containment protocol
- Documenting that cleaning was performed according
to specifications - from Final Report of AIHA Microbial Growth Task
Force (May 2001)
90Quality Controlof the Abatement Project
- Other recommended key QA performance indicators
are - Documenting that mold removal has been in accord
with the approved remediation plan - Documenting that remediated areas were checked
for any remaining unremediated mold and / or
water damage that may have been revealed during
the demolition / cleaning process - from Final Report of AIHA Microbial Growth Task
Force (May 2001)
91New Remediation Technology
- Building Fumigation Using Chlorine Dioxide Gas to
permeate construction materials including wall
cavities - Non-intrusive remediation
- Follow up verification clearance testing has
proved successful - Building must be evacuated and tented
- Safety flammable gas
- Cost and logistical issues
92- Mold Remediation Scenario
- Initial assessment revealed multiple sources of
water intrusion and water damaged building
materials - Extensive visible mold growth identified during
assessment - Written remediation protocols developed including
use of negative pressure containments and air
scrubbers - Remediation work consisted of demo. of entire
inside of building - Final visual inspections and clearance sampling
performed at end of project
93(No Transcript)
94(No Transcript)
95(No Transcript)
96Mold Resistant Coatings
97Worker Protection
- No worker who has any sort of immune suppression,
asthma or mold allergy or who has recently had a
severe cold or flu should undertake work - NIOSH respirator with HEPA, or PAPR
- Goggles, gloves, safety boots
- Disposable TYVEK suit
- Electrical Safety
98(No Transcript)
99Abatement - General Points
- Remedy the water problem first
- Classification of work and work practices based
on NYC 1993 protocol - April 2000 revision significantly less rigorous
than 1993 protocol
100Small area clean up (Level I)gt 10 square feet
- Can still cause health risk or contaminate other
areas - Regular staff with suitable training and
protection - Work area unoccupied - adjacent areas OK
(exceptions) - Dust suppression, sealed bags for removal
- Clean-up with damp cloth and detergent
101Mid size isolated area clean-up(Level II)10 - 30
square feet
- Regular staff with suitable training and
protection - Work area unoccupied - adjacent areas OK
(exceptions) - Work area plastic sheeted and tape sealed
- Dust suppression, sealed bags for removal
- HEPA vacuum Clean-up with damp cloth and detergent
102Large isolated areas (Level III)30 -100 square
feet
- H and S professional consultation
- Trained workers, with personal protection
- Work area plastic sheeted and tape sealed
- Seal ducts and grills
- Work area and directly adjacent areas unoccupied
- high risk individuals moved - If abatement dusty use Level 4 procedures
103Level 4 Extensive Contamination gt100 square
feet contiguous
- H and S professional consultation
- Trained workers, with full personal protection
- Work area fully contained, HEPA exhaust, airlocks
and decontamination room - Adjacent areas can be occupied - high risk
individuals moved - HEPA vacuum and clean up before barriers
dismantled - Air monitoring prior to reoccupancy
104Level IV Contamination
105Level V - Remediation of HVAC
- Small areas lt10 square feet regular staff, larger
areas trained workers - System shut down
- Consider biocide
- Consultant supervision and air sampling prior to
reoccupancy if large scale contamination - Mold
- Biocides
- Coatings
106Mold In Crawl-spaces
- Perform drainage and foundation improvements
first, if necessary - Consider several options, perhaps in combination,
to reduce moisture load in the crawl-space - Cover soil with thick moisture barrier or
concrete over open soil - Provide powered ventilation, perhaps push / pull,
perhaps on humidistat control - Remove fibrous insulation, replace with closed
cell foam
107Post-abatement Monitoring
108Steps to Remediation Closure
- No visual and / or sensory evidence of mold
contamination during walkthrough of the building - No visual and / or sensory evidence of mold
contamination during inspection of HVAC system - Measurements of temp., humidity, CO2, and CO
within recognized guidelines / standards - Sampling for biocides or coatings
- Acceptable results following sampling and
analyses for mold
109Clearance Criteria
- The success of a remediation effort is judged in
part by the visible degree of contaminant removal
that is achieved. - Effectiveness may also be confirmed by
sampling. - From Bioaerosols Assessment and Control (ACGIH,
1999)
110Clearance Criteria
- The ultimate criterion for the adequacy of
abatement efforts for treating biological
contamination is the ability of people to occupy
or reoccupy the space without health complaints
or physical discomfort. - From Bioaerosols Assessment and Control (ACGIH,
1999)
111Regulations and Guidelines
112- Regulations
- No US EPA Regulations While EPA recently
implemented guidelines for remediation projects,
currently, no EPA regulations or standards
regarding airborne mold contaminants exists - OSHA Regulations - General Duty Clause
- Guidance documents on investigation, sampling,
and remediation - State and Local guidelines
- The Institute of Inspection, Cleaning and
Restoration Certification (IICRC) Standard S500
and S520 - the definitive mold remediation
standard - Focus is shifting towards required licensing of
consultants and contractors - Highly improbable that interior permissible
exposure levels in buildings will ever be
established
113Mold Legislation
- State
- California
- October 2001 - Toxic Mold Bill passed
- Directs CA Department of Health to set limits and
standards regarding mold - Requires landlords and sellers to make certain
disclosures regarding mold contamination - Includes presence of mold in housing codes
114Mold Legislation
- State (continued)
- New York
- NYC Department of Health has implemented
Guidelines on Assessment and Remediation of Fungi
in Indoor Environments - While the Guidelines are intended for the use of
building engineers and management and are not a
legal mandate, their ultimate application in the
courts is foreseeable
115Mold Legislation
- State cont.
- Maryland
- Promulgating legislation to protect workers from
mold related illnesses - Texas
- Investigating the issue
- Other States
- Some have created specific agencies to deal with
mold and other indoor air quality health issues
(i.e. Minnesota Department of Health's Indoor Air
Unit)
116Guidelines
- EPA
- IAQ
- Mold
- ASHRAE Standard 62 1989 - IAQ
- requires air filters or dust collectors to remove
microbes - systems should be designed to prevent growth of
microbes - ASHRAE Standard 55 - 2004 Thermal Comfort
117The 1992 ASHRAE Comfort Zone
118Consensus Standards
- ACGIH Bioaerosols Assessment and Control
- New York City Panel, 1993 (Revised April 2000)
- Set abatement practices classified by area of
mold to be abated - Revision recommends same precautions regardless
of species - AIHA Field Guide, 1996
- Urgent risk management recommended for confirmed
presence of - Stachybotrys chartarum
- Aspergillus versicolor
- Aspergillus flavus
- Aspergillus fumigatus
- Fusarium moniliforme, etc.
119Internet Resources
- AIHA
- http//www.aiha.org/content/topics/mold
- EML
- http//www.emlab.com/app/fungi/Fungi.po
- The Mold Inspector
- http//www.moldinspector.com/index.html
- The University of Minnesota EHS
- http//www.dehs.umn.edu/iaq/flood.html
- The Illinois Mycological Association
- http//www.ilmyco.gen.chicago.il.us/index.html
- Xenco Labs
- http//www.xenco.com/xLabs_Mold_Library_A.htm
- Pathcon Labs
- http//www.pathcon.com
- CDC / NIOSH
- http//www.cdc.gov/mold
- Mold Help
- http//www.mold-help.org/index.php
- ACGIH
- http//www.acgih.org/resources/press/Mold05.htm
- New York City Health Department
- http//www.ci.nyc.ny.us/html/doh/html/epi/moldrpt1
.html - US EPA
- http//www.epa.gov/iaq/largebldgs/index.html
- http//www.epa.gov/mold/index.html
120Questions Answers