Title: General
1Information as Pathologys Ultimate Trump Card
Opportunities in the Digital Age
ROBERT L. MICHEL Editor In Chief THE DARK
REPORT Spicewood, Texas
Pathology Visions 2007 San Diego,
California October 21-23, 2007
rmichel_at_darkreport.com ph 512-264-7103 fax
512-264-0969
2My Goals Today!
- One Review primary trends currently reshaping
healthcare and lab services. - Two Relate these trends to appropriate responses
in anatomic pathology in coming years. - Three Evaluate the evolutionary versus
revolutionary potential for change in how
pathology uses digital technologies to add value.
3My Thesis
- For pathology, digitization is a critical path
to maintaining and increasing the value
propositionto users of lab data. - Multiple healthcare trends will create
opportunities for digitized pathology to
increase its role and contribution in the
clinical continuum.
4Four Basic Sources of ChangeIn U.S Healthcare
Market
Discussed at Executive War College
- One Consumers as primary buyers of healthcare.
(Private and Medicare/Medicaid.) - Two Major commitment to universal electronic
medical record (EMR) and integration of
healthcare data. - Three New diagnostic lab technology
genetic-based lab tests, automation, POCT. - Four Widespread introduction of Deming-based
quality management methods into healthcare and
clinical laboratory profession.
5Drive to Universal EMR
Change Agent Two
- Federal government taking lead role in fostering
development of universal EMR (electronic medical
record). - Hospitals and health systems scurrying to
integrate existing data repositories and create
single view patient record. - Enterprise IT integration is soaking up majority
of hospital IT budgets. - Digitizing radiology images and work processes is
another expensive drain on hospital IT dollars.
6Change Agent Three
New Technology in the Lab
- Steady stream of new diagnostic tests, many based
on molecular technologies. - Point-of-care testing (POCT) growing regularly in
tests and capabilities. - Different automation products available for
pre-analytical, analytical, post-analytical.
(Even middleware as automation.) - Impact of these technologies magnified by
enhanced informatics solutions. - Remember Labs end product is info!
7Change Agent Four
Quality Management Methods
- Healthcarepushed by employersnow using quality
management systems. - Savvy hospitals and labs are learning that
Lean/Six Sigma provides competitive advantage,
once the organization embraces these quality
methods. - Quality requires accurate measurements, more on
this later. - First mover to early adopter to general
adoption by labs and hospitals. - Lab Quality Confab, Atlanta, Sept. 19-20.
8Importance of Information Technology
- Software is more sophisticated.
- Storage costs and computing costs are declining
steadily. - Wireless connections are ubiquitous and can
handle higher volumes of information. - Advances in Internet technology make it feasible
to perform more functions using a Web platform. - Interconnectivity and integration continually
easier to achieve.
9IT as Threat and Opportunity
- Information is the end product of all clinical
labs and pathology groups. - Hospitals working to integrate clinical data into
real-time patient EMR. - Office-based physicians are implementing EMR
systems. - RHIOs (Regional Health Information Networks)
under development across the United States and
Canada. - Labs must integrate with these users.
10Pace of Change Accelerates
- Laboratory medicine in the midst of an
accelerating cycle of change. - Can identify six specific sectors within
laboratory medicine undergoing major realignment. - In each sector, rapid series of events over the
past six to 24 months. -
11Managed Care Contracting
Lab Sector One
- United Health does 10-year deal with LabCorp,
excludes Quest Diagnostics. - Horizon BC/BS does exclusive contract with
LabCorp in New Jersey. Quest out. - Aetna does exclusive with Quest, excludes
LabCorp. - Cigna renews national contracts with both
LabCorp and Quest, and does it early. - LabCorps strategy of regional managed care
laboratory networks.
12Clinical Lab Acquisitions
Lab Sector Two
- Sonic Healthcare Ltd enters USA. In 24 months,
spends 820 million to acquire 8 labs with 500
million in annual revenue. - Apax Partners LP buys Spectrum Lab Network
(November, 2005). - Laboratory Partners, Inc. acquires Terre Haute
Medical Labs and Cincinnati lab. - New investors bidding aggressively for
laboratory assets and reshaping the market.
13Anatomic Pathology Services
Lab Sector Three
- Quest Diagnostics pays 2 billion for AmeriPath
(with 750 million in sales). - Aurora Diagnostics acquires nine pathology
groups in 12 months, now at 60 million in sales. - Caris buys Pathology Partners.
- Water Tower Equity Partners buys Lakewood
Pathology Associates. - CBL Path raising lots of capitalto fuel rapid
expansion.
14Molecular Diagnostics
Lab Sector Four
- Specialized startups, often with proprietary or
patented diagnostic technology. - RedPath Integrated Pathology
- Signature Genomic Laboratories
- Access Genetics
- Roches hostile offer of 3 billion for Ventana
Medical Systems (282 million in sales). - Vision Systems Ltd Ventana enters agreement to
buy Cytyc offers more money. Danaher (Leica)
outbids both.
15In Vitro Diagnostics Firms
Lab Sector Five
- 5 of 15 largest IVD firms in world have entered
acquisition agreements in past 16 months. - Siemens pays 14 billion for DPC, Bayer
Diagnostics, and Dade Behring. - GE buys Abbott for 8.1 billion, then breaks the
deal. - Hologix pays 6.1 billion for Cytyc (606
million in sales).
16Health IT Companies
Lab Sector Six
- Ongoing consolidation and product acquisition
among IT companies. - Per Se Technologies acquired by McKesson.
- Pathology Service Associates (PSA) acquired by
Med3000. - Data Innovations buys P.G.P. s.a. of Brussels,
Belgium. - Misys unloads former Sunquest product line to
California investment group.
17Anatomic Path Under Siege
- Collectively, these trends and market forces are
having substantial impact on anatomic pathology. - Lets take a closer look
18Landscape for Change-2000Big Changes in Anatomic
Pathology
- Emergence of national AP firms, such as UroCor,
DIANON Systems, IMPATH. - Some consolidation of pathology groups in large
urban markets (related to consolidation of
hospital ownership). - Emergence of first specialty testing companies in
molecular diagnostics, such as Myriad Genetics. - As a profitable, growing sector, AP catches
attention of two blood brothers.
19Fast Forward to Year 2007 Looking at Anatomic
Path Services
- Quest Diagnostics and LabCorp expanding into
anatomic pathology. (Quest/AmeriPath now
employees 800 to 900 pathologists. LabCorp
employs 400 pathologists.) - Growing number of national AP labs, such as
Bostwick Labs, CBL Path, Clarient, Claris,
Lakewood Pathology, OUR Labs. - Specialty physicians, such as urologists and GIs,
establishing in-house anatomic pathology
services. (TC/PC arrangements.)
20Year 2007 Looking at Molecular Diagnostics
- Steady growth in numbers of specialty testing
companies with proprietary or patent-protected
diagnostic technology. - Athena Diagnostics, Clarient, Genomic Health,
RedPath Innovative Pathology are just a few
examples. - These firms want the specimens so tests can be
performed in their laboratories. Business goal is
to be exclusive provider of these diagnostic
technologies.
21Looking Forward from 2007 Dominant trends in
Healthcarecontinued
- Patient safety and pay-for-performance have one
thing in common - Providers must closely measure outcomes,
increasingly in real time. - Providers must then use this data to improve
outcomes. - Integration of healthcare IT makes this
increasingly easier and cheaper. - Laboratories produce informationthese trends are
both threats and opportunities.
22Looking Forward from 2007 Dominant trends in
Healthcarecontinued
- Increased scrutiny of outcomes and public ranking
of providers by quality of outcomes motivates
clinicians to use lab tests more effectively. - Example public release of cardiovascular surgery
outcomes, by providers, in New York, starting in
early 1990s. - Opportunity for labs and pathology groups to
increase their role as laboratory medicine
consultants to clinicians.
23Imaging Intersects with Pathology Consolidation
/ Integration of In Vitro In Vivo DIagnostics
- Siemens acquires
- Shared Medical Services (SMS)2000
- Diagnostic Products Corp (DPC)-2006
- Bayer Diagnostics-2006
- Dade Behring-2007
- GE acquires
- Triple G Corporation2003
- Amersham PLC2003 (diagnostic imaging agents,
protein separations) - Abbott Diagnostics2007 (deal busts apart)
- Philips Corporationwill it also acquire LIS and
in vitro diagnostic companies?
24Lets Put Things Together
- Fact large purchasers of healthcare are making
rapid progress in gathering data about the cost
of care and outcomes produced by individual
hospitals, physicians, laboratories, and other
providers. - These purchasers will use this data to reward
superior performers and give poor performers a
motive to change or exit as a clinical service
provider.
25That is Lab Opportunity
- Laboratories are skilled at collecting data and
converting it into information. - Referring physicians, under pressure to improve
outcomes and the cost per healthcare encounter,
will have motive to give greater value to lab
testing and consultation services. - Laboratory medicine has the technology,
knowledge, and experience to help clinicians
improve outcomes, reduce unnecessary costs of
care.
26Quality Management
- Pace of these trends will be magnified by wider
adoption of Deming-based quality management
principles. - As noted, Lean and Six Sigma techniques have
passed through first mover and early adopter
stages. - Now gaining acceptance across both the hospital
and laboratory industry. - Quality management, by its use of real-time data
to measure work processes, reinforces wider
trends in healthcare.
27Evolution or Revolution?
- We can argue about pace of change
- but it is clear that the American healthcare
system is preparing to undergo a radical
makeover during the next decade. - Change always creates new winners and losers.
28Comment on Anatomic Pathology
- Anatomic pathology is a sector of lab medicine
facing wrenching change. - Most threatened private pathology group
practices serving community hospitals. - For rational reasons, partners in these groups
are reticent to invest in their own businessnor
consider regional consolidation. - Growth in pathology profession is already taking
the form of salaried positions.
29Investors Changing Pathology
- In general, private pathology groups are not
investing adequately in technology and
informatics. - Investor-owned pathology groups are investing in
technology. - Any opportunity to increase revenues and build
market share will be pursued by commercial
pathology firms. - Use of enhanced informatics and digitization is
consistent with this strategy.
30Why Investor Interest?
- Less money, less time, less regulation to bring a
new diagnostic test to market and earn profits. - Pharma up to 10 years, 500 billion.
- IVD 2-3 years, 30 million
- Sales of just 60 million/year make a new lab
test a financial home run.
31And Theres More for Investors!
- Investors know demographics and aging
baby-boomers will fuel demand for existing and
new lab tests. - Priority of early detection, use of personalized
medicine, and increase in pharmacogenomics/compan
ion diagnostics only adds more demand. - Value proposition of well-researched clinical
benefit of a new lab test is generally accepted
by payersthus, ample reimbursement.
32Necessary Responses
- Pathology groups need to develop subspecialty
expertise, especially in genetics and molecular
pathology. - Sophisticated informatics strategy is a must!
(See next slide.) - Regional consolidation of pathology resources is
the right strategy to create critical mass and
market clout. - Community hospital-based pathology groups must be
willing to invest in their own business
(practice).
33Pathology Informatics
- Healthcare is eliminating paper. Pathologists
must do the same, in parallel. - Pathology groups need to support not just
electronic claims and electronic reports, but
direct interfaces with referring physicians. - EMR adoption by large physician groups is key
trend and requires bi-directional interface
gateways with labs and pathology groups.
34IT in Pathology
- With EMR use expanding and electronic patient
referrals increasing, demand for full electronic
pathology report (with digitized images) will
grow. - Within pathology profession, needfor complex
molecular work-ups to bring together data from
several sources reinforces use of digital images
and data. - Pay-for-performance and evidence-based medicine
will require full digital pathology record that
supports data mining and research analysis.
35Supporting Efficiency
- Pathologists must support both clinical and
operational efficiency. - Physicians wont use labs that dont support
physicians clinical workflow and operational
workflow. - That requires pathologists to support the
physicians evolution to full digital
implementation. - These are additional reasons why pathology groups
should have a sophisticated informatics strategy.
36Its A Revolution in Pathology
- Status quo strategy no longer sustainable for
private pathology groups. - New winners emerging
- Investor-funded pathology companies.
- Regional, consolidated pathology super groups
- Selected academic center pathology departments
with a market mindset. - Owners of patented or proprietary diagnostic
technology.
-30-