Voting

1
(No Transcript)
2
Voting
Systems
Performance
Rating
3
Purpose
openly
develop
useful, objective and substantially comprehensive
performance rating
standards
for US voting systems.
4
P.L. Vora, B. Adida, R. Bucholz, D. Chaum, D.L.
Dill, D. Jefferson, D.W. Jones, W. Lattin, A.D.
Rubin, M.I. Shamos, and M. Yung
COMMUNICATIONS OF THE ACM November 2004/Vol. 47,
No. 11
5
Unique Structure

• Modeled after IETF
• Everything transparent and online
• Decisions two weeks after meetings
• Anyone can join at largehowever, Council
  Groups elect their own members

DESIGNED TO BE

• ANSI Accredited Standards Developer
• Majority of Council Groups must approve standards
  by (non-secret) majority vote

6
Council Groups
Technology/Security Experts
Election Official/Experts
Advocates Social Scientists
Vendors
7
Advocates and Social Scientists
Stephen Ansolabehere - MIT David Aragon -
Voter March Ren Bucholz - Electronic Frontier
Foundation Lillie Coney - Electronic Privacy
Information Center Frederick Conrad - University
of Michigan Joe Hall - University of
California at Berkeley, SIMS William Kelleher -
PresidentialElectionReform_at_yahoogroups.com Bob
Kibrick - Verified Voting Eric Lazarus -
Decision Smith Bo Lipari - New Yorkers for
Verified Voting James McCarthy - National
Federation of the Blind Dick Niemi - Department
of Political Science, University of Rochester
Dennis Paull - Commonwealth Institute Rob
Richie - FairVote - The Center for Voting and
Democracy Dan Seligson - Pew Charitable Trusts
Suzanne Taylor - Morrison Institute for Public
Policy, Arizona State University Ellen Theisen
- Voters Unite Daniel Tokaji - Ohio State
University Mike Traugott - Ctr. for Political
Studies, Inst. for Social Research, Univ. of
Michigan Founder
8
Ben Adida - MIT Andrew Appel - Princeton
University Karl Auerbach - No Affiliation Josh
Benaloh - Microsoft Research Matt Bishop -
UC Davis Darlene Blake - public policy research
organization Jeremy Bryans - Newcastle Upon
Tyne University Duncan Buell - University of
South Carolina Ron Crane - truthandhope.org
Open Voting Consortium David Dill - Verified
Voting Michael Fischer - Yale University
TrueVoteCT.org Ari Juels - RSA Security
Stanley Klein - TrueVoteMD William Lattin -
TTFN Associates Vincent Lipsio - Lipsio
Enterprises Peter Neumann - SRI International
Avi Rubin - Johns Hopkins University Peter
Ryan - Newcastle Upon Tyne University Ted
Selker - MIT Michael Shamos - Carnegie
Mellon University Jeroen van de Graaf -
Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Brazil
Poorvi Vora - George Washington University
David Wagner - UC Berkeley Daniel Wang - San
Diego State Unversity Moti Yung - Columbia
University Founder
Technology and Security Expert
9
Election Officials and Experts
Bill Bryan - Louisiana Department of Justice
Cathy Darling - Shasta County Clerk and
Registrar of Voters (CA) William Gardner - New
Hampshire Secretary of State David Jefferson -
CA Secretary of State's Technical Oversight
Committee Douglas Jones - University of Iowa
Andy Lokken - Ramsey County Elections Ralph
Munro - Former Washington Secretary of State
Freddie Oakley - Clerk Recorder, Yolo County,
CA Ion Sancho - supervisor of elections, Leon
County florida, no party affiliation Warren
Slocum - Chief Elections Officer, San Mateo
County, CA Gene Wittry - Election Commission
Board, Peoria IL Founder
10
Vendors
Alfie Charles - Sequoia Voting Systems David
Chaum - Votegrity Kevin Chung - AVANTE
International Technology Guy Duncan - Election
Systems and Software Arthur Keller - Open
Voting Consortium Neil McClure - Hart
InterCivic Sanford Morganstein - Populex
Corporation Andrew Neff - VoteHere Ian Piper
- Diebold Election Systems, Inc. Howard Van
Pelt - Advanced Voting Systems Richard Vogel
- Vogue Election Systems Founder
11
Election Official/Experts
Technology/Security Experts
Advocates Social Scientists
Vendors
12
(chair) Executive Committee
Election Official/Experts
Technology/Security Experts
Advocates Social Scientists
Vendors
David Aragon
Peter Neumann
David Jefferson
Arthur Keller
(chair)
Member Executive Committee
13
Council
(chair) Executive Committee
Federal/Standards Advisors
Members at Large
Council Group
Election Official/Experts
Technology/Security Experts
Advocates Social Scientists
Vendors
Member Executive Committee
14
Council
(chair) Executive Committee
Federal/Standards Advisors
Members at Large
Council Group
Election Official/Experts
Technology/Security Experts
Advocates Social Scientists
Vendors
Area
Integrity
Reliability
Accuracy
Privacy
Operations
Accessibility
Secrecy
Robustness
Example Rating Working Group
Example Model/Overall Working Group
Member Executive Committee
Area Director
Working Group
15
.org