Title: Trey Cash
1Trey Cash Senior Vice President
2Asset Identification Valuation Process in
General
-
- Identify assets
- What is being sold
- Greenfield
- Brownfield
- What is not being sold i.e.
- Liabilities
- Residual cash flows after meeting financial
performance tests - Value of restrictive covenants
- Methods to value assets
- Discounted Cash Flow
- Comparable Sales transaction
- Replacement cost
- Develop assumptions and benchmarks
3Identifying Assets
- Revenue-producing assets
- Asset must be well defined and easy to isolate
(i.e.) - Complete system
- Specific alignment
- Sufficient size to cover transaction costs
- Useful life commensurate with structure of
transaction - Asset condition
- Ability to define operating standards
- Strategic impact of removing control over the
asset from the governmental owner
4Defining what is being sold
- Non-financial requirements need to be considered
when modeling cash flows or developing
peer-comparable transactions - Time horizon
- Asset performance (historic and expected)
- Pricing limitations (i.e. maximum allowable
annual growth of the toll or service charge) - Impact on other governmental functions
- Risk aversion
- Asset control spectrum (impact of retained
control on value to third party) - Human resources
- Identification of responsibilities
- Exit strategy (value to have options to regain
control)
5Develop financial model
- Identifying financial considerations in selecting
alternatives - Benchmarking assumptions to other comparable
sales for which information is available - Debt capacity analysis (public or private entity)
- Revenue and expense modeling
- Defining and comparing weighted average costs of
capital under alternatives - Physical condition of asset
- Limitations imposed by existing financial
arrangements - Ratings impacts
6Analyzing Traffic Forecast (Main Driver to
Valuation)
- Compare assumptions within forecast to actual
results being experienced within the region - Compare assumptions with other rated or enhanced
transactions - Identify key value drivers and limitations to
growth - Consider risk analysis of traffic forecast
- A study to determine the probability of a
forecast achieving its forecasted outcomes both
in terms of revenue and expenses - This is usually done with a peer review by a
traffic consultant that provides a range of
possible outcomes
7Asset Sales and Long Dated Concessions
- Identify financial and market considerations
related to potential sale or concession of an
asset - Asset definition
- Economic value
- Potential acquirers
- Ability to raise capital
- Access to credit capacity
- Value to potential acquirer(s)
- Financial versus strategic investment
- Potential ancillary benefits such as depreciation
- Acquisition financial risk profile and impact to
seller - Payment conditions and items that diminish value
8Potential mitigating factors that affect value
- Structure sale versus concession (length of
concession) - Ability to enjoy tax ownership
- Ability to avoid local taxes such as sales and ad
valorem taxes - Condition of asset condition upon return of asset
at end of concession - Limitations on revenue growth
- Cap on potential tolls increase
- Limitation on diversion of cars
- Ability to impose financial penalties if the
asset is not available for public use
9Potential mitigating factors that affect value
- Greenfield Projects
- Alignment issues related to physical placement of
facility - Right of way acquisition risk
- Environmental and Regulatory approval process
- Brownfield Projects
- Restrictions on the use of proceeds from a state
and federal level - Required third party approvals
- Cost to release asset to be transferred
(defeasance of existing debt)
10Global Investor Market Survey of Potential
Participants
- European Investors
- Abertis (Spain)
- Autostrade (Italy)
- Balfour Beatty (UK)
- Bilfinger Berger (Germany)
- Bouygues (France)
- Brisa (Portugal)
- Cintra (Spain)
- Vinci (Spain)
- Australian/Asian Investors
- AMP Capital (Aus)
- Access Economics (Aus)
- ANZ Infrastructure (Aus)
- Babcock Brown (Aus)
- Challenger Financial Services (Aus)
- Cheung Kong Infrastructure (Hong Kong)
- Colonial First Infrastructure (Aus)
- Hastings Funds Management (Aus)
- Industry Funds Management (Aus)
- Macquarie Infrastructure Group (Aus)
- Transfield Services
- Transurban
- North American Investors
- AIG (US)
- bcIMC (Canada)
- Borealis Infrastructure (Canada)
- CalPers (US)
- Caryle (US)
- CDP Capital (Canada)
- CPP Investments (Canada)
- Fortress (US)
- Kilmer van Nostrand (Canada)
- Ontario Teachers Pension Plan (Canada)
- OP Trust (Canada)
11First Southwest Companys Role
- Provide the resources and experience to assist
governmental entities throughout all phases of an
assets financial life cycle, including helping
to - Define the financial alternatives
- Develop and execute a rigorous process to compare
the alternatives - Develop and execute a desired path