Title: GLY 150: Earthquakes and Volcanoes Spring 2005 04212005
1GLY 150 Earthquakes and VolcanoesSpring 2005
04/21/2005
Lecture 23
Re-landscaping the backyard ???
http//geology.utah.gov/utahgeo/hazards/index.htm
2AnnouncementsGLY 150 Earthquakes and Volcanoes
- The next journal assignment is due Today. If you
still have questions regarding the grading the
grading criteria please see me or the T.A.
(recent small magnitude earthquake in NMSZ).
Next Thursday will be your last journal
assignment. - Instructor office hours are Mon. 200-300 and
Wed. 200-300 - A homework assignment will be posted by tomorrow.
It will be due next Thursday. - Both of your texts will now be helpful,
especially with regard to figures shown in class
and similar pictures in your geology text.
3Extra Credit OpportunityGLY 150 Earthquakes and
Volcanoes
- I have a list of events we have not studied in
class. See Rachel or myself to find out the
topics you will write about. - For each talk, write a four page (single space,
12 inch font, 1 inch margins) summary of the
event, tectonic setting, its implications,
reasons for damage and fatalities, related
archeological evidence, etc. etc. and and receive
4 bonus points added to your total exam score for
the semester. - Follow the directions closely or no credit will
be given - If you write two reports you will receive 8 bonus
points - For those of you who have written reports on one
or both of the lectures, you may only accumulate
8 bonus points total for the semester so if you
have already accumulated your bonus points dont
do this too. If you get less than 4 points on
any of the assignments you can complete this
project so as to account for points missed. - The due date will very. You can choose to
complete this assignment at any time for the
remainder of the class. The assignment will be
due 1 week after you are given a topic.
4Events this QuarterSpring 2005
Note Some of the eruptions may be ongoing so be
sure to check their current status
5WavesBasic Terms
- Wave a disturbance that propagates in time and
space - Crest highest point of the wave
- Trough lowest point of the wave
- Wavelength horizontal distance between
consecutive peaks or troughs - Period at a point, the length of time between
the passage of equivalent heights on the wave - Amplitude (a.k.a. wave height) vertical distance
between the peak and the trough, i.e., the
maximum size of the disturbance
Crest
Trough
http//oceanlink.island.net/oinfo/acoustics/soundw
ave.gif
6WavesPeriod and Frequency
- T Period
- V Wave Velocity
- l Wavelength
- f Frequency
- Wave Velocity how quickly the disturbance moves
- Period the time between successive peaks of the
wave - T l /V
- Frequency the number of oscillations per second.
It is the inverse of the period - F 1/T
Crest
Trough
V
http//oceanlink.island.net/oinfo/acoustics/soundw
ave.gif
7WavesFrequency
- Frequency the number of oscillations per second.
It is the inverse of the period - The frequency of seismic waves is a factor in
determining the amount and type of damage due to
earthquakes
Short Wavelength
Long Wavelength
8WavesAmplitude
- Amplitude (a.k.a. wave height) vertical distance
between the peak and the trough, i.e., the
maximum size of the disturbance
http//earthquake.usgs.gov/image_glossary/amplitud
e.html
9WavesWavelength, Period, and Velocity
- Wavelength horizontal distance between
consecutive peaks or troughs - Period at a point, the length of time between
the passage of equivalent heights on the wave - Wave Velocity how quickly the disturbance moves,
i.e. its propagation speed
Wavelength
Velocity
Period
Velocity
10Seismic Waves
- Body Waves
- P-waves longitudinal waves
- S-waves transverse waves
- Surface Waves
- Love waves
- Rayleigh waves
P-wave
S-wave
Love Wave
Fig. 3.3 Bolt, 1999
Rayleigh Wave
11P-Waves
Body Wave
- Occur because the Earth resists compression
- Velocity depends on how strongly rocks resist
compression - Fastest elastic wave (typically 6 km/s for the
Earths crust) - Longitudinal particle motion (i.e., the motion of
the wave is parallel to the direction in which
the wave propagates)
Compression
Undisturbed
Undisturbed
Dilatation
Fig. 3.3 Bolt, 1999
12S-Waves
Body Wave
- Occur because the Earth resists shear
- Velocity depends on how strongly rocks resist
shearing - Slower than P-waves (typically 3.5 km/s for the
Earths crust) - VS 0.577 VP
- Transverse particle motion (i.e., the motion of
the wave is perpendicular to the direction in
which the wave propagates) - CAN NOT propagate through liquids (e.g. the outer
core)
Undisturbed
Fig. 3.3 Bolt, 1999
13Love Waves
Surface Wave
- Arise because the Earth has a free surface (like
water waves) - Travel more at about the same velocity as S-waves
(VLove VS) - Horizontally polarized transverse particle motion
- Cannot propagate through liquids (e.g. the outer
core) - Side-to-side motion particularly damaging
- Amplitude decreases with depth
Undisturbed
Fig. 3.3 Bolt, 1999
14Rayleigh Waves
Surface Wave
- Arise because the Earth has a free surface (like
water waves) - Travel more slowly than S-waves (VRayleigh 0.92
VS) - Retrograde-elliptical motion (counterclockwise)
- Like ocean waves
- Amplitude decays with
Undisturbed
Fig. 3.3 Bolt, 1999
15Seismic WavesPropagation Pattern
- Surface waves (Love, Rayleigh) generated when the
body waves (P-wave, S-wave) reach the Earths
surface
http//www.essc.psu.edu/ammon/HTML/Classes/IntroQ
uakes/Notes/waves_and_interior.html
16Surface WavesAnother Perspective
Surface Waves
Love Wave
- Amplitude decays with depth
Rayleigh Wave
Both from http//www.essc.psu.edu/ammon/HTML/Clas
ses/IntroQuakes/Notes/waves_and_interior.html
17Propagating Waves General Terms
- Wavefront the propagating front of a wave (think
of ripples in water) - Ray a path oriented perpendicular to the
wavefront - Shows the direction that the wave is going
http//www.eas.purdue.edu/braile/edumod/slinky/sl
inky.htm
18Propagating Waves Expanding Wavefronts
- Body waves expand as spherical wavefronts within
the Earth (3D) - Surface waves expand as circular wavefronts on
the Earths surface (2D)
a.k.a. focus
http//earthquake.usgs.gov/faq/meas.html
19Wave Propagation EffectsRefraction - I
http//160.94.61.144/courses/2301/min15_optics1.ht
ml
Rays
- The bending of waves that results because of
velocity changes in the material through which
the wave is propagating - The velocity of a wave changes when the
properties of the material through which it is
traveling change
Wavefronts
http//www.scitoys.com/scitoys/scitoys/light/perma
nent_rainbows/permanent_rainbows.html
20Wave Propagation EffectsRefraction - III
- The real Earth is a layered body and material
properties change with depth - Generally, seismic velocities increase with depth
- Seismic waves in the Earth travel along a
distinctive a curved path
http//www.essc.psu.edu/ammon/HTML/Classes/IntroQ
uakes/Notes/waves_and_interior.html
21Wave Propagation EffectsReflection
- Waves bounce off interfaces between materials
with different properties - e.g., crust-mantle boundary
- e.g., core-mantle boundary
- Numerous other boundaries found within the Earth
Rock Type 1
Rock Type 2
http//www.surfacesensor.com/Principles/refraction
.htm
http//160.94.61.144/courses/2301/min15_optics1.ht
ml
22Wave Propagation EffectsReflection and Refraction
- There are numerous material interfaces in the
Earths crust (upper 15-20 km). As a result,
earthquake waves can travel an infinite number of
paths - Direct waves
- Refracted waves
- Reflected waves
Fig. 1.10a Bolt, 1999
Seismic waves reflect and refract from various
layers within the earth
Direct Wave
23Seismic WavesSeismic Wave Density Variations
With Depth
- Below the asthenosphere P S-wave velocities and
densities increase with depth
- At core mantle boundary
- S-waves disappear because they cannot propagate
through the liquid outer core - P-wave velocities and density drop but then
continue to increase - S-waves reappear in the inner core
- Note that wave velocity increases with density
(proportional to pressure)
Upper Mantle
P-wave
Density
P-wave
S-wave
Density
S-wave
Lower Mantle
24Wave Propagation In The Earth
- Seismic waves from earthquakes propagate through
the entire Earth (layered body material
properties change with depth) - There are numerous material interfaces throughout
the Earth. The result is that earthquake waves
can travel an infinite number of paths - Direct waves, refracted waves, and reflected
waves - Note S-waves do not propagate through the outer
core, its liquid
http//www.eas.purdue.edu/braile/edumod/slinky/sl
inky.htm, similar to Fig. 4.3, Bolt, 1999
25Seismic WavesWhat Controls the Level of Shaking
and Damage?
- Magnitude of Earthquake
- The more energy released during the earthquake
the greater the shaking - Distance From Focus
- Shaking decays with distance from the focus
(spherical spreading, attenuation) - Directivity
- If the fault ruptures towards you the shaking
will be higher than if the fault ruptures away
from you - Local Amplification of Seismic Waves
- Topography
- Sedimentary Basins
- Unconsolidated soils (sand, mud, fill, etc.)
amplify shaking
26Earthquake RuptureArea of Rupture
- The area of the fault that ruptures is
proportional to the size of the event - Earthquakes only occur within the brittle upper
zone of the crust (a.k.a. seismogenic layer) - upper 15-20 km of the curst
- The largest earthquakes rupture the entire
thickness of the seismogenic crust
http//www.essc.psu.edu/ammon/HTML/Classes/IntroQ
uakes/Notes/earthquake_size.html
27Distance From FocusDecay In Amplitude With
Distance Spherical Spreading
2D or 3D
- As a seismic wave spreads out, the same amount of
energy is distributed over a larger/longer
wavefront - As a result, the amplitude of the wave gets
smaller with distance (i.e., energy must be
conserved) - Effects P and S waves more rapidly than Love and
Rayleigh waves - P S waves spread out in a 3D volume (they are
body waves) - Love and Rayleigh waves spread out across the
Earths 2D surface (they are surface waves)
http//www.npmoc.navy.mil/KBay/soundprop.htm
28Distance From FocusDecay In Amplitude With
Distance - Attenuation
- As wave propagates, surrounding material absorbs
some of its energy - As a result, the amplitude of the wave gets
smaller with distance - Damps high-frequency waves more rapidly than
low-frequency waves - All waves lose approximately the same amount of
energy per cycle (i.e., one complete oscillation) - Low frequency waves lose less energy over a given
distance, because the go through fewer cycles,
than high frequency waves
Short Wavelength
Long Wavelength
29Directivity
ShakeMap from the 1994 Northridge earthquake
- Directed Rupture
- Earthquake ground motions in the direction of
rupture propagation are often more severe than
ground motions in other directions from the
earthquake focus
White arrow gives direction of rupture propagation
http//earthquake.usgs.gov/image_glossary/directiv
ity.html
30Local Amplification Topography
- Focuses earthquake waves
- Concentrates energy
- Traps earthquake waves, increasing the duration
of shaking
Arrows give wave propagation direction
31Local Amplification Sedimentary Basins
Arrows give wave propagation direction
- Focuses earthquake waves (like a lens)
- Concentrates energy
- Amplifies earthquake waves
- Because wave velocities in sediment are slower,
incoming waves stack up, thereby increasing wave
amplitudes - Traps earthquake waves, increasing the duration
of shaking
Wavefront
32Local Amplification Sedimentary Basins
Site on solid rock
- Note how amplitude of seismic waves increases as
seismometers get closer to the basin
Earthquake Epicenter
Basin
Fig. 3.8 Bolt, 1999
33Local AmplificationSoft Soils
- Amplifies earthquake waves
- Because wave velocities in soil are slower,
incoming waves stack up, thereby increasing wave
amplitudes - Traps earthquake waves, increasing the duration
of shaking
34Local AmplificationSoft Soils
- Amplifies earthquake waves
- Because wave velocities in soil are slower,
incoming waves stack up, thereby increasing wave
amplitudes - Example seismograms
- Sediment vs. Rock
Body wave travel paths thought the Earth
35Seismic WavesWhat You Feel During an Earthquake
- P-waves arrive first. For a small earthquake
they are generally not felt. - S-waves arrive next and are usually the strongest
and most destructive earthquake waves. - Surface waves (Love and Rayleigh) arrive later
- They travel at the Earths surface so have to
travel farther in slower materials - They are slow
Body wave travel paths thought the Earth
http//www.essc.psu.edu/ammon/HTML/Classes/IntroQ
uakes/Notes/waves_and_interior.html
36Seismic WavesWhat You Feel During an Earthquake
- Since P-wave are longitudinal and generally
coming from deep in the Earth, you often just
feel a sudden vertical bump under your feet, then
nothing until - Since S-waves are transverse and generally coming
from deep within the Earth, when they arrive
things start shaking from side to side - When the surface ways arrive, Love waves are
transverse so there is still side to side
shacking but you may also feel a rolling
component from the Rayleigh waves
Fig. 1.10a Bolt, 1999
Seismic waves bounce off various reflectors
within the earth
37Seismic WavesWhat You Feel During an Earthquake
- Your distance from the earthquake influences what
you feel in the earthquake - Near the earthquake focus
- Wave amplitudes are bigger so you feel more of
them - Sharp P and S waves are felt most strongly
- Far from the earthquake focus
- Since the different wave types travel at
different velocities, the waves are more spread
out in time (i.e., the shaking might last longer,
S-P difference larger) - Rolling surface waves are felt most strongly
- Why?
- Attenuation Waves attenuate (lose energy) with
increasing distance. High frequency waves
attenuate more quickly than low frequencies. - Spherical Spreading Surface waves lose less
energy with distance than body waves because
surface waves spread out in 2D and body waves
spread out in 3D. Thus, surface waves can be
felt more strongly, further away
38Seismic WavesWhat You Feel During an Earthquake
- Other Factors
- Buildings, especially tall ones, may amplify
shaking - Often people on the upper floors are the only
ones to notice small earthquakes - Buildings can continue to oscillate even after
the ground stops shaking - Prolongs the duration shaking for those inside
the building
Body wave travel paths thought the Earth
39SeismographsIntroduction
- Seismograph instrument that records the time and
amplitude of ground motions - Older instruments measured only vertical
component of deformation - Newer instruments measure three components of
motion independently Effectively have three
instruments in one seismometer - East-west component North-south component
Vertical component - Seismometer senses ground motion
Fig. 3.2 Bolt, 1999
40SeismographsOutput
http//www.mgs.md.gov/esic/seisnet/help.html
- Drum rotates as pen records ground motions
- Provides a continuous record of ground motion in
a compact fashion - Today this is done digitally (i.e. paperless
seismograms)
http//www.mgs.md.gov/esic/seisnet/help.html
41SeismogramsIntroduction
- Seismogram a record of ground motion vs. time
- Because waves oscillate in different directions,
tend to see different waves on different
components - Wave Velocities
- P-waves are fastest (arrive first)
- S-waves are next (arrive second)
- Surface waves are slowest (arrive last)
S-wave Arrival
P-wave Arrival
Surface Wave Arrival
http//www.eas.purdue.edu/braile/edumod/slinky/sl
inky.htm, similar to Fig. 8.4, Bolt, 1999
42SeismogramsTypes of Measurements
- Seismograms generally measure one of the
following - Ground Displacement
- Ground Velocity
- Ground Acceleration
http//earthquake.usgs.gov/image_glossary/displace
ment.html
43Locating Earthquakes I
- Seismic waves propagate out from the
epicenter/focus - Stations in a seismic network record the first
arrivals at times which depend on their distance
from the source
http//earthquake.usgs.gov/faq/images/seismapb.gif
44Locating Earthquakes II
- Recall that P-waves travel faster than S-waves
- The time difference between the P- and S-wave
arrivals can be used to determine the distance to
the earthquake epicenter - As distance from the focus increases, the S-P
time increases - Similar to using the time between a lighting
flash and thunder clap to determine distance to a
thunderstorm
travel time from focus to seismograph
http//www.usd.edu/esci/figures/BluePlanet.html
45Locating Earthquakes II
- Observation S-P time
- Can determine distances because scientists have
prior knowledge of S and P wave velocities in the
Earths - Velocity Distance/Time
- Distance VelocityTime
- Time Distance/Velocity
- S-P Time (Distance/VS) (Distance/VP)
- Can solve above equation for distance
http//www.tulane.edu/sanelson/geol204/eqcauses.h
tm
46Locating Earthquakes IIITriangulation
- For each seismographic station draw a circle,
centered at the station, with radius equal to the
calculated distance - Need at least 3 stations
- The more stations the better
- The epicenter of the earthquake is at the point
of intersection of the circles
Fig. 4.9 Pipkin Trent, 2001 similar to Fig.
3.6, Bolt, 1999
47Mercalli vs. Richter Measurements
http//www.wooster.edu/seismic/Images/RICHTER.gif
48Richter Magnitude
- Known/measured quantities
- S-P Time
- Wave Amplitude (corrected for distance from
focus) - Insert above information into chart and draw line
between the two points to determine Richter
magnitude - Best known
- magnitude scale
Magnitude
Amplitude
S-P Time
http//earthquake.usgs.gov/image_glossary/richter_
scale.html, same as Box 8-1, Bolt, 1999
49Richter Magnitude What the Numbers Mean
- M 2 Detectable by instruments only
- M 4 People feel faint tremors
- M 5 Structural damage begins to occur
- M 8 Stronger buildings destroyed
http//www.stvincent.ac.uk/Resources/EarthSci/Eart
h/magnitude.html
50Earthquake MeasurementOther Magnitude Scales
- For application to distant earthquakes
- Body Wave Magnitude uses the first 5 seconds of
a teleseismic (a.k.a. distant) P-wave - Surface Wave Magnitude derived from the maximum
amplitude of the Rayleigh wave - Other magnitude scales also exist
- All give approximately the same values (within
0.3-0.5 magnitude units)
http//www.essc.psu.edu/ammon/HTML/Classes/IntroQ
uakes/Notes/earthquake_size.html
51Problems With Instrumental Magnitude Measures
- Most magnitude measures underestimate the
magnitude of extremely large events - Magnitude scales saturate
- Based on instrumental measurements at a
particular point in the seismogram - Rupture lengths so long in large earthquakes that
the duration of shaking is much longer - Instrumental measures do not capture all the
information
http//www.essc.psu.edu/ammon/HTML/Classes/IntroQ
uakes/Notes/earthquake_size.html
52Earthquake MeasurementMoment Magnitude
- Moment Magnitude more accurately describes the
energy released in large earthquakes - Calculated from moment of the earthquake.
Depends on average earthquake slip, fault area,
and rigidity (resistance to motion) of the
surrounding rock - (Note Rupture Area LW)
- Moment RigidityRupture AreaAvg. Displacement
During EQ - The most widely used magnitude scale in common
practice - Magnitudes are similar to Richter magnitudes
except for largest earthquakes
http//earthquake.usgs.gov/image_glossary/seismic_
moment.html
53Earthquake MeasurementMoment Magnitude
M 7.3
- Moment magnitude is proportional to slip
magnitude and rupture area - As rupture area increases, earthquake magnitude
increases - As amount of slip increases, earthquake magnitude
increases
M 6.9
M 6.9
M 5.6
M 6.7
http//earthquake.usgs.gov/image_glossary/magnitud
e.html
54Earthquake MeasurementEnergy Release
- Earthquake magnitude scales are logarithmic such
that a unit increase in magnitude results in a
roughly 32-fold increase in the amount of energy
released during the event - e.g., Richter Magnitude
- Unit increase in magnitude 10x increase in
amplitude of ground shaking - Unit increase in magnitude 32x increase in
energy released
Magnitude Approximate Equivalent TNT Energy
4.0 1010 tons
5.0 31800
tons 6.0
1,010,000 tons 7.0
31,800,000 tons 8.0
1,010,000,000 tons 9.0
31,800,000,000 tons
55Earthquake MeasurementHow Big, How Often?
- Descriptor Magnitude Average Annually
- Great 8 and higher
1 - Major 7 - 7.9
18 - Strong 6 - 6.9
120 - Moderate 5 - 5.9
800 - Light 4 - 4.9
6,200 (estimated) - Minor 3 - 3.9
49,000 (estimated) - Very Minor 3 about 1,000 per day
-
Magnitude 1 - 2 about 8,000 per day
Data from http//wwwneic.cr.usgs.gov/neis/eqlists/
eqstats.html
56Induce Lots of Little Earthquakes?Can This
Eliminate the Big One?
- Compared to a M 7 earthquake, a M 6
earthquake releases 32 times less energy - To remove possibility of damage, induced
earthquakes should be less than M 4 (induced
earthquakes are typically M - Major plate boundary earthquakes are typically M
7-8 - 1 M8 Earthquake 32323232 M4 Earthquakes
- 1,048,576 M4
Earthquakes - 12 M4
Earthquakes per day on San Andreas Fault - Even a M 6 earthquake would require
- 1 M6 Earthquake 3232 M4 Earthquakes
- 1,024 M4
Earthquakes - 4 M4
Earthquakes per year on San Andreas Fault - And what about .
- All the other faults within the San Andreas
System - Liability insurance if something goes wrong
- Cost
Best Case Scenario
57Earthquake PredictionGoals
- Motivation
- To reduce damage to lives and property
- Prior knowledge useful for choosing sites of
critical structures (e.g. dams, nuclear reactors) - We can determine where on Earth earthquakes are
likely (plate tectonics). - There is currently no reliable way to predict
(within days to months) when a major earthquake
will occur - Can estimate earthquake times with an accuracy or
/- 50-150 years (not really practical) - Objective
- Predict the date
- Predict the location
- Predict the intensity of damage in the quake
- Japan, the former Soviet Union, China, and the
U.S. have lead the earthquake prediction effort
58Earthquake PredictionThe Prediction Dilemma
- If a prediction is made, it is generally made in
an area that is know to be seismically active - By chance alone, the odds of an earthquake are
not zero - If a firm prediction is made and nothing happens,
that must be taken as proof that the methods is
invalid (at least part of the time) - If a prediction is made and an earthquake occurs,
it cannot be taken as proof that the methods used
to make the prediction were correct. They may
fail on future occasions - Must develop body of evidence
- Generally agreed that post-predictions
(predictions made after the earthquake using data
from before the earthquake) dont count. Though
useful, the results may be biased.
59How Often Do Earthquakes Recur?
- Lithospheric plates are moving steadily at
well-known velocities - Since the plates are rigid there is relatively
little internal deformation - The plate boundaries are stuck between
earthquakes - As the plates continue to move, the force
eventually becomes so large that the plate
boundary suddenly becomes unstuck - This is an earthquake
- Accommodates relative motion between the two
plates at the plate boundary
Steady Motion
Steady Motion
Stuck Patch
similar to Fig. In This Dynamic Earth
(http//pubs.usgs.gov/publications/text/historical
.html) Plate 13, Bolt, 1999
60Seismic Gaps
Fig. 7.6, Bolt, 1999
- If it has been a long time since the last
earthquake on a certain segment of the plate
boundary, than it is a likely place for a future
earthquake - The plates move forward interminably
- To accommodate this relative motion, earthquakes
must occur repeatedly - The entire plate boundary does not break at one
time. In each earthquake only a small segment
does - Since the plate is moving at uniform velocity,
each segment must ultimately accommodate the same
amount of motion - Each plate boundary segment must keep up with the
motion of the plate interior
61Seismic GapsLoma Prieta Seismic Gap
- Seismic Gap a part of a fault that is known to
have earthquakes but that has not had one for a
long time - The earthquake makes up the deficit in motion
instantaneously
http//pubs.usgs.gov/publications/text/tectonics.h
tmlanchor19989073
62Seismic Gaps
- Seismic Gap a part of a fault that is known to
have earthquakes but that has not had one for a
long time - The earthquake makes up the deficit in motion
instantaneously
Mexico
http//tlacaelel.igeofcu.unam.mx/vladimir/guerrer
o20level/leveling.html
63Estimating Recurrence Intervals
- Terms
- Long-term fault slip rate (i.e. relative plate
velocity) often accurately know in well-studied
areas from plate tectonics - Time of last earthquake sometimes known
- Earthquake slip a matter of speculation
- Using the seismic gap hypothesis, if we assume an
average earthquake slip, than we can estimate
recurrence interval - Recurrence interval average earthquake slip /
long-term slip rate - This hypothesis predicts that earthquakes occur
at regularly repeating intervals (unfortunately,
this is not entirely true)