Expertise Oriented Approaches

1
Expertise Oriented Approaches

• The expert oriented approaches use experts in
  panel format and depend on their judgment to
  evaluate the program. This method is used by
  accreditation agencies and sports performances
  such as diving.
• Read Chapter 8 in your textbook.

2
Adversary Oriented Approaches

• These adversary oriented approaches either borrow
  from the legal system or from the debate.
  Evidence for and against the program is developed
  and presented either to a jury or to a group of
  stakeholders.
• Read Chapter 9 in your textbook.

3
Participant Oriented Approaches

• The participant oriented approaches use various
  levels of stakeholders to determine values,
  criteria, needs, data and information
  requirements for the evaluation. Parlett and
  Hamilton devised the illuminative model which
  focuses on intense scrutiny of the program.
  Stake developed the responsive model which is a
  pluralistic approach. Guba developed the
  naturalistic model which uses qualitative
  methods. Read chapter 10 of your textbook.

4
Comparative Analysis

• Read your Textbooks Chapter 11.
• Find examples of two or more evaluations for each
  of two of the six approaches. Use Figure 11.1 as
  a basis for comparing the four evaluations. Do
  you think that different approaches may produce
  different results?
• In all six approaches there seems to be five
  common areas of investigation. Look at
  evaluations from each and see if you can discern
  the common inquiries