Title: Family Therapy and Mental Health
1Family Therapy and Mental Health
- University of Guelph
- Office of Open Learning
2Course Instructor
- Carlton Brown, M.Sc., M.Div., RMFT
- 3-1216 Upper Wentworth Street, Hamilton ON L9A
4W2 - Tel 905-388-8728
- Email carl_at_mftsolutions.ca
- Slides http//www.mftsolutions.ca/Pages/MentalHea
lthCourse.html
3By the End of Today
- Schizophrenia and Bipolar Disorder
- DSM Criteria
- Types of Intervention
- Medications
- Videos
- Student Presentation
- Experiential Activities
4How Are We Doing So Far?
- Comments and/or Fishbowl
- What do you like about mental health?
- What do you not like about mental health?
- What do you want to do before the end of the
course?
4
5Definition of a Mental Disorder
- clinically significant behavioral or
psychological syndrome or pattern that occurs in
an individual and that is associated with present
distress (e.g., a painful symptom) or disability
(i.e., impairment in one or more important areas
of functioning) or with a significantly increased
risk of suffering death, pain, disability, or an
important loss of freedom.
6Mental Disorder, continued
- Must not be expectable and culturally sanctioned
response to a particular event (e.g. death of
loved one) - Must be a current manifestation of dysfunction
- Deviant behaviour and conflicts with society are
not included unless the deviance or conflict is a
symptom of individual dysfunction, as above
7But What About....
- Mental Order, or a
- Manual of the Sanities
- Christopher Peterson and Martin E.P. Seligman
(2004), Character Strengths and Virtues A
Handbook and Classification. Washington DC and
New York American Psychological Association and
Oxford University Press
7
8The DSM
- Preamble
- Childhood, Cognitive Disorders, Medical
Conditions and Substance Abuse - Schizophrenia and Other Psychotic Disorders
- Mood
- Anxiety
- Interlude
- Body, Faking, DID, Sex, Eating, Sleeping,
Impulse-Control and Adjustment - Personality and Postlude
9Mental Illness Categories
- Thinking
- Feeling
- Behaving
9
10Beware of Categories!
- Thinking affects feeling
- e.g. expectation, mood, and winning the lottery
- Feeling affects thinking
- e.g. Becks Cognitive Triad
- Im worthless
- The world is unfair
- Its not going to get better
- Thinking and Feeling affect Behaviour
- Behaviour affects Thinking and Feeling
10
11Thinking (Psychosis)
- DSM Chapter on Schizophrenia and Other Psychotic
Disorders - psychosis si'kos?s
- noun ( pl. -ses -?sez)
- a severe mental disorder in which thought and
emotions are so impaired that contact is lost
with external reality. - ORIGIN mid 19th cent. from Greek psukhosis
animation, from psukhoun give life to, from
psukhe soul, mind.
11
12Psychotic
- delusions
- hallucinations
- lack of insight
- or maybe with insight
- broaden to include other positive symptoms of
schizophrenia (disorganized speech, disorganized
or catatonic behaviour) - too broad unable to cope with life
- loss of ego boundaries
12
13(No Transcript)
14Im Still Here
- The Truth About Schizophrenia
14
15Schizophrenia
- lasts for at least 6 months
- includes at least one month of active symptoms
(delusions, hallucinations, disorganized speech,
disorganized behaviour, negative symptoms - 2 or
more unless severe)
15
16Schizophrenia and Other Psychotic Disorders
- Schizophrenia
- Schizophreniform Disorder
- less than six months, better functioning
- Schizoaffective Disorder
- active symptoms before or after (active symptoms
mood) - Delusional Disorder
- one month of nonbizarre delusions
17Schizophrenia and Other Psychotic Disorders
- Brief Psychotic Disorder
- 1 day to less than 1 month
- Shared Psychotic Disorder
- same content as another person of longer duration
- Psychotic Disorder due to a General Medical
Condition (including substance-induced) - Psychotic Disorder Not Otherwise Specified (NOS)
18Schizophrenia
- Characteristic signs and symptoms
- Positive and negative symptoms
- Present for most of a month (less if treated)
19Schizophrenia
- Some signs persisting for at least 6 months
- Marked social or occupational dysfunction
- Not better accounted for by something else
20Schizophrenia
- Wide range of cognitive and affective dysfunction
- A lot of variation among individuals
21Schizophrenia
- Positive symptoms
- Excessive or distorted normal functions
- Negative symptoms
- Diminution or loss of normal functions
22Positive Symptoms of Schizophrenia
- Psychotic
- Delusions distorted thought content
- Hallucinations distorted perceptions
- Disorganized
- Disorganized speech distorted language and
thought process - Grossly disorganized or catatonic behaviour
distorted self-monitoring of behaviour
23Negative Symptoms of Schizophrenia
- Affective flattening
- Restricted range and intensity of emotional
expression - Alogia
- Restricted fluency and productivity of thought
and speech - Avolition
- Restricted initiation of goal-directed behaviour
24Delusions
- Erroneous beliefs
- Usually involve misinterpretations of perceptions
or experiences - Many possible themes
25Delusional themes
- Persecutory someone (maybe you) is out to get me
- Referential that TV announcer is talking about
me, newspaper article is about me, biblical
prophecy is about me - Somatic I have cancer, gas poisoning, a
transmitter planted in my brain
26Delusional themes
- Grandiose I actually work for the CIA, Im the
son of God, etc. - (personal experience two deities can coexist on
the same floor, but not two government agents) - Religious delusions are common, especially if the
person is having auditory hallucinations (Who is
speaking?), and also because of lot of our
subclinical cultural context is religious
27Bizarre Delusions
- Sometimes difficult to judge what is bizarre
- If clearly impossible or not derivative of normal
life experience, then bizarre - E.g. someone has removed all my internal organs
and left no marks (bizarre) vs. the police are
watching me when in fact not true (nonbizarre)
28Hallucinations
- Most common hearing a voice or voices
- Must be fully awake
- Must not be culturally condoned
- One or more voices carrying out a running
commentary on the persons behaviour is
considered particularly characteristic of
Schizophrenia
29Disorganization
- Thinking
- Evidenced in speech, changes topics, tangential
conversation, loose associations (I saw a duck
which means Ill lose my job today) - Severely disorganized word salad,
incomprehensible - Mild disorganization is normal in university
course instructors and other non-schizophrenic
individuals
30Disorganization
- Behaviour
- Avolition, non goal oriented behaviour
- Silliness
- Unpredictable agitation
- Poor attention to ADLs (activities of daily
living), e.g. disheveled - Inappropriate, e.g. winter coat in summer, public
masturbation, unpredictable shouting, swearing
31Catatonia
- Decreased reactivity to environment
- Varying degrees
- May be unaware of surroundings, may actively
resist movement, assume bizarre posture, etc. - May be secondary to something else, not
necessarily diagnostic of schizophrenia
32Diagnosis
- Characteristic Symptoms (2 or more)
- Delusions (1 if bizarre)
- Hallucinations (1 if commentary or two or more
voices - see Im Still Here clip) - Disorganized speech
- Disorganized behaviour
- Negative symptoms
- Social or occupational dysfunction
33Diagnosis, cont
- C. Duration
- Acute 1 month
- Continuous signs 6 months
- D. Exclude
- Schizoaffective Disorder
- Mood Disorder with Psychotic features
- E. Exclude general medical condition or substance
abuse
34Diagnosis, cont.
- F. Consider Autistic or other Pervasive
Developmental Disorder, Schizophrenia may be
added under certain conditions
35Subtypes
- 295.30 Paranoid (high functioning)
- 295.10 Disorganized (hebephrenic)
- 295.20 Catatonic (Echolalia, Echopraxia)
- 295.90 Undifferentiated (Criterion A met)
- 295.60 Residual (at least one past episode of
schizophrenia, some continuing disturbance)
36Schizophreniform Disorder
- Like Schizophrenia (Criterion A met, delusions
and hallucinations), except - Total duration is 1 6 months (i.e. less than 6
months) - Dont have to have impaired social or
occupational functioning (Criterion B)
37Schizoaffective Disorder
- A. Meets criterion A for Schizophrenia and at
some point of active illness has a significant
mood disturbance (depressed, manic or mixed) - B. At least two weeks of delusions or
hallucinations without mood disturbance - C. Mood symptoms most of the time
38Delusional Disorder
- One or more nonbizarre delusions that persist for
at least 1 month - Minor hallucinations allowed
- Functioning is not impaired apart from the impact
of the delusion, e.g. if the mafia are after me,
I might wear a disguise
39Delusional Subtypes
- Erotomanic Anne Murray is in love with me
- Grandiose I am an advisor to the president, or
I have a special message from God (nonbizarre) - Jealous my spouse is unfaithful
- Persecutory Im being poisoned, blackballed,
talked about - Somatic I have bad body odor, lice, my bowel
isnt functioning properly
40Brief Psychotic
- Sudden onset of positive symptoms
- Lasts at least a day but less than a month, and
the person returns to full functioning - Exclude Mood Disorder with Psychotic Features,
Schizoaffective Disorder, Schizophrenia,
substance abuse and general medical condition
41Shared Psychotic
- Develops in an individual who has a close
relationship to another who already has a
psychotic disorder with prominent delusions - Results in shared delusions
- Very rare
42The Positive and Negative Syndrome Scale (PANSS)
- A medical scale used for measuring symptom
severity in patients with schizophrenia - Name refers to the syndrome of positive symptoms
(present) and negative symptoms (absent) observed
43The Positive and Negative Syndrome Scale (PANSS)
- Developed by Kay, S.R., Fiszbein, A. Opler, L.
(1987) - Integration of the Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale
and the Psychopathology Rating Scale - 30-item scale 7 positive symptoms, 7 negative
symptoms, 16 general psychopathology items - Scored on 7-point Likert scale by severity
44The Positive and Negative Syndrome Scale (PANSS)
- Benefits
- Broad evaluation
- Good reliability and validity (used extensively
in research) - Challenges
- Assessment is based on patients perceptions
- Long interview (30-40 min.) could be hard to
focus or tiring for patient
45Impact on Relationships
- Video clip - A Beautiful Mind
- True story
- Man with schizophrenia
- Well developed delusions
- Some of what you see is true
- Some of what you see is not true
- Imagine being his wife
46Psychosis and Marriage
- Michael P. Maniacci, The Psychotic Couple in
J. Carlson L. Sperry, eds (1998), The
Disordered Couple (Bristol, PA Brunner/Mazel),
pp. 57 - 81
47Psychotics do Marry
- Large variation in functioning
- Often intelligent eccentric good mate
- Tend to attract partners who are either
controlling or dependent - Either tends to increase stress on the
psychosis-prone partner so that illness
precipitates
48Development of Psychosis
- Predispositions
- Detached style of relating
- Eccentric
- Sense of not belonging, or of being different
- Two parallel thought patterns develop
- Consensually validated
- Idiosyncratic (private fantasies)
- Meet the minimum requirements of community, live
in private world
49Development of Psychosis
- Add stress
- Detached style leads to social isolation and
makes goal-attainment difficult - Failed goals leads to setting higher goals and
more failure - Retreat into private (fantasy) world, now even
less successful - Biological vulnerability activated
50Relational Dynamics
- Controlling partner expects performance, places
demands, increases stress, and obtains secondary
gains when partner falls ill - Dependent partner leans on psychotic partner for
leadership, increases stress, psychotic partner
falls ill, and dependent partner rallies
temporarily so the psychotic partner can rest
51Postpsychotic Conflicts
- Psychosis gives the affected partner a vacation
but the experience is traumatic to the partner
and to the patient
52Treatment
- Manage the psychosis
- Engage the non-psychotic partner to address his
or her needs and lend support and understanding - Explore the relational dynamics
- Modify individual psychodynamics
53Manage the Psychosis
- Medication helps
- Dopamine receptor antagonists (standard
antipsychotics or neuroleptics) - Haldol (haloperidol)
- Thorazine (chlorpromazine)
- Serotonin-dopamine antagonists (atypical
antipsychotics or neuroleptics) - Risperdal (risperidone)
- Clozaril (clozapine)
54Newer Antipsychotics
- Olanzapine
- Sertindole
- Quetiapine
55Treatment Protocols
- Choose a medication that has tolerable side
effects, start with a low dose - Standard antipsychotics have extrapyramidal side
effects (movement disorders) - Atypical antipsychotics have a host of other side
effects (leukopenia, weight gain) - Consider ECT as an alternative therapy
56What MFTs can do
- Encourage patients to be patient with their
doctors (the right medication at the right dose
takes time) - Encourage patients to tell their doctors what
their side effects are (stiffness, weight gain,
sexual dysfunction) - Encourage patients to stay on their medications
even when they feel well
57Effectiveness Research
- William R. McFarlane et al. (2003), Family
psychoeducation and schizophrenia a review of
the literature. Journal of Marital and Family
Therapy 29 (2), 223-245
58Family Interventions for Schizophrenia
- The Role of MFTs in Treatment
- of Serious Mental Illness
59Background The Concept of
Expressed Emotion
- Expressed Emotion (EE)
- Came about from studying why patients relapsed
- Developed over a twelve year span, 1956-1968,
involving three different research projects - Found that patients were more likely to relapse
if returning home to their parents or wives
60Background The Concept of
Expressed Emotion
- Patients were believed to be susceptible to
sensory overload - Three main components correlated highly with
relapse - Criticism, hostility, and over-involvement
- Challenge How to reduce these elements
- without blaming families?
61Family Interventions for Schizophrenia
- Four levels of intervention
- (Marsh Lefley, p.55)
- Family Consultation
- Family Education
- Family Psychoeducation
- Family Therapy
621) Family Consultation
- Meet with family members at or close to initial
crisis - Connect through identifying and normalizing
feelings - Provide information regarding illness and
treatment options - Help formulate service plan
- Connect with community resources
632) Family Education
- Approximately 80 of patients not on meds and 40
on meds relapse within one year of discharge - By reducing high EE in families, relapse rates
can go down to 13 - Need to provide effective aftercare for patients
by forming cooperative relationships with the
patients families
642) Family Education
- Survival Skills for Families
- Information about illness
- Information about illness management
- Coping Strategies
- Return to Functioning
- Continued Treatment or Disengagement
653) Family Psychoeducation
- Takes advantage of group cohesion to
- address stigma and reduce isolation
- increase hope and empower families
- assist with problem solving
- model appropriate boundaries
663) Family Psychoeducation
- Psychoeducational approach is in use most
extensively with families of patients with
schizophrenia - Families are the de facto caretakers of
individuals with schizophrenia since
deinstitutionalization - Families can be trained to create an
interactional environment that compensates for
functional disability
673) Family Psychoeducation
- Need to regulate attention and arousal by
- Antipsychotic medication
- Reducing the intensity, negativity, quantity, and
complexity of stimuli from the environment
683) Family Psychoeducation
- Educational Workshop
- 4 -7 families, 1 ½ - 2 hours, bi-weekly for 6-24
months - Begin with informal lecture and discussion with
AV aids, handouts, etc. - Sessions centre around the Family Guidelines
693) Family Psychoeducation
- Structure of sessions (p.376)
- Socialize, follow-up on task and weeks events
- Report from family
- Present relevant biosocial information
- Reminder/explanation of family guideline
- Define a workable problem
- Focus either on communication skills or problem
solving - Review
703) Family Psychoeducation
- Other techniques
- Modeling (e.g. low-key)
- Sharing common experiences
- Normalize and validate
- Mourning losses
- Emphasize strengths
- Build hope and optimism
- Shifting boundaries (e.g. cross-parenting
interventions)
714) Family Therapy
- May be provided as an adjunct to other treatments
- Not recommended in the acute or stabilization
phases - Most common method is BFT (see Falloon, Boyd
McGill, 1984 Miklowitz Goldstein, 1997 Mueser
Glynn, 1999) with focus on communication skills
and problem solving
724) Family Therapy
- Medical Family Therapy (McDaniel, Hepworth
Doherty, 1992) - Integrates concerns about health and illness in a
systems framework for psychotherapy - An approach to psychosocial aspects of illness
- Can be adapted and expanded with different
theoretical orientations
73Medical Family Therapy Techniques
- Recognize biological dimension
- Solicit the illness story
- Respect defenses, remove blame, accept
unacceptable feelings - Maintain communication
- Attend to developmental issues
- Increase a sense of agency in patient and family
- Leave the door open for future contact
74Soliciting the Illness Story
- Listen empathically
- Attempt to understand the families experience of
the illness - Empathy, respect, non-judgemental, emphasize
strengths
75Soliciting the Illness Story
- Sample questions
- What do you think caused the illness?
- What do you fear most about it?
- What might make healing now a struggle for you?
- What changes in the family do you think will be
needed now? - How do you expect other family members will react
to this?
76Soliciting the Illness Story
- Take a genogram with the family to trace their
particular history with illness and loss - Find out about family beliefs, myths, or legacies
about illness and health - What do these mean to family members?
- How do they contribute to or create a barrier to
healing? - Be sensitive to and curious about
- Cultural differences and religious beliefs
77Developmental Issues
- Progression of illness
- Interaction between illness and individual/
family development - Interaction between illness, patient, family, and
caregiver system - Put the Illness In its Place
- Dont allow the illness to dominate the familys
schedule or organize the familys emotional life
78Family Treatment Models
- Behavioural Family Therapy
79Behavioural Family Therapy
- Non-blaming stance ideal for these families
- The concept that families develop patterns of
behaviour that, while appearing counterproductive
to the observer, nevertheless represent their
best efforts to respond to their current
circumstances is the cornerstone of BFT
(Falloon, p.67)
80Behavioural Family Therapy
- Most extensively studied model of family
intervention for severe mental illness - Combines education and social learning strategies
designed to equip families with knowledge and
skills to better manage illness - Particular focus on communication and
problem-solving skills
81Behavioural Family Therapy
- Assessment (Falloon, 1991)
- Conducted on two levels
- Problem analysis
- Functional analysis
- Problem analysis is the process of pinpointing
the exact behaviours that are causing concern - Functional analysis attempts to define the
context in which these behaviours contribute to
dysfunction
82Behavioural Family Therapy
- Problem Analysis
- Individual, dyadic and family sessions are used
to join with the family and to explore each
family members perception of the problem - Patience and focus are needed to help family
describe problem in specific behavioural terms - Charting may be used to track frequency of
problem behaviours
83Behavioural Family Therapy
- Problem Analysis
- At the completion of this phase the therapist
will - Have pinpointed one or more family problems
- Have defined the frequency of their occurrence
- Have some preliminary hypotheses about the
factors contributing to the problem(s) - A hierarchy of problems to address may need to be
established
84Behavioural Family Therapy
- Functional Analysis
- Extends problem analysis to the system level
- Identifies antecedents and consequences of
problem behaviour - Antecedents are stimuli that trigger behaviour
(e.g. loud noise, drug use, lack of sleep) - Consequences are reinforcing stimuli that either
increase or decrease probability of behaviour
reoccurring
85Behavioural Family Therapy
- Sample questions for functional analysis
- What would the person (or family) gain or lose if
the problem were resolved? - Who (or what) reinforces the problem with
attention, sympathy, and support? - Under what circumstances is the problem increased
or decreased in intensity? - What do family members currently do to cope with
the problem?
86Behavioural Family Therapy
- Functional Analysis
- Also includes investigation into strengths and
weaknesses of family in coping with problem - Coping methods are evaluated in terms of
effectiveness - Shaping the familys existing coping skills is
much easier than teaching new skills from scratch - Narrative exceptions
- Solution focused translate old
skills to new problem
87Behavioural Family Therapy
- Five Techniques
- Education
- Communication training
- Problem-solving training
- Operant conditioning
- Contingency contracting
88Behavioural Family Therapy
- Education
- Could include information on illness, individual
and family development, principles of social
learning, stress management, etc. - Goal is to provide family with rationale for
management of the problem and subsequent
interventions
89Behavioural Family Therapy
- Communication training
- Skills include active listening, expressing
positive feelings, making positive requests,
expressing negative feelings, compromise and
negotiation, and requesting time out - See Mueser p.64-66 in text for summary of skills
and steps to training - Note communication skills need to precede
problem-solving skills
90Behavioural Family Therapy
- 3. Problem-solving guidelines (Jacobson
Christensen, 1996) - In stating a problem, try to begin with something
positive - Be specific
- Express your feelings
- Be brief when defining problems
- Both people should acknowledge their role in
creating and maintaining problem
91Behavioural Family Therapy
- 3. Problem-solving guidelines
- Discuss only one problem at a time
- Paraphrase
- Dont make inferences - talk only about what you
can observe - Be neutral rather than negative
- Focus on solutions
92Behavioural Family Therapy
- 3. Problem-solving guidelines
- Behaviour change should include mutuality
- and compromise
- Discuss pros and cons of proposed solutions
- Reach agreement
93Behavioural Family Therapy
- 4. Operant Conditioning Strategies
- Two predominant methods
- Shaping
- Time out procedures
- Taught through instruction, behavioural
rehearsal, and modeling
94Behavioural Family Therapy
- 5. Contingency Contracting
- Used to replace hostile, coercive, blaming
patterns by cooperative, mutually pleasing
behaviour - Contract between two or more family members that
specifies behaviours each desires the other to
perform - Rewards are included and specified
95 96Bipolar Disorder
96
97Mr. Jones
97
98Manic Episode
- Abnormally and persistently elevated, expansive,
or irritable mood - Must last at least 1 week or result in a hospital
stay - At least 3 of
- Inflated self esteem or grandiosity
- Decreased need for sleep
- Pressure of speech
99Manic Episode, continued
- At least 3 of, continued
- Flight of ideas
- Distractibility
- Increased goal seeking or psychomotor agitation
- Excessive involvement in risky, pleasurable
activities (shopping, sex, foolish business
investments) - Exclude Mixed Episode
100Manic Episode, continued
- Marked impairment in occupational or social
functioning - Not due to substance or medical condition
101Major Depressive Episode
- Five or more of the following over a two week
period, at least one of the first two - Depressed mood (irritable child or adolescent)
- Diminished interest or pleasure in almost all
activities most of the day, every day - Significant unintentional weight loss/gain
- Insomnia or hypersomnia
- Psychomotor agitation or retardation
102Major Depressive Episode
- Five or more, continued
- Fatigue or loss of energy
- Feelings of worthlessness or excessive guilt
- Difficulty thinking or concentrating
- Recurrent thoughts of death, SI, with or without
plan - Exclude Mixed Episode
- Significant impairment of occupational or social
functioning
103Major Depressive Episode
- Not due to drugs or a medical disorder
- Not due to bereavement
104Mixed Episode
- At least a week where, every day, the criteria
are met for a manic episode and a major
depressive episode - Marked impairment in social or occupational
functioning or requires hospitalization or has
psychotic features - Not due to drugs or a general medical condition
105Hypomanic Episode
- Abnormally and persistently elevated, expansive
or irritable mood lasting at least 4 days - At least three of
- Inflated self esteem or grandiosity (non
delusional) - Decreased need for sleep
- Pressure of speech
106Hypomanic
- At least three, continued
- Flight of ideas
- Distractibility
- Increased goal-seeking or psychomotor agitation
- Excessive involvement in high risk pleasure
activities - Four of the above if irritable
- Otherwise like Manic Episode except not
delusional or hallucinatory
107Bipolar Disorders
- Bipolar I
- One or more manic or mixed episodes
- At least one major depressive episode
- Dont count substance or medical condition
induced episodes - Exclude schizoaffective disorder and other
psychotic disorders
108Bipolar Disorders
- Bipolar II
- One or more major depressive episodes
- At least one hypomanic episode
- Bipolar I
- Mostly up, more likely hospitalized for mania
- Bipolar II
- Mostly down, more likely hospitalized for
depression
109Treatment
- Lithium and other mood stabilizers
- Very effective, bad side effects
- Go back and review the treatments for
schizophrenia - Apply the same techniques, adapted for primarily
mood disorders
110Stigma Mental Health
- 1 in 5 Canadians will develop a mental health
problem in their lifetime (CAMH) - Many do not seek help because of the stigma of
having a mental health problem - Stigma includes
- Prejudice (neg. attitudes)
- Discrimination (neg. behaviours)
111Stigma Mental Health
- Stigma affects people in three ways
- Exclusion from normal activities and
opportunities including work, housing, etc. - Internalization stigma is internalized,
contributing to shame and isolation - Contributes to maintaining the secret
112330 430
- Benny and Joon
- Therapist tag
- Charades
- SRS
113(No Transcript)
114430 500
- Next class Friday, October 1st
- Here (same place)
- Personality Disorders