Title: FDA Advisory Panel
1Medtronic InSync ICD Cardiac Resynchronization
System
- FDA Advisory Panel
- March 5, 2002
2Agenda
3Introduction and Background
4Introduction
- Over a third of moderate to severe heart failure
patients (in NYHA Functional Class III or IV)
have ventricular dysynchrony, evidenced by a QRS
duration ? 130 ms1 - Associated with
- Limited exercise tolerance
- Impaired quality of life and functional capacity
- Poor left ventricular systolic function2
1 Aaronson KD, et al. Circulation 1997
952660-2667. 2 Zardini M, et al. Eur Heart J
2000 2(Suppl J) J16-J22
5InSync Study Design
Implant Attempt
Successful Implant
Pre-discharge Randomization
Baseline
? 1 week
Stable Medical Therapy
Double Blinded
Control
CRT
1, 3, 6 Month Follow-up
1, 3, 6 Month Follow-up
- Control VDI mode
- Treatment (CRT) VDD mode
CRT
CRT
Long term follow up every 6 months
6InSync Study Primary Endpoints
PMA P010015, approved 8/28/01
7InSync Study Secondary Clinical Endpoints
8InSync Primary Safety Results Summary
- Achieved all primary 6-month safety objectives
including - Implant success
- 6-month device related complications attributed
to - InSync Model 8040
- Attain Models 2187 and Model 2188 LV leads
- InSync system
- Attain Models 2187 and 2188 LV lead 6-month
pacing threshold
9InSyncDeath or Worsening Heart Failure
RequiringHospitalization or IV Medications
P 0.02
CRT
Control
Patients At Risk
10Combining Resynchronization and ICD Function in
a Single Device
- Model 7272 InSync ICD
- Dual-chamber VT and VF detection
- Antitachycardia (ATP) pacing, cardioversion and
defibrillation VT and VF therapies - Simultaneous biventricular pacing
- RV sensing only
11Study Design, Methodology andPatient Population
12Entry Criteria
- Chronic heart failure
- ? 18 years of age
- NYHA Functional Class II, III or IV
- QRS duration ? 130 ms
- LVEF ? 35
- LVEDD ? 55 millimeters (echo measure)
- Stable HF medical regimen for ? 1 month
- ACE-I or substitute, if tolerated
- ß-blocker - stable regimen for ? 3 months
- Indication for an ICD
13InSync ICD Study Design
Implant Attempt
Successful Implant
Pre-discharge Randomization
Baseline
? 1 week
Stable Medical Therapy
Double Blinded
Control
CRT
1, 3, 6 Month Follow-up
1, 3, 6 Month Follow-up
- Control DDI mode
- Treatment (CRT) DDD mode
- ICD active in all patients
- Heart failure medication stability maintained
CRT
CRT
Long term follow up every 6 months
14Timing of Baseline Tests
15Study Features to Maintain the Blind
- Blinded
- Patients (study ID card)
- Heart failure staff
- Listed on study blinding log
- Blinded to ECGs
- Conducted QOL, 6 minute hall walk, patients
global assessment, NYHA classification and HF
exam - Events Classification Committee
- Unblinded
- EP staff
- Listed on study blinding log
- Viewed ECGs, device printouts, etc
- Data placed into secure study envelopes
16Primary Safety Objectives
- InSync ICD-related complication-free survival at
3 months - Attain Model 4189 LV lead-related
complication-free survival at 6 months - Attain Model 2187/2188 LV lead- related
complication-free survival at 6 months - InSync ICD system-related complication-free
survival at 6 months
17Secondary Safety Objectives
- Characterize patient survival
- Characterize complication events
- Characterize observation events
18Lead Effectiveness Objectives
- Implant success
- Evaluate the electrical performance of the Model
4189 LV lead - Evaluate the electrical performance of the Model
2187 and Model 2188 LV leads
19Evaluation of Integrity of ICD Function
- Spontaneous VT/VF therapy effectiveness
- Comparison of VT/VF event rates in the control
and treatment arms - ATP therapy efficacy with biventricular pacing
- Implant ventricular defibrillation criterion
20Primary Effectiveness Endpoints
- As pre-specified in the investigational plan for
NYHA Class III and IV patients, the following
change from baseline to 6-month visit between
control and treatment groups in - Quality of life (MLWHF Questionnaire)
- NYHA class
- 6-minute hall walk distance
- As pre-specified in the investigational plan, all
3 endpoints must be met at P lt 0.05, or 2 met at
P lt 0.025, or 1 met at P lt 0.0167
21Secondary Effectiveness Endpoints
- Clinical endpoints
- Exercise performance
- Clinical composite response
- Health care utilization
- Physiological variables
- Echocardiographic variables
- QRS duration
- Neurohormonal variables
22Study Milestones
PMA Update submitted November 9, 2001
PMA submitted May 3, 2001
1st implant October 4, 1999
100 NYHA Class III IV 6-month visitsMarch, 2001
224 NYHA Class III IV 6-month visitsOctober,
2001
23Patient Disposition
As pre-specified in the I.P., data from NYHA
Class III/IV patients are discussed in this
presentation
Implant Attempts n636
NYHA Class III/IV n421
NYHA Class II n215
Randomized n362
Randomized n192
Control n176
CRT n186
Control n106
CRT n86
24Patient Disposition
Implant Attempts n421
Unsuccessful Implants n50
Implant Success n371
Not Randomized n9
Randomized n362
Control n176
CRT n186
25Patient Disposition
Control n 176
CRT n 186
26Methodology Overview
- Safety Data
- As pre-specified in the investigational plan,
data from NYHA Class II, III and IV patients were
submitted to FDA for the primary safety
objectives - At FDAs request, safety data from NYHA Class III
and IV patients only are included in the Panel
Pack and in this presentation
27Methodology Overview
- Efficacy Data
- The investigational plan pre-specified that the
primary efficacy analysis was to be based on
patients with paired data at 6 months, excluding
crossovers - Results presented are based on an intent-to-treat
analysis for patients with paired data at 6
months, including crossovers - Results of the pre-specified crossover excluded
and last-observation-carried forward analyses
will also be summarized
28Patient Demographics
29Patient Demographics
30Safety Results
31Primary Safety Objectives
- InSync ICD-related complication-free survival at
3 months - Attain Model 4189 LV lead-related
complication-free survival at 6 months - Attain Model 2187/2188 LV lead- related
complication-free survival at 6 months - InSync ICD system-related complication-free
survival at 6 months
32Secondary Safety Objectives
- Characterize patient survival
- Characterize complication events
- Characterize observation events
33Lead Effectiveness Objectives
- Implant success
- Evaluate the electrical performance of the Model
4189 LV lead - Evaluate the electrical performance of the Model
2187 and Model 2188 LV leads
34Evaluation of Integrity of ICD Function
- Spontaneous VT/VF therapy effectiveness
- Comparison of VT/VF event rates in the control
and treatment arms - ATP therapy efficacy with biventricular pacing
- Implant ventricular defibrillation criterion
35Lead Placement and LV Venous Anatomy
A. Lateral (marginal) cardiac vein B.
Postero-lateral cardiac vein C. Posterior
cardiac vein D. Middle cardiac vein E. Great
cardiac vein
A
- Attain LV Model 4189
- Transvenous, 4 French
- Stylet/catheter Delivered
- Unipolar
B
C
E
D
36Adverse Event Definitions
- Complication An adverse event requiring invasive
intervention or that results in the death of or
serious injury to the patient or in the
termination of a significant device function - Observation An adverse event not requiring
invasive intervention or resolves spontaneously - System-related complication A device-related
complication that occurs after the initially
implanted functioning system, comprised of
Model 7272 InSync ICD, a Model 4189, 2187 or 2188
LV lead, and RA and RV leads
37Implant Success
Patient Implant Attempts n421
Unsuccessful Implants n50
Implant Success n371
Implant success defined per the protocol as a
successfully placed LV lead.
38Unsuccessful Implants (n50)
Not mutually exclusive
39Adverse Events During the Implant Procedure
40Resolution of Adverse Events During the Implant
Procedure
Categories not mutually exclusive.
41Resolution of Implant Dissection/Perforation
Events
- 432 implant attempts
- 22 events (22 patients)
No patient deaths related to these events.
42Primary Safety Objective 1 Freedom From InSync
ICD Related Complications at 3 Months
- 371 patients implanted
- 7 complications in 7 patients
- Observed 3-month rate 98.6
- Lower 95 confidence bound 97.6
- Performance objective 95 LCB ? 89
Performance Objective
43Freedom From InSync ICD Related Complications at
3 Months
- 371 patients implanted
- 7 events (7 patients)
44Primary Safety Objective 2 Freedom From Attain
Model 4189 LV Lead-Related Complications at 6
Months
- 315 patients implanted
- 49 events (in 44 patients)
- Observed 6-month rate 85.1
- Lower 95 confidence bound 81.7
- Performance objective 95 LCB ? 75
Performance Objective
45Freedom From Attain Model 4189 LV Lead-Related
Complications at 6 Months
- 315 patients implanted
- 49 events (44 patients)
Not mutually exclusive
46Attain Model 4189 LV Lead Related Complication
Event Resolution
Not mutually exclusive
47Primary Safety Objective 3Freedom From Attain
Model 2187/2188 LV Lead-Related Complications at
6 Months
- 56 patients implanted
- 5 events in 5 patients
- Observed 6-month rate 89.9
- Lower 95 confidence bound 82.9
- Performance objective 95 LCB ? 75
Performance Objective
48Freedom From Attain Model 2187/2188 LV
Lead-Related Complications at 6 Months
- 56 patients implanted
- 5 events (5 patients)
49Primary Safety Objective 4InSync ICD
System-Related Complications at 6 Months
- 371 patients implanted
- 79 events in 65 patients
- Observed 6 month rate 81.1
- Lower 95 confidence bound 77.6
- Performance objective 95 LCB ? 67
Performance Objective
50Primary Safety Results Summary
- All primary safety objectives satisfied
- Device-related complications attributed to
- InSync ICD Model 7272
- Attain Models 4189, 2187 and 2188 leads
- InSync ICD system
51Secondary Safety Results
52Spontaneous VT/VF Therapy Effectiveness
-
- VT terminated after all therapies were delivered
(5 episodes) - FVT/VT terminated after redetection but before
additional therapies could be delivered (4
episodes) - VF terminated after all therapies were delivered
(1 episode)
53VT/VF Episodes Control vs. CRTPatients
Completing 6 Months of Follow-up
54ATP Efficacy During Spontaneous VT
55Ventricular Defibrillation Testing
56Lead Effectiveness Results
57Lead Effectiveness Objective 1Implant Success
Results
- Performance Objective
- Lower 95 Confidence Limit gt 83
- Results
- Observed rate 371 successes / 421 attempts
88.1 - Lower Limit of 2-Sided 95 C.I. 84.6
Implant success defined per the protocol as a
successfully placed LV lead.
58Lead Effectiveness Objective 2 Attain Model
4189 LV Lead Pacing Threshold Performance
- Performance Objective
- The upper 95 confidence bound for the mean
pacing voltage threshold is lt 3.0 Volts - Results
- Mean 6-month pacing threshold 1.5 Volts ? 0.9
Volts - Upper limit of 2-sided 95 confidence interval
1.7 Volts
59Voltage Pacing Threshold for Attain Model 4189 LV
Leads
n424
n416
n381
n306
n125
n35
n441
1.5
1.7
1.6
1.5
1.5
1.7
1.5
60Lead Effectiveness Objective 3 Attain Model
2187/2188 LV Lead Pacing Threshold Performance
- Performance Objective
- The upper 95 confidence bound for the mean
pacing voltage threshold is lt 3.0 Volts - Results
- Mean 6-month pacing threshold 1.9 Volts ? 1.0
Volts - Upper limit of 2-sided 95 confidence interval
2.2 Volts
61Voltage Pacing Threshold for Attain Model
2187/2188 LV Leads
n82
n79
n74
n62
n29
n18
n79
1.6
1.7
2.3
1.9
1.7
1.7
1.9
62Effectiveness Results
63Primary Efficacy Endpoints
Change from baseline to 6-month follow up between
control and treatment groups in
- QOL score
- NYHA class
- 6 minute hall walk distance
64Change in Quality of Life Score
P0.0098
Score (Median)
? -19
? -10
Control n 119
CRT n 128
65Change in NYHA Functional Class
P0.028
66Change in NYHA Functional Class
Control (n 123)
CRT (n 131)
67Change in 6-Minute Hall Walk Distance
P0.408
Distance Walked (Median)
? 56
? 53
Control n 118
CRT n 122
68Summary of Effect on Primary Endpoints
69Secondary Effectiveness Results
70Secondary Effectiveness Endpoints
- Clinical endpoints
- Exercise performance
- Clinical composite response
- Healthcare utilization
- Physiological variables
- Echocardiographic variables
- QRS duration
- Plasma neurohormones
71Secondary Effectiveness ResultsClinical
Endpoints
72Exercise PerformancePeak VO2 and Exercise
Duration
P0.05
Plt0.001
? 0.0
? -26
? 58
? 1.1
Control n 93
CRT n 96
Control n 96
CRT n 97
73Clinical Composite Response - Definition
- Improved
- Improved NYHA class or global assessment
- Worsened
- Death worsening heart failure leading to
hospitalization or permanent withdrawal of
therapy or worsening of NYHA class or global
assessment - No Change
Packer et al. J Cardiac Failure 20017176-182.
74Clinical Composite Response Results
P 0.038
75Hospitalization ResultsTotal Days Hospitalized
Through 6 Months
All-Cause Hospitalization
Heart Failure Hospitalization
P 0.18
P 0.11
Control Group 134 hospitalizations
(79 pts) CRT Group 127
hospitalizations (75 pts)
Control Group 70 hospitalizations (47
pts) CRT Group 54
hospitalizations (39 pts)
76InSync ICDDeath or Worsening Heart Failure
RequiringHospitalization or IV Medications
P 0.07
CRT
Control
Patients At Risk
77Secondary Effectiveness ResultsPhysiological
Variables
78Change in Echo Parameters
79Change in Echo/ECG Parameters
80Change in Neurohormone Levels
81Comparison of InSync and InSync ICD
82InSync ICD Study Design
Implant Attempt
Successful Implant
Pre-discharge Randomization
Baseline
? 1 week
Stable Medical Therapy
Double Blinded
Control
CRT
1, 3, 6 Month Follow-up
1, 3, 6 Month Follow-up
- Control DDI mode
- Treatment (CRT) DDD mode
- ICD active in all patients
- Heart failure medication stability maintained
CRT
CRT
Long term follow up every 6 months
83Timing of Baseline Tests
84Comparison of Patient Demographics InSync and
InSync ICD
85Comparison of Patient Demographics InSync and
InSync ICD
86Change in Quality of Life Score(InSync ICD vs.
InSync)
InSync
InSync ICD
P0.010
P0.003
87Change in NYHA Class(InSync ICD vs. InSync)
InSync
InSync ICD
Plt0.001
P0.02
88Change in 6-Minute Hall Walk Distance (InSync
ICD vs. InSync)
InSync
InSync ICD
P0.003
P0.408
89InSync and InSync ICD StudiesPrimary Endpoints
White InSync Study Yellow InSync ICD Study
90InSync and InSync ICD StudiesSecondary Clinical
Endpoints
White InSync Study Yellow InSync ICD Study
91InSync ICDDeath or Worsening Heart Failure
RequiringHospitalization or IV Medications
P 0.07
CRT
Control
Patients At Risk
92InSyncDeath or Worsening Heart Failure
RequiringHospitalization or IV Medications
P 0.02
CRT
Control
Patients At Risk
93Hospitalization Results InSync ICDTotal Days
Hospitalized Through 6 Months
All-Cause Hospitalization
Heart Failure Hospitalization
P 0.18
P 0.11
Control Group 134 hospitalizations
(79 pts) CRT Group 127
hospitalizations (75 pts)
Control Group 70 hospitalizations (47
pts) CRT Group 54
hospitalizations (39 pts)
94Hospitalization Results InSyncTotal Days
Hospitalized Through 6 Months
All-Cause Hospitalization
Heart Failure Hospitalization
P0.002
P0.083
Control Group 99 hospitalizations (60 pts)
CRT Group 80 hospitalizations (57 pts)
Control Group 39 hospitalizations (27 pts)
CRT Group 20 hospitalizations (14 pts)
95The End