The blind leading the blind

1
?????

• The blind leading the blind

2
??????
3

• ??

4
(No Transcript)
5
???????

• ?????????????
• ??????
• ??????
• ?????????
• ?????????????
• ???????????
• ?????????????
• ??????????????

6
????????

• ????
• ???????,??????????
• ??????????????????
• ????????????(De-optimise)

• ????
• ?S?????,??????????
• ????S???????
• ??S????,???????,?????

???????1X????????X????
7
??????

• ??
• ???
• ???(brainstorming)
• ???????
• ????
• TRIZ
• ?????????
• ???????
• ????
• ???
• ?????

??(Transfer)

• ????
• ????
• ????
• ????

?????????
???????????
8
(No Transcript)
9
????????????
?????? ??????
????2/3?? ????1/3??
?????????? ????????????
???????????? ??????????
???? ??CAD?????
10
??

• ??????????????,???????????,???????,???????????????
  
• ????????????????,????,???????????????,????
• ????????????????,????1X???X??,??????????????

11
?? ??????

• ????????????????,??????
• ??????
• ???????????????????????????
• ??????????
• ?????????????????

12
(No Transcript)
13
(No Transcript)
14
What is design tutorial?
15
Master and apprentice' model

• Master is omnipotent
• Master demonstrate
• Apprentice mimic
• Master correct apprentice

16
Everything in master and apprentice model is
predictableApprentices will become masters
eventually, after a long time
17
Difficulties in mentoring

• May not know the issue/topic
• Have no time to learn the topic
• Have no time to design a correct answer
• Not sure if a correct answer exist
• Even if the mentor has a correct answer, he
  must tell the student the answer immediately, and
  then abandon the topic!

18
?????

• ?????
• ????????????
• ????????,?????????
• ???????????????????
• ????????????????
• ??????????????????

19
??????????

• ?????
• ??????????????????
• ????????????,???????????????
• ????????????????,???????
• ????,????????????????????,????????

20
Design is Engineering is Science
?????,??????,??????,??????????,???????? ??