Title: International Taxation
1International Taxation
- Introduction
- Howard Godfrey, Ph.D., CPA
2- International Taxation
- The U.S. imposes taxes on worldwide income of
U.S. taxpayers (citizens, resident aliens and
corporations organized in the U.S.). - The U.S. imposes taxes on non-resident aliens
(not U.S. citizens) and non-resident entities on
income earned in the U.S. - A foreign person, who becomes a U.S. resident, is
taxed like a U.S. citizen (on worldwide income). - A foreign owned corp. that is organized in this
country is subject to U.S. income taxes. Etc.
3(No Transcript)
4(No Transcript)
5(No Transcript)
6Notes for case for Bud
- Please note that the case for Bud involves a U.S.
tax person. Same principles apply for a U.S.
corporation with a branch in the foreign country,
or a U.S. proprietorship with a branch operation
in the foreign country. - These concepts do not apply to a foreign person
with income earned in the U.S.(Alien working in
U.S., etc.)
7(No Transcript)
8- Please note the variety of ways the tax systems
of various countries may interact with each
other. - In a territorial system, each country imposes
taxes on income earned in its territory. - In a world-wide or global system, a county taxes
income earned worldwide by its citizens. This may
cause income to be taxed in more than one
country. - Double taxation. Credits allowed, etc.
9- The following slides involve the taxation of
income earned in the U.S. and income earned in
the U.K. - The tax rates are hypothetical and various
assumptions are made regarding the nature of the
tax systems territorial, world-wide, etc. - The examples are designed to illustrate important
concepts and may not accurately reflect the tax
systems actually in effect in the countries.
10(No Transcript)
11(No Transcript)
12(No Transcript)
13(No Transcript)
14(No Transcript)
15(No Transcript)
16(No Transcript)
17(No Transcript)
18(No Transcript)
19(No Transcript)
20- Note you can repeat the slides above for a U.S.
Corporation. The U.S. corporation has net income
from U.S. operations of 100,000 and net income
from a branch office in a foreign country. - The same principles apply.
- Other rules apply for foreign Sub.
21- Note The first slide (results) for Bud involves
him simply excluding the income earned in a
foreign country. That is the essence of Sec. 911,
which allows a worker in a foreign country to
exclude 80,000 per year, as well as certain
housing costs.
22(No Transcript)
23(No Transcript)
24(No Transcript)
25(No Transcript)
26- Look at Example 16-3 and the preceding formula
for the tax credit limit. - What happens if she also earns some interest
income in a foreign country that does not impose
an income tax. - Would that cause the value of the fraction on the
tax credit formula slide to be larger, leading to
a larger credit limit? - No. See Tax Credit Limits example 16-4
- Baskets and separate limits for them!!!!!
27(No Transcript)
28(No Transcript)
29(No Transcript)
30(No Transcript)
31(No Transcript)
32(No Transcript)
33(No Transcript)
34- Foreign Tax Credit
- Jackson Corp.s taxable income for 2006 from all
of its global operations was 500,000, resulting
in U.S. federal income tax of 200,000 before
credits. Jacksons taxable income from foreign
sources was 125,000 during 2006. Jackson paid
income taxes of 60,000 to foreign governments.
What is Jacksons foreign tax credit limitation
for 2006? - a. 200,000 b. 60,000
- c. 50,000 d. 12,500
35(No Transcript)
36(No Transcript)
37Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- CHOOSING A DEDUCTION, CREDIT OR EXCLUSION
- A taxpayer should carefully choose between (1) a
deduction for foreign income taxes, - (2) a credit on for foreign income taxes, or
- (3) an exclusion of up to 80,000 of foreign
earnings from U.S. gross income.
38Case 1-1
- Case 1. A U.S. citizen has the opportunity to
earn an extra 100,000, and that income is earned
in a foreign country. The taxpayers U.S. income
tax is 30,000 (marginal rate of 30) on the
foreign income and the foreign government imposes
an income tax of 20,000 on that income.
39(No Transcript)
40Case 1-3
- The Code provides a deduction for foreign income
taxes paid. A deduction of 20,000 for these
taxes will generate a tax savings of 6,000 (30
of 20,000). - However, a tax credit for these foreign taxes
will yield a savings on U.S. income tax of
20,000. - The greatest saving is realized by excluding
100,000 from U.S. income, thereby saving U.S.
income tax of 30,000.
41Case 1-4
- Best situation is to earn tax-free income in
foreign country and exclude it from the U.S.
income tax computations.
42Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- Section 911 provides an (a)
- (1) exclusion of up to 80,000 of foreign earned
income - (2) exclusion for foreign housing costs by
employees and - (3) deduction of certain foreign housing costs by
self-employed individuals.
43Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- Sara applies for and receives a work assignment
in England for Big Corp. She moved to London on
1-1-2006. She worked and lived there continuously
until the middle of 2007, when she returned to
the U.S. Her salary is 200,000 per year, in both
2006 and 2007. What is the amount of her foreign
earned income exclusion for 2007? - a. 0 b. 40,000 c. 60,000 d. 80,000
44Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- A taxpayer working in a foreign country reports
total world-wide income on Form 1040 and then
takes a deduction for AGI for the exclusions
provided by Section 911. In effect, the
exclusions are taken via deductions on the Form
1040.
45Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- The terms foreign, abroad and overseas
refer to a situation in which a taxpayer lives
and works in a foreign country.
46Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- Regular Tax Rules Continue to Apply. A taxpayer
working abroad is subject to all of the tax rules
applicable to those living in this country, and
must deal with additional rules that are uniquely
applicable those with foreign income.
47Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- Regular Tax Rules Continue to Apply. Worldwide
income is reported on the Form 1040, even though
the foreign income may be subject to foreign
income taxes as well.
48Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- A taxpayer working abroad is subject to the
regular rules that require inclusion in income of
all fringe benefits that do not qualify for
exclusion under Section 132 or other sections of
the code. For example, fringe benefits in the
form of the right to use the employers property
or facilities are fully taxable unless excluded
under Section 119.
49Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- Case 1. A taxpayer lives in Japan and is employed
there all year. He receives a salary of 6,000 a
month. He lives rent-free in a house provided by
the employer that has a fair rental value of
3,000 a month. The house is not provided for the
employers convenience. The taxpayer has 72,000
salary from foreign sources plus 36,000 fair
rental value of the house, for a total of
108,000 of foreign earned income. - These amounts may be excluded as foreign housing
costs or as part of foreign earned income.
50Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- Self-Employment Tax. A self-employed taxpayer is
generally subject to the same rules for paying
self-employment tax whether he lives in the
United States or abroad.
51Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- Case 2. A consultant works abroad and qualifies
for the foreign earned income exclusion. Foreign
gross income is 95,000, business deductions
total 27,000, and net profit is 68,000.
52Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- Case 2.
- Self-employment tax is paid on all of net profit,
including the amount excluded from income for
regular income tax purposes (unless there is an
agreement with the foreign country so that only
one country imposes social security tax or S.E
tax ).
53Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- Allocating Income to a Tax Year. The foreign
earned income exclusion of up to 80,000 per year
makes it important to accurately identify the
year in which foreign income is earned.
54Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- Case 3. A taxpayer in a foreign country has
tax-free income of 160,000 over a two-year
period when he earns 80,000 in 2005 and 80,000
in 2006. If the same taxpayer earns 70,000 in
2005 and 90,000 in 2006, he will have tax-free
income of only 150,000 in the same two year
period.
55Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- Case 3. However, assume the compensation of
90,000 received in 2006 actually included a
bonus of 10,000 for service in 2005. In this
case, he will qualify for an exclusion of 90,000
on the 2006 tax return consisting of 80,000
for 2006 and 10,000 of the unused exclusion from
2005.
56Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- When working with compensation for services, it
is necessary to compute the amount of gross
income to be excluded, and then disallow the
deductions for certain expenditures that are
identified with excluded income.
57Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- Case 4. An employee works for an employer for the
entire year but works in a foreign country for
only 11 months of the year. Only the gross income
earned in the foreign country will be excluded,
up to a prorated amount of the 80,000 maximum
exclusion.
58Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- Case 4 Contd.
- A deduction for unreimbursed employee expenses
will be disallowed, to the extent they relate to
gross income that is excluded.
59Questions to Ask About Income
- Is the income required to be included in gross
income under general tax rules? - Is the income classified as U.S. income or
foreign source income? - Is the income classified as earned income?
- In what year was the income earned? (It is
generally allocated to the year in which it was
earned, and is subject to the annual exclusion
limit for that year).
60Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- The benefits of Section 911 are available even
though the foreign earned income may be
tax-exempt in the foreign country. This means a
U.S. citizen or resident alien working in a
foreign country may earn income that is entirely
free of income taxes. Investment income and other
income that is not considered foreign earned
income are not covered by Section 911.
61Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- Section 911(a) of the Code allows a "qualified
individual," as defined in 911(d)(1), to exclude
foreign earned income and housing cost amounts
from gross income. - Section 911(c)(4) of the Code allows a qualified
individual to deduct housing cost amounts from
gross income.
62Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- Section 911(d)(1) of the Code defines the term
"qualified individual" as an individual whose tax
home is in a foreign country and who is - (A) a citizen of the United States and
establishes to the satisfaction of the Secretary
of the Treasury that the individual has been a
bona fide resident of a foreign country or
countries for an uninterrupted period that
includes an entire taxable year, or
63Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- Section 911(d)(1) of the Code defines the term
"qualified individual" as an individual whose tax
home is in a foreign country and who is - ---
- (B) a citizen or resident of the United States
who, during any period of 12 consecutive months,
is present in a foreign country or countries
during at least 330 full days.
64Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- 26 U.S.C. 911(a)(1). "Foreign earned income" is
the amount an individual receives "from sources
within a foreign country ... which constitutes
earned income attributable to services performed
by such individual" during the applicable time
period described in 26 U.S.C. 911(d)(1)(A) or
(B).
65Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- Under 911(d)(1)(A) or (B), to qualify for the
exclusion, the individual's tax home must be in a
foreign country and the individual must be a
United States citizen who has been a bona fide
resident of the foreign country for the entire
tax year or a United States citizen or resident
who has been present in the foreign country for
at least 330 full days of twelve consecutive
months. See also 26 C.F.R. 1.911-2(a).
66Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- The regulations define a "foreign country" as
"any territory under the sovereignty of a
government other than that of the United States,"
id. 1.911-2(h), and "United States" to "include
any territory under the sovereignty of the United
States," including its "possessions and
territories," id. 1.911-2(g).
67Exclusion Example
- The following slides contain an example that
illustrates the overall procedure.
68(No Transcript)
69(No Transcript)
70(No Transcript)
71Foreign Operations
- The easiest way for a U.S. enterprise to engage
in global commerce is simply to sell
U.S.-produced goods and services abroad. These
sales can be conducted with little or no foreign
presence and allow the business to explore
foreign markets without making costly financial
commitments to foreign operations.
72Foreign Operations
- The U.S. tax consequences of simple export sales
are straightforward. All such income is taxed in
the United States to the U.S. taxpayer. Whether
foreign taxes must be paid on this export income
depends on the particular law of the foreign
jurisdiction and whether the U.S. taxpayer is
deemed to have a foreign business presence there
(often called a "permanent establishment").
73Foreign Operations
- Tax rules applicable to U.S. persons that control
business operations in foreign countries depend
on whether the business operations are conducted
directly (through a foreign branch, for example)
or indirectly (through a separate foreign
corporation).
74Foreign Operations
- A U.S. person that conducts foreign operations
directly includes the income and losses from such
operations on the person's U.S. tax return for
the year the income is earned or the loss is
incurred.
75Alt. Forms for Foreign Operations
- Detailed rules are provided for the translation
into U.S. currency of amounts with respect to
such foreign operations. The income from the U.S.
person's foreign operations thus is subject to
current U.S. tax. However, the foreign tax credit
may reduce or eliminate the U.S. tax on such
income.
76Alt. Forms for Foreign Operations
- A U.S. company can enter foreign markets in a
number of ways. - It may simply hire foreign sales representatives
to market its products in other countries. - It may permit unrelated foreign companies to use
patents, processes and trademarks that it
developed through licensing arrangements.
77Alt. Forms for Foreign Operations
- These two alternatives involve no physical
presence by the U.S. company in the foreign
jurisdiction thus, the income earned might or
might not be subject to foreign taxes, depending
on the applicable treaty provisions if a treaty
exists.
78Alt. Forms for Foreign Operations
- To expand foreign operations, having a physical
presence in the foreign country can become
necessary. - The legal form for establishing this presence has
four basic alternatives and is critical to
determining the U.S. tax consequences of the
resulting foreign income.
79Foreign Branch Operations
- First the U.S. corporation can simply establish a
branch office in the foreign country. - Such a branch is not a legal entity distinct from
the U.S. Corporation thus any income it earns is
included in worldwide taxable income. - If the U.S. corporation pays taxes in the foreign
country on branch earnings, it can claim a
foreign tax credit subject to the same rules and
limits.
80Alt. Forms for Foreign Operations
- Second, the U.S. corporation could conduct
operations in partnership with others. Its share
of partnership income is subject to U.S. taxation
The corporation's share of any foreign income
taxes paid on partnership earnings is assed
through to the corporation and is includible in
its foreign tax credit.
81- Foreign Branch Operations
82Foreign Branch Operations
- Sections 985 through 989 of the Internal Revenue
Code of 1986 to provide rules for the treatment
of foreign currency transactions. Section 985(a)
provides that, unless otherwise provided in
regulations, all determinations under subtitle A
of the Code shall be made in the taxpayer's
functional currency (as defined in section
985(b)).
83Alt. Forms for Foreign Operations
- Second, the U.S. corporation could conduct
operations in partnership with others. Its share
of partnership income is subject to U.S. taxation
The corporation's share of any foreign income
taxes paid on partnership earnings is assed
through to the corporation and is includible in
its foreign tax credit.
84Alt. Forms for Foreign Operations
- The third and fourth alternatives involve the
formation of a controlled subsidiary to conduct
foreign operations, - incorporated in either the United States or a
foreign country.
85- Foreign Corporate Operations
86Alt. Forms for Foreign Operations
- Controlled Subsidiaries
- For tax and nontax purposes, the U.S. corporation
might wish to establish a controlled subsidiary
to engage in foreign operations. - Such a subsidiary is a separate legal entity with
the U.S. corporation as the controlling (often
sole) shareholder.
87Alt. Forms for Foreign Operations
- Controlled Subsidiaries
- In many foreign countries, legal restrictions
exist on foreign ownership of property. Thus,
operation through a foreign subsidiary might be
the only feasible alternative. In other
countries, so-called branch profits taxes could
discourage the use of a branch operation and
favor the establishment of a subsidiary. The
optimal choice varies from country to country and
situation to situation.
88Alt. Forms for Foreign Operations
- Taxation of the controlled subsidiary's earnings
depends on whether the subsidiary is incorporated
in the United States or in a foreign country. - A controlled U.S. subsidiary's income is subject
to U.S. taxation when earned under general
corporate tax rules.
89Alt. Forms for Foreign Operations
- If the controlled U.S. sub pays dividends to its
parent, the dividends typically qualify for the
100 percent dividends-received deduction and thus
produce no U.S. tax at the time of repatriation.
The U.S. parent's consolidated tax return
includes the controlled U.S. subsidiary, and the
consolidated group claims a foreign tax credit
related to the subsidiary's foreign income and
foreign taxes paid.
90Alt. Forms for Foreign Operations
- A controlled foreign sub. is not an eligible
corporation for purposes of consolidated return
rules and thus cannot be included in the U. S.
parent corporation's consolidated tax return. - However, the income of a controlled foreign
subsidiary is not subject to U.S. taxation when
it is earned.
91Alt. Forms for Foreign Operations
- Instead, earnings of a foreign subsidiary escape
U.S. taxation until earnings are repatriated to
the U.S., meaning when they are paid to the U.S.
parent corporation as a dividend. - The foreign jurisdiction probably taxes the
income when earned and might also assess a tax on
any dividend payments to the U.S. parent.
92Alt. Forms for Foreign Operations
- When a foreign subsidiary pays a dividend to its
U.S. parent, it is paying out net earnings after
paying foreign taxes. For U.S. tax purposes, the
parent corporation recognizes dividend income
equal to the gross earnings (before reduction by
the foreign taxes paid) and then takes a deemed
paid foreign tax credit for the applicable tax
amount
93Alt. Forms for Foreign Operations
- Taxable dividend income equals the net dividend
received plus any foreign withholding tax on the
dividend distribution plus foreign taxes paid by
the controlled foreign subsidiary on the income
from which the dividend is distributed. Note that
dividends received from foreign corporations are
not eligible for the dividends-received
deduction, so the total grossed up amount of the
dividend is subject to U.S. tax.
94- Alt. Forms for Foreign Operations
- Charlotte Corp.s taxable income for 2006 from
all of its global operations was 1,000,000,
resulting in U.S. federal income tax of 340,000
before credits. Charlottes wholly owned
subsidiary (which is incorporated in a foreign
country) earned net income of 200,000 in the
foreign country in 2006. Charlotte received no
dividend from the foreign subsidiary in 2006, but
received a dividend of 50,000 in 2007. Charlotte
reports (on its U.S. corporate tax return) income
of its foreign subsidiary of - a. 200,000 for 2006 b. 200,000 for 2007
- c. 50,000 for 2006 d. 0 in 2006 0 in 2007
95Alt. Forms for Foreign Operations
- Repeat the preceding question, except assume that
the income of the subsidiary is Subpart F income. - Charlotte reports (on its U.S. corporate tax
return) income of its foreign subsidiary of - a. 200,000 for 2006
- b. 200,000 for 2007
- c. 50,000 for 2007
- d. 0 in 2006 and 0 in 2007
96US Corp and Subsidiary
- The following slide summarizes the transactions
of a U.S. parent corporation (USC) and its wholly
owned subsidiary corporation organized and
operating in the Cayman Islands (CSub). - Parent (USC) manufactures widgets in the U.S.
sells them to its Cayman Subsidiary (CSub). - The Cayman Subsidiary sells the widgets in other
parts of the world. - Initially, we ignore transfer pricing limits and
subpart F.
97(No Transcript)
98(No Transcript)
99(No Transcript)
100(No Transcript)
101- What happens if we change our intercompany
pricing policy, and sell the widgets to the
Cayman subsidiary at our cost, so that we
break-even in the United States?
102(No Transcript)
103(No Transcript)
104(No Transcript)
105(No Transcript)
106Subpart F
- Suppose in the preceding slide, USC is actually
selling its product to various customers
throughout the world. - The Cayman Islands sub is a sales agent (paper
corporation) that technically buys from USC for
600,000 and sells to USCs customers for
1,000,000. - The products are shipped directly to USCs
customers and USC actually handles the billing,
etc.If CSub does not produce in the Cayman
Islands and does not sell in the Cayman Islands,
Subpart F comes into play. USC is treated as
receiving a distribution of CSub earnings on the
last day of the year. See bottom of page 16-26
107Subpart F
- Suppose in the preceding slide, USC is actually
selling its product to a wholly owned German
Subsidiary. - USC uses the Cayman Islands sub as a sales agent
to buy from USC for 600,000 and sell to the
German Subsidiary for 1,000,000. - German subsidiary will sell the products in
Germany for 1,000,000. - Without transfer pricing limits or Subpart F,
there would be no profit to be taxed in the U.S.
or in Germany.
108Transfer Pricing
- The variance in tax rates and tax systems among
countries, provide a strong incentive for a
multinational enterprise to shift income,
deductions, or tax credits among commonly
controlled entities in order to arrive at a
reduced overall tax burden. - Such a shifting of items between commonly
controlled entities could be accomplished by
setting artificial transfer prices for
transactions between group members.
109Transfer Pricing
- Assume that a U.S. corp. has a wholly-owned
foreign sub. - The U.S. corp. manufactures a product
domestically and sells it to the foreign
subsidiary. The foreign sub., in turn, sells the
product to unrelated third parties. Due to the
U.S. parent's control of its subsidiary, the
price which is charged by the parent to the
subsidiary theoretically could be set
independently of ordinary market forces.
110Transfer Pricing
- If the foreign sub is established in a
jurisdiction that subjects its profits from the
sale of the product to an effective rate of tax
lower than the effective U.S. tax rate, then the
U.S. corp may be inclined to undercharge the
foreign subsidiary for the product.
111Transfer Pricing
- By doing so, a portion of the combined profits of
the group from the manufacture and sale of the
product would be shifted out of a high-tax
jurisdiction (the U.S.) and into a lower-tax
jurisdiction (the foreign corporation's home
country).
112Transfer Pricing
- By contrast, U.S. companies owning foreign
subsidiaries that are located in countries with
effective tax rates that are higher than the U.S.
rates may have an incentive to overcharge for
sales from the U.S. parent to the foreign
subsidiary in order to shift profits, and the
resulting tax, into the United States. The
ultimate result of this process would be a
reduced worldwide tax liability of the
multinational enterprise.
113Transfer Pricing
- Under section 482, the Secretary of the Treasury
is authorized to redetermine the income of an
entity subject to U.S. taxation, when it appears
that an improper shifting of income between that
entity and a commonly controlled entity in
another country has occurred.
114- Now take a look at kind of double taxation.
115- Harold Arrowsmith
- This controversy arose in connection with the
estate of Harold Arrowsmith (hereinafter
"decedent"), who died intestate in Germany on
August 15, 1989. He was born, raised, and
educated in Baltimore, Maryland and received a
degree from the Johns Hopkins University in 1950.
He continued to live in Maryland until 1974 when
he sold his house and put his furniture in
storage.
116- He briefly resided in an apartment-hotel in
Washington, D.C., but moved to Germany in 1975.
Although the decedent remained a U.S. citizen his
entire life, filed U.S. income tax returns, and
maintained a Maryland driver's license, he
returned only occasionally to the United States
to present the results of his research and
writings.
117- His assets in Maryland consisted almost entirely
of intangible personal property, specifically
publicly-traded securities worth nearly 30
million, held at the Mercantile-Safe Deposit and
Trust Company.
118- The decedent's heirs initially filed a petition
for probate in Baltimore County in September
1989, asserting that because "the decedent was
domiciled in Maryland and a majority of his
assets are located in this state," the Register
of Wills for Baltimore County (hereinafter "the
Register") was the proper office in which to file
the petition.
119- On May 14, 1990, the appellees paid 2,000,000 to
the Register in inheritance taxes. - About that time, the estate also paid Maryland
and Federal estate taxes, in the amount of
1,957,164 and 11,010,462, respectively.
120- Concurrent with the administration of the
decedent's estate in the United States, parallel
probate proceedings were initiated in Germany.
Unable to ascertain the decedent's heirs, the
German tax authorities appointed a curator to
administer his estate under German law. - Concluding that at the time of his death the
decedent was domiciled in Germany, the German tax
authorities asserted that Germany was entitled to
the inheritance taxes on his entire worldwide
estate.
121- The total German tax assessed was approximately
17,511,145. - The German curator turned over all of the
decedent's assets located in Germany, totaling
1,022,355, to the German tax authorities as
partial payment of the assessed taxes, leaving an
unpaid German inheritance tax balance of
approximately 16,488,790, exclusive of interest
and administrative penalties for failure to file
timely returns or make timely payment.
122- What do you say?
- Did you notice the grand total of taxes?
123(No Transcript)