Title: D.r Nishant Nawani, MS
1Change In Corneal Endothelial cell Morphology
Following Trabeculectomy With Mitomycin-C
- D.r Nishant Nawani, MS
- Dr. Surinder Singh Pandav, MD
- Dr. Amit Gupta, MD
- Dr. Sushmita Kaushik, MD
- Advanced Eye Centre
- PGIMER, Chandigarh
The authors have no financial interest in the
subject matter of this poster.
2Introduction
- Outcome of glaucoma filtering surgery improved by
the use of antifibroblastic drugs such as
Mitomycin- C (MMC) - MMC has potential corneal toxic effects
- Clinically corneal endothelial cell toxicity can
manifest as change in the endothelial cell
morphology i.e., pleomorphism and polymegethism
and a reduction in the endothelial cell density - Endothelial cell changes are reported to
stabilize 3 months after intraocular surgery -
Arch Ophthalmol
19861041164-1169 - Endothelial morphology after application of MMC
have been studied - using electron microscopy Arch
Ophthalmol 1994112533 - non contact specular microscopy J
Glaucoma 200817654-657 -
Cornea 200221
300-304 - Endothelial mosaic better visualized in
edematous or scarred corneas by confocal
microscopy -
Techniques in Ophthalmology 2005319-26
3Aim and Objectives
- To study the change in corneal endothelial cell
characteristics by confocal microscopy following
trabeculectomy with 0.04 MMC
4Materials and Methods
- DESIGN
- Prospective, non-randomized, interventional case
series which included 30 patients - TWO GROUPS
- Group 1 Those undergoing trabeculectomy with
0.04 MMC applied for two minutes (n15) - Group 2 Those undergoing trabeculectomy without
MMC as adjunct (n15) - INCLUSION CRITERIA
- Age more than 18 years
- Primary or secondary open angle glaucoma
- Primary or Secondary angle closure glaucoma
- Uncontrolled intraocular pressure, not responding
to maximal medical therapy - EXCLUSION CRITERIA
- Previous intraocular surgery, scleral buckling
- Corneal degenerations and dystrophies
- Corneal scarring after infective diseases
- Dry eye patients
-
5- Baseline examination
- Comprehensive ophthalmic examination including
gonioscopy and, confocal microscopy (NIDEK
CONFOSCAN II, Nidek Technologies, Japan) to study
corneal endothelium - Surgical Procedure
- Standard trabeculectomy , limbus based
conjunctival flap - Half thickness, triangular scleral flap 4mm x
4mm, base at limbus - MMC o.04 applied with surgical sponge between
scleral flap and Tenons capsule for 2 minutes - Irrigated with 10 ml of BSS over 1-2 minutes
- Scleral flap closed with two releaseable, and one
fixed sutures - Tenons and conjunctiva closed in two layers
- Follow Up
- Patients were followed up on at days
1,2,7,14,30,60,90 post surgery - Confocal microscopy was done at 1 and 3 months
post surgery
6 ResultsPaired nonparametric test (Wilcoxon)
was used to compare pre- and postoperative
parameters and the Mann-Whitney test was used to
compare data between the two groups .Plt 0.05 as
the criterion for statistical significance
Patient Characteristics
Feature Group I (n15) Group II (n15) Total
Age in years SD (range) 40.47 10.72 (23-58) 50.40 12.21 (23-66)
Gender (MalesFemales) 132 114 246
Diagnosis Primary open angle glaucoma Primary closed angle glaucoma Secondary open angle glaucoma Secondary closed angle glaucoma
Diagnosis Primary open angle glaucoma Primary closed angle glaucoma Secondary open angle glaucoma Secondary closed angle glaucoma 2 6 8
Diagnosis Primary open angle glaucoma Primary closed angle glaucoma Secondary open angle glaucoma Secondary closed angle glaucoma 3 6 9
Diagnosis Primary open angle glaucoma Primary closed angle glaucoma Secondary open angle glaucoma Secondary closed angle glaucoma 8 2 10
Diagnosis Primary open angle glaucoma Primary closed angle glaucoma Secondary open angle glaucoma Secondary closed angle glaucoma 2 1 3
7Comparison Of Change In IOP and no. of
Antiglaucoma Medications(Pre and Post surgery)
Group I (MMC) IOP SD (mmHg) Medications SD Group I (MMC) IOP SD (mmHg) Medications SD Group II IOP SD (mmHg) Medications SD Group II IOP SD (mmHg) Medications SD
Pre-op (n15) 29.60 11.28 3.80 0.86 30.20 8.51 3.67 .98
1 month (n12) 10.58 3.52 (p0.002) 0.17 0.38 (p0.002) 14.64 4.01 (p0.018) 0.45 0.82 (p0.003)
3 months (n9) 12.56 3.24 (p0.013) 0.22 0.44 (p0.007) 16.29 4.82 (p0.018) 0.86 1.21 (p0.016)
8Change in central corneal thickness (CCT) Pre and
Post surgery
Group I (MMC) CCT SD (microns) Group II CCT SD (microns)
Pre-op (n15) 553.33 38.18 536.36 57.48
1 month 533.50 36.84 (p0.025, n12) 548.55 37.77 (p0.562, n11)
3 months 536.56 47.56 (p0.038, n9) 552.00 38.41 (p0.108,n7)
9Endothelial Morphometry
Endothelial Characteristic Group I (MMC) Group I (MMC) Group I (MMC) Group II Group II Group II
Endothelial Characteristic Pre-op (n15) 1 month (n12) 3 months (n9) Pre-op (n15) 1month (n11) 3months (n7)
CCEC mean SD (cells/mm2) 2080.07 379.76 1958.25 367.42 (p0.239) 1967.00 380.56 (p0.374) 2116.71 316.44 1979.09 256.71 (p.131) 2068.00 364.62 (p1.00)
Mean cell area (MCA) mean SD (mm2) 496.36 91.19 528.17 102.69 (p0.091) 525.78 102.48 (p0.314) 494.66 76.14 521.07 68.25 (p0.477) 493.14 90.95 (p1.00)
Pleomorphism mean SD () 46.88 13.89 44.51 11.85 (p0.937) 48.73 5.17 (p0.953) 46.18 11.99 45.91 12.34 (p0.625) 43.07 10.69 (p0.866)
Polymegethism mean SD () 37.62 6.93 35.02 5.06 (p0.195) 35.17 7.57 (p0.107) 36.19 7.28 37.20 6.49 (p0.790) 40.00 8.54 (p0.889)
10Reduction in cell count from baseline () Reduction in cell count from baseline () Reduction in cell count from baseline ()
Group I (MMC) Group II
1 month 5.85 6.48
3 months 5.46 2.28
11Discussion
- Endothelial cell changes
- Effacement of intercellular junctions with
cellular swelling and transcellular vacuole
formation using electron microscopy (Mcdermott
et al., 1994) - In trabeculectomies where MMC has been used,
endothelial cell loss at 3months - 11 by Pastor et al. (1993)
- 14.5 by Sihota et al.(1998)
- 9.5 by Storr-Paulsen et al. (2008)
- 5.46 (current study)
- Summary
- IOP reduction is significant in both groups
- Decrease in CCT was significant in the MMC group
- Endothelial cell counts decreased at one month
post op with slightly better recovery of counts
in non MMC group at three months - Mean cell area increased at one month post op,
parallel to decrease in endothelial counts with
trend to recovery at three months
12Conclusion
- MMC 0.04 when applied for two minutes, shows no
significant toxic effects on the corneal
endothelium at 3 months following trabeculectomy