Title: Semen preparation techniques for ART
1Semen preparation techniques for ART
- Gülnaz Sahin, MD
- Ege University Family Planning and Infertility
Research and Treatment Center
2- The onset of clinical assisted reproduction, a
quarter of a century ago, required the isolation
of motile spermatozoa - Since the birth of Louise Brown on 25 July 1978
and the subsequent onset of assisted reproduction
in the human, scientists and clinicians were more
and more urged to improve sperm separation
techniques as the percentage of andrological
cases increased rapidly
3-
- The first sperm separation methods were one
or two washing procedures with subsequent
resuspension of the male germ cells (1-3)
1. Edwards RG, Bavister BD, Steptoe PC Early
stages of fertilization in vitro of human oocytes
matured in vitro. Nature 1969 2. Edwards RG,
Steptoe PC, Purdy JM Establishing full term
human pregnancies using cleaving embryos grown in
vitro. Br J Obstet Gynaecol 1980 3. Lopata A,
Brown JB, Leeton JF, Talbot JM, Wood C In vitro
fertilization of preovulatory oocytes and embryo
transfer in infertile patients treated with
clomiphene and human chorionic gonadotropin.
Fertil Steril 1978
4- Researchers then described a single wash
- followed by a swim-up procedure from the cell
pellet. -
- Following these first reports on human
sperm separation, more sophisticated methods were
developed to obtain sufficient amounts of motile,
functionally competent spermatozoa for IVF.
Mahadevan M, Baker G Assessment and preparation
of semen for in vitro fertilization. In Clinical
In Vitro Fertilization Edited byWood C, Trounson
A. Springer-Verlag, Berlin 1984
5- On principle, these techniques can be
differentiated in migration, density gradient
centrifugation and filtration - Swim-up (Mahadevan and Baker, 1984)
- Percoll density gradient centrifugation (Gorus
Pipeleers, 1981) - Glass-wool (Paulson Polakoski, 1977)
- Sephadex bead filtration (Lopez et al.,1993)
6The ideal sperm separation technique
- should
- be quick,
- easy and cost-effective,
- isolate as much motile spermatozoa as possible,
- not cause sperm damage or nonphysiological
alterations of the separated sperm cells, - eliminate dead spermatozoa and other cells,
including leukocytes and bacterias, - eliminate toxic or bioactive substances like
decapacitation factors or reactive oxygen species
(ROS) and, - allow processing of larger volumes of ejaculates.
7- The quality of sperm samples is one of the
factors determining successful assisted
reproduction -
- (Ombelet et al. 2003)
8Ejeculated semen
- Viscous liquid composed of mixture of
testicular, epididymal secretions containing
spermatozoa and prostatic secretions produced at
the time of ejeculation. - This seminal plasma contains substances which
inhibit capasitation and prevent fertilization - Capacitation of eutherian spermatozoa is
essential for fertilization not only in vivo but
also in vitro, and underlies the manipulation of
spermatozoa for clinical invitro fertilization
(IVF).
9The purpose
- Concentrate the motile spermatozoa in a fraction
which is free of seminal plasma and debris - Maximalize the changes of fertilization to
provide as many normally fertilized ooctes as
possible - Elemination of seminal PG, lymphokines, cytokines
and infectious agents - Reduce the number of free oxygen radicals
10Collection of sperm
- The male partner should collect semen into a
sterile, clearly labelled disposible plastic jar
with in a room adjecent to the IVF laboratory - The time of sample collection should be recorded
on the label - Semen should be prepared soon after liquefaction
- If liquefaction delayed or specimen viscous
mixing the specimen 11 with medium may help or
enzymatically liquefaction can be done (ie
a-amylase, hyolurinidase, tripsin based
dissolving sol.) - 10 µl of the sample is taken to check sperm
consentration and motility
11 - Initial assesment of density and motility allow
to choose the most appopriate method of sperm
preparation - The choice of sperm preparation method depens
on, - the motile count, ratio between
motile/immotile count, volume, presence of
antibodies, agglutination
12ROS (reactive oxygen species) induced damage
- Morphologically abnormal spermatozoa with
retained spermatid cytoplasm and leukocytes
present within the ejaculate generate free
radicals in vitro - Centrifugation can be harmful to human
spermatozoa (forses in excess of 800 g applied) - Centrifugal pelleting of unselected human sperm
populations often resulted in the generation of
free radical or reactive oxygen species (ROS)
within the sperm pellet that could irreversible
damage to the spermatozoa that can impaireven
totally destroytheir fertilizing cability.
Aitken RJ, Clarkson JS. J Androl.1988
13ROS induced damage
- ROS are generated both by leukocytes present in
semen and spermatozoa - ROS affect not only the sperm plasma membrane by
causing phospholipid peroxidation, but also the
sperm DNA by causing strand breaks that can be
revealed by various tests of sperm DNA integrity - spermatozoa prepared by simple washing will
definitely be at a much greater risk of
contributing a defective genome to the embryo and
could underlie the increased developmental
failure of ICSI-derived embryos after the 8-cell
stage when the embryonic genome is activated
Saccas et al, 1997, Evenson et
al.,1999 Shoukir et al, 1998)
14Swim-up
- Is still used largely in IVF laboratories around
the world. - Although its use among the male factor
infertility group is very limited, the swim-up is
still the standard technique for patients with
normozoospermia and female infertility. - This procedure has several variations
15Standart swim-up
- The methodology of conventional swim-up is
based - on the active movement of spermatozoa from
the prewashed cell pellet into an overlaying
medium. Typically, the incubation time is 60
minutes.
16Direct swim-up from liquefied semen
- A maximum recovery is obtained by using multiple
tubes with small volumes of semen per tube, thus
maximizing the combined total interface area
between semen and culture medium. - Mortimer suggested the use of 250 µl semen and
500 to 600 µl culture medium per tube
17Pellet and swim-up
- Alternatively, semen sample may be diluted and
centrifuged and pellet overlaid with medium - Useful for viscous samples
- Not recommended when motility is very poor or
large degree of cellular contamination and debris - Has disadvantage of peroxidative damage during
centrifugation with defective sperm and white
cells
Aitken RJ, 1990
18The sperm select system
- employs a high-purity preparation of 3000 kd
sodium hyaluronate at a 1-mg/mL final
concentration in culture medium. - It has been shown a significantly higher
percentage of motile spermatozoa and, the
achievement of a higher pregnancy rate compare
with traditional swim-up in a clinical IVF
program - However, it has been shown to increase the
calcium influx into spermatozoa and induce
acrosome reaction
Wikland M et al. A selfmigration method for
preparation of sperm for in-vitro
fertilization.Hum Reprod. 19872191195.
19Migration-sedimantation
- swim-up technique combined with a sedimentation
step - spermatozoa swim up directly from liquefied semen
into the supernatant medium and subsequently
sediment in that inner cone within an hour - Zavos et al.proposed the use of a multi-chamber
tube to retrieve functional spermatozoa for
assisted reproductive techniques by means of a
swim-up and sedimentation method.
Zavos PM et al Use of the multi-ZSC one-step
standardized swimup method recovery of
high-quality spermatozoa for intrauterine
insemination or other forms of assisted
reproductive technologies. Fertil Steril 2000,
74834-835.
20Density gradients
- Various gradient procedures
- It is rapid, relatively simple to perform
- Abnormal sperm, immotile sperm and debris can
largely eliminate - Generally the recovery of motile sperm is greater
with gradients but the percentages of sperm with
progressive motility is usually lower than with
swim-up
21Density gradients
- Colloidal silica particles (coated with
PVPPercoll) - Silane coated silica particles (Isolate,
PureSperm, SilSelect) - Nycodenz (iodinated hydrocarbon), Ficoll, Highly
purified arabinogalactan
22-
- The ejaculate is placed on top of the
density media with higher density and is then
centrifuged for 1530 minutes - Highly motile spermatozoa move actively in
the direction of the sedimentation gradient and
can therefore penetrate the boundary quicker than
poorly motile or immotile cells, thus, highly
motile sperm cells are enriched in the soft
pellet at the bottom
23Density gradients
- Percoll was withdrawn from clinical use by its
manufacturer in 1996 - PVP-coated silica that can have deleterious
effects on sperm membranes, and may affect
subsequent fertilization events (De vos et al,
1997) because of high endotoxin levels - Products contain silane-coated silica particles,
adjusted for the osmolarity with polysucrose ,
have very low toxicity. All these replacement
products are non-irritating and are approved for
human in vivo use.
24Density gradients
- Density gradients protect the sperm from trauma
of centrifugation - High proportion of functional sperm can be
recovere - Two or three step gradients are simple and highly
effective in preparing motile sperm from
suboptimal samples - In general longer centrifugation time increases
the recovery of both motile and immotile sperm - Debris, round cells, abnormal forms never reach
the bottom of the tube because of their low
density
25Density gradients
- Gradients with larger volumes result in improved
filtration, but decreased yield - Three layers of mini-gradient improve filtration,
recovery of sperm from severely oligospermic
samples - Samples wiht large amont of debris should be
distributed in smaller volumes over several
gradients - Severely asthenoozospermic samples,with normal
density can also be distrubuted over a series of
mini-gradients
26Density gradients
27Mini-gradient(95/70/50)
- Make layers with 0.3 ml f each sol95,70,50
- Dilute semen 11 with culture medium, centrifuge
at 200 g for 10 minutes - Resuspend the pellet in 0.3 ml culture medium and
layer over mini-gradient - Centrifuge at 600 g, for 20-30 minutes
- Recover the pellet, resuspend in 0.5 ml culture
medium and assess count and motility. Proceed
exactly as for two step gradient prep either
centrifuge at 200 g for 5 min and resuspended
pellet, or layer over the pellet for a swim up
28Sedimantation method or layering under paraffin
oil
- Useful for samples with very low counts and poor
motility - Very effective in removing debris, requires
several hours of preparation - Wash the sample by dilution and cent.twice
- Resuspend the pellet in a reduce volume of medium
- Layer this suspansion under paraffin oil in a
small petri dish, place in a desiccator and gas
with 5 CO2 - Leave at room temp for 3-24 hours.
- Carefully aspirate motile sperm by using a fine
drawn pipette
29Glass wool filtration
- Motile spermatozoa are separated from immotile
sperm cells by means of densely packed glass wool
fibres - Potential risks of the technique damages of the
spermatozoa or the occurrence of glass wool
fragments in the filtrate essentially depend on
the kind of glass wool used and on the intensity
of the washing prior to the filtration. - uses the whole volume of the ejaculate and
therefore yields a significantly higher total
number of motile spermatozoa and do not required
prewash step - it can also be used for patients with oligo-
and/or asthenozoospermia
Henkel R et al., J Assist Reprod Genet
1994 Berger T et al., Fertil Steril 1985
30Glass wool filtration
- glass wool filtration has been shown to
eliminate leukocytes to an extent of up to 90,
this effect significantly contributes to a
reduction of free radicals in the ejaculate - Glass wool filtration like the density
gradient centrifugation with PureSperm or the
migration sedimentation technique significantly
selects normally chromatin-condensed spermatozoa
31Semen preparation techniques for intrauterine
inseminationBoomsma CM, Heineman MJ, Cohlen BJ,
Farquhar C
- Summary
- The effectiveness of specific sperm preparation
techniques for increasing pregnancy rates in
subfertile couples undergoing intrauterine
insemination (IUI) is unknown - Semen preparation techniques are used in assisted
reproduction to separate sperm, which have a
normal appearance and move spontaneously, from
the fluid portion of the semen in which the sperm
are suspended. It is known that white blood
cells, bacteria and dead sperm in semen can
produce oxygen radicals that can impair
fertilization of the egg. This review found that
there is insufficient evidence to recommend any
specific sperm preparation technique for
subfertile couples undergoing intrauterine
insemination (a procedure which places sperm
directly into the uterus) as there were no
differences in pregnancy rates. More research is
needed.
Cochrane Reviews March 2004
32Which procedure for IUI?Swim-up/Gradient?
Boomsma CM, Heineman MJ, Cohlen BJ, Farquhar C
.Cochrane Reviews March 2004
33Which procedure for IUI?Swim-up/Gradient?
Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2004
34Sperm processing
- Samples with an acceptable number of motile sperm
( gt 20 millions / ml ) can be processed
efficiently by sperm wash twice and swim-up. - Poor quality semen samples should be processed
using density gradient centrifugation DGC.
Morshedi M et al, 2003
35Sperm preparation for ICSI
- Combination of methods can be use
- Extremely oligospermic/asthenozoospermic samples
cannot be prepared by density centrifugation or
swim-up
36High-speed centrifugation and washing
- Cryptozoospermic samples which must be prepared
for ICSI can be centrifuged directly at 1800 g
for 5 minutes or diluted with medium and then
centrifuged at 1800 g for 5 min. - Wash the pellet with small volume of medium(0.5
ml) and centrifuge at 200 g for 5 min. - Recover this pellet in a minimal volume of
medium(20-50 µl), and overlay with mineral oil
37Sperm preparation for ICSI Extremely
oligospermic/asthenozoospermic samples
- 1. Centrifuge the whole sample, 1800 g, 5minutes,
wash with medium, and resuspend the pellet in a
small volume of medium - 2. Apply sample directly to the injection dish,
without PVP,or add an aliquot suspension to a
drop of HEPES buffered medium without PVP - 3. If possible, use the injection pipette to
select a moving sperm with apparently normal
morphology from this drop and transfer it into
the PVP or into another drop of HEPES buffered
medium - 4. If there is debris attached to the sperm,
clean it by pipetting the sperm with the
injection pipette - 5. It may sometimes be helpful to connect the
sperm droplet to another small medium droplet by
means of a bridge of medium, and allow motile
sperm to swim out into the clean droplet
38No motile sperm
- It may possible to see slight tail movement in a
medium drop without PVP. - If absolutely no motile sperm are found, immotile
sperm may be used. The fertilization rate with
immotile sperm is generally lower. Previous
assesment with a vital stain may be helpful
before deciding ICSI treatment
39No motile sperm
- To date, two different approaches for the
distinction between live and dead spermatozoa - the initiation of motility as sign of vitality
by means of stimulants - the identification of live spermatozoa according
to their membrane integrity by means of the
hypo-osmotic swelling test (HOS test).
40PDE inhibitor
- As pentoxifylline stimulates motility without
altering the sperm membrane, it appeared as an
ideal substance to initiate motility in immotile
spermatozoa - This method was successfully used to identify
live testicular and epididymal spermatozoa and
live births are reported
Terriou P et al., J Assist Reprod Genet 2000,
17194-199. Nodar F et al, Fertil Steril 1999,
711149-1152.
41HOS (hypo-osmotic swelling test)
- Assesses the osmoregulatory ability of the sperm,
and the functional integrity of its membranes - Can be used to discriminate viable sperm from
non-viables in a sample which has zero motility - In hyposmotic environment sperms react by
swelling of the tail. Dead spermatozoa whose
plasma membranes are no longer intact do not show
tail swelling
Jeyendrn RS, Van der Ven HH, et al. (1984)J
Reprod Fertil 70219228.
42(No Transcript)
43No motile sperm
- Shown significantly elevated fertilization and
pregnancy rates when oocytes were injected with
HOS-positive sperm - Sperm immotility is significantly positively
correlated with sperm DNA fragmentation, the
probability to select such DNA-damaged
spermatozoa for ICSI is higher - According to present knowledge, sperm DNA
fragmentation might cause an impaired embryonic
development and early embryonic death - Therefore, a careful examination and counselling
of the patients seems mandatory, and
fertilization with ICSI should not be performed
at all cost
Henkel R et al, RBM Online 2003, 7474-484.
Asch R et al, Hum Reprod 1995 Jurisicova A
et al, Mol Hum Reprod 1996 Simerly C et al.,
InGenetics of Human Male Fertility Edited by
Barratt C et al, Paris 1997258-286. Aitken RJ
et al, Biol Reprod 1998, 591037-1046.
44Abnormal heads
- In cases with 100 abnormal head anomalies, the
fertililization and implantation rates lower,
individual judgment should be applied to each
case, with several assessment of several
different semen samples - Globoozospermia,100 head anomaly, where all
sperm lack an acrosomal cap debate continues as
to whether it is ethically advisable to offer
treatment to these man
45Retrograde ejeculation
- Bladder shoul emptied via catheter, approximately
20 ml of culture medium then installed - After ejeculation, bladder is again emptied,
entire sample centrifuged - Resulting pellet can then be resuspended in
medium and processed on appopriate density
gradients
46Retrograde ejeculation
- 1 gm bicarbonate PO night before and morning
- Split the urine 10 ml. fractions and santrifugate
at 300 g, 5 min - Resulting pellet can then be resuspended in
medium and processed on appopriate density
gradients
47Azoospermia epididymal sperm
- Can be obtained by open microscopic surgery or by
percutaneus puncture using by needle to aspirate
fluid - If large numbers of sperm are found, they can
processed by density gradient or swim-up - Samples with fewer sperm can be washed and
centrifuged with IVF medium, and concentrated
sample is than added to microdroplets in the
injection dish.
48Azoospermia Testicular sperm
- Testicular tissue is obtained either by open
biopsy or percutaneus fine-needle aspiration - Place tissue into a small petri dish of warm
culture media with hepes, albumin - Dissect and squeeze tubules using fine gauge
needles - Transfer raw suspension to a test tube and vortex
for 30 s - Depending on concentration, motility, amount of
debris, either use directly after wash and
resuspension or seperate on a density gredient - Leave sperm to incubate to allow sperm to gain
motility up to 24 hours in culture media with
albumin at 37C under 5 CO2 - for same day use, prepare plate for ICSI and
leave at 37C in Hepes buffered culture media
with albumin
49 enzimatic digestion or mechanical preparation of
testicular tissue
- The optimal method of obtaining suitable sperm
from testicular tissue is still under debate - Mechanical preparation by mincing and
- shredding
- Enzimatic digestion by using collagenase
- It has been shown no advantages one over the
other preparation method
Verheyen et al. Hum Reprod, 1995
Salzbrunn et al. Hum Reprod, 1996
V.Baukloh on behalf of German Sociaty for
Human Repro. BiologyHum Reprod,2002
50sperm morphology and genotype
- Abnormally small and large sperm heads are often
associated with aneuploidy and diploidy - It has been shown that morphologically abnormal
spermatozoa can carry normal karyotypes (Martin
and Rademaker, 1988) and can produce normal
offspring - This subject is a major area of current research
51Sperm DNA damage
- DNA damage in human spermatozoa is negatively
correlated with pregnancy rates in both natural
and assisted conception cycles and has been
linked with both increased rates of miscarriage
and diseases in the offspring - (Aitken, 1999 Loft et al., 2003 Lewis and
Aitken, 2005)
52Sperm DNA aneuploidy
53Sperm cromatin condensation
- The degree of nuclear chromatin condensation can
be assessed by various techniques such as aniline
blue (Terquem Dadoune, 1983), acridine orange
(Tejada et al., 1984) or chromomycinCMA3 (Bianchi
et al., 1993) - Manicardi et al. (1995) and Sakkas et al. (1996)
have indicated that in a normal semen sample CMA3
Fluorescence can be taken at lt30, while levels
above these values would be indicative of a semen
sample containing spermatozoa with abnormal
chromatin
54(No Transcript)
55Hammadeh ME. Int JAndrol.200124360-368
56Hammadeh ME. Int JAndrol.200124360-368
57Hammadeh ME. Int JAndrol.200124360-368
- The proportion of chromatin condensed spermatozoa
increased after sperm processing with swim-up,
PureSperm gradients centrifugation and glass-wool
in comparison with the value observed in the
native semen samples - This increase was significantly shown higher
after semen separation with glass-wool in
comparison with traditional swim-up - However, there were no significant differences in
the fertilization, implantation and pregnancy
rates of sperm prepared by means of swim-up,
PureSperm or glasswool filtration - Their conclution was, glass-wool filtration could
be used as the first choice for semen preparation
in an ICSI programme as the natural selection is
bypassed. Swim-up and Pure Sperm should be used
for semen processing in IVF programme
58- Density gradient centrifugation separate
spermatozoa according to their density and
favours the isolation of the motile and normal
morphological spermatozoa (Mortimer et al,1999) - Differential gradient sperm separation method
using Percoll is superior to the swim-up method
for selecting sperm with normal morphology
(Prakash et al.,1998) - Sakkas et al. (2000) investigated the efficiency
of the PureSperm, Percoll and swim-up preparation
techniques to eliminate spermatozoa with nuclear
anomalies. They indicated that both the PureSperm
and Percoll techniques can enrich the sperm
population by separating those with nicked DNA
and with poorly condensed chromatin
59- Henkel et al (1994), demonstrated that glass-wool
filtration results in a significant higher
percentage of normal chromatin condensed
spermatozoa compared with the ejaculate - Soderlund Lundin (2000) was also demonstrated
that PureSperm-treated spermatozoa resulted in
similar fertilization and pregnancy rates as
using spermatozoa obtained after the swim-up
procedure.
60(MACS) annexinV magnetic-activated cell sorting
separation
- Successful fertilization requires a sperm plasma
membrane with normal integrity and function
(Flesch et al., 2000) - The plasma membrane is one of the key structures
in spermatozoa of infertile men displaying
apoptotic features(Glander and Schaller, 1999) - The phospholipid phosphatidylserine (PS), which
is normally present on the inner leaflet of the
plasma membrane, becomes externalized to the
outer leaflet (Vermes et al., 1995), The
externalization of PS is currently accepted as a
membrane marker for early apoptosis (Martin et
al., 1995)
61MACS
- Annexin V is characterized by high affinity for
PS and does not have the ability to pass the
intact sperm membrane. Therefore, annexin V
binding to spermatozoa characterizes disturbed
integrity of the sperm membrane(Glander and
Schaller, 1999), - Colloidal super-paramagnetie microbeads (50 nm
in diameter) conjugated with annexin V have been
shown to separate the dead and apoptotic
spermatozoa by magnetic activated cell sorting
(MACS), Cells exposing PS bound to these
microbeads (annexin positive) are enriched to
high extent within a column containing iron balls
when placed in a very strong magnetic field.
Cells with intact membranes remain unlabelled
(annexin negative), and pass freely through the
column (Miltenyi et al., 1990 von Schonfeldt et
al., 1999)
62MACS
- The combination of MACS with density gradient
centrifugation (DGC) in a single sperm
preparation protocol results in spermatozoa with
superior quality (Said et al., 2005a) - In general, MACS is a feasible and safe method
that may be used to provide a high-quality sperm
fraction (Glander et al., 2002 Grunewald et al.,
2001 Paasch et al., 2003b, 2005) - The high sperm recovery rate following advocates
the use of this protocol as sperm preparation
technique prior to assisted reproduction.
Separating a distinctive population of
nonapoptotic spermatozoa with intact membranes
and subjecting it to IVF or ICSI is a step
further in optimizing the outcome of assisted
reproduction - Nevertheless, future experiments using animal
models that evaluate embryo viability and genetic
integrity would still be needed before the
technique could be applied to human cases.
63PICSI
- Hyaluronan (H) is a major constituent of the
cumulus oophorous matrix and may play a critical
role in the selection of functionally competent
sperm during in vivo fertilization. - The in vitro selection of sperm for ICSI is
critical and may influence the developmental
potential of the resulting embryo. - Research has demonstrated that specific motile
sperm attach to H and that such H-bound (HB)
sperm carry enhanced levels of developmental
maturity, sperm chromatin integrity and normal
morphology. HB sperm may therefore contain
increased levels of functional competence. - The PICSI plate provides microdrops of H for
sperm selection
Gabor Huzsar,MD Yale University K. C.Worrilow,
H. T. Huynh, et al. ASRM 2007 October OP
64PICSI
- Authors suggests that the use of HB-sperm in ICSI
may allow the isolation of sperm with potentially
enhanced levels of functional competence, thereby
exerting a positive paternal influence on
preimplantation embryogenesis. The statistically
significant reduced levels of fragmentation,
increased cpr and decreased mr associated with
the use of PICSI-derived embryos is promising.
K. C.Worrilow, H. T. Huynh, et al. ASRM 2007
October OP
65(No Transcript)
66- The highes quality spermatozoa in the
ejaculate are the most electronegative (Kirchhoff
and Schroter, 2001 Giuliani et al., 2004
Ainsworth et al., 2005) and spermatozoa can be
separated from other contaminating
electronegative cells (such as leukocytes)by
their small cross-sectional size - rapid (5 min), efficient and selective, with
no contaminating cells from TESE biopsy material
67