Title: Exercise And Statin
1Exercise And Statin Associated Myopathy
Paul D. Thompson, MD Director of
Cardiology Henry Low Heart Center Hartford
Hospital Hartford, CT
2Statins In the Water ?
Paul D. Thompson, MD Director of
Cardiology Henry Low Heart Center, Hartford
Hospital Hartford, CT
3Not So Fast
- There Are No Long Term Studies of
Continuous Statin Treatment - The Number Needed to Treat for Low Risk
Patients is Huge - Statins Have Side Effects
- That No Pharmaceutical Company Wants to
Study
4Collaborators
- Brown University Peter Herbert, Eileen
Cullinane, Stan Sady, - University of Pittsburgh Joe Zmuda, Rich Zimet,
Susan Yurgalevitch - Duke University John Guyton
- Hartford Hospital - Beth Parker, Jeff Capizzi,
Amanda Augieri, William Roman, Lindsay Lorson,
Mauren Yuscavitch, Brenda Foxen, Mary Beth
Moran, Cherie Biblie, Rick Seip, Gualberto Ruano - Umass - Priscilla Clarkson, Maria Urso, Amy
Kearns - Tufts University Richard Karas
- Washington Childrens Medical Center - Eric
Hoffman - UConn Linda Pescatello
5Thompson - Conflicts of Interest
- Grant / Research Support GlaxoSmithKline /
Merck / Roche / Pfizer / AstraZeneca / NIH / B.
Braun / Genomas - Consultant Astra Zenica / Merck /
Schering-Plough / Takeda / Roche / Genomas
/Abbott / Runners World - Speakers Bureau Merck / Pfizer / Abbott /
Astra Zenica / Schering-Plough - Stock Shareholder Zoll / General Electric /
JA Wiley Publishing / Zimmer / Medtronic /
Abbott /
6Peripheral Cells
High-Affinity Uptake
Low-Affinity Uptake
FFA
Capillary
LPL
Low-Affinity VLDL Uptake
High-Affinity Uptake
Acetyl CoA
HMG-CoA Reductase
Bile Acids
Cholesterol
Bile
ACAT
Cholesterol Esters
Bile Acids
Cholesterol
Fecal Excretion
7Capillary
Increased High-Affinity LDL Uptake
Decreased LDL Cholesterol
ß-hydroxy-ß-methylglutaryl CoA
Inhibition of Cholesterol Synthesis
Mevalonate
Cholesterol
HMG-CoA REDUCTASE INHIBITORS
8There Are Three Principles of Managing
Lipids With Medications
9First Principle of Lipid Drug Management
10- They Produce Remarkable Reductions in LDL
Levels
11LDL-C Reductions with Different Statin Strategies
Change in LDL-C from baseline ()
-10
20
-30
-40
-50
-60
-5
-15
-25
-35
-45
-55
0
rosuvastatin
atorvastatin
simvastatin
pravastatin
Adapted from Jones PH et alAm J Cardiol
200392152160
12Second Principle of Lipid Drug Management
13They Cure Almost Every Lipid Problem That
Ails You
- LDL Cholesterol
- Triglycerides
- HDL Cholesterol
- LDL Particle Size
- Hs CRP
14Simvastatin Expanded-Dose Study
Lipid Changes
10 0 -10 -20 -30 -40 -50 -60
8
7
6
change from baseline (median)
-21
-23
-30
-33
-35
Simvastatin 40mg Simvastatin 80mg Simvastatin
100mg
-40
-41
-47
-53
N156
HDL Cholesterol
Triglycerides
Total Cholesterol
LDL Cholesterol
Am J Cardiol 19977938-42
15Third Principle of Lipid Drug Management
16- They Have Incredible Outcome DATA
17Multiple Studies Showed a Relationship
BetweenLDL-C Reduction and CHD Relative Risk
MI myocardial infarction. Adapted with
permission from Robinson JG et al. J Am Coll
Cardiol. 20054618551862.
18Statins Lower Risk - Even if the Risk
Factor is Not LDL-Cholesterol
19Statins In the Water ?
20Not So Fast
- There Are No Long Term Studies of
Continuous Statin Treatment - The Number Needed to Treat for Low Risk
Patients is Huge - Statins Have Side Effects
- That No Pharmaceutical Company Wants to
Study
21I Came Here Not To Bury Statins
But There Is A Problem
22Statin Associated Myopathy
23Exercise Statin Myopathy - Take Home
Messages
- Statins Are Remarkably Effective at Reducing
CAD Risk - But Can Produce Myopathic (and Possibly
Neurological) Side Effects - Exercise Causes Many of The CK Elevations
Attributed to Statins - Exercise Magnifies Statin Myalgia CK
Increases - Some Patients Report Weakness, But There is
Little Objective Data on Muscle Strength - Long Term Muscle Effects of Statins Are
Unknown
24Exercise Statin Myopathy - Take Home
Messages
- Statins Are Remarkably Effective at Reducing
CAD Risk - But Can Produce Myopathic (and Possibly
Neurological) Side Effects - Exercise Causes Many of The CK Elevations
Attributed to Statins - Exercise Magnifies Statin Myalgia CK
Increases - Some Patients Report Weakness, But There is
Little Objective Data on Muscle Strength - Long Term Muscle Effects of Statins Are
Unknown
25Statin - Related Muscle Complaints
- Myositis and Rhabdomyolysis - CK gt 10 X ULN
- Increased CK lt 10 X ULN ? Symptoms
- Myalgia With No CK Increases
- Muscle Weakness - Virtually Unstudied
- Muscle Cramps
- Persistent Myalgia CK ?s Even After
Withdrawal -
26Exercise Statin Myopathy - Take Home
Messages
- Statins Are Remarkably Effective at Reducing
CAD Risk - But Can Produce Myopathic (and Possibly
Neurological) Side Effects - Exercise Causes Many of The CK Elevations
Attributed to Statins - Exercise Magnifies Statin Myalgia CK
Increases - Some Patients Report Weakness, But There is
Little Objective Data on Muscle Strength - Long Term Muscle Effects of Statins Are
Unknown
27Exercise ALONE Can Produce Remarkable CK
Increases
- So That Many CK Increases Attributed to
Statins Are Due to Exercise
28Siegel AJ, Silverman LM, Lopez RE. Yale J Biol
Med. 1980 Jul-Aug53(4)275-9.
29(No Transcript)
30Functional SNPs Associated with
Human Muscle Size and
Strength
FAMuSS
NIH RO1-NS40606-01A1
Study
- Thompson, et al Med Science in Sports
Exercise. 2004 36 1132-1139.
3110 Men
- Performed 45 Minutes Of Non-Dominant Arm
Exercises - Standing Curls, Preacher Curls, Triceps
Extensions - On Days 1 3
- CKs Obtained on Daily For 5 Days
32Bilbie SM, Seip RL, Bilbie CL, Clarkson, PM,
Thompson, PD. Submitted.
33Exercise Statin Myopathy - Take Home
Messages
- Statins Are Remarkably Effective at Reducing
CAD Risk - But Can Produce Myopathic (and Possibly
Neurological) Side Effects - Exercise Causes Many of The CK Elevations
Attributed to Statins - Exercise Magnifies Statin Myalgia CK
Increases - Some Patients Report Weakness, But There is
Little Objective Data on Muscle Strength - Long Term Muscle Effects of Statins Are
Unknown
34Collected Cases
- Among 22 Professional Athletes
- With LDL Receptor Defects
- Only 6 Could Tolerate Statins
- Despite Multiple Attempts With Fluva, Lova,
Prava, Atorva, Simva
Sinzinger Br J Clin Phar 2004
35PRedIction of Muscular Risk in Observational
Conditions orPRIMO Study
- 7,924 French Patients on Fluva 80, Atorva
40-80, Prava 40, Simva 40-80, for 3 mos - 10.5 Reported Muscular Symptoms
- The Rate was 14.7 in Patients Practicing
Intense Form of Sport vs 10.8 Who Did
Only Leisure Time Activities - Pain Was Triggered in 41 - 53 by
Unusual Physical Activity
Bruckert CV Drugs Therapy 2005
36Exercise Statin Myopathy - Take Home
Messages
- Statins Are Remarkably Effective at Reducing
CAD Risk - But Can Produce Myopathic (and Possibly
Neurological) Side Effects - Exercise Causes Many of The CK Elevations
Attributed to Statins - Exercise Magnifies Statin Myalgia CK
Increases - Some Patients Report Weakness, But There is
Little Objective Data on Muscle Strength - Long Term Muscle Effects of Statins Are
Unknown
37Do Statins Increase the Muscle Injury of
Exercise ?
38Exercise - Induced CK Elevations -
- 59 Men Aged 18-65
- LDL gt 130 mg/dl
- Randomly to Placebo or Lova 40 mg
- At 4 Weeks Maximal EXT, Downhill Walking
at 65 HR for 3 X 15 Min Bouts - Thompson et al Metabolism 1997
39CK Elevations After Downhill Walking
Thompson et al Metabolism 1997
40Exercise - Induced CK Elevations -
- Two Men Excluded Because of Marked CK
Increases - Thompson et al Metabolism 1997
41Med Sci Sports Exercise 2009
42Study Design
- 3 blood draws
- CK isoenzymes
EXPO 24 HRS PRE
FINISH LINE POST
24 HOURS POST
43Study Population
- 43 controls
- 51 7 yrs
- 29 men and 8 women
- 37 statin users
- 56 8 yrs
- 30 men and 13 women
44Log Transformed CK Response
p 0.02
45Exercise Statin Myopathy - Take Home
Messages
- Statins Are Remarkably Effective at Reducing
CAD Risk - But Can Produce Myopathic (and Possibly
Neurological) Side Effects - Exercise Causes Many of The CK Elevations
Attributed to Statins - Exercise Magnifies Statin Myalgia CK
Increases - Some Patients Report Weakness, But There is
Little Objective Data on Muscle Strength - Long Term Muscle Effects of Statins Are
Unknown
46The Effect of Statins on Skeletal Muscle
FunctionNIH RO1 081893
- 440 Subjects
- Randomized to Atorvastatin 80 or Placebo
- 6 Months
- Strength - Handgrip, Biceps, Quadriceps -
Static Dynamic Strength - Quadriceps Endurance
- Exercise Oxygen Uptake Respiratory Quotient
47What Causes Statin Myopathy ?
48I DONT KNOW
49(No Transcript)
50Possible Mechanisms of Statin Induced Muscle
Injury
- 1. Reduced Sarcolemmal Cholesterol
- 2. Reduced T-Tubule Sarcoplamic Recticulum
Cholesterol Draeger JPath 2006 - 3. Reduced Isoprenoids Ubiquinone - Co-enzy Q10
- 4. Reduced Prenylation of GTP Binding Proteins -
Ras, Rac and Rho - Cell Maintenance, Growth
Reduced Apoptosis Coleman Cell Death Differ 2002 - 5. Changes in Fat Metabolism
- (Phillips P Atherosclerosis 2005)
- 6.  Increased Muscle Cholesterol ? Plant
Sterol 2nd to LDL Receptor Activity (Paiva
Clin Pharmacol Ther 2005) - Failure to Appropriately Repair Damaged
Muscle (Urso . Thompson ATVB 2005) - Vitamin D Deficiency
- Inflammation (Inflammatory Myopathy)
51Possible Mechanisms of Statin Induced Muscle
Injury
- 1. Reduced Sarcolemmal Cholesterol
- 2. Reduced T-Tubule Sarcoplamic Recticulum
Cholesterol Draeger JPath 2006 - 3. Reduced Isoprenoids Ubiquinone - Co-enzy Q10
- 4. Reduced Prenylation of GTP Binding Proteins -
Ras, Rac and Rho - Cell Maintenance, Growth
Reduced Apoptosis Coleman Cell Death Differ 2002 - 5. Changes in Fat Metabolism
- (Phillips P Atherosclerosis 2005)
- 6.  Increased Muscle Cholesterol ? Plant
Sterol 2nd to LDL Receptor Activity (Paiva
Clin Pharmacol Ther 2005) - Failure to Appropriately Repair Damaged
Muscle (Urso . Thompson ATVB 2005) - Vitamin D Deficiency
- Inflammation (Inflammatory Myopathy)
52Coenzyme Q10 in Statin Myopathy
- 1 RC1 AT005836-01
- NIH/NCCAM
53135 Subjects with Prior Statin Complaints
Weekly phone calls Pain Questionnaires used to
assess muscle symptoms and document myalgia
54Total LDL Reductions Were Greatest in
True Myalgics
True 12 Non 19
D-C Morales, B Parker, L Lorson, D Polk, PD
Thompson. ACC 2011
55Possible Mechanisms of Statin Induced Muscle
Injury
- 1. Reduced Sarcolemmal Cholesterol
- 2. Reduced T-Tubule Sarcoplamic Recticulum
Cholesterol Draeger JPath 2006 - 3. Reduced Isoprenoids Ubiquinone - Co-enzy Q10
- 4. Reduced Prenylation of GTP Binding Proteins -
Ras, Rac and Rho - Cell Maintenance, Growth
Reduced Apoptosis Coleman Cell Death Differ 2002 - 5. Changes in Fat Metabolism
- (Phillips P Atherosclerosis 2005)
- 6.  Increased Muscle Cholesterol ? Plant
Sterol 2nd to LDL Receptor Activity (Paiva
Clin Pharmacol Ther 2005) - Failure to Appropriately Repair Damaged
Muscle (Urso . Thompson ATVB 2005) - Vitamin D Deficiency
- Inflammation (Inflammatory Myopathy)
56Decreases in Serum Q10 LDL-C With Statin
Therapy
Ghirlanda J Clin Pharmacol 1993
57Most (me Marcoff Thompson, JACC 2007)
Attributed the Q10 Decrease to Decreases in
LDL/VLDL.But
Kawashiri et. al. Clin Pharm Therapeutics
58Co Q10 ?
- Muscle Biopsies From 132 Patients With
Statin Myopathies - 50 - Co Q10 Levels - 2-4 SDs lt Normal
Vladutiu et al Am C Rheum 2004 Abstract 1784
59Is The Reduced Q10 The Cause or The
Result of Mitochondrial / Muscle Problems
- Something Else Could Be Hurting The Muscle,
Decreasing Mitochondria Numbers, and Q10
Levels
60Studies of Skeletal Muscle CoQ10 levels after
treatment with statins plt0.05 plt0.01
plt0.001 (Marcoff Thompson, JACC 2007)
v
61There Are Two Appropriately Designed (
Published) Trials
62Coenzyme Q10 Improves Myopathic Pain in
Statin Treated Patients
- Prospective, Randomized, Blinded Trial
- Vitamin E 400 IU vs. Q10 100 mg QD
- 30 Days in Statin Myopathic Patients
- 14 Patients to E, 18 to Q10
- Pain Severity ? 40 With Q10
- Pain Severity ? 9 With E
Caso Am J Card 2007
63Coenzyme Q10 Does Not Improve Simvastatin
Tolerability in Dylipidemic Patients with
Prior Statin-Induced Myalgia
- Prospective, Randomized, Blinded Trial
- 44 Patients Prior Myalgia
- Simva 10-40 mg Q-Gel 200 QD or Simva
Placebo - No Difference in Simva Tolerance
- No Difference in Myalgia Scores
Young JM et al Circ 2007114II-41
64Ubiquinone or Co Enzyme Q10 ?
- There is No Convincing Evidence
65Coenzyme Q10 in Statin Myopathy
- 1 RC1 AT005836-01
- NIH/NCCAM
66Possible Mechanisms of Statin Induced Muscle
Injury
- 1. Reduced Sarcolemmal Cholesterol
- 2. Reduced T-Tubule Sarcoplamic Recticulum
Cholesterol Draeger JPath 2006 - 3. Reduced Isoprenoids Ubiquinone - Co-enzy Q10
- 4. Reduced Prenylation of GTP Binding Proteins -
Ras, Rac and Rho - Cell Maintenance, Growth
Reduced Apoptosis Coleman Cell Death Differ 2002 - 5. Changes in Fat Metabolism
- (Phillips P Atherosclerosis 2005)
- 6.  Increased Muscle Cholesterol ? Plant
Sterol 2nd to LDL Receptor Activity (Paiva
Clin Pharmacol Ther 2005) - Failure to Appropriately Repair Damaged
Muscle (Urso . Thompson ATVB 2005) - Vitamin D Deficiency
- Inflammation (Inflammatory Myopathy)
67Fat Myopathy ??
68Damage to Type 1 Fibers
STATIN
NO STATIN
Patients who experienced muscle symptoms
with normal CK levels Statins withdrawn for 3
mo When placebo was used, Symptoms
disappeared Stained For Lipid
Phillips et al., 2003
69Capillary
Increased High-Affinity LDL Uptake
Decreased LDL Cholesterol
ß-hydroxy-ß-methylglutaryl CoA
Inhibition of Cholesterol Synthesis
Mevalonate
Cholesterol
HMG-CoA REDUCTASE INHIBITORS
70Possible Mechanisms of Statin Induced Muscle
Injury
- 1. Reduced Sarcolemmal Cholesterol
- 2. Reduced T-Tubule Sarcoplamic Recticulum
Cholesterol Draeger JPath 2006 - 3. Reduced Isoprenoids Ubiquinone - Co-enzy Q10
- 4. Reduced Prenylation of GTP Binding Proteins -
Ras, Rac and Rho - Cell Maintenance, Growth
Reduced Apoptosis Coleman Cell Death Differ 2002 - 5. Changes in Fat Metabolism
- (Phillips P Atherosclerosis 2005)
- 6.  Increased Muscle Cholesterol ? Plant
Sterol 2nd to LDL Receptor Activity (Paiva
Clin Pharmacol Ther 2005) - Failure to Appropriately Repair Damaged
Muscle (Urso . Thompson ATVB 2005) - Vitamin D Deficiency
- Inflammation (Inflammatory Myopathy)
71Failure to Repair Damaged Muscle
- The Ubiquitin Proteosome Pathway
(Urso . Thompson ATVB 2005)
72Hoffman EP, Nader GA. Nat Med. 200410584-5.
73Atrogin 1 Background 1 Hanai ... Lecker. J.
Clin. Invest. 2007
- Ubiquitin Proteosome Pathway Breaks Down
Skeletal Muscle - Ubiquitin Protein Ligase E3 or Atrogin 1
(AT-1) - AT-1 Increases with Denervation Precedes
Muscle Loss - AT-1 Increases in Failing Hearts, Post
Partum Uterus - Muscles W/O AT-1 Do Not Atrophy Grow
Normally
74Our Gene Expression Studies Also Suggest a
Role for Atrogin
75EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN
D31
D1
Statin/ Placebo
Biopsy Right Left Vastus Lateralis
Biopsy Right Left Vastus Lateralis
Exercise Left Leg
Exercise Right Leg
76GENE EXPRESSION
- GeneChip
- Human Genome U133
- plus 2.0 array
- 47,000 transcripts and variants
- 38,500 genes
77There Are Few Changes With Statin Treatment
No Exercise, But Lots of Gene Change
With Statin Exercise
78qRT-PCR Results- Atrogin-1
79Hanai ... Lecker. J. Clin. Invest. 2007
80Possible Mechanisms of Statin Induced Muscle
Injury
- 1. Reduced Sarcolemmal Cholesterol
- 2. Reduced T-Tubule Sarcoplamic Recticulum
Cholesterol Draeger JPath 2006 - 3. Reduced Isoprenoids Ubiquinone - Co-enzy Q10
- 4. Reduced Prenylation of GTP Binding Proteins -
Ras, Rac and Rho - Cell Maintenance, Growth
Reduced Apoptosis Coleman Cell Death Differ 2002 - 5. Changes in Fat Metabolism
- (Phillips P Atherosclerosis 2005)
- 6.  Increased Muscle Cholesterol ? Plant
Sterol 2nd to LDL Receptor Activity (Paiva
Clin Pharmacol Ther 2005) - Failure to Appropriately Repair Damaged
Muscle (Urso . Thompson ATVB 2005) - Vitamin D Deficiency
- Inflammation (Inflammatory Myopathy)
81(No Transcript)
82Possible Mechanisms of Statin Induced Muscle
Injury
- 1. Reduced Sarcolemmal Cholesterol
- 2. Reduced T-Tubule Sarcoplamic Recticulum
Cholesterol Draeger JPath 2006 - 3. Reduced Isoprenoids Ubiquinone - Co-enzy Q10
- 4. Reduced Prenylation of GTP Binding Proteins -
Ras, Rac and Rho - Cell Maintenance, Growth
Reduced Apoptosis Coleman Cell Death Differ 2002 - 5. Changes in Fat Metabolism
- (Phillips P Atherosclerosis 2005)
- 6.  Increased Muscle Cholesterol ? Plant
Sterol 2nd to LDL Receptor Activity (Paiva
Clin Pharmacol Ther 2005) - Failure to Appropriately Repair Damaged
Muscle (Urso . Thompson ATVB 2005) - Vitamin D Deficiency
- Inflammation (Inflammatory Myopathy)
83(No Transcript)
84Exercise Statin Myopathy - Take Home
Messages
- Statins Are Remarkably Effective at Reducing
CAD Risk - But Can Produce Myopathic (and Possibly
Neurological) Side Effects - Exercise Causes Many of The CK Elevations
Attributed to Statins - Exercise Magnifies Statin Myalgia CK
Increases - Some Patients Report Weakness, But There is
Little Objective Data on Muscle Strength - Long Term Muscle Effects of Statins Are
Unknown
85Statins and Cognition
- Pilot Studies of Cognitive Side Effects
86It All Started With A Case
87Case Study 1
- 65-year-old Caucasian
- On atorvastatin 10 mg/day
- Mood alteration, memory difficulties
- Cognitive evaluation and fMRI of the brain
- On and off (2 months) statin therapy
- Significant improvement in cognitive function off
statins
88Using MRI to Investigate
Snapshot of VR Pool Environment
89fMRI Results
Neuronal activation during the difficult version
of the Sternberg Task, depicted by colored
regions on the 3D-rendered brains, during
encoding (left) and response selection (right)
while the subject was on 10 mg atorvastatin
(bottom) and 2 months following atorvastatin
cessation (top).
90Pilot Study 2
- fMRI during two tasks
- Sternberg Task
- Figural Memory Test
- 19 adults from 6 month statin study
- 14 on atorvastatin and 5 on placebo
- Pre-post scans
91FMRI Results FIG MEM
Figure 2. FMRI activation on 3D-rendered brain
showing changes in activation with statin use
displayed at p0.005 uncorrected level during the
encoding (left) and recognition (right) phase of
the Figural Memory Test.
92(No Transcript)
93NowDont Get Crazy
- I Came Here Not to Bury Statins, But to
Praise Them - But We Should Only Use Them When Their is
Likely to Be Benefit - And Not Put Them in the Drinking Water
- Until We Are Sure There is no Harm
94Myalgia Treatment ?
- Are Symptoms Tolerable? Measure CK
- Stop Drug Until No SX
- Try Another Statin
- Try Lower Doses Plus Minus Ezetimibe
- Try Another Class of Drug
- Try Chinese Red Rice Yeast 2 Tabs HS
- Try Atorva or Rosuva QOD or BIW
- Use Tonic (Quinine) Water HS for Cramps
- Do Pulse Therapy
- Use Q10 Supplements
95Rosuvastatin (5 mg or 10 mg) Twice a Week in
Patients Intolerant to Daily Statins
Gadarla, Kearns, Thompson Am J Cardiol 2008
96Collaborators
- Brown University Peter Herbert, Eileen
Cullinane, Stan Sady, - University of Pittsburgh Joe Zmuda, Rich Zimet,
Susan Yurgalevitch - Duke University John Guyton
- Hartford Hospital - Beth Parker, Jeff Capizzi,
Amanda Augieri, William Roman, Lindsay Lorson,
Mauren Yuscavitch, Brenda Foxen, Mary Beth
Moran, Cherie Biblie, Rick Seip, Gualberto Ruano - Umass - Priscilla Clarkson, Maria Urso, Amy
Kearns - Tufts University Richard Karas
- Washington Childrens Medical Center - Eric
Hoffman
97An Overview ofStatin Associated Myopathy
Paul D. Thompson, MD Director of
Cardiology Henry Low Heart Center, Hartford
Hospital Hartford, CT