Argument of Policy

1
Argument of Policy

• D1 A toy car is not a vehicle
• D2 A toy car is a vehicle
• ___________________________________
• D1 promotes shared family time (social goal)
• D2 hinders shared family time
• Therefore, D1 better decision
• Relevant rule should (ought to) be read as not
  applying to Timmys toy car i.e. toy car not a
  vehicle

2
Argument of Principle

1. L1 Ln establish RIGHT to peaceful enjoyment of
   public spaces
2. ART (Anal-retentive Tom) has a right to peaceful
   enjoyment of public spaces
3. ART has a right to peaceful enjoyment of park
4. Timmy and his toy car violate ARTs right to
   peaceful enjoyment of park
5. Therefore, D2 should (ought to) be the decision
6. Therefore, relevant rule should be read as
   APPLYING to Timmys toy car i.e. toy car IS a
   vehicle
7. Timmy must go off to the big house for few years