Title: THORNTONS PLC
1THORNTONS PLC INTERIM RESULTS PRESENTATION 28
weeks to 10 January 2009 WEDNESDAY 18 FEBRUARY
2009
2INTERIM RESULTS
m 2008/09 2007/08 change
Turnover 128.4m 126.7m 1.3
Profit before tax 7.3m 11.9m -38.7
EBITDA 14.6m 19.0m -23.0
EPS (Basic) 3.3p 12.5p -73.9
Underlying EPS 7.5p 12.5p -39.6
Interim dividend per share 1.20p 1.95p -38.5
3H1 SALES (28 WEEKS)
m 2008/09 2007/08 change
Retail 80.7m 82.1m -1.7
Franchise 9.9m 9.6m 3.7
Commercial 32.4m 29.7m 8.9
Thorntons Direct 5.4m 5.3m 1.2
Total 128.4m 126.7m 1.3
4BRANDED OUTLETS
2007/08 H1 New Resites Closures 2008/09 H1
Retail 378 4 - (1) 381
Franchise 252 11 - (3) 260
Total 630 15 - (4) 641
Retail LfL Sales 3.7 -3.7
5MARGINS AND PBT
2008/09 2007/08 change
Sales (m) 128.4m 126.7m 1.3
Gross margin ( of sales) 49.2 51.5 (2.3)
PBT ( of sales) 5.7 9.4 (3.7)
Underlying tax charge 31.7 31.7 -
One-off deferred tax charge arising from abolition of IBAs (m) 2.9m -
6GROSS PROFIT AND OPERATING EXPENSES
Gross profit margin 2007/08 51.5
Change in sales channel mix (0.5)
Promotional sales activity (1.5)
Production cost increases (2.2)
Price increases 2.5
Other (0.6)
Gross profit margin 2008/09 49.2
Operating expense ( of sales)
2007/08 41.6
2008/09 43.2
7CASH AND DEBT
m 2008/09 2007/08
EBITDA 14.6m 19.0m
Share-based payment charge etc 0.3m -
Working capital movements 9.6m 5.7m
Operating cashflow 24.5m 24.7m
Net capital investment (7.3)m (4.5)m
Interest (1.2)m (1.2)m
Dividends (3.2)m (3.2)m
Share issue proceeds - 0.2m
Other - mainly tax (0.8)m (0.9)m
Movement in net debt 12.0m 15.1m
Closing net debt 16.3m 11.3m
8EXISTING COVENANTS
Bank covenant tests were met at the end of H1
- Interest cover
- Net debt to EBITDA
- Fixed charge cover
9STRATEGY
Deliver sustainable, profitable growth by
- Developing innovative new products
- Giving the brand greater relevance and a more
premium feel - Modernising the instore environment
- Further expanding the Commercial and Direct
business - Attracting and retaining the best people
BUT ADAPTED TO CURRENT MARKET CONDITIONS AND WITH
GREATER EMPHASIS ON COST SAVING INITIATIVES
10NEW PRODUCT SUCCESSES
- Excellent sales of Thorntons Moments in first
half - 2.6m in Thorntons stores
- 2.2 in Commercial sales
- Chocolate Blocks
- 0.8m in Thorntons stores from September to
Christmas - Fusions
- Successfully tested in 20 stores and online
despite cut back in support - Ice Cream
- 2 new varieties planned for this summer - mint
and white
11INCREASING BRAND RELEVANCE
- The building blocks are in place. Consumers are
increasingly seeing us as being accessible and
relevant to them.
2007 2008
Source Brand Tracker Christmas 2008
12IN-STORE ENVIRONMENT
Transforming the Customer Experience in 6 Concept
Stores
- Launch of five new stores in Kingston, Reading,
Bluewater, Nottingham (King Street) and
Edinburgh. The first step in creating a
contemporary and interactive in-store experience
for customers - First Hot Chocolate Bar in the UK in Nottingham
(Listergate). A welcoming, modern destination,
indulgent hot drinks and cakes, and the Thorntons
in store chocolatier - Added a net 3 new own stores and 8 new
franchisees in the half year
13CUSTOMER SERVICE IMPROVEMENTS
Own Stores
-
- New EPOS successfully implemented (over 4m
capex) - Transaction time down by 2/3
- Reduced queues at Christmas
- On time, on budget, all functional benefits
delivered - Improved stock management resulting in improved
availability - Auto replenishment fully implemented
- No Christmas stock hangover
- Improved in-store navigation
14COMMERCIAL SALES GROWTH
- Successful re-launch of the Thorntons inlaid
boxed chocolates range, leading to 23 growth - Added Mints and Dark Collections to the
Commercial range - Driven value into the market predominantly by
full value sales throughout the season - Strong product availability throughout the
Christmas season - Strong growth via independent and convenience
sectors due to increased distribution - A successful first season in the twist-wrap
category with the Thorntons
Moments brand - Grew the total business 8.9 despite the loss of
the Woolworths
account. Growth excluding Woolworths
was a strong 15
15INLAID BOXED CHOCOLATE VALUE GROWTH
Value Sales (m)
Change YOY
25 -6 10 -34 3 -4 49 -4
Source Nielsen Scantrack data to 27.12.08
16THORNTONS GROWTH OUTPERFORMS THE MARKET
Thorntons Inlaid (MAT)
Inlaid Market (MAT)
Kg (m)
m
m
Kg (m)
Thorntons has shown growth in both value and
volume terms, bucking the declining trend of the
total inlaid market. We have seen faster growth
in value than volume, suggesting that our growth
has come whilst discounting less than the total
inlaid market.
Source Nielsen Scantrack data to 27.12.08
Assorted Chocolates in an Inlaid Box
17STEADY INCREASES IN OVERALL DISTRIBUTION
Thorntons Weighted Distribution
Removal of Advent calendars, (increased selling
space)
2nd phase of Christmas stock displays
Introduction of Christmas stock displays
Stores listing any Thorntons product as a of
total number of outlets in the country weighted
by the relative importance of the store (usually
on category volume)
Source Nielsen Scantrack data to 27.12.08
18CHRISTMAS COMMERCIAL PERFORMANCE
Inlaid (m)
Twist Wrap (m)
Source Nielsen Scantrack data to 27.12.08
19THORNTONS DIRECT
- Online sales growth of 26 offset the decline of
the corporate sector due to the challenging
economic climate, leading to overall sales growth
of 1.3 -
- October launch of new online checkout process was
a key driver of improved site conversion by 11
YoY -
- Improved CRM focus lead to 125 increase in sales
generated via e-mails - deeper database segmentation
- more targeted communications
-
- Successful 30 growth of the database through new
initiatives to increase awareness of
www.thorntons.co.uk helped secure new visitors to
the site and deliver market share gains -
- Service level improvements to gt 98.5 across
- both consumer and corporate
20ATTRACTING AND RETAINING THE BEST PEOPLE
- Sarah Riley, new Director of HR, joined in August
- 2008
- Developed an HR strategy aimed at individual,
team and business performance improvement - Introduced a business wide employee engagement
survey - achieved 56 response rate
- 64 employee engagement index
- action planning taking place throughout business
at team level - Store staff turnover continues to decline with
consequent improvement to customer services and
sales - Won 2 awards in the 2008 Personnel Today Awards
in relation to achievements in working practices
across retail
21PROFIT IMPROVEMENT INITIATIVES
Growth Opportunities
- Driving footfall harder e.g. improved window
communication, bounce back schemes, sampling,
Perfect Partner offers, etc - Most boxed chocolate competitors are sourced in
Euros - Woolworths creates an opportunity on the High
Street in our own stores, franchises and other
accounts - Recruitment of Woolworths Category Manager as
consultant until Easter - Opportunities in other accounts
- Eg Sainsburys, Morrisons and ASDA Valentines
offers on TV - Opportunity for Corporate Sales into the Hotel
sector gathering momentum
22PROFIT IMPROVEMENT INITIATIVES
Cost Saving Initiatives - Operational
- Brought sourcing of Thorntons Moments in-house
- Streamlining production
- 1.1m Capex for second flexible packaging line
- Delivering 30 improvement on direct packaging
labour costs - 2.7 improvement of labour derived average
product margin - No overtime costs compared to last year (early
Easter) - Improvements to factory layout to avoid
unnecessary intermediate handling
23PROFIT IMPROVEMENT INITIATIVES
Cost Saving Initiatives Operational ..(cont.)
- More effective purchasing of raw materials
(except cocoa) and consumables by using
e-auctions - Further standardising packaging and ingredients
- Dual sourcing from the Far East (ribbons, trim
and rigid boxes) - Froze all small IT projects
- Realigned Thorntons Direct costs in line with
drop in Corporate sales
24RAW MATERIALS UPDATE
Dairy markets have collapsed against recent
highs, whereas the cocoa market continues its
bullish trend
Cocoa Jul 07- Present Date
154
177
100
115
Butter Jul 07- Present Date
140
85
100
57
25PROFIT IMPROVEMENT INITIATIVES
Cost Saving Initiatives - Payroll
- Froze external recruitment in the Autumn
- More closely aligned shop staff hours to sales
- Changing defined benefit pension scheme (closed
to new starters in 2002) from final salary to
career average (CARE) - Gave all employees the opportunity to apply for
flexible working for a limited time period - Invited applications from employees who want to
take a sabbatical - Engaged employees in taking unpaid leave
- Kept redundancies to a minimum to keep skilled
employees ready for the upturn
26PROFIT IMPROVEMENT INITIATIVES
Cost Saving Initiatives - Property
Cost Saving Initiatives - Property
- Over 40 of estate due for lease renewals or rent
reviews due to rapid increase in store numbers 10
years ago - Thorntons perceived as a good quality tenant
(good covenant) - New leases/lease renewals
- 5 year lease maximum
- No more upward only reviews if we agree a
longer lease - Monthly payments
- Reduced rent (if a renewal)
- Rent Reviews
- Nil increases (due to upward only clauses)
- Monthly payments where possible
27PROFIT IMPROVEMENT INITIATIVES
Cost Saving Initiatives Property ..(cont)
- Service Charges
- Downward trend, Landlords acting together because
they are having to pay service charges and rates
on empty properties - eg, Meadowhall (Sheffield) 20
- White Rose (Leeds) 15
- Laborious process 380 stores and over 150
Landlords but benefits next 5 years
28OUTLOOK
Thorntons is continuing to make progress despite
the current market conditions. Our focus on
customer service combined with our strong
operational platform and cost initiatives
position us well to take advantage of
opportunities to improve performance in the
second half of the financial year. These include
- a three week longer selling season due to a late
Easter - increased selling opportunities following the
closure of Woolworths - improved manufacturing productivity versus last
year when we incurred higher costs due to the
early Easter
29SUMMARY
- Positive like for likes every week since
Christmas (except snow week) - Well positioned to emerge from current market
conditions a more vibrant, efficient business - The Board has agreed a reduced dividend of 1.20
pence per share in line with underlying earnings