Title: Joint PPCConvenors meeting
1Joint PPC/Convenors meeting
- Purpose
- Common baseline
- Key objectives for the week
- Issues to be addressed
2Agenda
- Briefing by Secretariat
- Meeting details
- Priorities for the week
- As set in Vico Equense
- ISO Issues
- Project issues
- Liaison challenges
- Administrative issues
- Action item status
- Issues from the PPC and Convenors
3Briefing by Secretariat
- Ron Kolakowski is sole Secretariat representative
this week - Ballot status on SC4ONLINE
- Website development
- Advanced resolutions
4Meeting details
- Industry day Wednesday
- Offsite in the morning
- Workshop in the afternoon
- Liaison plenary combined with OTF on Monday
evening - PLIB seminar all day Friday (in French)
5Challenges from Vico Equense
- Project targets as declared to the Secretariat
- - Less than 5 of projects delayed
- AP221, AP236, PAS 20542 published
- Draft of AP233
- AP235 CD out for ballot
- MANDATE and PSL submitted for publication to ISO
- 13584-501 and -511 submitted to ISO
- Coherent NWI on catalogue XML accepted
- Supplementary Directives update out for ballot
- ISO TMB Standards as Databases proposal delivered
- SC4 MA proposal/database business case drafted
- PAFOC proposal for AP203
- JWG1 documents - ballot coordination
- Strategy for harmonisation with core components
- Proposal for improved liaison with TC154
- Role of SC4 established on RFID application
standards - Reduced cost base for 2007 meetings
6WG plans from Vico Equense
- WG2
- NWI for joint activity with 22745 team for simple
XML schema for exchange of part characteristics - NWI for simplified XML schema for PLIB covering
dictionaries and reference dictionary - NWI proposal for using spreadsheets to capture
PLIB information - NWI for Web services for reconciliation of source
organisation, code name, and ontology services - NWI proposal for property templates
- IS version of 13584-511 sent to Geneva following
review by TC2 - Draft of DIS for modified dictionary model
13584-42, for review at meeting
7WG plans from Vico Equense
- WG3
- Launch of DIS ballot for AP 203 ed 2
- Draft of AP209e2
- Completion of TS documents for AP 210 ed 2
modules - Launch of DIS ballot for AP210 ed2
- Submission of AP221 for publication
- CD for AP233 by April 6
- Launch of DIS ballot for AP235 by September
- Publication of ISO 10303 AP236 on furniture
8WG plans from Vico Equense
- WG3
- Delivery of final AP238 by end May
- Plan for final draft of 15926-3 TS
- NWI/CD TS for 15926-6
- NWI on Gellish table, Process monitoring data,
OWL representation of ISO 15926-2 - Development of draft TS version of 15926-3 for
review in Toulouse - Ballot resolution for 15926-4
- Ballot resolution for 15926-7 for templates
9WG plans from Vico Equense
- JWG8
- Submission of ISO 15531-43 by end March
- Submission of ISO 18629-13, -14, -41, -42, -43,
-44 by end March - New work item on 15531-44 by end May
10WG plans from Vico Equense
- WG12
- Launch of CD ballot on Part 45 ed2 to support AP
235 - Draft of 10303-58 ready for CD ballot
- Draft of ISO 10303-59 for CD ballot in July
- Submission of 10303-52, -53, -110 for DIS ballot
- Completion of CD ballots for ISO 22745-1,11,13,20
- Launch of CD/TS ballot for 22745-10,30,50, 200
- Launch of CD ballot of ISO 8000 components for
Catalogue Management
11Key ISO developments
- Brian Stanton here until Tuesday
- Latest ISO Directives
- Part 1 PPC/secretariat to look at process
impact - Part 2 incorporated in Supplementary Directives
draft - Internal Committee balloting application
- New submission interface with progress tracking
- SC4 can submit multiple parts by arrangement
- MA/RA can be based on TS, but note six year life
12Cancellations by ISO
- DIS/FDIS dates fixed in ISO database for NWI
- Three month period of grace for DIS delivery
- No new cancellations
- Due for cancellation in September 10303-112
- Great care needed as projects approach targets
- AP233 came under threat due to poor information
- Work programme extracts now available online -
updated daily - Critical
- Warning
- Cancelled in last year
- Extracted and loaded on SC4ONLINE
13ISO publication process
- Process improvements
- New ISO editor (Brian Stanton) to help SC4 to
maintain SDs to be fully compliant with ISO
Directives and practice - ISO editor to review documents before submission
(2 wks) - Aim is to minimise editorial intervention
- Need to sort requirement for individual DIS of
module - Some SD updates required to match current
practice - PPC to sort any process changes in Handbook
- HTML
- Agreed delivery packaging for modules - process
refinement in SC4 to be enforced by Secretariat - SD updates to reflect final decisions
- Possible use of CSS for harvested documents
14ISO PDF rules
- ITSIG has agreed that
- Acrobat version 4.05 and above may be used
- Distillation of files shall be to PDF
compatibility level 1.3 - to allow for the addition of digital rights
management features, PDF files may be edited and
saved as PDF version 1.5 - The ISO/CS will thus accept PDF files up to and
including PDF version 1.5 provided that they have
been distilled to PDF compatibility level 1.3
15ISO marketing strategy
- Range of products
- Modules to be published individually, followed by
CD-ROM package of AP and modules - Niche market packages of APs
- STEP CD-ROM
- ISO CS would like to promote SC4 standards more
strongly with industry need more marketing
material eg ISO Focus articles - Suggestion that modules be treated as a standards
database, with a single repository under
configuration control by a maintenance agency
16Standards as databases (1)
- ISO TMB activity
- Four main classes of database identified
- Terms and definitions
- Graphical symbols
- Product data definitions / Product properties
- Reference data
- Individual items (lists) or structured data
- Development - items stored in database, or
database as master - Accessibility public or restricted to
authorized users - Final product as document (paper/electronic),
database or both - Business model free (preferred by TCs), or
various forms of payment (preferred by ISO)
17Standards as databases (2)
- Group now working electronically
- Consultation from ISO on use of stage code system
and IEC process - Chris Kreiler and MA team provided SC4 position
- Based on draft MA document
18Project Management
- Project updates in advance
- 209 tasks in ISO work programme some missing
- Systematic reviews completed NWI option
- AP221, AP210, AP236 late
- Tasks showing late/missing information
- PLIB parts 501 and 511
- 15926-4
- Eleven parts in ISO publication
- Project updates will be sought during the meeting
- Ron Kolakowski has the database
19Project Issues
- Confirmation of overall SC4 product terminology
as per exploder - Change Management for modules implementation
- Maintenance agency for reference data libraries
and 22745 - Business and governance models MA/RA
- Supplementary directives update
20New work items
- NWI proposals to be reviewed
- MANDATE Part 44
- Gear forms from TC60 via Germany
- Others?
- Review set for Tuesday at 1300
21Liaison challenges
- Objections from IAI to AP 241 proposal IAI now
seem to want to standardise PAS 16739 - Briefly met TC10 chair happy to collaborate
- Collaboration with TC10 on ISO 16792 - technical
documentation - ISO/TC 10/WG 17 Vocabulary of terms and
definitions - Study group on document management between IEC
TC3 and ISO TC10 - Coordination with TC171/SC2 on PDF/E
- ISO TC37 terminology Coordination on their NWI
on Product Data Classification (from last
August...) - ISO TC67 interest in 15926 Parts 4-7
- Liaisons to TC8 and TC184/SC5 required
- Coordination with JTC1/SC7 on Systems Engineering
NWI - Requirements for liaison with ISO TC215 on
medical informatics (Germany) - Electrical liaisons - IEC TC93 liaison
statement - Review of list of liaisons
- discrepancies with ISO
- effectiveness
22IEC SB3
- NWI form offered as alternative to Change
Management form - ISO/IEC Guide 75 on strategic principles for
industrial automation to be published after
editorial corrections - eBusiness Framework being extended to cover
Industrial automation PPC Big Picture - O3NEIDA consortium supporting open standards for
industrial automation - New chairman being sought
- IEC TC93 not present
23TC154
- Chair met with TC184 and TC154 chairs in November
- Now have clear view of work programme almost
entirely resourced by UN/CEFACT - AFNOR working on requested proposal for
accommodating TC154 work programme in TC184 - Draft produced January 2006
- Final proposal due June 2006
- No longer urgent, since TC154 chair and
secretariat now available until 2008
reluctantly - Integration at WG level is unacceptable to TC154
- Integration at SC level doesnt change anything
- Are there any requirements for joint work?
- TC154 chair present this week to discuss further
- Both WG2 and ISO 22745 projects engaging with
UN/CEFACT
24JTC1/SC31 on RFID
- Liaison meeting and telecon with TC20/WG13 and
JTC1/SC31 in ad hoc group Mason, Benson,
Radack, Leal, Swindells, Sandsmark, Yee - SC31 appointed Rob Leibrandt as liaison officer
- Action items for SC4
- Review process for definition of information
objects - Identify suitable information objects and apply
for AFI/NSI as appropriate - NWI for extension of ISO TS 21849 to general
industrial use - Appointment of liaison officers
- Interesting set of technical issues identified
- Possible use in other parts of TC184
- Activity being promoted through MoU/MG
- SC31 approved continuation of ad hoc group
25IEC TC65 proposal on JWG1 trial
- IEC TC65 would like to undertake a trial of the
JWG1 process to develop a common definition of
Product Properties and Classification across
Industrial Data - Involves SC4/WG2 and IEC SC65A/B/C, SC17B and
SC22G - Based on ISO 13584/IEC 61360
- Each group responsible for technology in their
own area
26MoU/MG matters
- Integrated standards view of eBusiness updated
- Common IPR policy for standards from different
groups - Facilitates use of combinations of standards to
meet business need - ISO/IEC/ITU agreement welcomed
- Rolling review of MoU/MG recommendations not
more than three years - Valuable exchange with collocated UN/CEFACT and
ISO TC154 meetings - Howard Mason of BAE Systems, Chair of ISO
TC184/SC4 confirmed as MoU/MG chair for 2006-2007 - Next meeting in October, prior to Hershey
- Any issues?
27Current MoU/MG issues (1)
- Framework for eBusiness standards
- Includes CEFACT and OASIS models
- Actively supported by NIST eBSC activity
- Aligned with open-edi model
- Supported by matrix of descriptions and examples
- Being used for standards planning by the US
Aerospace industry and other groups
28Semantics - Terminology
Scenarios
Service assembly
10
Consraints
Contractual and regulatory
Security
Registry/Repostory for Discovery, Presence,
Availability
7
Conformance and interoperability testing
Process models
Information content/components Classification
schemes Component libraries Enterprise data and
metadata Reference data Identifiers
Data Assembly
37
29
3
8
13
14
15
24
19
11
16
9
17
Process definition mechanisms
Information definition mechanisms
4
5
32
Service definition mechanisms
26
18
23
Representation options
27
28
Transport options
30
35
34
22
Networks
31
38
Guidelines
Physical representation
20
n is row number in eBSC matrix
n
Rev 4 2005-06-10
29Current MoU/MG issues (2)
- Open registry for eBusiness standards work
- Based on MoU/MG Framework
- Metadata and mechanism to be defined
- Need federated approach, with moderation for
consistency - ANSI offering to host
- All members to highlight relevant NWI for
visibility - Terminology
- Federated structure of definition databases
- Appropriate business model required for free
downloads from the web - Semantic interoperability principles document
agreed
30Current MoU/MG issues (3)
- Information architecture
- Product classification schemes
- e-Catalogues/Dictionaries - JWG1 defining
consistent structure and content based on PLIB
(ISO 13584/IEC61360) - Enterprise information models
- Master data/code lists - repositories of valid
values to support core components - multilingual
support needed
31Current MoU/MG issues (4)
- ebXML Core Components methods and procedures
- First four ebXML specifications from OASIS
adopted as ISO 15000 - CCTS 2.01 from CEFACT adopted as ISO 15000-5
- Updates to be forwarded for ISO standardisation
- Agreement to focus core component development
through CEFACT TBG17 - OASIS, OAGIS 9.0, AIAG,
CEFACT,. - Core component open development process to be
clearly articulated by May 2006, based on initial
experience with UBL and TDED components.
Library administration process drafted - Naming and Design Rules being harmonised between
UBL and the other groups - Harmonisation of information modelling methods
32Current MoU/MG issues (5)
- Universal Business Language (UBL)
- Version 1.0 accepted as OASIS standard - may go
to ISO - Localisation in the Far East - opportunity for
TC37 - UBL 2.0 due 4Q2006
- Transfer to CEFACT after 2.0 being negotiated
- Test case for CCTS 3.0
- Convergence with UNeDOCS and TDED being explored
- Open tools for generating UN Layout Key documents
and HTML forms - Global name and address standards
- UPU standard for postal addresses
- Need further consideration of location for
deliveries, etc - Harmonised taxonomy of eGovernment services
33Current MoU/MG issues (6)
- Feasibility study to converge the GS1 GPC and
UNSPSC classification schemes - Biometrics
- Secure container transportation
- Web services relaunch of JTC1 study group
- Cultural diversity
- Consistent URN for standards ISO proposal
- Clear set of definitions for different elements
of security to be defined - Data protection/privacy requirements to be
defined by government bodies, for action by
standards groups
34Administrative action items
- STEPmod backups
- HTML build of modules
- Standards retention policy for SC4
- Governance of SC4ONLINE
- Policy issues from SC4 Resolutions - PPC
- Handbook updates PPC
- Improving the work between meetings
- Open source standards?
35QC items
- Dated references to non-SC4 standards
- Bugzilla requirements statement
- Possible use of HTML CSS for harvested documents
36CEO items
- Web page for vendor products - CEO to consider
- Updates to SOAP - CEO
- CEO to provide libraries of documents to
plagiarise for articles
37WG13 launch
- 24 experts nominated
- Need to select Convenor and deputy 4 candidates
- Bruno Garnier-Moiroux
- Tim King
- Junfeng Zhan
- Steve Arnett (Deputy)
- SC4 to select and appoint
38Convenor Vacancies
- QC deputy
- Deputy for WG11
- Participants for WG11
- Participants for WG3/T19 - AP203 ed2, AP214 ed 3
39Future meetings
- 22-27 October 2006 Hershey, Pennsylvania, USA
- (50th plenary)
- 25-30 March 2007 Funchal, Portugal
- 1-6 July 2007 Ibusuki, Japan
- October 2007 Dallas, TX, USA hosted by SOLE
- Autumn 2008 - Korea
40Other issues
41Liaisons - Brief Reports
- SC4/OMG overlaps and related activities - David
Price - Maintenance Agency for the ISO 13399 Dictionaries
- Norman Swindells - ECCMA and AC135 - Peter Benson
- IAI and PAS 16739 Thomas Leibich
42Liaison Plenary/Open Technical Forum
- Topic Manufacturing - product data needs
- for the next generation
- Time Monday 17.30-20.00
- Presentations
- The IMS project - Bob Kiggans
- IEC SB3 Industrial Automation model - Howard
Mason - Liaison with ISO TC 184/SC 5 Introduction to IEC
62264 by Jean-Jacques Michel - ISO 13399 - Jonas Nordstrom
- STEP Shipbuilding Demonstration Highlights - Ron
Wood - Product description and cataloguing for
manufacturing equipment - Raymond Betz - The PROMISE project PLM - Dimitris Kiritsis
- From post-processor programming to STEP world and
Long Term Archiving - Pierre-Laurent Kociemba
(CEO - CIMPA / EADS) - Liaison with ASD STEP LOng Term ARchival Project
- Jean-Yves Delaunay (SC 4 Airbus Coordinator)
43Challenge for the future
- Standards are the next business paradigm
- SC4 standards have been proved to deliver benefit
to organisations which implement them - Much of the current work programme is completed
within a year - What does SC4 need to deliver in the next three
years in order to drive the wider deployment of
its standards and information models? - What barriers do we need to break down?
- What is the KILLER AP(P)?