Title: The Healthcare Sector
1The Healthcare Sector
- Healthcare Team
- Josh Dritz
- Ribhe Elsalaymeh
- Matthew Endress
- Corey Jansen
- Aasim Khwaja
- Matt Titus
- Colleen Zaczek
2Agenda
- Current Situation
- SP Breakdown
- The Sector Clock
- Investment Recommendation
- Names to be Reduced
- Cardinal Health, Inc. (CAH)
- Johnson and Johnson (JNJ)
- Conclusion
3Current Situation
- Current SIM weighting (September 23, 2003)
- 16.54 of SIM portfolio
- Overweight by 2.89
- Recovery warrants a move away from defensive
stocks - As a growth investors we put a greater weight on
slowing growth rate than the undervalued status - Recommend moving to a 1 underweight for the
overall sector
4SP Breakdown Sub-sector Weights
Pharmaceuticals dominate Four sub-sectors
account for more than 90 of the Healthcare sector
Data as of October 31, 2003
5The Sector Clock
The time is 400 for the Healthcare Sector Cheap
without catalyst
6Investment Summary
- We recommend maintaining current positions in the
following stocks - AmerisourceBergen (ABC) continuing earnings
growth due to additional efficiencies gained from
merger as well as increased demand for
pharmaceuticals due to Medicare Bill - Amgen Inc. (AMGN), Medtronic (MDT) Biotech
offers continued growth potential due to
proprietary technologies and pioneering attitudes
of the firms in this sector - UnitedHealth Group (UNH) overall windfall
expected for HMOs due to Medicare bill which
increases payments for all groups - Pfizer (PFE) demographics strength, Medicare
bill, bigger gains from efficiencies in the
supply chain than competition, and merger
synergies - We recommend reducing holdings in the following
stocks - Cardinal Health, Inc. (CAH)
- Johnson and Johnson (JNJ)
7Cardinal Health, Inc. (CAH)
- Global healthcare services company focused on
wholesale drug distribution with diversified
businesses in other areas of healthcare - Medical Products and Services
- Automation and Information Services
- Pharmaceutical Technologies and Services
- Current Position -- 4.67 of the SIM portfolio
- Recommended Position 2.36 of the SIM portfolio
- Reasons to Keep
- Solid company
- Defensive position is still important
- Most diversified of competition with high margin
components (AIS, PTS) - Reasons to Sell
- Continuing pressures on wholesale distribution
margins and overall business model - Major contracts up for bid
- Price pressure on suppliers
8Cardinal Health, Inc. (CAH)
- Trend indicates that CAH may not be able to
outpace the overall Healthcare sector for much
longer
9Cardinal Health, Inc. (CAH)
- P/E ratio still attractive, supporting keeping
the stock in the portfolio with reduction in
overall investment weighting
10Cardinal Health, Inc. (CAH)
- ROE has maintained consistent level
- Margin is better than competition and improving
due to diversification into more profitable
sectors of the market
11Cardinal Health, Inc. (CAH)
- Slowing net income growth
- Buy margin opportunities in wholesale drug
distribution business are going away - Sell margin in wholesale drug distribution is
non-existent
12Johnson and Johnson (JNJ)
- Global manufacturer of healthcare related
products pharmaceutical, surgical equipment,
and consumer health products - Current Position 1.58 of the SIM portfolio
- Recommended Position 0 of the SIM portfolio
- Reasons to Sell
- Pharmaceutical business the key driver of sales
and EPS growth over the past several years has
begun to moderate due to patent expiration and
launch of competitor products - Medical device competition (stents) is
threatening the margins on JNJs highest margin
product line
13Johnson and Johnson (JNJ)
- Moderately valued relative to the sector with in
line growth (there are higher growth stocks in
the portfolio at lower P/E ratios)
14Johnson and Johnson (JNJ)
- Concerned about growth rate trends due to supply
constraints and competition from BSX (stents) and
others
15Johnson and Johnson (JNJ)
- Current value of the stock includes current
trends in operating margins and ROE - Competition and patent pressure put future growth
of these measures at risk
16Johnson and Johnson (JNJ)
- Inventory rise is concerning given industry-wide
changes in distribution trends need to cut
production to get that product into the channel - Long-term debt is of interest
17Johnson and Johnson (JNJ)
- Would have expected Gross Profit to grow at a
faster rate due to Stent sales which is not
evident here
18Conclusion
- Several sub-sectors of the Healthcare portfolio
remain attractive - External factors continue to point to top and
bottom line growth - Competition from generics and weaker pipeline
threaten growth potential of the Pharma space - Demographic drivers already reflected in stock
prices of many sub-sectors - Overall reduce holdings to capture recent gains
and fund move toward higher growth stocks as
economy recovers and B2B spending increases