Title: Protons%20for%20Breakfast
1Protons for Breakfast
- Week 6
- Do we need nuclear power?
2In the event of an alarm sounding
3Nuclear PowerThe UK Energy Scene
Security of Supply
Cost!
Carbon
Carbon
Carbon
Renewables versus Nuclear
Chernobyl
Carbon
Carbon
Carbon
Link to Weapons
Diversity of Supply
Carbon
Carbon
Sustainability
Waste!
4Nuclear PowerThe UK Context
- How is electricity generated?
- How much electricity does Britain need and where
does it come from? - Nuclear Power Stations are due for closure
- Energy Gap?
- How to replace the lost generating capacity?
- Reduce demand, Wind Power, Tidal Barrage, Solar
Power? - Nuclear Power?
- Radioactivity Nuclear Fission
- Pros and Cons
5Tonights TalkElectricity generation in the UK
- How is electricity generated?
- How much electricity does Britain need and where
does it come from? - Nuclear Power Stations are due for closure
- How to replace the lost generating capacity?
- Reduce demand, Wind Power, Tidal Barrage, Solar
Power? - Nuclear Power?
- Radioactivity Nuclear Fission
- Pros and Cons
Does Britian need nuclear power?
6Helpers
- Jonathan Pearce
- Laurie Winkless
- Lindsay Chapman
- Mateusz Szymanski
- Matthew Tedaldi
- Nathan Stradling
- Neelaksh Sadhoo
- Paul Carroll
- Peter Quested
- Peter Woolliams
- Piers de Lavison
- Rainer Winkler
- Richard Gilham
- Robin Underwood
- Ruth Montgomery
- Sharmila Hanson
- Stephanie Bell
- Steven Legg
- Tim Burnitt
Experts Martin Milton Tom Gardiner Paul
Quincy Nigel Fox Heather Browning Andrew
Gregory Andrew Beardmore David Knight Bob
Clarke Kevin Lees Alan DuSautoy Alan
Turnbull Nigel Jennett John Makepeace Simon Jerome
- Amanda Law
- Andrew Hanson
- Arzu Arinc
- Averil Horton
- Clive Scoggins
- Deborah Lea
- Emma Woolliams
- Gianluca Memoli
- Heather Browning
- Jacquie Elkin
- James Miall
- Jeff Flowers
- Jenny Wilkinson
- Jian Wang
- Joanna Lee
- John Makepeace
- John Mountford
7Electricity
Where does it come from?
8Tonights Talk
- How is electricity generated?
9How is electricity generated? (1)
Type of station Electricity made by What makes coil turn? Energy Source Ultimate Source
Coal Coil turning in a magnetic field Turbine driven by hot steam Chemical C O2 ? CO2 Solar
Gas Coil turning in a magnetic field Turbines driven by hot gas and steam Chemical CH4 2O2 ? CO2 2H20 Solar
Nuclear Coil turning in a magnetic field Turbine driven by hot steam Nuclear Fission U n? ??? Stellar
Wind/Wave Coil turning in a magnetic field Turbine driven by air or water Nuclear Fusion 4H ? He Solar
Mamod Coil turning in a magnetic field Pistons driven by steam Chemical C O2 ? CO2 ?
10Mamod
11While the station powers up
- Please take 10 minutes to fill out the feedback
forms. - These forms are important
- They help everyone involved in the course assess
whether it has been successful, and decide what
to change and what to keep the same
Ticking the boxes is important, but your
comments are especially valuable.
12- How much electricity do we need?
13Electricity Generation in UK Daily variations in
2001/2002
- gigawatt (GW)
- billion watts 109 W
- 1000000000 W
- 10 Million Light bulbs
1 gigawatt (GW) billion watts 109 W 10 Million
100 W light bulbs Roughly speaking 1 large power
station
14Electricity Demand 2001-2009
Mmmm. Looks near to 60 GW peak demand!
15Electricity Generation in UK Daily variations in
2001/2002
- 1 gigawatt (GW)
- billion watts 109 W
- 10 Million 100 W light bulbs
- Roughly speaking 1 large power station
Required generating capacity (GW) Summer Winter
Peak 45 60
Base 25 30
Daily Maximum- Daily Minimum 30 30
16Energy Consumption Right Now!
- How do we meet this demand?
17Electricity Generation in UK
- Typical Winter Demand
- Thursday 6th December 2001
Power (GW)
50
40
Large Coal
30
20
Gas (Combined Cycle)
10
Nuclear
0
600
1200
1800
2400
000
Time of Day
18Electricity Generation in UK Data from 2004
19Current UK Nuclear CapacityHistory and Future
History
20Electricity Generation in UK 2020
- Nuclear will decline
- Renewables will increase
- but by how much?
- No shortage of coal and gas
- See BP Energy Review
- Cost?
- Security of supply?
Wind/Biomass/Landfill Gas
3.5
Imports
Hydroelectric
2.5
1
Coal
Nuclear
33
Oil
1
Gas
40
http//www.bp.com/productlanding.do?categoryId692
9contentId7044622
21Alternatives?
60
50
- Is it possible to
- Reduce Gas and Coal generation
- Increase Renewables
- Avoid replacing Nuclear Power stations
40
30
20
Can we reduce demand?
10
22What to do?Reduce Demand
- My familys electricity usage for the last four
years - Can we make people and businesses use
less?electricity? - Price
- Rationing
2000 kWh 20 reduction
260 a year
23Electricity Usage in UK 2004
Universal use of CF light bulbs will eliminate
the need for 1 large power station
24Alternatives?
60
Most people would think this is wildly optimistic!
50
- So reducing demand could help.
40
30
What can wind provide?
20
10
25Wind Power (1)UK Wind in 2007
- UK has some of the best sites in Europe
- Currently
- 154 Projects
- 1900 Turbines
- 2.293 GW
- Plus
- 1.3 GW under construction
- 4.6 GW planning approved
- 9.8 GW seeking approval
- 18 GW in a few years time
26Wind Power Could we get 10 (5.3 GW) of
electricity from wind?
- Wind has problems of
- availability
- variability
27Alternatives?
60
Very ambitious, but achievable
50
WIND
40
- So wind can provide a lot of power,
- but we cant control when it is generated
- Could we store some of the power?
30
20
10
28Wind Power The Grid
- Electricity needs to be generated at exactly the
time it is needed. - Storage is possible, but difficult
- Variability limits likely maximum wind
contribution to about - 10? Yes
- 20? Arguably
- 30? Unlikely
Photo Credit Spencer Jarvis
29Electricity Generation in UKPumped Storage
- 0 to 1.3 GW in 12 seconds
30Other Alternatives?
60
50
WIND
WIND STOR
- So reducing demand can help.
- And wind and stored energy could help too
-
- What about solar electricity?
40
30
20
10
31Solar Photo VoltaicStep 1
- Put this on your roof
- 9 m2
- Twickenham
32Solar Photo Voltaic Step 2
33Solar Photo VoltaicHey presto!
AMAZING FACT! In the summer months there is
more solar energy at UK latitude than EVER
reaches the Equator!
PLUS GOVERNMENT CASHBACK! 0.35 for every unit
fed back to the grid!
- Average 3.5 kWh/day (1277.5 kWh/year)
- Saving 3.5 x 13 pence per kWh 46 p/day (166 /
year) - Cost in 2005 9000
- Return on investment 1.8
34Other Alternatives?
60
Mainly in Summer
50
WIND
WIND STOR
40
- So reducing demand can help.
- And wind and stored energy could help too.
- Even solar energy can help
-
SUN
30
20
10
35Severn Tidal Barrage
- Could generate 10 of UK demand
- 5 GW
- 15B
36Summary
MmmEvery one of these figures looks optimistic
60
50
WIND
WIND STOR
Action Effect (GW)
Reducing demand 10
wind and stored energy 10
tidal barrage or lagoons 10
Solar energy 3
And there are many other possibilities ?
40
SUN
TIDE
30
20
10
37Nuclear PowerThe UK Context
The UK is committed to 34 reduction in CO2
emission by 2020
The UK is committed to 80 reduction in CO2
emission by 2050
Sustainable and diverse supplies are more secure
Renewables AND Nuclear
Renewables versus Nuclear
Energy costs likely to rise in long term
38Carbon Crunch
60
50
WIND
WIND STOR
Method of generation Kilograms of CO2 emitter for every 1 kWhe supplied
Coal ?1
Gas (CCGT) ?0.5
Wind ?0.01
Tide ?0.01
Nuclear ?0.01
40
SUN
TIDE
30
20
10
39Summary
60
50
WIND
WIND STOR
- 11 GW of CO2-free generating capacity will be
retiring in the next 17 years - Even replacing it will not reduce CO2 emissions
40
SUN
TIDE
30
20
10
So lets find out about nuclear power!
40- To understand nuclear power
- and how it works
- we first need to understand about
- Radioactivity
41Some radioactive things (10)
- Lets look at some radioactive things
- Detectors
- Cloud Chamber
- Supermarket Radioactivity
42Remember this
43Powers of Ten Nuclear Power
1018
1024
100
106
1012
10-6
1030
1036
10-18
10-12
Very Very Large
Very Very Small
103
109
1015
10-3
1021
1027
1033
10-15
10-9
The issues surrounding nuclear power involve
physical processes with length scales spanning 25
powers of 10!
44How are atoms made?
Electrical Repulsion
proton
Interact by the short range strong force not
electrical
45How are atoms made?
46What is Radioactivity(2)
- Normally nuclei act as heavy point-like centres
for atoms - More than 99.9 of the mass of every atom is made
of nuclear matter - More than 99.9 of the mass of your breakfast is
made of nuclear matter
Nucleus
47What is Radioactivity(3)
- The number of protons () in the nucleus
determines the number of electrons required to
make the atom neutral - This determines the chemical and physical
properties of the atom - But the number of neutrons in a nucleus can vary
48What is Radioactivity(4)Example 39K, 40K and 41K
- Potassium is 2.4 of the Earths crust
- Natural potassium (symbol K) has three isotopes
39K
19 protons 20 neutrons 20 19 39
40K
19 protons 21 neutrons 21 19 40
41K
19 protons 22 neutrons 22 19 41
93.3
6.7
49What is Radioactivity(6)
- Three types of radioactivity
- Named with the Greek a, b, c
- a alpha, b beta, g gamma
- Nuclei with a balanced number of protons and
neutrons are stable
Isotopes with too many protons Isotopes withtoo many neutrons
Alpha decay Beta decay
Emission of fast moving helium nucleus Emission of fast moving electron
And gamma radiation And gamma radiation
50What is Radioactivity(8)Alpha (a) Decay
Nucleus with too many protons
51What is Radioactivity(8)Beta (b) Decay
Nucleus with too many neutrons
52Radioactivity
- What are the health risks
- of ionising radiation?
53Radioactive health risksIntroduction
- Radioactive emissions a alpha, b beta, g gamma
- If they pass living cells, they interact
electrically and cause damage. - Cells are killed
- Can cause mutations and cancer
- Very bad for you
- Fortunately we have evolved in a radioactive
world
54Radioactive health risksMeasurement units
- Many ways of measuring radioactive dose
- Optimal measure for effect on human health is the
- Sievert
55Radioactive health risksAnnual average UK dose
Source Dose (mSv)
Natural
Cosmic 0.26
Gamma rays 0.35
Internal 0.3
Radon 1.3
Artificial
Medical 0.37
Occupational 0.007
Fallout 0.005
Products 0.0004
Discharges 0.0002
Total 2.6
- Average annual dose to the UK population from all
sources - Average 0.0026 Sieverts
- Average 2.6 milliSieverts
- About 7 microSieverts /day
56Radioactive health risksSources
From food About 15 million potassium 40 atoms and
7000 natural uranium atoms disintegrate inside us
each hour
57What is Nuclear Power?
- Nuclear Power
- How does it work?
58Nuclear Fission (1)Fission means splitting
- Some heavy nuclei can be induced to fission i.e.
split in two by the addition of a single neutron - Nuclear fragments move very fast. As they
interact with nearby atoms they cause tremendous
heating
One more wafer thin neutron, Sir?
59Nuclear Fission (2)Uranium
- Uranium has two common isotopes 238U and 235U
- Uranium has 92 protons
- The 238 or 235 is the total number of protons and
neutrons
238U 235U
neutrons 238 92 146 235 92 143
natural uranium. 99.3 0.7
Fissile? No Yes
60Nuclear Fission (3)Uranium Fission
- 235U n gtgtgt 236U n
- After a short while
- 236U gtgtgt fragments 3 n
61Nuclear Fission (4)Chain reaction
- 235U n gtgtgt 236U gtgtgt Fragments 3n
62Nuclear Fission (5)Chain reaction
- Each fission produces 3 extra neutrons on average
- If more than one neutron produces an additional
fission - The rate of fission increases
- If uncontrolled leads to a nuclear explosion
- If less than one neutron produces an additional
fission - Then the rate of fission decreases
- Nuclear reactions will die out
- If exactly one neutron produces an additional
fission - Sustainable nuclear reaction
63Nuclear Power Stations
64UK Nuclear Energy update
AREVA and Electricité de France's (EDF) European
Pressurized Reactor (EPR) Westinghouse Electric
Company's (WEC) AP1000 pressurized water reactor
(PWR)
Westinghouse Link
65What is Nuclear Power?
66Nuclear PowerThe UK Context
Energy Density
Radioactive Emissions
Very low CO2 emissions
Reliability
67Nuclear Fission (6)
- 1 kg natural uranium has a volume of 50 cm3
- Produces 40 thousand kWh
- Equivalent to 16 tons of coal
- Nuclear energy is cleaner than coal
- Lower radioactive emissions
- Much less radioactive waste
- Conventional Power Stations
- Cheaper than nuclear because they dont pay to
clean up their waste (CO2) - Reliability
- One fifth of UK electricity supply for last 30
years
68What is Nuclear Power?
69Nuclear PowerThe UK Context
Terrorism
Chernobyl
Waste!
Link to Weapons
70Nuclear PowerThe UK Context
Chernobyl
71Catastrophic ExplosionChernobyl
- 26 April 1986
- 31 dead Immediately
- Ultimate death toll
- 100?
- 15,000?
72Chernobyl Effect on UK
Fall out from atmospheric atomic weapons testing
- Total radiation dose was 20 times less than the
dose from the atmospheric bomb tests from 1945 to
1963.
Annual dose (micro Sieverts)
Chernobyl
1951
1988
Year
73Nuclear PowerThe UK Context
Waste!
74Nuclear Fission (4)Chain reaction
- 235U n gtgtgt 236U gtgtgt Fragments 3n
75Waste (4)Carbon versus Nuclear
Waste Radioactive Waste Carbon Waste(CO2)
Cost Large, but calculable Incalculable
Worldwide Physical Mass lt1 million tonnes cumulative total gt30 billion tonnes per year
Manageable Probably Probably not
76Nuclear PowerThe UK Context
Link to Weapons
77Nuclear Fission (6)Chain reaction
- Nuclear phenomena has always been associated with
great hopes and great fears. - Chicago
- 325 P.M. December 2, 1942
- Nuclear Age began
- Gain 1.0006
78Nuclear Fission (6)Hopes
- Arthur Compton
- One of the things that I shall not forget is the
expressions on the faces of some of the men.
There was Fermi's faceone saw in him no sign of
elation. The experiment had worked just as he had
expected and that was that. But I remember best
of all the face of Crawford Greenewalt. His eyes
were shining. He had seen a miracle, and a
miracle it was indeed. The dawn of a new age. As
we walked back across the campus, he talked of
his vision endless supplies of power to turn the
wheels of industry, new research techniques that
would enrich the life of man, vast new
possibilities yet hidden.
79Nuclear Fission (6)Fears
- Leo Szillard
- There was a crowd there and when it dispersed,
Fermi and I stayed there alone. Enrico Fermi and
I remained. I shook hands with Fermi and I said
that I thought this day would go down as a black
day in the history of mankind. - I was quite aware of the dangers. Not because I
am so wise but because I have read a book written
by H. G. Wells called The World Set Free. He
wrote this before the First World War and
described in it the development of atomic bombs,
and the war fought by atomic bombs. So I was
aware of these things. - But I was also aware of the fact that something
had to be done if the Germans get the bomb before
we have it. They had knowledge. They had the
people to do it and would have forced us to
surrender if we didn't have bombs also. - We had no choice, or we thought we had no choice.
80Nuclear PowerThe UK Context
Terrorism
81Nuclear terrorism (1)
- September 11, 2001?
- What would happen if terrorists flew an aeroplane
into a nuclear reactor?
82Do we need nuclear power?
- We face a possible Energy Gap in the years to
come. -
- We need to reduce Carbon emissions!
- Difficult to see how we will sustain current
levels of consumption without building new
nuclear power. - But we still have a choice
Summary
83Nuclear PowerThe UK Context
The Answer!
84The answer?
- Collect interstellar hydrogen and turn it into
helium - Build a fusion reactor bigger than the Earth!
- Position the reactor about 93 million miles away
- Call it the Super Universal Neutrino machine (or
SUN)
85UK Nuclear Energy update
AREVA and Electricité de France's (EDF) European
Pressurized Reactor (EPR) Westinghouse Electric
Company's (WEC) AP1000 pressurized water reactor
(PWR)
Westinghouse Link
86What is Nuclear Power?
- Nuclear
- Positives Negatives
87Nuclear Fission (6)Chain reaction
- Nuclear phenomena has always been associated with
great hopes and great fears. - Chicago
- 325 P.M. December 2, 1942
- Nuclear Age began
- Gain 1.0006
88Nuclear Fission (6)Hopes
- Arthur Compton
- One of the things that I shall not forget is the
expressions on the faces of some of the men.
There was Fermi's faceone saw in him no sign of
elation. The experiment had worked just as he had
expected and that was that. But I remember best
of all the face of Crawford Greenewalt. His eyes
were shining. He had seen a miracle, and a
miracle it was indeed. The dawn of a new age. As
we walked back across the campus, he talked of
his vision endless supplies of power to turn the
wheels of industry, new research techniques that
would enrich the life of man, vast new
possibilities yet hidden.
89Nuclear Fission (6)Fears
- Leo Szillard
- There was a crowd there and when it dispersed,
Fermi and I stayed there alone. Enrico Fermi and
I remained. I shook hands with Fermi and I said
that I thought this day would go down as a black
day in the history of mankind. - I was quite aware of the dangers. Not because I
am so wise but because I have read a book written
by H. G. Wells called The World Set Free. He
wrote this before the First World War and
described in it the development of atomic bombs,
and the war fought by atomic bombs. So I was
aware of these things. - But I was also aware of the fact that something
had to be done if the Germans get the bomb before
we have it. They had knowledge. They had the
people to do it and would have forced us to
surrender if we didn't have bombs also. - We had no choice, or we thought we had no choice.
90What is Nuclear Power?
- Sounds like a lot of trouble Why bother?
91Nuclear Fission (6)
- 1 kg natural uranium has a volume of 50 cm3
- Produces 40 thousand kWh
- Equivalent to 16 tons of coal
- Nuclear energy is cleaner than coal
- Lower radioactive emissions
- Much less radioactive waste
- Conventional Power Stations
- Cheaper than nuclear because they dont pay to
clean up their waste (CO2)
92What is Nuclear Power?
- OK so nuclear power is quite interesting.Are
there any downsides? - Link to nuclear weapons
- Possibility of catastrophic explosion
- Radioactive waste
- Possibility of nuclear terrorism
93Catastrophic ExposionChernobyl
- 26 April 1986
- 31 dead Immediately
- Ultimate death toll
- 100?
- 15,000?
94Chernobyl Effect on UK
Fall out from atmospheric atomic weapons testing
- Total radiation emissions were 20 times less than
the emissions from the atmospheric bomb tests
from 1945 to 1963.
Annual dose (micro Sieverts)
Chernobyl
1951
1988
Year
95Radioactive waste (1)Low level waste
- Low level waste
- Not very radioactive
- Much of it is precautionary
- No problem really
96Radioactive waste (2)Intermediate level waste
- Intermediate level waste
- Very radioactive
- Quite a lot of it
- Many different physical forms
- No problem with heat
- Requires isolation for thousands of years
97Radioactive waste (3)High level waste
- High level waste
- Used fuel rods
- Intensely radioactive
- Requires cooling
- Chemical mess
- Requires management for around 50 years
- Will remain intensely radioactive for tens of
thousands of years
98Radioactive waste (4)Amounts in cubic metres
- No permanent resting place has been found for
the high level waste
Type of Waste Year 2000 Year 2030
Low 424,000 1,411 ,000
Intermediate 100,000 260 ,000
High 1,200 3,000
Amounts in cubic metres
99Nuclear terrorism (1)
- September 11, 2001?
- What would happen if terrorists flew an aeroplane
into a nuclear reactor?
100Do we need nuclear power?You need to decide?
- Does Britian need nuclear power?
- Consider
- Our need to reduce carbon dioxide emissions
- The risks benefits of nuclear technology
- Do we want all countries to have nuclear power?
- The effect on renewables
- Undermining or supporting?
- The need to make decisions soon
- Build the next generation of nuclear power
stations? - Or not?
101Do we need nuclear power?
- Does Britian need nuclear power?
-
- Please find an answer!
102FusionThe answer?
- Collect interstellar hydrogen and turn it into
helium - Build a fusion reactor bigger than the Earth!
- Position the reactor about 93 million miles away
- Call it the Super Universal Neutrino machine (or
SUN)
103The End
- Thanks for coming to the course.If you enjoyed
it, please tell your friends and colleagues
104The Queen Dowager
105The Pub
106Resources
107Electricity GenerationThe case for nuclear power
- So maybe we should keep nuclear power for a
while? - What if one considers the supply of oil
108World Oil Production(projections)Oil prices
will rise
Table
109World Oil ProductionWe are close to the
midpoint
GigaBarrels of Oil Annual Production
110World Oil Production(the gap)
111Electricity GenerationThe case for nuclear power
- But is oil relevant to this problem?
- (still plenty of gas and coal)
112Electricity Generation in UK Pros and Cons
Type Pros Cons CO2 Kg/kWh
Nuclear Well suited to supplying base load Not popular Waste Problem 0.010
Wind Clean, plentiful, available in the UK Fluctuating Supply Unsightly? 0.001
113Radioactive health risksRadon
114Radioactive health risksHeight above sea level
15 km
0.01 mSv per hour
10 km
0.005 mSv per hour
7 km
Himalayas
0.001 mSv per hour
2.5 km
0.0001 mSv per hour
Mexico City
115Electricity Generation in UK 1950
- Back in 1950
- Basically just coal
116Electricity GenerationCO2 Emissions
- 1990 160 million tons
- 2005 150 million tons
- 2010 target 135 million tons
117Wind PowerEnvironmental Change Institute
- Wind has problems of
- availability
- variability
- Availability
- On average a 3MW turbine only generates 1 MW
- Sometimes, it generates nothing!
- Needs conventional back up
- Variability
- If wind speed changes
- 40 to 30 mph No problem
- 30 to 20 mph Output halves!
118Sustainable Development Commission
- Sustainable Development Commission
- The governments independent watchdog on
sustainable development - Report March 2006
- The two overriding concerns for Government are
the need to - reduce carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions as part of
efforts to tackle climate change, and - increase confidence in the security of energy
supply.
Nuclear power is not the answer to tackling
climate change or security of supply
119What is Radioactivity(5)Isotopes
- Nuclei with the same number of protons, but
different numbers of neutrons are called isotopes - Nuclei with an unbalanced ratio of protons and
neutrons are unstable - Instability is caused by electrical repulsion
between protonsactually a couple more but dont
worry about them for now
120What is Radioactivity (7)Summary
- Only nuclei with a balanced number of protons
and neutrons are stable
Isotopes with too many protons Isotopes withtoo many neutrons
Alpha decay Beta decay
Emission of fast moving helium nucleus Emission of fast moving electron
And gamma radiation And gamma radiation
121Current UK Nuclear CapacityWith retirement dates
Power Station Capacity GW Retirement
Calder Hall 0.194 2003
Chapelcross 0.196 2005
Sizewell A 0.420 2006
Dungeness A 0.450 2006
Oldbury 0.434 2008
Dungeness B 1.110 2008
Wylfa 0.980 2010
Hinkley Point B 1.220 2011
Hunterston B 1.190 2011
Hartlepool 1.210 2014
Heysham 1 1.150 2014
Heysham 2 1.250 2023
Torness 1.250 2023
Sizewell B 1.188 2035
- Current capacity is 12.4 GW
- Most of this will be retired by 2023
- Possibly much earlier
- If we dont replace it with nuclear power, what
should we replace it with? - Energy savings?
- A CO2 free technology?
- If we dont replace the power stations with
something, there will be power cuts! - http//www.dti.gov.uk/energy/nuclear/technology/hi
story.shtml
122Quiz
- 210Po is a radioactive isotope of polonium with
82 protons and 128 neutrons making a total of 210
nuclear particles