Title: Abacus Fund Management LLC Presentation
1THIS COMPOSITE PERFORMANCE RECORD IS HYPOTHETICAL
AND THESE TRADING ADVISORS HAVE NOT TRADED
TOGETHER IN THE MANNER SHOWN IN THE COMPOSITE.
HYPOTHETICAL PERFORMANCE RESULTS HAVE MANY
INHERENT LIMITATIONS, SOME OF WHICH ARE DESCRIBED
BELOW. NO REPRESENTATION IS BEING MADE THAT ANY
MULTI-ADVISOR MANAGED ACCOUNT OR POOL WILL OR IS
LIKELY TO ACHIEVE A COMPOSITE PERFORMANCE RECORD
SIMILAR TO THAT SHOWN. IN FACT, THERE ARE
FREQUENTLY SHARP DIFFERENCES BETWEEN A
HYPOTHETICAL COMPOSITE PERFORMANCE RECORD AND THE
ACTUAL RECORD SUBSEQUENTLY ACHIEVED.
2ONE OF THE LIMITATIONS OF A HYPOTHETICAL
COMPOSITE PERFORMANCE RECORD IS THAT DECISIONS
RELATING TO THE SELECTION OF TRADING ADVISORS AND
THE ALLOCATION OF ASSETS AMONG THOSE TRADING
ADVISORS WERE MADE WITH THE BENEFIT OF HINDSIGHT
BASED UPON THE HISTORICAL RATES OF RETURN OF THE
SELECTED TRADING ADVISORS. THEREFORE, COMPOSITE
PERFORMANCE RECORDS INVARIABLY SHOW POSITIVE
RATES OF RETURN. ANOTHER INHERENT LIMITATION ON
THESE RESULTS IS THAT THE ALLOCATION DECISIONS
REFLECTED IN THE PERFORMANCE RECORD WERE NOT MADE
UNDER ACTUAL MARKET CONDITIONS AND, THEREFORE,
CANNOT COMPLETELY ACCOUNT FOR THE IMPACT OF
FINANCIAL RISK IN ACTUAL TRADING. FURTHERMORE,
THE COMPOSITE PERFORMANCE RECORD MAY BE DISTORTED
BECAUSE THE ALLOCATION OF ASSETS CHANGES FROM
TIME TO TIME AND THESE ADJUSTMENTS ARE NOT
REFLECTED IN THE COMPOSITE.
3VK-Alpha CTA Selection Model
4VK-Alpha Introduction
- More than 10 years ago, while working as Director
of Managed Futures for a major international
banking organization, Emil van Essen, who is now
the President of VanKar Trading, observed that
many of the investment funds that had allocated
capital to a portfolio of the top performing
CTAs of the day were paradoxically
generating sub par performance. - After much testing, he discovered that most such
CTA portfolios were constructed with heavy
reliance on managers with high Sharpe ratios, low
correlation of returns and lengthy track
records. One thing, however, seemed clear the
then-current methodology did not work.
Regardless of how successful the CTAs had been
to date, how much due diligence was performed and
how thorough the analysis of each CTAs results,
the performance of the CTA portfolio was, at
best, unremarkable. And yet even today, many
years later, most funds are still constructed in
exactly the same way.
5VK-Alpha Introduction
- If traditional measures are poor predictors of
future CTA performance, then how can an investor
identify who next years star performers will
be? Perhaps more importantly, how can investors
avoid those CTAs who will collapse and disappear
in a sea of red ink? -
- After many years of work at solving this complex
puzzle, VanKar and its team of professional
software developers, engineers and mathematicians
have made a significant breakthrough which allows
us to combine CTA-specific performance data with
an analysis of general market conditions in a
model that predicts who the best and worst
performing CTAs will be for the next 12
months. In test after test, the model has
demonstrated an uncanny tendency to consistently
outperform both our competitors and the major
market benchmarks. In fact, no other known model
even approaches the consistent performance of the
VK-Alpha CTA Selection model.
6Background
- According to the National Futures Association,
there are currently over 1,700 registered CTAs
(including those who are dual registered as
Futures Commission Merchants, Introducing Brokers
and/or Commodity Pool Operators). Thoroughly
reviewing the strategy profiles and performance
returns of each of these manager candidates could
take weeks or even months. An investor would
most likely find that each prospective manager
offers its own unique trading methodology that
promises extraordinary results but does not
provide an accurate basis for assessment versus
its peers. So how do investors decide which
CTAs will help them most effectively meet their
investment goals?
7Background
- In response to this dilemma, the VK-Alpha CTA
Selection technology, a sophisticated analytical
model that carefully collects and reviews
performance data for over 400 CTAs with a wide
variety of trading models and strategies, and
then selects a portfolio of those CTAs
appropriate for the strategic investment
guidelines of the investor or fund. The
VK-Alpha technology focuses on CTAs with proven
track records, strong risk management controls
and low correlation to each other. Our tests
have shown that an investor who uses our VK-Alpha
technology can reasonably expect a significant
long term advantage over other alternative
investment portfolios. - At VanKar, we set out to build a
quantitatively-driven model that provides
investors with the technology necessary to
achieve their portfolio goals.
8VK-Alpha CTA Selection Technology
- The VK-Alpha CTA Selection technology was
developed over a period of ten years using
meticulous quantitative analysis of the
performance data from over 400 CTAs. VanKar has
identified a number of CTA performance
characteristics that have proven to be excellent
predictors of future CTA success. Under rigorous
test conditions, a portfolio selected using the
VK-Alpha CTA Selection technology has
historically shown significantly higher risk
adjusted returns and low correlation to familiar
market benchmarks. - Many investors select their CTAs using methods
that are both outdated and proven to be
unreliable predictors of investment success,
e.g., high risk adjusted returns, high Sharpe
ratio, recent performance strength and
non-correlation to the other investments in their
portfolio. Our groundbreaking research and
state-of-the-art analytics have resulted in the
VK-Alpha CTA Selection technology, which allows
us to predict and select the CTAs that we feel
have the greatest prospects for success. We are
confident that our methods, the product of years
of intensive research and development, will help
Abacus outperform the universe of Managed Futures
programs and other alternative investment
vehicles.
9The Database
- Most CTAs report their trading results on a
monthly basis. We have built an enormous
database that includes over 20 years of such
results from most active CTAs in the Managed
Futures industry. As we collect the data, it is
first filtered to eliminate those CTAs with
insufficient track records and/or negative
lifetime returns. We then normalize the data so
that the returns may be viewed in risk-equivalent
terms. - These adjusted results are then entered into the
VK-Alpha CTA Selection model where a number of
additional calculations and tests are
administered. Ultimately, the model produces for
each CTA a fingerprint that summarizes that
CTAs key characteristics. These characteristics
are both manager-specific (performance, risk,
markets traded, etc.) and general economic
(interest rate levels, overall market volatility
by markets, etc.).
10The CTA Rankings
- The VK-Alpha CTA Selection model compares the
fingerprint of each CTA to those of all the other
CTAs at key points in history. Once we have
reviewed these historical matches, we can
determine which CTAs are most likely to show
strong performance over the next 12 months. We
are then able to rank them from highest to lowest
based on expected risk-adjusted returns. These
quantitatively-based rankings act as the
foundation of our ability to create portfolios of
CTAs that match the requirements of our clients.
11VK-Alpha CTA Selection Model
Formatting Data Standard performance database
is categorized and pre-formatted for use with our
software.
12CTA Selection Overview
Portfolio Analysis Our software contains the
model. Using historical data, we can simulate
the growth of 1000 if a portfolio was
constructed and managed using the model.
13CTA Selection Overview
Portfolio Analysis The software also tells us
current rankings of all investments so that we
may prepare for future allocations.
14CTA Selection Overview
- Here we can see under "Money Allocation Methods"
that we are allocating equal amounts of equity to
10 different investments to the highest ranked
CTAs. - In addition to the model, we also show the
average monthly percent return for the "market"
which is the average of all qualified
investments. - The market return shows us the result if we had
invested in all available investments.
15CTA Selection Overview
- Our model portfolio is constructed using the top
"x" ranked investments in each re-allocation
period. - Instead of picking the top rank, what if we
picked the bottom rank? - The return labeled "0_10" shows us the portfolio
result if we had picked the investments that
ranked in the bottom 10 as ranked by our model.
16CTA Selection Overview
- Does the model rankings have any predictive
power? If it does, a portfolio constructed of
low ranking investment at the time should show
below average future results. - Portfolio of high ranking investments should
predict above average future results and mid
ranking investments should show average future
returns - Continued on next slide
17CTA Selection Overview
- That is exactly what happens. Below are
portfolio results based on each decile of
predicted model rank and their corresponding
portfolio future returns. - Obviously, the prediction is not exact but the
model rank is directly related to the future
portfolio return.
18CTA Selection Overview
Model Reporting Once a simulation is run, a
report can be generated to determine the makeup
of the portfolio at each re-allocation period..
19CTA Selection Overview
Data Export The report may be exported to
excel for further analysis.
20The Technology at Work
- Our work in selecting an appropriate portfolio of
CTAs is the product of in-depth discussions with
our clients in order to determine their
requirements with respect to performance and
risk. Therefore, there is no standard VanKar
portfolio all portfolios are customized and
unique to the client. However, for purposes of
our demonstration here, let us assume that we are
working with two different clients and that each
of these clients has different investment needs.
- Client A desires exposure to Managed Futures, but
does not want to actively switch from one CTA to
another in order to maximize returns. Client A
desires a more passive management style and we
will, therefore, recommend and structure a more
conservative approach. Suppose further that our
Client B wants to be more active in switching
CTAs in order to achieve the highest possible
returns while still holding the CTAs for a
reasonable period of time. We have applied the
VK-Alpha CTA Selection technology independently
to the needs of the two clients and developed a
different hypothetical approach for both of
them. The two hypothetical approaches are
identified below as (A) Standard and (B)
Aggressive.
21The Technology at Work
- Each of the two approaches shown below is based
on a hypothetical portfolio of ten actual CTAs,
although in practice the number of CTAs selected
will, of course, vary depending on the needs of
the client. Both approaches employ the same
power to predict, but vary primarily in how often
CTAs are switched in the portfolio. Generally,
the more aggressive the switching, the better the
long term results. The approach selected will
also depend, of course, on the investment
parameters of the investor. The VK-Alpha CTA
Selection model strives to match an investors
goals with a selection approach that has the
highest probability of meeting their risk and
return needs
22CTA Selection Overview
- Model A and Model B are two models that have
been created by VK-Alpha. - Model A is more conservative with a long holding
period while Model B is more aggressive with a
shorter holding period. - Figure 1
23CTA Selection Overview
- Figure 1 demonstrates the normalized growth of an
initial theoretical 1,000 investment from
January 1995, until today, a period of over 10
years, using each of the two approaches outlined
above. Perhaps the first thing that Figure 1
highlights is that the returns of both
approaches greatly exceed that of the Stark 300
Index, a performance benchmark based on the
returns of over 300 managers from the CTA
community. Looking closer, Figure 1 also shows
that the returns for the aggressive approach
outstrip those of the standard approach. - The aggressive approach allows the client to
remain regularly invested with the CTAs ranked
in only the top percentiles. The average holding
time for each CTA in the portfolio using the
aggressive approach is, on average, two and a
half years. The average holding time for each
CTA in the portfolio under the standard approach
is, on average, approximately four years.
24Figure 2 demonstrates the return of both our
hypothetical approaches over a 10 year period.
Again, that the results of the Abacus CTA
Selection model outperform the Stark 300 Index
benchmark over the same period is clearly
apparent.
25CTA Selection Overview
- It is important to keep in mind that the VK-Alpha
CTA Selection technology is constantly ingesting
new data and performing iterative calculations
for each of over 400 CTAs in order to determine
which are most likely to outperform the others.
Because the technology is dynamic and the CTAs
rankings change monthly, the aggressive approach
allows the portfolio to regularily switch out of
lower ranked CTAs and into the highest ranked
CTAs. This aggressive approach helps maintain a
portfolio of very high ranked CTAs and therefore
is likely to produce the highest possible future
returns. The standard approach is still very
successful, but sacrifices some return in order
to maintain a longer hold period for the average
CTA. -
- What is important to note in Figures 1 and 2
above is the relationship between the two basic
approaches. The aggressive approach yields the
higher returns over time but requires more
frequent switches and, therefore, the most
account maintenance. The standard approach posts
lower returns but requires less switching between
CTAs. Figures 1 and 2 also highlight the fact
that the returns for both models greatly exceed
the returns for more conventional measures such
as the Stark 300 Index.
26CTA Selection Overview
- Having examined the relationship between the
various approaches elicited by the VL-Alpha CTA
Selection technology, we now examine a current
(December, 2005) snapshot of the model at work.
Figure 3, on the next page, demonstrates the
year-to-date performance of those CTAs that the
model has selected as the ten most likely to earn
the highest returns. For purposes of comparison,
Figure 3 also includes the return over the same
period for the Stark 300 Index and the mean
average of the ten CTAs featured. The two bars
to the far right side of the Figure show that the
mean return for the period is a positive 5.17 ,
while the 300 CTAs featured in the Stark 300
Index returned a positive 3.36 over the same
period. The remaining ten bars feature the
individual performance history of those 10 CTAs
that ranked highest in the monthly VL-Alpha CTA
Selection rankings.
27Figure 3
CTA Selection Overview
28CTA Selection Overview
- On the other hand, Figure 4 on the next page
demonstrates the year-to-date performance of
those CTAs that the model has selected as the
ten most likely to earn the lowest returns over
the next year. Again, as with Figure 3 above,
Figure 4, next page, also shows the return over
the same period for the Stark 300 Index and the
mean average of the ten CTAs featured for
purposes of comparison.
29Figure 4
CTA Selection Overview
30CTA Selection Overview
- Not all successful CTAs perform well all the
time. In both Figures 3 and 4,on previous pages,
the CTAs selected are identified by name.
Figure 4 shows that there are some highly
reputable managers with substantial assets under
management who, for whatever reason, had poor
performance during the testing period. These are
CTAs that, without the predictive power of the
VK-Alpha CTA Selection technology, investors
might have selected themselves and could easily
have in their own portfolios today. - The VK-Alpha CTA Selection model forecasted
that these CTAs would not perform well over the
period and Figure 4 demonstrates that this
prediction has indeed ultimately become a
reality. In other words, the VK-Alpha CTA
Selection technology would have helped investors
avoid downturns in their own portfolio returns.
31Figure 5
CTA Selection Overview
32CTA Selection Overview
- Figure 5 compares, from several
perspectives, the year-to-date performance of the
top-ranked CTAs with those of the bottom-ranked
CTAs. In each case and regardless of the point
of comparison, the gap between the top-ranked
CTAs and the bottom ranked CTAs is
significant. These tests confirm that the
VK-Alpha CTA Selection technology can accurately
predict which CTAs will outperform their peers.
In other words, our model does what it is
supposed to do. - As one might expect, the performance of
the top picks is in all cases positive and the
performance of those in the bottom picks is in
all cases negative. Moreover, the magnitude of
the gains of the CTAs in the top 20th percentile
is greater than the magnitude of the gains of the
CTAs in the top 50th percentile. And, not
surprisingly, the magnitude of their losses is
smaller.
33Summary of Results
- As shown in each Figure above, our test
results demonstrate that the VK-Alpha CTA
Selection technology successfully predicts CTA
performance. This allows investors to act with
confidence when selecting CTAs and allocating
assets. Similarly, investors can avoid those
CTAs with the lowest expectation of success.
The Figures above clearly demonstrate that the
CTAs selected by the VK-Alpha CTA Selection
technology have performed promisingly when
compared both to their peers and to other market
benchmarks.
34Conclusion
- VanKar Trading offers a dynamic new approach
to alternative investments. Our VK-Alpha CTA
Selection technology collects and reviews
performance data for a broad universe of
Commodity Trading Advisors, and structures
portfolios of these managers that can provide
investors with a significant long term advantage
over traditional investment portfolios. - We believe that our technology provides the
best risk/ reward potential available in
alternative investments today. For further
information, please contact Emil van Essen at
(312) 578-0225
35What makes VanKar Different?
36- Emil van Essen
- Over 17 Years of Financial Industry Experience.
- Original Director of Managed Futures with the
BANK OF MONTREAL. - Principal and President of the Asset Management
Division of Vankar Trading Corp. - A long standing registered Commodity Trading
Advisor (CTA) who is also a component of the
Stark 300 CTA Index. - Prominent global keynote speaker on CTA Selection
methods. - Consults worldwide on the construction of
multi-manager Alternative Investment Portfolios. - Former Director of Quantitative Futures Analysis
with Refco LLC.
37- John Karvelas
- Over 15 Years of Financial Industry Experience.
- Principal President of the Brokerage and Trading
Operations of VanKar Trading Corp.