Review of Hickey and Mohan and then Sustainable Development

1
Review of Hickey and Mohan and then Sustainable
Development

• Craig Jeffrey

2
Hickey and Mohan article 5 key sections

• 1. History of Participatory devt. (PD)
• 2. Sociology Review of PD in practice
• 3. Analysis Where has PD worked?
• 4. Recommendation radical citizenship
• 5. Recommendation II critical modernism

3
Section 1 History of PD

• 1. Traces PD back to 1940s (Table 1)
• 2. Argues for approach that links imminent devt.
  (devt. policies) to immanent devt. (ongoing
  historical change)

4
Section 2 Review of PD in practice

• Participatory governance and decentralization
• NGOS and PD
• 3. Social movements

5
Section 3 Analysis where has PD worked?

• Identify four commonalities across success
  stories PD succeeded when
• 1. Part of broader radical project
• 2. Connected imminent with immanent
• 3. Concerned with citizenship
• 4. Econ and political power holders are different
  people

6
Section 4 Recommendation Radical citizenship

• 1. Need broad defn. of citizenship
• 2. Include people marginalized
• 3. Engage with difference (Mouffe)

7
Section 5 Recommendation 2 Critical Modernism

• 1. Rethink rather than reject devt.
• 2. Need ecology of agents which blends the
  institutional capacities of the state and
  associational resources of civil society
  (drawing on Heller)

8
Sustainable Development Lecture Structure

• 1. The Stockholm Conference 1972
• 2. World Conservation Strategy 1980
• 3. Brundtland Report 1987
• 4. Evaluating Sustainable Development

9
Grand Theories of DevelopmentWhere was the
environment?

• A resource, to be used for economic growth
• Something to be traded off against modernisation
  and growth
• The past, tradition modernity was
  technological, futurist, bright, clean.
• Especially true of modernization theory

10
The Stockholm Conference

• 1972 UN Conference on the Human Environment
• Brought together 113 countries from North and
  South
• Argued for integrating environmental protection
  with development
• Primarily concerned with issues arising from
  industrialisation

11
Outcomes

• The creation of the United Nations Environment
  Programme (UNEP)
• Set in train greater scientific co-operation
  (e.g. climate change)
• Helped encourage the World Conservation Strategy

12
The World Conservation Strategy

• Published in 1980 by WWF, IUCN and UNEP
• Stressed importance of managing global commons-
  sea, air.
• Emphasized people-centred development
• Several countries launched National Action Plans

13
WCS Problems

• Did not anticipate political obstacles to meeting
  conservation goals
• Abstract language humans in the ecosystem
• Alarmist conservation or disaster

14
The Brundtland Report

• 1983 UN established the World Commission on
  Environment and Development.
• Chaired by Gro Harlem Brundtland.
• 1987 Brundtland Report published

15
Key Features of the Brundtland Report

• Popularised term sustainable development
  defined as development which meets the needs
  of the present generation without compromising
  the ability of the next generation to meet their
  needs
• 2. Discussed environment and development
  together, e.g. links between land degradation and
  poverty

16
Key Features of the Brundtland Report (cont.d)

• 3. Begins with people discusses type of
  environmental policies required to meet social
  and economic goals.
• 4. Concerned with reforming global financial
  system in favour of global south, e.g. ending
  protectionism in the global north
• 5. Advocates capital flow to the global south

17
Strengths of Sustainable Development concept

• Places environmental concerns at forefront
• Considers environmental and social questions
  together
• Acts as a rallying call for environmental groups

18
The Sustainable Development Triangle
Environmental sustainability
Sustained economic growth
Sustained improvement in social well-being
19
ButSustainable Development may be too
vague...Four common meanings are

• 1) literal sustaining anything
• 2) ecological sustaining the ecological basis of
  human life
• 3) social sustaining the social basis of human
  life
• 4) economic sustaining growth

20
Implications of vagueness

• May promote consensus building, BUT
• Often prevents focused policies
• West may manipulate ideas of SD to attach
  conditions to aid
• Powerful groups WITHIN poorer countries may use
  ideas of SD to prevent change

21
Conclusions

• From early 1970s increased concern with impact of
  development on environment
• In 1980s shifted to emphasis on sustainable
  development (SD)
• Need to consider the power of words how is SD
  deployed?