Title: EU Enlargement
1- EU Enlargement the case of Romania
- Magda R Tepoi,
- Istambul, April, 16th, 2009
2EU Enlargement
- Enlargement is one of the European Union most
powerful policy tools.It is a carefully managed
process which helps the trasformation of the
countries involved, extending peace, stability,
prosperity, democracy, human rights ad the the
rule of law across Europe. - It began with the Inner Six, who founded the
European Coal and Steel Community (the EU's
predecessor) in 1951. Since then, the EU's
membership has grown to twenty-seven with the
most recent expansion to Bulgaria and Romania in
2007. - There is more to come Croatia and Turkey,
Macedonia, Albania, Bosnia-Herzegovina.
3Snagov Declaration
- Romania signed its Europe Agreement in 1993 and
submitted its official application for membership
in the EU in 1995, the third country to do so
after Hungary and Poland. Along with its official
EU application, Romania submitted the Snagov
Declaration, signed by all fourteen political
parties declaring their full support for EU
membership.
4Benefits of EU Accession
- Removal of any obstacles in the trade with EU
Member States - Common trade policy with third countries
- Harmonization of entire legislation, capital
market regulations, taxation, accounting rules gt
higher transparency and simplification - Structural funds (33 billion euro till 2013)
- Open gate for EU towards CIS, Asia, Middle East,
Northern Africa - Participation in major projects in the Black Sea
Extended Area and in the Central Eastern
European Region - Romania-important role in assuring the energy
security for Europe (major transit pipelines,
energy production supply)
510 indicators where Romania is over the EU average
6Pre-accession assistance granted to Romania by
the EU
- 1992-1999 amounted to approximately 1.2 billion
euro - 2000-2003 Romania received approximately 660
million euro per year, through the three
pre-accession instruments PHARE, ISPA and SAPARD
- 2004-2006 of up to 40 increase in 2006 (around
2.8 billion euro)
7Absorption rate of pre-accession funds
- PHARE, ISPA and SAPARD
- Beginning of March 2009, from the total of
5.679.000.000 euro for the period 2000-2007, have
been made contracts of 5.110.000.000 euro,
absorption rate 90. - The payments for these contracts represents
3.469.000.000 euro, absorption rate 70.
8Pre-accession and structural funds
- Phare - Stuctural Funds (European Regional
Development Fund (ERDF) and Social European Fund
ESF) - Sapard - European Agriculture Fund for Rural
Development (EAFRD) and The European Fishery Fund
The EFF - ISPA - European Cohesion Fund
9IPA Instrument for Pre-accession Assistance
- From 2007 onwards EU is channeling its
pre-accession funding through one single
instrument called IPAIPAs aim is to be a bridge
between external assistance and internal
policies. - IPA objectives are the following
- Support Turkey in its bid for membership,
including the necessary economic, political and
social reforms - Help prepare the country for the management of
structural funds. - As a consequence IPA also
- Readies Turkey for multi-annual planning
- Supports Turkey in sound financial management of
EU funds - IPA will provide countries seeking EU
membership with a total amount of 11.5Â
billion in the seven-year term from 2007 onwards.
- The preliminary EC draft budget for 2007
envisages that Turkey could get over  2 billion
for the first four years of IPA (2007-2010) -
- IPAs five components are
- Transition Assistance and Institution Building
Component 1 - Regional and Cross-Border Co-operation
Component 2 - Regional Development Component 3
- Human Resources Development Component 4
- Rural Development Component 5
10Structural Funds for Romania
- Romania will benefit of more than 30 billion Euro
structural and cohesion funds from the EU for the
2007-2013 period. - 19.7 billion Euro under Convergence objective
- 13.3 billion Euro under Common Agricultural
Policy - The structural funds are managed by the European
Commission and the goal is to finance the
structural measures from the community for
helping regions with a delay in their
development, for reconversion of affected area's
where there is a industrial decline and to fight
against long time unemployment.
11Structural Funds for Romania
- There are 4 types of structural funds. Each one
handles specific domains and they have specific
aims. - European Regional Development Fund (ERDF) -
intended to reduce regional imbalance and assist
less favoured regions via local development
(local development, create and safeguard
sustainable jobs and support SME's). - European Social Fund (ESF) - focuses mainly on
training and job creation, the reintegration of
the work force and the fight against
unemployment. There is a specific topic this
funds finances projects for training and
assistance to hire people. - European Cohesion Fund contributes to very large
infrastructure projects, such us the
trans-European transport networks (TEN-T) and
large-scale investments in the environment
sector. - In Romania, the investments from the structural
funds will be complemented by the Common
Agricultural Policy funds. These are - The European Fishery Fund The EFF (2007-2013)
will have a financial contribution to adapt and
to modernize this sector. - FEADR European Agriculture Fund for Rural
Development (EAFRD) will finance the rural
development measures and support agriculture
(especially in the regions that are under
developed).
12Structural Funds for Romania
- The National Development Plan (NDP) is a specific
concept for the European economic and social
cohesion politics that provide a stable and
coherent concept for the development of the
member states. - The first step to access the funds for Romania is
the approval of the national development plan.
NDP 2007-2013 is a strategic planning and multi
annual financing document approved by the
Romanian Government. The primary objective of the
Romanian NDP is to reduce the economical and
social gap between the members states and Romania
as quickly as possible. - The global objectives are based on 3 specific
objectives - To increase the competitiveness of the Romanian
economy (long term) - To develop the European standards for basic
infrastructure - To optimize the efficient use of the autochthon
human capital
1314 domains that can be financed with structural
funds and cohesion funds from the EU
- Technical Research and Development
- Informatization (ICT) of the society
- Transport
- Energy
- Environmental protection and prevention of risks
- Tourism
- Culture
- Urban and rural development
- Support for SME's and entrepreneurs
- Access to stable work places
- Social inclusion for disfavoured persons
- Development of the human capital and resources
- Investments in social infrastructure including
those in health and education - Promoting the development of partnerships
14Responsable authorities
The Ministry of Public Finance from Romania is
the authority responsible for the coordination
of the national authorities in charge of the
administration of the structural funds. The
operational programmes will be coordinated by the
following national authorities Ministry of
Economy and Trade Increase of Economic
Competitiveness-Â Ministry of Transport,
Construction and Tourism Transport
Infrastructure-Â Ministry of Environment and
Water Management  Environment Infrastructure- Mi
nistry of Labour, Social Solidarity and Family
Human Resources Development-Â Â Ministry of
Agriculture, Forests and Rural Development
Agriculture and Rural Development-Â Ministry of
European Integration Regional Development and
European Territorial Cooperation-Â Ministry of
Public Finances Technical Assistance-Â Ministry
of Administration and Interior Administrative
Capacity Development
15Sectoral Operational Programmes2007 -2013
- Technical Assistance Operational Programme 0.9
- Sectoral Operational Programme (SOP) Increase of
Economic Competitiveness 13.3 - Sectoral Operational Programme for Environment
23.5 (audited by the Commissionon on 16 Jan
2009) - Sectoral Operational Programme Transport (SOPT)
23.7 - Regional Operational Programme 19.4
- Operational Programme Administrative Capacity
Development 1.1 - Sectoral Operational Programme- Human Resources
Development 18.1
16 Obstacles in the way of a better use of
Structural Funds
- 1. The in-efficiency of civil servants - almost
20.000 civil servants (gt half in ministries, the
other in county councils, prefectures, town
halls in 2007 and 2008, Romania absorbed
structural funds of 176 millions euro, but the
civil servants from public administration
received 300 millions euro a lot of
consumtion, smqll investments) - 2. Bureaucracy Almost all applicant guides are
full of too many specific and technical terms - Business people should be concentrated on the
business project not on understanding a
complicated process - 3. Lack of experience In certain situations for
instance big contracts, which are international
auctioned, the authorities try to contract local
experts or consultants to help or to train the
permanent personal. The companies that
participate to the auction are looking for the
cheapest not the best experts. This aspect make
most of the times, that the projects that are
going to improve the performance of the people
employed in the organisations that are
responsible for the European fund to have a
limited impact. The legal framework does not help
at all those who wants to make projects. - 4. National obstacles
- 5. Time formalities
- 6. Errors in funds demanding Not only state
institutions are responsible of the low level of
European Structural Funds absorption. (The OP
-do not answer to a development vision we are
aiming at and do not indicate stong and
distinctive directions of development -rather
seem to feel some gaps and refresh an exhausted
economy then to look after a deep srtuctural
reform) - the mentality (CCI work)
- pre-accession assistance especially Phare
component helped us a lot in building the adm.
capacity for structural funds. Over 30 handbooks
and procedures required for managing and
implementing structural assistance were made with
the help of foreign experts and projesct
preparation benefit from the support of the
pre-accession assistance. - the way in which a program is running, the
payment conditions are quite restrictive. - in the case of the private companies this kind
of financing is accessible for those which could
implement the project by their own, with own
resources or with credits, but with the help of
European funds they will implementing faster. - this aspect should be explained very clearly.
For this reason, there are still many companies
that has very low profitability and limited
resources, who hope that they will make mirracols
with the help of an European fund.
17Countries from the first wave and the use of
European Funds
18Structural funds use
- First year of membership
- Cehia 41,5 absorbtion 0,18
- Polonia 42,8 0,19
- Slovacia 41,6 0,24
- Ungaria 42,9 0,38
- România 21,7 (2007) contribution-0.36
19Challenges for a better use of Structural Funds
- The maintain of an increasing economic growth
over 5 yearly till the Euro adoption - Building an effective administrative capacity in
order to increase the number of the eligible
projects (training, change mentality, to make a
long term strategy) - (see the European Innovation Scoreboard
2006, Romania occupies the lowest position among
the European countries in what concerns the
innovation capacity, and this fact represent a
concern tourism see Spain ) - the OP do not answer to a development
vision we are aiming at and do not indicate stong
and distinctive directions - of development -rather seem to feel some gaps
and refresh an exhausted economy then to look
after a deep srtuctural reform - The possibility for the general consolidated
budget to generate co financing of almost 1
yearly GDP, without the exceeding of 3 of the
fiscal deficit - The insurance of a proper level of co-financing
both through private sources and also credits
20Chambers of CommerceIssues from Romanian
businesses (in the implementation of
pre-accession funds)
- 1)Â Programme Administration
- The financing programmes are managed at central
level, by the public administration, yet often
responsibilities for coordination also as
intermediaries , management, monitoring and
reporting are separate and applied by different
institutions for different programmes, which
makes funding accession procedures both
bureaucratic and difficult to evaluate and
monitor, as a whole.
21Chambers of CommerceIssues from Romanian
businesses (in the implementation of
pre-accession funds)
- 2)Â Applying for Funds
- The business community in Romania was often
confronted with a number of concrete problems in
accessing community funding which do not differ
to European businesses - burdensome and bureaucratic procedures and
documentation while applying for funds - too detailed reporting procedures, consuming an
important amount of time and resources - a slow decision process that may lead to losing
opportunities for businesses - the projects must be financed in advance and
refunding is often delayed of the actual payment - approval competencies are raised at too high
levels, losing sight of the real needs in
planning and running the businesses
22Chambers of CommerceIssues from Romanian
businesses (in the implementation of
pre-accession funds)
- general problems, the business community the
need for training and education in drafting of
projects and financing mainly in view of
preparing the use of European funds (example
CCRUNER VPN) - insufficient consultancy in the field
- the credit market is underdeveloped which makes
difficult to ensure the required co-funding
23Regional Economic Development by Continuous
Entrepreneurs Improvement
- The main purpose of the project was to increase
the regional economic development by improving
the quality of the staff of Chambers in providing
services of professional trainingimproving the
quality of enterprises management specialists
from the North-East Region in the following
fieldsassimilation of hi-technology
noveltiesassimilation of good practicing and
international commerce management applying the
management of quality.so that to be ensured the
development of the local area business
environment and integration of regional business
environment in European area. - In the first section of the project will be
organized seminars of improvement regarding the
staff of the Chambers from the North-East Region,
provided by European and Romanian specialists, in
the following fieldsforeign trade
TQMe-signcommercial arbitration project
management in international economic
cooperationEuropean politics and strategy for
SMEsEuropean economic legislation for
international cooperation. - In the second section of the project,
beneficiaries are the companies from the
North-East Region willing to expand their
businesses across the borders, in EU. - The seminars have been organized in a Virtual
Private Network system, in the following Romanian
counties Iasi, Neamt, Suceava, Bacau and
Botosani.
24Chambers of CommerceIssues from Romanian
businesses (in the implementation of
pre-accession funds)
- 3)Â Market Failure and Displacement
- Establishing the fields in which additional
funding is necessary is difficult to make unless
businesses are dully consulted. However analyses
that are carried to this purpose, are often based
on incomplete or outdate information, while,
between the assessment period and the actual
allocation of funds market conditions may change. - To ensure a better allocation of funding, the
chambers of commerce and industry initiate a
mechanism of regular consultation with the
business community on the real needs for
financing, through specialized public hearings,
questionnaires and a market surveillance
mechanism
25Chambers of CommerceIssues from Romanian
businesses (in the implementation of
pre-accession funds)
- 4)Â Administration of Funds
- The cooperation between the public administration
and the chambers must be based on the
understanding of the role that chambers of
commerce and industry play in supporting the
enterprises, their capacity to work in a
structural, professional network of centers for
information, consultancy, representation and
coordination of the business community. - The chambers of commerce and industry make the
necessary efforts to create mechanisms and
instruments for communication, cooperation and
partnership with the public administration and
NGOs that have responsibilities in regional
development issues.Â
26THE ROLE OF THE ROMANIAN CHAMBERS OF COMMERCE AND
INDUSTRY IN DEVELOPING THE REGIONAL POLICIES and
implementing the European Funding
- Lobbying and advising national governments on
the formation of regional policies - The chambers of commerce and industry from
Romania (CCIT) participate in regional
programming, within the mechanism of elaboration
in partnership of the multi-annual Regional
Development Plans. - The Chamber of Commerce and Industry of Romania
and Bucharest Municipality (CCIRB) was a member
of the National Transparency Committee for
Monitoring the Community Funds. - CCIRB participates to the social dialogue, both
at national level (as a permanent guest, in the
Economic and Social Council and the Social
Dialogue Committees of the economic ministries)
and at local level Social Dialogue Committees
of the counties Prefectures. - CCIRB participates to the Consultative Council
for the Negociation of Romanias Accession to the
EU and the Working Groups, on negociation
chapters, established within the Council. - EPE bringing companies closer to Lisbon agenda
(the movie)
27 Some facts figures on EPE companiesINVOLVEMEN
T OF EU INSTITUTIONS
- EU political representatives involved in national
programmes EPE(11programmes received) - Members of the European Parliament Approx. 115
- European Commission 7 EU commissioners
- Other representatives from EU institutions
(Commissions DGs, EESC, etc.) Approx. 35 - 740 MePs have received an information letter on
the companiesvote
28THE ROLE OF THE ROMANIAN CHAMBERS OF COMMERCE AND
INDUSTRY IN DEVELOPING THE REGIONAL POLICIES and
implementing the European Funding
- Representing businesses on regional partnership
groups - In Romania, the chambers of commerce and
industry were nominated as members in the
Regional Development Councils (having
responsibilities in programming and
implementation of the regional development
policies aproval of the regional programming
documents monitoring of the funds use). - In the meantime Chambers of Commerce and
Industry in Romania closely cooperate with the
Regional Development Agencies (NGOs set up as
executive entities of the Regional Development
Councils, for the elaboration and implementation
of the programming documents implementation of
the regional development programmes technical
monitoring of the funds use)
29THE ROLE OF THE ROMANIAN CHAMBERS OF COMMERCE AND
INDUSTRY IN DEVELOPING THE REGIONAL POLICIES and
implementing the European Funding
- Carrying out of regional policy and implementing
local initiatives for the benefit of the area - CCIRB and the local chambers of commerce and
industry participate to the organization of
networks of centers for information and
consulting, in cooperation with the National
Agency for SMEs and Cooperation, Minister of
Environment and local public administration. - Romanian Business School of the Chambers of
Commerce and Industry participates to a series of
projects, mostly with European funding in the
field of education for businesses,
entrepreneurship and continuous vocational
training. - Very important is the training for EPSO (European
Selection Personal Office) competition for those
who wants to become public servants in European
Institutions.
30THE ROLE OF THE ROMANIAN CHAMBERS OF COMMERCE AND
INDUSTRY IN DEVELOPING THE REGIONAL POLICIES and
implementing the European Funding
- Advising businesses on the access to funds and
projects - Chambers of Commerce and Industry trains
specialists and sets up information and
consultancy structures for entrepreneurs, in
projects evaluation and applying for
pre-accession funding - Through the programs initiated by Eurochambres
(CAPE I, CAPE II and CAPE III) local Chambers of
Commerce and Industry in Romania have been given
assisstance and training in order to better
advise their members on EU matters. - Through the Euro Info Centres network chambers of
commerce and industry in Romania contribute to
the readiness of businesses for EU integration,
with information and advice on the acquis
communautaire issues, Internal Market, explaining
of community mechanisms and policies.Â
31Romanias Geo-strategic Position
Area 238,391 km2 92,043 sq mi. the 9th in EU
Population 21.7 mill inhabitants the 7th in EU
Capital city Bucharest 1.9 mill inh
Member of EU, WTO, IMF, WB, NATO
Our friend the wind
32Romanias Strategic Location
- The Eastern border of the inland European Union
- Strategic position at the turning point where EU
meets the Balkans and CIS countries
33Competitive Taxation
Country Corporate Tax
Romania 16
Hungary 16
Slovakia 19
Poland 19
Estonia 20
Croatia 20.32
Slovenia 25
Czech Rep. 28
FLAT TAX 16 16
VAT 19 19
SOCIAL SECURITY 43.5 39.5 by the end of 2008
AVERAGE GROSS WAGE (2008) 480 euro 480 euro
MINIMUM GROSS WAGE (2008) 135 euro 135 euro
34Macroeconomic Performance GDP real growth
Source National Institute of Statistics
35Macroeconomic Performance Inflation rate
Source National Bank of Romania
36Macroeconomic Performance Unemployment rate
36
37Foreign direct investments - million Euro -
Source National Bank of Romania
38Foreign Investors Advantages
- foreign investments allowed in all sectors of
economy - possibility to freely manage the company with
full ownership rights - full repatriation of capital and profits
- protection against expropriation and
nationalization - national treatment for foreign investors
39Main trade partners - 2007 -
Top export partner countries percentage of total export Top export partner countries percentage of total export
Italy 18,10
Germany 16,95
France 7,64
Turkey 7,12
Hungary 5,34
Great Britain 4.36
Bulgaria 2.67
Austria 2.66
Spain 2.27
Poland 2.18
SUA 2.09
Holland 2,06
Greece 1.76
Belgium 1.60
Ukraine 1.54
Top import partner countries percentage of total import Top import partner countries percentage of total import
Germany 17,25
Italy 13,72
Hungary 6,75
France 6.48
Russian Federation 6,30
Turkey 5,78
Austria 4,67
Holland 3.52
Poland 3.28
China 2,83
Czech Rep. 2.34
Spain 2.07
Belgium 1,93
Great Britain 1,92
Greece 1,49
40Top reasons to invest in Romania (1)
- Market Location Advantage
- Second largest market in Central and Eastern
Europe (over 21 million inhabitants)Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â
      - Easy access to the countries of the former CIS
countries, Balkans, the Middle East and Northern
Africa - Junction of three prospective European
transportation corridors nos. 4, 7 9 - Resource Advantage
- Skilled labor force, with solid knowledge in
technology, IT and engineering - Rich natural resources, including fertile
agricultural land, oil and gas - Important potential for tourism
41Top reasons to invest in Romania (2)
- Economic Advantage
- Sustainable economic growth
- Functional Market Economy status
- Competitive tax policy
- Decreasing inflation
- Permanent financial assistance for SME's
Development - Structural funds
- Improving Infrastructure Advantage
- Well-developed networks of mobile
telecommunications in GSM systems - Branch offices and representatives of well-known
international banks - Commitment to improve the highway infrastructure
to EU standards - Extensive maritime and river navigation
facilities
42Map of Industrial Parks
- More than 40 Industrial Parks
- Both private public
- Greenfield Brownfield
- Access to utilities
- Package of services offered by the park
administration - Wide variety of activities to be developed
- Some created for high-tech activities
43Potential Sectors for Investment
- Manufacturing
- Automotive parts
- IT Communication
- Electric Electronics
- Wood processing
- Construction materials
- Textile
- Food processing
- Infrastructure
- Outsourcing and logistics
44Automotive Industry Opportunities
- Experience in the field of car makers
- Automotive component parts rapidly growing
sector currently over 175 major manufacturers - Availability of labor force
- Labor cost monthly average salary approx. Euro
250-300 - Total number employed 600.000
- Trained work force
- 7 colleges in vehicle technology 500 graduates
each year - 25 colleges in mechanical engineering 1.000
graduates / year - Availability of suppliers and subcontractors
- Presence of RD centers
- Successful investment stories in the field
45Automotive top-tier investors
2006 1 bill investment 1.6 bill turnover 12 thou employees 2007 230.500 cars sold New projects A gear boxes facility 217 mill of Renault-Nissan Alliance A RD Centre "Renault Tehnologie Roumanie" 456 mill - 2012
Ford took over the state-owned shares of Automobile Craiova (72.4 ) for 57 million, and pledged to invest 675 mill to modernize the factory and increase the number of employees Ford is awaiting for the results of the EC investigation on the Romanian government helping the takeover Ford took over the state-owned shares of Automobile Craiova (72.4 ) for 57 million, and pledged to invest 675 mill to modernize the factory and increase the number of employees Ford is awaiting for the results of the EC investigation on the Romanian government helping the takeover
Automotive component parts sector the fastest growing sector in Romania 5.8 bill investment inflows to increase up to 9-10 bill until 2010 Huge presence of international top-tier players TYRES (Michelin, Pirelli, Continental) WIRES (Yazaki, SEWS, Leoni, Lear, Valeo, Delphi) BEARINGS (SNR, Ina Schaeffler, Koyo), SOFTWARE (Siemens VDO) SEATS (Johnson Controls), etc. Automotive component parts sector the fastest growing sector in Romania 5.8 bill investment inflows to increase up to 9-10 bill until 2010 Huge presence of international top-tier players TYRES (Michelin, Pirelli, Continental) WIRES (Yazaki, SEWS, Leoni, Lear, Valeo, Delphi) BEARINGS (SNR, Ina Schaeffler, Koyo), SOFTWARE (Siemens VDO) SEATS (Johnson Controls), etc. Automotive component parts sector the fastest growing sector in Romania 5.8 bill investment inflows to increase up to 9-10 bill until 2010 Huge presence of international top-tier players TYRES (Michelin, Pirelli, Continental) WIRES (Yazaki, SEWS, Leoni, Lear, Valeo, Delphi) BEARINGS (SNR, Ina Schaeffler, Koyo), SOFTWARE (Siemens VDO) SEATS (Johnson Controls), etc.
46Romanian ITC Industry Trends
- High density of Romanian IT specialists (five
times higher than in Russia, and seven times than
in India). - Romanian Olympic students are usually placed in
top 4 with China, US and Russia. - In Microsoft the second spoken language is
Romanian - Low brain drain phenomenon in Romania
- IT sector is constantly growing
- Major multinational IT companies such as
Microsoft, HP, Oracle, Cisco, Intel and Motorola
are present in Romania - many of them use Romania
as regional headquarters.
47A Top European Location for product RD,
outsourcing, customer service and BPO
In 2006 Microsoft opened a Global Technical Support Center creating around 700 jobs One GE group companies established an IT outsourcing, financial services and supply chain BPO HP set up a BPO in Bucharest for financial and administrative services, dedicated to EMEA region - up to 1200 employees
In 2006 WIPRO decided to set up a BPO center in Bucharest for IT services covering the East European market - 700 employees Ericsson opened in Romania, in July this year, a New Global Service Delivery Center - 70 of the employees will be young graduates BPO aiming to offer outsourcing services in HR, finance and procurement to work
48Availability of Human Capital
- Young population (more than 55 is under the age
of 40 and 37 is between 25 and 49 years old) - Almost 21.7 million people
- 104 higher education institutions
- 112 thou university graduates
- Availability of technical engineers
- High industrial experience
- Flexibility
Cities with more than 100,000 inhabitants Cities with more than 100,000 inhabitants
more than 1,000,000 inhabitants
300,000 400,000 inhabitants
200,000 300,000 inhabitants
100,000 200,000 inhabitants
Source National Institute of Statistics Source National Institute of Statistics
49Valuable Human Potential
- high performances in international competitions
- high percentage of technically competent
professionals (23 are engineering graduates out
of 720 students enrolled) - highest growth rate of IT specialists in the
region (Annually 7000 university graduates in the
software field More then 3.000 students in 105
local Cisco academies)
University graduates in Romania (by education
field)
Source National Institute of Statistics
- strong language skills (English, French, German,
Italian, Spanish, Russian, etc.) - large skilled labor force at comparatively low
wage rates