Applicability Statement of NSIS Protocols in Mobile Environments draftietfnsisapplicabilitymobilitys

1
Applicability Statement of NSIS Protocols in
Mobile Environmentsdraft-ietf-nsis-applicability-
mobility-signaling-09.txt

• Takako Sanda, Xiaoming Fu, Seong-Ho Jeong, Jukka
  Manner and Hannes Tschofenig
• IETF71 in Philadelphia
• 12 Mar. 2008

2
Changes Between -08 and -09

• Security Consideration has been cleaned up.
• Only refer GIST, QoS NSLP, NATFW security
  discussions
• gt Need your review and comments
• Open issues for NATFW has been closed
  (temporally)
• How old pinhole is torn after MNs handover? -gt
  Automatically tone by timer
• Does it mandatory that MN sets S-flag when it
  detect attaching a private network-gt This is out
  of scope of Mobility draft

3
Open Issue

• Is it necessary to revise MIP Interaction?
• One out of all cases are explained in detail, and
  others are explained differences and similarities
• All cases Combination of Sequential Mode
  and Parallel mode for tunneling section
  Sender-initiated and receiver-initiated MIPv4
  FA CoA, MIPv4 co-located CoA, and MIPv6 cases
• gt Is current structure fine?
• gt Or, is it necessary to describe details for
  all cases?

4
ML Comments (1) NATFW

• The mobility draft also needs to discuss NATFW
  and Mobility operations.
• gt Need Text Proposals
• Offline DiscussionThu. 12-Mar.,
  1510-1610Meet at IETF registration desk !

5
ML Comments (2) Basic Operation

• It is probably good to split the solutions part
  in NTLP and NSLP specific sections.
• what NTLP can do
• what each of the NSLPs can do
• Not only MN is sender, sender-initiated
  reservation case, but also other reservation
  case should be described.
• gt Needs comments and text proposals

6
ML Comments (3) Problem Statement

• Problem Statement should not cover both problem
  statement and NSIS solutions
• gt Authors will revise accordingly

7
ML Comments (4) Further Study

• Purpose of further study section is not very
  clear in the text.
• gt Authors will revise accordingly

8
Schedule

• Mid Jun. 2008
• Submitting -10, covers all on-going open issues
  and comments
• End Jun. 2008
• Discussing WGLC comments
• Sep 2008
• Submit 'Applicability Statement of NSIS Protocols
  in Mobile Environments' to the IESG as an
  Informational RFC