Clause 9 Comment Resolution 5/21/03 Montreal, Quebec

1
Clause 9 Comment Resolution5/21/03 Montreal,
Quebec
2
Clause 9 Comment Resolution

• 138 total comments
• 29 editorial
• 50 technical non-binding
• 59 technical binding
• 69 total accepted
• 22 accepted
• 30 accept modified
• 17 accept duplicate
• 8 total rejected
• 7 rejected
• 1 rejected duplicate
• 15 withdrawn
• 6 superceded
• 9 deferred to WG
• 5 deferred to clause 6 / 9 joint CRG
• 2 punted from clause 6
• Editor granted license to resolve editorial
  comments

3
Key Items

• Accepted
• 506 Accept Clause9ClarifyResBsMay18.pdf
  fairness clarifications (as modified)
• 605 KK changes to conservative rate comp state
  table presented to group on Monday.
• Punt to WG
• 542 FRTT proposal jl_frtt_01.fm /pdf to WG (DVJ
  proposes echo)
• 513, 514, 515, 564, 565, 620 DVJ new clause 9
  text deferred to WG but will integrate good
  explanatory materials in any case.
• Rejected
• 624, 625 DVJ new clause 9 rejected commenter
  disagrees
• 526, 527 Wording bugs removed by removing
  offending functions (Leon comments DVJ
  objections)
• 586 suggestion to move activeWeights data
  structure and computation to data path
• 612 downstreamCongested is set correctly
• 613, 614 Hops-to-congestion should maintain
  previous value when not congested
• 627 Simulations have shown that fairness
  algorithm works with configured defaults. No
  need to provide.